Monday, November 23, 2009

JANET HALLEY: TAKE A BREAK FROM FEMINISM

I just read the 2006 book “Split Decisions” by Janet Halley, a professor at Harvard Law School.

I try to keep up with feminist thinking, as you can tell from prior Posts. Feminism has been one of the most substantial influences on the way things have gone in the country these past few decades (the Biblical 40 years and heading toward half-a-century, now) and since it mostly receives a very Politically Correct kid-glove treatment in the mainstream media, it seems to me that it needs a much more careful and not so cream-puffy an examination.

The subtitle caught my eye: ‘How and Why to Take a Break from Feminism’. Now that, I thought, is something you don’t see every day. Especially from an established and prestigiously placed feminist and female author.

It’s never been my position that women (not to be equated with feminists, nor vice versa) should be considered nothing more than the docile herd in the deerpark of male sexual conquests, nor do I hold any brief for males who define themselves, their lives, and their ‘success’ in terms of sexual conquests, especially violent ones. Such a habitus does no good for the maturational prospects of any male, as well as harming any female who comes within range.

So I read the book last night and have a few thoughts. This is not a formal review, of course, so I’m only covering the thoughts that strike me. I’ll give page numbers from the text* when I quote a major point.

She quotes a couple of feminist slogans: “I’ll see it when I believe it” and “I’ll see it when I can theorize it” (p3). These seem to refer to the valid enough epistemological insight that if you don’t have a category for something, you may well not even notice it.

It’s not a bad insight. I recall when I first heard an electronic siren (the whoo-whoo, woop-woop) that began to replace the old mechanical sirens (that sounded like smaller versions of the air-raid sirens of World War 2): I didn’t hear it at first, but rather I felt it – I realized after a bit that my eardrums seemed to be vibrating. Focusing on that odd sensation, it was only then that I realized that something was making a noise, and it turned out to be the local fire chief, whose 1960 Pontiac was coming up the street with its red bubble revolving and this strange contraption on the roof apparently making the noise. The chief was having a hard time moving along, since most drivers didn’t seem to realize what his cutting-edge, state of the art, new-fangled siren was (long before the end of that decade, all Americans who watched the TV news came to know the sound very well).

I didn’t have a mental file for that sound, so I actually didn’t hear it – I only felt its effects (on my poor eardrums). But after that I had a file and I heard them for what they were. That’s epistemology for you.

At the same time, though, I hadn’t studied meteorology and knew what thunder was, so some stuff seems to come almost pre-loaded in the human brain, or it’s learned so early – before the capacity for self-awareness is fully operational – that it seems like you’ve known it all along.

But that part about ‘theorizing’ adds an extra layer of complication: it’s one thing to encounter a strange new machine and put together for yourself what the thing does. It’s a different level of life’s Vulcan chess game to interpret for yourself what an idea or a ‘concept’ is and what it’s all about and what it does. And then to assume that your take on that idea or concept (not physically real like the machine) is the full and accurate take to be had about the thing. And then another step to assume that other folks should agree with you. And then another step to assume that if they don’t, then they just don’t get it and need to made to agree with you.

You see where these things can go. As Bilbo tells Frodo there in Bag End, taking a single step outside your door is a momentous and freighted thing: you never can tell where the Road will take you. (Did you think it was just a movie or just a fiction?)

Halley mentions “the thrill of liberation from the self”, which I think she is defining when she goes on to say “the complexly constituted erotic self”. I can’t be comfortable with any implication that the self – the marvelous human self – can be reduced to its (admittedly complex) sexual aspects and potentials. If for no other reason, I think that the Framers imagined a Constitution that would provide a framework for the political affairs of a citizenry who were indeed individuals who were – according to their individual gifts and lights – efficaciously committed to maturing the self that each of them possessed, thus then coming together to deliberate about their public affairs, thus both grounding and holding accountable the government that the Framers were oh-so-carefully limiting and structuring through the actual Constitution.

If no complex, dynamically maturing Citizens, then no way that the Constitutional machine itself could keep going; like a Ferris wheel (not invented, I agree, at the time of the Framers) that required struts to keep it solidly and stably anchored if it were to perform its marvelous movement.

In the Constitutional vision, The People is/are the struts that hold the great machine up and also anchor it against the various momentums of its own movements. Otherwise you get the vivid result so neatly imagined by Steven Spielberg in his 1978 film “1941”, where the Ferris wheel, shot free from its struts, rolls drunkenly along a pier and over the edge into the sea. You might have realized the same sensation yourself in recent years, watching national policy and the Beltway careen ever more drunkenly. There is an edge out there, ahead of Us, somewhere.

In order to be credibly feminist, any approach has to accept the following stipulations, says Halley: a) that there is a distinction between male and female; b) that the female is subordinated to the male; c) that opposition to that subordination is required (p17).

I can see that and I can accept it as an approach to construing American civic life. I would be verrry uncomfortable if the primary unity, the core identity, of Americans as Americans, was subordinated to that, however. If for no other reason than the threat posed to the integrity of The People in the vital role of holding up and holding steady the great machine of the Constitutional arrangement. Once ‘gender’ (or any other aspect of anyone’s complex identity) functionally replaces ‘American’ as the most important definition, then for the most fundamental political purposes at least, We in a heepa trubble.

And if a theory insists that “subordinated sexuality” is the most important and immediate aspect of fully one-half of the Citizenry’s identity, then not only as individuals but as a Citizenry We are taking a mighty limited view of Ourselves, as human beings and as a People. And there will be consequences, just as surely as deconstructing the struts on a Ferris wheel will yield rather inevitable consequences.

Haley muses that by the early 1980s much feminist theorizing – not all of it congruent and easily meshed – had already been done. But then three things happened: a) AIDS; b) ‘power feminism’s’** determination to focus on domestic violence and sexual violence; c) postmodernism (p28).

About (a) I simply note that a thoroughly ‘liberated’ (which is to say unlimited and un-Shaped) sexual range can have profound, even if unintended consequences – although the effects on the maturity and genuine human development of the individual are, though less obvious, even worse than the disease itself.

About (b) I would note that in that same decade of the 1990s that Halley will call “the decade par excellence of governance feminism”*** (p32) this country adopted a host of police-state tactics, including registries (domestic violence and sex offense), arrest without warrant on the simple say-so of another citizen (domestic violence), special courts (domestic violence), and the widespread government-sponsored certification of an entire group of citizens as incorrigible and recidivist monstrosities (sex offense) that allegedly required not only extensive police monitoring but widespread public notification (sex offense). I would also note that the Constitutional difficulties with the sex-offense laws have increased exponentially, rather than declined, in the two decades since their inception and now include traditionally conservative elements such as the Cato Institute and the actual State governments and police agencies themselves.

This can hardly be an unintended consequence when so much of feminist thought considers “male sexuality to be a vast social problem” (p27). Or, as Lacanian linguistic theory would put it: all of a sudden, almost one-half of the Citizenry of this nation were, in the blink of an eye, and with the politicos' eager support, 'problematized'. Now that is something you haven't seen too often in human history, and that's probably not just coincidence: governments and nations who embark on such a path aren't going to last too long. Or, as one dead white male has put it, echoing some other dead white male: "a house divided against itself cannot stand".

It is thus a recipe for profound public, civic, political damage, when – especially with the connivance of the elected officials of the government – almost one half of the nation’s citizens are conceived of as a vast social problem almost overnight. It reminds one of the sudden Soviet attitude and policy toward the Kulaks; but more relevantly to a democracy, it clearly promises to rend the polity jaggedly and profoundly. You find yourself asking: what democratic government in its right mind would undertake to support such a program? And so enthusiastically?

And, of course, having once fractured The People so profoundly, the limits on overweening government built into the Constitutional ethos are themselves effectively fractured as well. As We have been seeing of late.

About (c) Halley herself describes postmodernism’s “anti-foundational, libertine, irrationalist, anti-moralistic” elements (p29). How could it escape anybody that such a caustic dissolvent would most likely corrode much of the machinery and the struts of the Constitution? Would most likely corrode and even corrupt the maturity and civic competence of the individual Citizens themselves?

Halley reports herself “happy” that governance feminism made certain problems “visible” and showed “reality” while “making life better, even if marginally – for women” (p32). About the Constitutional ramifications, and the ramifications for many individuals – most of them males - ever more intensely coming to light, Halley has nothing to say, nor is there even an entry for ‘Constitution’ in a comprehensive Index at the back of the book. Which, as I have been saying recently, is one of the gravest problems with the entire feminist enterprise as it has been embraced and fulfilled by government policy, regulation, and – oy – criminal law.

She quotes admiringly Catharine MacKinnon, early theorizer and icon of in-your-face feminism (although Halley quickly notes that MacKinnon has a mellower later phase as well): “My consciousness is true, yours is false, never mind why”(p44). This is quickly followed by a second bon mot: “I know I’m right because it feels right to me, never mind why”.

As the Brits would say: So there it is then. In the proverbial nutshell. Never mind why. How carry on a democratic politics, how conduct any sort of civil or civic discussion at all? Nor is it enough to say that this is from her ‘early’ period and perhaps later disowned, modified, or de-emphasized; this was the type of stuff that overran such conceptual and intellectual defenses as the Beltway in the Reagan era might have mustered.

It’s a sign of precisely the approach – Never Mind Why – that has resulted in the destruction of a politics (or political class) based on deliberation and gravitas, and the erection (as it were) of a politics (and political class) of emotional assertion and thorough-going anti-intellectualism. Let’s not think that Rush Limbaugh is purely a product of the Right; the launch skids were greased for that behemoth by MacKinnon and her brassy and cocky (as it were) sistern (male and female).

The media lapped it up like catnip.

And this goes a great way toward explaining that jaw-dropping media moment in the now infamous Duke Lacrosse gang-rape when, as the prosecutor's case started to cave in by the chunkful, almost one hundred of the faculty stated officially to the media that "facts don't matter". The Theory had convicted these 'males', these 'men', and - as Goebbels was fond of telling the German people, "that's all you need to know".

It was MacKinnon’s insight to “use the law to resist male domination” (p56). Now male domination, except in the most overt cases of rape, is something that – in feminism’s own schematic – you have to believe in and theorize in order to ‘see’. Something so deep – if it is, and subtle – as it apparently is, and long-lived – as it is claimed to be … something that complex is not something against which any rational government deploys the short, sharp, blunt-edged tool of the criminal law. But again … the Beltway did. And is still doing.

Which is not to say that ‘male domination’ doesn’t exist. But granted that it does, in some form, and to some extent rather short of ‘total’, then it was going to take some careful and extensive deliberation to get to work on it. Which is neither the European revolutionary way, nor the impatient attention-challenged American way – and the feminists had drunk deeply from both tainted wells. Enter then the vote-addled Democrats, certain that the female demographic was too frakking big to lose and that the ‘white industrial male’ demographic was most certainly going the way of the dodo, courtesy of the corporate biggies who were paying handsomely into the Beltway’s PACs for the privilege of ‘outsourcing’ as fast as they could line up cheap labor in the paddies, fields, and backstreets of the Third World. Those were the days.

In short, MacKinnon’s plan – espoused by the vote-addled politicos – was to “use law to undo gender” (p56). Once again, it may seem strange that a democratic and Constitutionally-limited government would seek to deploy its carefully constrained authority in order to undo with Law what millennia of human history, tradition, and experience indicated might be a substantial human reality, but as it worked its way through the Looking-Glass the Beltway lost track of just what ‘strange’ might be. Which was the plan; it was Incorrect to be judgmental and categorize things, especially in an insensitive and negative way. Those were the days.

Cultural feminism holds, in Halley’s taxonomy, that “women have a distinct consciousness and/or culture”, although then this consciousness might derive either from their biological situation or from “their historical oppression by men” (p58). Which leaves a lot of blank space to be filled in on the map.

Halley uses an interesting and useful example: imagine that women make good mothers. An ‘essentialist’ analysis would say that women are naturally maternal, while a ‘social constructivist’ analysis would say that men made women do all the mothering so they just sort of got good at it. When last I got a memo on the subject, you could lose your job or wind up in front of some sort of adjudication if you proposed that the former might well be the case (although one never gets all the memos in an ongoing revolution that bids fair to become permanent … sort of like wars that are forecast to last generations – although I don’t think that anybody planned the Hundred Years War with that particular timeframe in mind).

As I’ve said before, from everything known about Evolution, its Modus Operandi – verrry well established – is to provide deeply for the most important purposes. So, in something as primary as the reproductive survival of the species, and in a species that has the largest relative brain of all the animal kingdom and takes the longest time to mature to full brain potency, then the big E would probably want to ensure steady and reliable care. It would ensure that by preparing the child-bearer as deeply and complexly as possible. And perhaps the lumpish Fred Flintstones of the earliest hominid communities realized exactly what Wilma seemed to be able to do with kids; perhaps they weren’t such cartoon characters as they have been made out to be.

To imagine Evolution looking at both the male and the female adults of the species and merely dismissively waving its hand in a Yeah, Whatevvvvverrrrrr sorta way … I don’t think so. Evolution, unlike Americans nowadays, doesn’t just wave its hand dismissively and leave it up to the meat-sacks. It takes steps – verrrry specific steps. I’m jus’ sayin’.

Halley quotes Robin West, author if 1997’s “Caring for Justice” and, Halley opines, “one of the legal academy’s most articulate and theoretically astute cultural feminists”: “There is such a thing as patriarchy - ‘the social system when men’s interests trump women’s whenever they conflict’ – … [and] no society is utterly free of it, even this one ” (p60).

Which says a lot less than it looks like it’s saying. No society is utterly free of anything, and surely the contention that America is one of the most horribly patriarchal of them all has become gospel (you should pardon the expression) among American elites and among all those kiddies whose parents have recently shelled out two-hundred and fifty large for a first-rate education.

But according to this theory, feminism is also “an irrepressible human reality” – which kind of jars since the last memo I saw was to the effect that the afore-mentioned patriarchy had repressed it all since just a few minutes after the beginning of recorded human history. So it leaves you wondering how an irrepressible human reality was so repressible for so long and more or less so thoroughly. I’m jus’ sayin’. Is it at all possible that it was so repressible from the get-go since even the most benighted cave-folk got the impression that to the best of their observation that’s the way things worked best for the species?

Which is not to say that therefore the world should go back to the cave (although you could say that most of it has never left Plato’s Cave, but let me not digress). But it is to say that if something has been chugging along since about the beginning of human history then you might not want to just haul off and rip it out by the roots on the basis of the most trendy theories, no matter how forcefully asserted. Some serious deliberative thought might be in order. It’s not as if it were as clear as, say, the blatant injustice of the old Jim Crow laws.

Further, for MacKinnon – who was riding pretty high in elite circles during the 1980s – male domination was not a “moral” issue (p61). I take this to mean that it was not a matter of individual males acting illegally or immorally; rather, the thing should be seen as a deep-seated gender-wide issue that required the hammer and sickle of the Law, as hefty and robust as the Beltway could wield them. The hammer and sickle, that is to say, to be struck at the roots of the male sex as a class – which has more than a vaguely Commie ring to it. (Funny, that as the Soviets and their ideas and their political system were lurching toward utter implosion and dissolution ‘over there’ their illuminations were being taken up as the new gospel ‘over here’ – funny, funny, funny).

Women, it was said – and I am not in complete disagreement with this – were not simply discriminated against but were “subordinated” and “undervalued” (p62).

Personally, I think – and this is hardly original, I agree – that one of the greatest candidates for the term ‘original sinfulness’ is the perennial human tendency to undervalue the human species in all its powerful and marvelous potential. This is truly a profound and abiding human tragedy, and the seedbed of catastrophes great and small; nor is each small or individual instance of it any less significant merely because of its ‘small’, ‘individual’ site. A human being, truly, is a terrible thing to waste. And, I believe, the entire species pays for such losses.

There are, it is said – and no doubt this was impressed upon the less-then-profound politicos – two diametric sexes, and they are set against each other, and that is absolutely the fundamental human (and political) reality; there are “gendered harms” (p63) that women suffer and men, precisely, do not. And it is the government’s responsibility – the politicos were told in season and out of season – to fix that.

About harms males may suffer for being male, nothing is said. Which is as it should be – feminism is an advocacy after all, and you expect an advocacy to speak highly and vividly about its clients’ concerns. But all of this has been presented – over the past few decades – not as an advocacy position looking for some purchase on the political ground, but rather as the hugest and most awful discovery ever to be made in the history of the species. Intellectual hubris or P.T. Barnum exaggeration or a shrewd Goebbelsian shot in the air that will spark a public stampede (and a stampede among the halls of the government) … you can take your pick as to the relative proportions of each in the recipe.

West is continued: “Virtuous sexuality is feminine sexuality and it has a decidedly infantile, lesbian, and caring shape” (p64). This foregoing is asserted proudly. The theory, it seems, is that young girls develop a deep love for older women in their lives (their mothers, one imagines, first of all) but are too soon ripped away from that caring and nurturing experience in order to define themselves by and conform themselves to their roles in the domination-subordination script imposed by patriarchy as an established concept and by sex-crazed, thoughtlessly assertive and violently aggressive ‘men’.

And once again, one wonders: it’s a theory and deserves a careful look, but would any democratic government in its right mind simply throw the weight of its authority, prestige, and the consensus of its very legitimacy behind such a vision? No wonder that even after Bush the Egregious frakked up the economy and started two losing wars, the Democrats were just able to squeak by in the last presidential election.

Halley will quote the feminist writer Adrienne Rich who posits “a redemptive, feminist, intrinsically lesbian sexuality”, even “infinitely redemptive” (p64). And another feminist writer, Ellen Bass, who posits the “redeemed sexuality of the original desire” (meaning the original attraction of the young girl to the older female). Is it just me or am I right in thinking that if this statement were about males, then such an assertion would bring you dangerously close to the NAMBLA position?

And I’m still not in agreement that ‘sex’ and the having of it somehow constitutes the essence of being human and the epitome of human achievement, self-awareness and self-definition. Where would We be if Homer and Dante and Michelangelo and Theresa of Avila and Elizabeth I**** followed such a philosophy of self and of the human? Of course there was Catherine the Great (the empress, not the feminist philosopher) … but her mark on history was not as great as the possibilities of her position might have provided, and there was that stuff about the Guardsmen … and something about a horse.

But now Halley gets to some material that I think contains crucial information, relevant to the situation the country faces today.

In 1982 the psychologist Carol Gilligan wrote the book “In a Different Voice”. She asserted that the moral development of females and males differed. The boys developed an “ethic of justice, predicated on the understanding of human beings as individuated and separate, and on the rule of logic and the rule of law”.

The girls, however, “saw that the world is not made up of separated, self-seeking individuals but rather of interrelations, connections webbing everyone together in communities of concern”; further, that “they made moral decisions not through abstract reasoning from rules but by balancing the infinitesimal and acute needs of everybody concerned” (p69). (Italics mine) This, Gilligan said, is an ‘ethic of caring’.

The boys’ “ethic of justice” was contrasted to the girls’ “ethic of caring”.

THIS, as the kids would say, is HUGE.

If you think you can hear oblique echoes of the Sotomayor confirmation hearings, I think what you have here is the American start of it all.

But more fundamentally, I think what you have here is the dark beating heart of the intensifying Constitutional corrosion that has been going on for decades, for which the Bush Era skullduggery is not a cause or source, but merely a symptom and a result.

If you look at what the boys are doing, you will see the essential philosophy underlying the Constitutional ethos: individual persons, responsible for themselves and their development, responsible as well for their actions, but they will be judged – if such be required – according to the logic of cause and effect and according to the rules of the applicable laws. The government, of course, is as contained in its powers and the responsible use of them as the individual citizens are contained by their responsibilities under the laws.

The girls – in Gilligan’s schematic – entertain a vision that is hell and gone from that. It’s a more maternal (!) approach: whichever baby is crying is to be helped along and soothed, regardless of whether there is a ‘reason’ for it to be crying. It’s a fine approach for dealing with still undeveloped infants still helplessly subject to the waves of their passions and emotions’ they can’t be expected to use their ‘reason’ to self-modulate their emotions.

But a nation is comprised of adults who are responsible. Or should be. Or perhaps must be.

The ‘ethic of caring’ works perfectly well for infants. But the ‘ethic of justice’ is what works for adults. If you’re going to have a Constitutionally envisioned limited government, grounded by a Constitutionally envisioned mature Citizenry.

Any government that is going to appoint itself as the Fixer of All Pain is going to be taking on the role of God and the angels – and will demand that much authority (it can never attain that much wisdom). Bill Clinton’s nifty soundbite – I feel your pain – stems ultimately from this schematic of Gilligan’s, I think.

It seems to me that Bush the Egregious merely took advantage of the Constitutional deformities already enshrined by the Left’s or reputedly liberal emotionalism, applied it to the emotional situation created by 9-11, and the rest is history – although a history still bursting even now.

And his puppet Attorney General, Gonzales, surely was not intelligent enough or observant enough to declare the Constitution “quaint”. I would say that the Constitution was rendered unworkable the moment a quarter century or so ago when Gilligan’s ‘ethics of care’ began to gain traction inside the Beltway and in the law schools (whence prosecutors, US Attorneys, politicians, and judges of all ranks have now sprung).

Halley doesn’t go into the downsides. She does mention the “dark side” of feminism, and that there is – and of necessity – “blood on its hands” from where things had to be done (though she doesn’t go so far as to repeat the old Communist saw about the eggs that have to be broken to make an omlette). More on that in a moment.

When she gets to the gist of her main point, fully expounding it towards the end of the book, she does remarkable work. Without rancor, supportively and yet firmly, she suggests that it’s time to Take A Break From Feminism (pp.341-ff).

And then she unpacks that.

Feminists need to stop repeating the “subordination mantra”, that women are subordinated (thus oppressed) by men. She calls it the “politics of injury” (I would call it ‘victimism’, but I can see where she’s trying not to be too inflammatory and, following the best advice of Gilbert and Sullivan, seeks to “gild the philosophic pill”.) She bravely adverts, nonetheless, to the follow-up phase in the Politics of Injury: questioning an assertion made by one of the injured is tantamount to re-injuring her.

Feminists have to stop seeing the “brain drain as a good thing”. Here she refers to something you don’t often see discussed in the media: that women who in their reflections and thoughts and observations come up with conclusions unacceptable to feminist orthodoxy are hounded or frozen out of the feminist ranks. She herself shares the feeling that when she wondered about the damage that available prostitutes might do to men she immediately felt that “it seems somehow not-feminist to suggest it”.

Feminists need to resist bad faith. The wide and frequent deployment of the Injury Triad (female injury plus female innocence plus male immunity) has to be acknowledged for what it does. It does not eliminate consequences and costs simply by removing those costs and consequences from women; it merely shifts those consequences and costs to others. And feminists who claim that they can exercise broad and deep political power without causing injury to – she dares to say it – men must stop such posturing, stop operating in such bad faith.

Feminists need to minimize moral perfectionism and their magical-realism style of thinking. They cannot claim that women, being oppressed and victims, can never themselves oppress and victimize others once they exercise power. Feminism, especially in the exercise of long-sought power, cannot hold itself as “morally immaculate” (p344).

Feminists need to deconstitute women’s suffering. Might it not harm a woman – she suggests – to insist that if she has been raped she is now so traumatized that she may well never recover? Is it always ‘blaming the victim’ to inquire whether in a particular case any activity of the female might have been contributory? Does it do women any good to dogmatically remove them from any responsibility for their experiences at all? Is the standard and required feminist “rape discourse” (subject-verb-object, man-raped-woman) sufficient to all situations and does it respect the complexity and integrity of human experience? Is it possible that in affirming and identifying with female “injury” feminism is actually intensifying it?

These are splendid questions. I’d have to say that they should have been asked long ago, but that is not the particular fault of Halley, whose book – with full and due regard for feminism’s acute sensibilities – asks questions that must be considered.

In fact, this whole concept of Theory needs to be looked at. It’s all very well for a bunch of humanities and literature types to think up ways they can play with a text like kids’ play-clay, but an actual living nation is not a ‘text’, nor is a society, and while the Constitution is a document, it’s a hell of a lot more than simply another piece of fiction to be parsed and cut-pasted.

In that regard, I recall what Frederick Crews said; he was speaking about Freudian theories, but it could apply to all this material here as well: “Freudian concepts retain some currency in popular lore, the arts, and the academic humanities, three arenas in which flawed but once modish ideas, secure from the menace of rigorous testing, can be kept indefinitely in play”.*****

Many of the foundational assumptions and assertions of feminist theory – in all the dense and indeed jungle-like tangle of its diversity – are very much still “in play”. For that matter, the entire country, the entire nation, the entire society, the entire culture, the entire ethos of Western civilization is very much a playing board, for games political as well as Theoretical.

Which does not, for all its brash and frizzy excitements, bespeak a becoming gravitas about just what an amazing but fragile construction has been bequeathed to Us. We may well improve upon it; but We are fools to ‘deconstruct’ it.

Still and all, Professor Halley has done a great and worthwhile service here. And I don’t know if anybody outside the charmed circle of feminist true-believers could do it with any chance of being heard. I am reminded of the observation that “only Nixon could go to China”, although I mean thereby no disrespect to Professor Halley.

I’d conclude this, however, by connecting another dot from beyond her book. An article by Joshua Kurlantzick, examining the curious and surprising persistence of the Communist Party in China despite the formation of a respectably endowed urban middle class, comes to the conclusion that – contrary to the conventional wisdom that the emergence of a middle class facilitates a move toward democracy – the Chinese urban middle classes are actually rather supportive of authoritarian government … because it seems a more reliable protector of their gains.

It seems to me that this is somewhat of the same problem that Obama is facing here, and one of the main reasons that he has been unable to fulfill so many of his campaign promises and – I believe – his own goals: too many who have gained much from the Identity Politics regime of the past forty years do not want to see too much change. And in that, for all practical purposes, such groups are natural (if silent) allies of the wealthy who also do not want to see what they have placed at risk of redistribution.

How Obama can overcome resistance from both sides – as it were – of the current political spectrum, from both remaining sources of the Beltway’s power (Identity Politics and corporate PAC contributions), is a very sobering question indeed.

In that sense, finally, I think Obama is in the same position as the Constitutional ethos itself: it’s under fire from both sides. The Identity Politics advocacies want to see it ‘reformed’ in order to remove its obstacles to their politically useful ‘politics and ethics of caring’ while the law-and-order Rightists want to see it diluted so as to ensure more ‘order’ than the traditional American vision allows the government police power to impose.

And surely, if the feminist visions of slavering male sex-addicts and the wealthy’s visions of a demanding and enraged and suddenly impoverished citizenry are allowed to run free, then they will both converge in an engorged police state, the better to regulate and control their respective bugbears and nightmares.

And if the Sixties insisted that there were no limits and no bounds and no Shapes to which any individual must conform – either in order to accept an external obligation or to fulfill an interior nature – then after several generations, such an unripened and immature citizenry must be both incapable of governing its government and in need of that government’s police power in order to enforce whatever civil order remains possible.

These are dark trajectories indeed.

Halley’s suggestions are certainly an excellent place to begin a desperately needed change of course.

NOTES

*My copy of the book is the Princeton University Press edition of 2006.

**With no disrespect to Halley, it’s like reviewing old Soviet history to read her enlightening list of assorted feminisms: power feminism, governance feminism, cultural feminism, liberal feminism, difference feminism, postcolonial feminism, sex-positive feminism, structuralist feminism, essentialist feminism, social constructivist feminism, convergentist hybrid feminism, divergentist hybrid feminism … one can’t help but think of Mensheviks, Bolsheviks, Old Bolsheviks, Trotskyites, Zinovievists, Narodniks, legal Marxists, primitive accumulationists, polycentrics, Titoists, permanent revolutionists, right deviationists, left deviationists, and a ghostly host of others including, of course, that greatest creator of ghosts, Stalinism. I suppose you could, if you were so inclined, describe this all this as “intense, theoretical productivity”.

***Who may be said to have abandoned the outsider-revolutionary approach, and instead concentrated on changing things from within the government and the major institutions (law schools, the judiciary, universities, and such).

****At one point in this book, Halley refers to Elizabeth – the queen who ruled England in the 1600s … or words to that effect. My immediate thought was that she could simply have said “Elizabeth I” or “Elizabeth I of England” but then it occurred to me that at this point in elite academic history, a substantial amount of her readers (even the Harvard ones) might not be able to place “Elizabeth I” either as to timeframe or place. I am not referring to the Ivy frosh who were recently discovered to reach the hallowed halls secure in the knowledge that Lincoln beat Hitler or the Kaiser and Kennedy followed Roosevelt. But then, they were all men, and dead white men at that.

*****Crews, Frederick. “Follies of the Wise”: Shoemaker-Hoard, Emeryville, CA; 2006. Page 16.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

ROBERT MCNAMARA

BEST, BRIGHTEST, AND BADLY MISTAKEN

Well, he’s gone. Not that We were ever going to get much more out of him. In the matter of Vietnam he apologized in that way that Beltway biggies do when they’ve been caught and can’t get out of it: a quickie Sorry and then you’re ‘ready to move on now’. Perhaps by now he’s found out just how out of sync that strategy is with Reality (capital ‘R’). He’s reached that level of things where consequences can’t simply be spun away. He’s not the only Beltway biggie on Reality’s list, I bet. And to think that most of them think they’ve had a good day if the media give them a puff or at least pass over them in silence.

At a Mississippi college in 1967 he said “The real threat to democracy comes from undermanagement … To undermanage reality is not to keep it free. It is simply to let some force other than reason shape reality.”

Well, now.

I think this is a key element in the Beltway ‘expert’ mentality. It’s worth looking into because We are in Our present grave condition only after long decades of ‘expert’ management (assisted, of course, by pols who know from nothing except whether this or that scheme will help keep them in office, pandering to the interests of their favorite advocacies or of their biggest PAC contributors).

It’s not the basic idea of ‘managing’ that’s bad. Hell, up until the Hippies and Boomers threw it out the window a major task of an adult life was precisely to manage and sustain a ‘self’ so that you could conduct a life. Managing your own self, a form of being a Master and Commander, was one of the primary tasks of an individual and an adult. And a Citizen.

That of course when overboard when the Boomers gleefully and fuzzily insisted that any attempt to shape your own reality was unnatural; and that if you just ‘let it all hang out’ then you would be natural – and that was groovy, if not ‘good’ (which sounded too much like being ‘judgmental’, man).

So ‘managing’ isn’t in itself bad. Hell, it was one of the more impressive lessons of World War Two, listening to Londoners and Brits standing upright amid the ruins of this or that block or neighborhood and quietly saying “we’ll manage”. And that they all had to do their bit.

Neither Boomers nor victimists want to hear that. The Boomers didn’t want to admit that there is a profound and lethal darkness deep down in human history, and the later victimists don’t want to admit that the individual self, formed in a certain character and anchored in a network of others similarly formed, can effect and sustain a robust resilience in the face of challenge and ‘pain’ and – hell – even ‘trauma’.

But the ‘management’ in which McNamara excelled wasn’t so deep as all that.

He was a technician, though on a grand scale. In World War Two he was on the air staff that planned and executed the firebombing of Japanese cities. He didn’t invent it, but he certainly carried the idea to a truly world-historical level of efficiency and success, as it were.

Nor was he a robot. He opined, if memory serves, to his commanding general that if America were to lose the war “we’ll all be prosecuted as war criminals”.

But – and this didn’t really do him any good in the long run – America won the war. Tojo, Yamashita, and the Nuremberg bunch all got prosecuted. McNamara had lived the dream of every war technician, and there would be no adverse consequences for anything he’d done. Which is perhaps the most lethal adverse consequence of all.

But it seemed to work at the time, and up he went, all the way to the top of the Ford Motor Company, and then Secretary of Defense (back in the days when those titles really really meant something big).

Nor is it a bad thing to want to “shape reality”.

But much depends on what you mean by ‘shape’ and what you mean by ‘reality’. If your initial definitions aren’t large enough to encompass what’s actually going on ‘out there’, then you’re going to be bringing a checker-board to a game of Vulcan chess, and he only had to look at the TV back then to see that Spock held huge and fateful wisdom for all cocky and super-bright humans.

If by ‘shape’ you mean simply manipulating reality by force of will or brute might, or by imposing your own vision on everybody involved, then you’ve put a hole in the boat before you’ve even left the harbor. He had just participated in a war that demonstrated clearly that Hitler’s idea of the supremacy of enlightened will – as Hitler imagined he had in superabundance – and military efficiency were not only not adequate to subdue the human species, but were also bound to ignite the opposition of sizable chunks of that species.

And if by ‘reality’ you simply mean static and inert ‘quantities’ that will stand still while you ‘shape’ them with your overpowering brilliance and force, then you have indeed brought a checkers mentality to a game of Vulcan chess. And so the ragged myrmidons of Uncle Ho and General Giap outfoxed McNamara although he kept reciting the mantra that “every quantitative measurement we have shows that we’re winning this war”. Except that We weren’t.*

And if your ‘reality’ in a democracy doesn’t include the considered opinion of The People, then in this regard too you are no longer ‘shaping’ reality; you’re just floundering around in your own little chunk of it as you have chosen to define it – leaving the rest of the variables to pretty much operate independently of your vision and your plans. And when you get to the point, then, where ‘reality’ is operating pretty much independently of you … well, individual persons with that problem wind up being diagnosed or becoming bankrupt. (Which should ring a few contemporary bells, no?)

But before there was a John Rawls to provide benefit-of-philosophy to the volatile concept of ‘elites’, and an ideological feminism to gleefully and arrogantly dismiss all those who ‘just don’t get it’, there was McNamara: sure that he could master the board and bring the game to a brilliantly successful conclusion if the lumps would just stay out of his way.

I can’t help but think that his example – or at least the parts his Beltway descendants chose to notice – inspired decades of advocates, lobbyists, ‘experts’ and the pols who ‘trust’ them, starting in the early 1970s. Whether the social engineers on the far Left who think that the most fundamental warp and woof of society and culture can and must be deconstructed and reconstructed in the twinkling of a revolutionary eye or on the far Right who think that those who already have money (and are willing to send chunks of it Beltway-bound to PACs) are the best and only gentlefolk to be trusted with money … well, you can see where things might go. Have gone.

He didn’t see that “emotion” had any role to play; only “reason”.

Of course, “emotion” is a vital characteristic of human beings; and quite an asset, if well managed by an individual. But then if individuals have not been raised to manage their emotions well, harnessing them and deploying them wisely and maturely … well, then you get crowds and mobs, precisely those lumpish things that McNamara (and the revolutionaries of the Left and the bigwigs of the Right) cannot trust to think or – even – to speak.

And there are many historical conceptions of “reason”. In the materialist and positivist Modern world, “reason” has been reduced merely to the process of abstract and calculating thought. In the Postmodern world it has been ‘exposed’ as a chimera, a dangerous fantasy that merely lures the mass of unsuspecting lumps who ‘just don’t get it’ into contributing to their own ignorance and oppression.

But there was a time when “reason” was a much fuller and richer concept. For Aristotle and Aquinas, say, it meant the ability of the human mind to grasp the true nature (and ‘shape’) of human existence, and order all human activity – individual and communal – toward coming into greater harmony with that ‘reality’, that Reality (capital ‘R’). Acting 'rationally' wasn't a 'male' sin of ignoring emotion; it was a constructive participation in the widest and deepest rhythms of human experience.

McNamara’s “reason” was far thinner and shallower than that. And when one of the last but most robust of the Camelot courtiers, Ted Sorenson, can bleat that McNamara was one of the most brilliant men he had ever known … that simply confesses the apparently perennial shortcomings of the Beltway elites: they are far less competent in grasping Reality than they want to think (or want Us to realize).

So here We are. Vietnam long gone, but its lessons mis-learned or ignored because fresh cadres of the Beltway elites have now saddled Us with larger and deeper defeats: in Iraq, in the economy, in the very fundaments of Our society, Our culture, and Our constitutional polity.

Ah, Robert … we hardly knew ye; but then you hardly knew yourself, though you thought you did. What you didn’t know is what shaped you and your legacy. Alas for you and for Us.

But now that appears to be a problem for far too many of Us. We are The People – and We need to be. The Beltway garden has run to seed – and become a jungle.

Put down the donuts. Time to weed the garden. And shape it into a reality more in line with the Constitutional vision. And maybe with Reality itself.

Back to the future – before the future turns its back on Us.

NOTE

*I’m not going to get sidetracked into the ultimately irrelevant question of whether American military strategy actually won every set-piece ‘battle’. War is fought for larger goals to which the military competence is merely an instrument. And none of those large goals – fuzzy and poorly thought-out in the Vietnam War – were met; just the opposite.

Labels: , ,

Monday, June 22, 2009

MORE SWEET LAND OF LIBERTY

Scott Saul over at ‘The Nation’ has written a review of Thomas Sugrue’s ‘Sweet Land of Liberty’, released last Fall. The book is about the ‘Northern Phase’ of the Civil Rights Movement. I had Posted about it back on November 26th, here.

At that time I said that there was a fundamental and fateful difference between the ‘Southern’ or ‘First’ Phase of the Civil Rights Movement, presided over by Martin Luther King, grounded firmly in a genuinely comprehensive and spiritually effort to unite all Americans in the non-violent struggle to realize the country’s still-unrealized ideals. It is from this phase that the uplifting now-iconic images of sit-ins and Freedom Riders and arm-linked clergy – black and white – are taken.

The ‘Second Phase’, I said, resulted from the spread of the movement – especially after the signing of the Voting Rights Act in July, 1965 – to the Northern and coastal urban setting, where King lost influence and the more revolution-minded and separatist-minded younger generation of activists took over. Indeed, I noted, it was less than two weeks after the Voting Rights Act signing that Watts suddenly exploded, effectively gutting LBJ’s ability to further deploy his massive skills in the service of integration in consequence.

Now comes Saul, with an interesting piece.

He begins by going back even further than the 1950s and the Montgomery era of Rosa Parks, to the wartime 1940s and the indications of racism in the real-estate trade as well as the efforts of individual and local black folk to bring to fruition the promise of 1865 and Reconstruction. Black Americans, after all, were shedding blood for human dignity, democracy, and ‘freedom’ in World War 2 and yet did not have it themselves at home.

The efforts of American blacks to – quite legitimately – take advantage of the opportunity of World War 2’s societal developments sparked a racism in the non-Southern portions of the country; but it was a far more subtle racism than the brutishly obvious ‘Southern’ racism that performed so vividly for the cameras in the 1950s and early 1960s.

But Saul wants to back Sugrue’s effort to show that there was a very real, if not so organized, civil rights movement outside the South well before Rosa Parks’s day. Which is certainly a legitimate historical project.

Yet there’s something else piggy-backed in there. Saul also goes after the “now-standard accounts like the PBS documentary ‘Eyes on the Prize’” wherein “the Northern movement literally explodes into view with the urban insurrections of the mid-to-late ‘60s – with Stokely Carmichael’s chant of ‘Black Power’ taken up in burning cities from Watts to Newark”. Well, yes, this is also a legitimate point; black folk in outside of the South were trying to get things done to improve their lot. And they faced resistance, though – as noted above – of a more subtle type than in the South of that era.

But, Saul goes on quickly, “From this angle, the Northern civil rights movement seems to coincide with the starburst and subsequent flameout, of Black Power and Black Power appears largely as a betrayal of Martin Luther King’s inclusive vision rather than as a strategy that evolved from the painful dilemmas faced by the Northern side of the movement.” This is a big leap. The inference is that there was a non-revolutionary Northern movement, one that kept on all along, from the 1940s (at least) all the way up through the Sixties and beyond. And Yes, there may well have been.

But Saul honestly observes that Sugrue “offers a history of the Northern civil rights movement in which the Black Panthers have been demoted to bit players, Angela Davis and the Attica prison revolt make no appearance” and a bunch of good-hearted little folks, so to speak, are “battling against faceless if powerful entities like the National Real Estate Board”.

The present scheme of understanding, Black Power displacing King and engaging in actual ‘revolutionary separatism’ with all the callow commitment of the young, is “profoundly incomplete” and Sugrue is going to correct that with his history, Saul claims.

Well, I’m not sure about the profundity of the incompleteness. It was the sudden metamorphosis of the civil rights movement into the Black Power movement that shocked the citizenry – all those riots and threats of armed revolutionary force in the service of a violently achieved separatism – and so gutted the Democrats’ vote-garnering strategy that they proceeded in a desperate and addle-pated way to simultaneously pander to any ‘black demands’ while also courting all sorts of other Identities – especially the ‘womens’ movement and, more precisely, the radical feminist ideology that proclaimed itself the representative of ‘women’s interests’.

And, relevantly to Us here today, the ‘Jewish vote’ by initiating a thorough indenture of US foreign policy to the visions, hopes, dreams, schemes and excitements of the Israeli State.

So while I acknowledge that Sugrue is performing a good service by accurately expanding the historical record, he is not stepping in to correct a “profound” incompleteness. The profound effects of the Black Power phenomenon are with Us still, and have poisoned relations between the races, even as it helped to enable an even larger civil divisiveness between ‘the genders’. Oy.

Indeed, future historians may come to mark the fall-out of the Black Power movement as the beginning of the end of America as a coherent polity, society, and citizenry, setting in motion a decline in civic health and unity that only increased as the decades of ‘revolution’ eagerly mushed forward on their Long March (Marches, plural, more properly).

This is a rather profound reality that the Left and those who like to think of themselves as ‘liberals’ would rather not contemplate. And who can blame them? Now that the fake-wealth and almost-fake money that plastered over the increasingly large and deep cracks in the very foundations of the polity has run out, and its greasy golden miasm starts to dissolve in the harsh cold winds of global and historical actualities, the Left would rather not look at things … in much the same way as the former Bushist banditti most strenuously resist being examined as to the lethal and duplicitous frakkery that they perpetrated when they were gaudily dressed in a lot of brief but vast authority.

More specifically, as Saul observes, it’s hard to tell a good story with no dramatic arc, and all the small, genuinely ‘grass-roots’ efforts of all those little-folk really doesn’t make for good theater or – face it – good television ‘news’. No blood, no threats, no posturing, no flames and wreckage … just a bunch of decent people trying to improve things in the face of admittedly subtle obstruction.

But this was, again, a key fracture-point. Faced with an opponent no longer providing overt hostility (think the Southern cops and politicians and a whole lotta the Southern white folks, firehoses, billy-clubs, police dogs, and even white-robes), the blacks looked to the government when the Dems controlling the government declared themselves ready to deploy the awesome government power against such a subtle enemy. It would be – if I may – the ‘military option’ by virtue of adopting the military metaphor and by virtue of attempting to root out a complex and deeply-rooted and profoundly subtle attitude on the part of a very large number of citizens, using the offensive weapons of the government police and regulatory power as if it were a military instrument. (An eerie doppelganging of the mistakes already being lustily funded in Vietnam, and an even more eerie precursor of the current wars in Iraq and Af-Pak.)

This was a grave – perhaps ultimately fatal – mistake for at least two reasons. First, the government cast itself as a warrior against a sizable fraction of its citizens (the ‘white, racist’ fraction), which – to all but the most inebriated – can only seem … ill-advised and fraught with darkling potentials.

Second, the government was going to be going after something so ‘subtle’ that the usual weaponry of civil and criminal law – attuned to ‘acts’ rather than ‘attitudes’ – were far too blunt as instruments or weapons to really and quickly achieve the objectives. Rather than ‘win the hearts and minds’ of the ‘subtle white racists’ of the not-Southern parts of the country, the government simply went to war against them.

But that’s the classic American way of doing things, isn’t it? Find a clear enemy, go after that enemy with ‘shock and awe’ and overwhelming force, and conquer that enemy quickly, cheaply, and with no lasting ill-consequences. And if you don’t succeed in that damp-dream on the first try, then keep doing it even more, with more of everything. Thus the course of the Vietnam War.

(And let Us not here overload the circuits by envisioning what happened when the government then went and declared war on an even larger fraction of the citizenry – males – on behalf of an even more politically attractive ‘demographic’, that ‘women’s vote’, administered, for convenience’ sake, by the ideological and radical elements of feminism. Oy gevalt.)

Now, of course, nobody in the past or present ‘elite’ wants to really talk about it. I suppose it would be like the captain and bridge team of the Titanic locking themselves away up there, to avoid having to come down to steerage, or even first class, to explain how they meant well and stuff happens and isn’t it good that we’re all now really really Nearer My God to Thee?

We’re going to be seeing a lot more of this type of ‘history’ now. For two reasons. First, these ‘elites’ of those storied days are now getting on and would like to ensure their legacy with a How-We-Did-It sort of memoir. Thus to some extent Sugrue here and – in matters feminist – Fred Strebeigh’s recent history* of the feministical machinations to change – by hook or by cocktail – the Beltway approach to American law in the service of their excited visions. They succeeded, by the by, although the consequences have not been altogether what they intended.

Second, it is prudent, wise, and surely shrewd to start spinning things before – the money and the miasm having blown away as aforementioned – folks start seeing more clearly just what the frak has been done over the past three and a half decades. Teddy Kennedy isn’t the only one looking to lock-in a preemptive spin before the fog blows off or before he is no longer – ummmm – physically present to ensure with the weight of that presence that only the nice parts are discussed. It’s an important part of ‘The Dream’ there in the Beltway: getting out of town with your reputation burnished.

Alas, history may prove as implacable as God was formerly. Or perhaps still is, once you wind up rather immediately in His presence. Oy gevalt and Ach.

Saul ends with observations that Sugrue has been unable to grapple with the failure of so much of the civil-rights movements’ initiatives. He tries to save the day with the thought that even while individual whites are no longer so racist, they are willing to countenance much institutional racism.

Here, Saul is trying to save ‘The Nation’s’ bacon as well as the entire post-1965 record. What else can be Correctly identified as a source of the failure? You can’t ‘blame the victim'. You can’t actually start going after pols – the Dems are the official hope of ‘liberals’ and to blame it all on ‘the Republicans’ or ‘the Right’ would be ludicrously tendentious. You can’t acknowledge that there were far more profound complexities than the heady revolutionaries and advocacies and the addled Beltway pols were willing to take into account before they pressed their assorted launch-buttons. You most surely can’t note that the anti-family and anti-male and anti-morality schemes of the radical and ideological feminist elements utterly undercut with scythe-like accuracy the fabric of black community and even individual identity and maturity. And it’s just too little of a bang and too much of a whimper to observe that it was one of the great and sad ironies of American history that the civil-rights movement arrived at such fruition as it achieved just at the point where America’s postwar economic world-hegemony was beginning to fail, starting what has now proved itself to be a probably irreversible and irretrievable decline.

And what self-respecting ‘liberal’ nowadays can blame it on ‘God’ with a straight face?

Saul nicely concludes that Sugrue deserves “much credit for forcing attention on the hard questions that the Northern civil-rights movement asked of American society. He deserves even more for forcing attention on the arduous questions that the movement’s disappointments reflect back on us.”

Those arduous questions have been around since at least Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s time, since Watts and Black Power. They were ignored; in their scramble for votes the Dems – and not long after the Republicans – neither asked them nor provided the type of moral leadership or at least example that would have helped American society look at itself carefully in the mirror.

Who is in a position to ask them now?

NOTES

*Fred Strebeigh, in his book “Equal: Women Shape American Law” . See also my Post and Notes “Their Ranters, Our Advocates” of June 3, 2009.

Labels: , , , , ,

Friday, June 05, 2009

MORE HOW

I’ve said that the things started going off the rails around here bigtime in the Sixties.

The Civil Rights Movement took a sudden and politically lethal turn for the worse only days after the signing of the Voting Rights Act in July 1965, when the Watts riots signaled that the ‘classical’ Civil Rights struggle of Martin Luther King was over, and its incarnation among the urban black populations – especially in those ‘revolution’ soaked days, was going to be far less a vision of a united American drive to achieve a new birth of its ideals, and something more of a greatly divisive struggle.

Then the War began to go badly and a badly shaken LBJ suddenly realized that the Democrats – confronted now with both a losing war and a civil-rights movement that had turned into a ‘revolution’ – were in a heap o’ trouble.

He reached out to blacks with the early forms of ‘affirmative action’.

And he reached out to Israel, offering something akin to total American subservience to Israel (in exchange, it was hoped, for a reliable ‘Jewish’ vote here at home); so desperate was LBJ that he was willing to see the USS Liberty and its entire crew of sailors go to the bottom rather than “embarrass our Israeli friends”, a status – by the by – which neither JFK nor Ike before him accorded them. The Israelis saw a golden opportunity when it was handed to them, and the rest is (ongoing) history.

As the feminist movement evolved rapidly in the late Sixties from the ‘gender equality’ feminism of such as Elshtain and Sommers to the ‘revolutionary’ Ideological Feminism that declared ‘gender war’, the Dems leaped to secure the reliable (and theoretically huge) ‘women’s vote’ by embracing the Ideological demands whatever they were. As canny and determined as the Israelis, the Ideologicals modeled their ‘politics’ on Mao’s ‘Long March’, Lenin’s acceptance of ‘vanguard elites’ who ‘got it’ to lead the benighted masses, and Goebbels’s well-honed playbook on how to manipulate public opinion and twist the organs of political authority.

The Republicans – up til then a smallish party in opposition – suddenly saw their opening: while making their own play for the ‘black’ vote and the ‘women’s’ vote, they also started to capitalize on the general consternation and confusion evoked in the majority of the citizenry by this or that ‘revolutionary’ change.

By 1976, the Dems under House Speaker Tip O’Neil had evolved the strategy of giving the organized lobbies or advocacies whatever they demanded in order to secure votes, while promising the corporations whatever they wanted in order to secure cash (through O’Neill’s invented Political Action Committees).

Meanwhile, America’s economic predominance – based largely on her remarkable manufacturing capacity, untouched by the otherwise universal destructiveness of World War 2 – was beginning to slip both in relative terms (as other nations began to recover or develop) and in actual terms (as corporations looked overseas to find less expensive workers and as far too much of the country’s capital was put into military production, to the neglect of industrial infrastructure capitalization).

It was in Reagan’s era, however, that the Beltway pols and elites, adopted a gambit deployed by the Japanese government about 1960: with substantial civic unrest due to the Japanese government’s continuing subservience to the American military presence and influence, Prime Minister Ikeda Hyato hit upon the marvelous diversionary strategy of promising the citizens a doubling of their income through high-speed economic growth. This would serve to deflect public attention and energy into economic success.

America at the time was actually starting to decline, industrially. So to create such an increase in everybody’s income, some other sector(s) of the economy had to be goosed. A symbolic example of the solution was Reagan’s directing the FCC to permit an immediate doubling of the time allowed for commercials on television; suddenly, Hollywood was showing huge ‘profits’ – but nothing was ‘produced’ in any lasting sense. The F.I.R.E. (Finance, Insurance, Real Estate) sector was allowed to slip its reins – the Savings & Loan disaster followed shortly thereafter.

The Dems under O’Neill had declared themselves “bipartisan”. No longer a Party in opposition (even when it controlled the government) they would work with the Republicans – one big happy family. Perhaps a crime-family, but such an impertinent observation was hardly patriotic.
With the arrival of the Clinton era, the country had declined even more significantly as a self-sustaining productive entity. This problem was turned into a Plan with ‘globalization’, whereby corporate industry was permitted to gut domestic capacity in order to ‘produce’ more cheaply abroad, while other nations’ manufacturing was increasingly imported – especially luxury goods.

Politically, the arrival of the Clintons sparked massive changes made at the behest of assorted members of the Identity Politics club, while the Republicans bulked up their own ‘base’ of fundamentalists, the socially conservative, and the just plain anxious. The government, awash in ‘money’ from all the new economic ‘progress’, was able to fund all its promises for entitlements. The Soviet Union had fallen, so there was no prospect of any rival superpower any longer.

Neither the Identity lobbies, the Israelis, nor the corporations – having bought and paid for their political support one way or another – wanted to see too much ‘change’ in the Beltway, so legislators happily gerrymandered themselves into sempiternal office.

The defense budget, eerily, kept on growing, despite the lack of superpower rivalry. It was one of the last actual ‘industries’ left in the country.

But by the turn of the millennium, that burst of ‘growth’ was running out of steam. So the banks – the quintessential ‘trustworthy’ American institution – were cut loose from oversight. Glass-Steagall was repealed and another economic ‘high’ was induced, not so much though from actual performance as from the creation of ‘instruments’ and the shuffling of much paper.

This too was erected into a Plan: America would henceforth be a ‘knowledge society’ and run a ‘knowledge economy’, providing a great living for those in-the-know, while requiring the services of large numbers of serf-like laborers to staff the big-box stores and blow the leaves. The older workers displaced from an economy that no longer saw itself in need of their services could live off their retirement benefits and refinance their homes for more cash to keep their golden years golden.

In domestic politics, the general surface celebration of ‘wealth’ distracted the citizenry from the increasing use of fear as a motivator or lubricant to ram through politically expedient programs. This or that outrage created this and that ‘emergency’ and ominous new laws, bolstered by ominous new legal theories, began to bite into the Constitutional ethos.

In the 2000 election the workings of vote-counting was halted – with most dubious Constitutionality – by the Supreme Court, which had gotten kind of used to 'guiding' the country to bright new uplands over the previous decades and which now claimed as justification a sort of emergency, created by the fact that the world’s only hyperpower might not have a President when January 20th, 2001 came.

Then came 9/11.

The now-established national neural pathways of fear and revenge were quickly drafted to bear the messages of war. And invasive, preventive war at that.

As with many of the dubious or at least insufficiently thought-out domestic ‘revolutionary reforms’ of previous decades, the war was begun the way many laws had been recently passed: just get it on the books and we’ll work out the details later. If some substantial untruths had to be told, well – it was all in a good cause; not-quite-truthful stats and stories had been foisted on the citizenry, and had provided cover for willing pols, for decades now.

This being America, the thought that truly lethal consequences might wreck everything was considered against God’s will, although there was some question as to whether God, having deputized America and given it the proverbial gun, had any other right to be involved.

The unleashing of the banks, on top of the rest of the F.I.R.E sector, proceeded – hardly surprisingly – to ignite a new Gilded Age, although this one was not built on the actual physical strength and potential of the entire nation, but only on the shrewds of its financial whiz-folk.

As with individuals, unregulated desire led to – ummmm – significant overindulgence.

The war turned out to be shot-through with unforeseen (though rather foreseeable) consequences.

The economy started to wobble, but when it did a fresh Bubble was created. The Japan-plan (with all respect to the Japanese) continued to lay down smoke like a destroyer. Wheeeee!
And so – in an eerie echo of one uneasy German observation during the Hitler years* – we got richer and richer and richer until we were poor.

Now the economic problem has Us placed on the horns of a terrible dilemma. If the government pulls in its belt enough to get the country solvent again, there will be hardly any money for entitlements or for basic services (except the war-machine). If the government ‘monetizes’ the debt, by printing more money, then foreign nations will no longer ‘buy’ Our debt by buying Our Treasury bonds. They might even start to stop using the dollar as the world’s reserve currency.
And then We shall be worth only what We are worth.

And economically speaking, that’s not too much just now.

Nor is any of this amenable to a cheerible just-change-your-attitude sort of approach, so popular for the past 30 or so years. It’s not just a question of ‘getting it’; there are fundamental realities in play that will not be affected by what any individuals – or even any voting bloc – choose to ‘just believe’.

It would appear that not only is History not dead, but there are realities ‘out there’ which exist and operate independently of what individuals – no matter how much they ‘get it’ – choose to believe.

One thinks of the respective pre-Revolution French or Russian aristocracies: wealthy enough to be utterly insulated from the realities around them, they continued quaffing tea and champagne on their fine lawns and in their fine dining rooms, until those realities came through the gates and through the windows.

We are all Marie Antoinette now.

And as ‘hopeful’ as that huge societal reality might be to some interested parties … it really isn’t.

NOTES

*Listening to the continuously upbeat Propaganda Ministry ‘reports’ from the far-too-numerous fighting fronts, one German ruefully observed: We shall win and win and win until we lose.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, May 18, 2009

CIVIL RIGHTS WRONGS

Richard Thompson Ford offers some interesting, if painfully cautious, thoughts.

The gist of it is that “if we really want to fix inequality, it’s time for a new approach”.

So you can see why he’s painfully careful, picking his way like a rider taking a horse along a narrow, cliff-cut road that’s only a few feet wide and has a 500-foot drop on the other side. While acknowledging that racial inequality still exists, he thinks We need to move beyond the old civil-rights approach: “We should be more circumspect in blaming racism, and hidden racists, for problems with more subtle causes”.

From his lips to God’s ear.

But you can’t get a big mass-movement started, you can’t get a whole bunch of people interested, by discussing subtle causes and nuances and assorted complicated dynamics. For a mass-movement that’s going to provide some political clout and punch, you need big, simple, cartoon-quality images and ‘symbols’. Whether or not they really exist, well … refined sensibilities don’t get a lot done in this world, do they?

Fifty and more years ago, Ford rightly notes, there were such clear and vivid realities: the Southrons, in a previous incarnation as out-and-out racists, displayed for the cameras and the world the ugly underside of the American experience. Putting an end to such vivid and overt race-based violence was a good thing for the government to do.

Putting an end to ‘racial inequality’, and even more to ‘racism’, however … now that was a much taller order. And much more complicated. You couldn’t just send in a super-posse of US Marshals and the 101st Airborne to put an end to that sort of thing. The government was going to have to get into people’s minds and hearts, into their thoughts and feelings, and that was going to mean taking government to a whole new level.*

Ford goes on immediately to say that We “must be more ambitious in directly confronting the decline of inner city neighborhoods”. Well, OK. But it’s been forty Biblical years that We’ve been having this problem on the front burner and if it just keeps getting worse, then “ambitious” just barely reaches the urgency with which such a ‘confronting’ needs to be carried out.

Worse, when it started there were not only a larger number of stable black families, but the whole national ethos was supportive of the ‘family’, and of the matrix of habits, mind-sets, heart-sets, and even virtues that grounded the family commitment and the participation of the family in the wider society. All that’s gone now, and it was the following ‘civil rights revolution’ – gender feminism’s revolution against ‘patriarchy’, marriage, ‘males’ generally, and even ‘heterosexuality’ – that both invited the government into even more adventurous forays into the minds and hearts and hearths of the citizenry and also ‘deconstructed’ the entire matrix, the entire ethos, that supported a stable, involved citizenry. Oy.

Much of the ‘decline of inner cities’ now has to be ascribed to fatherless families, single-parent mothers (often very young themselves) who have been ‘liberated’ into desperately needing a job (or at least a paycheck).

“Ambitious”, to repeat, hardly reaches the level of urgency in all this. A mental ‘drive’ through the American ethos now will resemble nothing so much as Allied troops driving their jeeps through the rubble-strewn passageways between the rubble-piles that once had been German streets and cities. Did We not notice?

He impressively tackles what has developed now in terms of criminal justice and imprisonment: criminal law and imprisonment is seen, it would appear, as “a new Jim Crow”. That sounds a bit too much as if some folks are now thinking that ‘racism’ has retrenched and taken a new form, as an arbitrarily erected and enforced effort to discriminate racially.

But Ford acknowledges that as great as the racial disparities are in the numbers of whites and blacks incarcerated, “they can’t be blamed on the kind of deliberate bigotry that once fueled Jim Crow laws”. He’s right.

“Instead”, he continues, “they are the largely the result of the lack of opportunities for lawful employment”.

Well, that’s certainly part of it. But why, after these forty Biblical years and dozens if not hundreds of billions of dollars, is there such a lack of opportunity? His characterization is one that has been around as a standard ‘explanation’ for decades.

Of course, the changing international economic situation didn’t help – the abandonment of the ‘Detroit Consensus’ and the embrace of ‘creatively destructive’ neoliberalism.

In fact, it is one of the cruel ironies of American history that the Civil Rights movement succeeded in establishing itself in 1965 (with the passage of the Voting Rights Act), just as America’s postwar economic supremacy was coming to an end. And then within a few years, feminism, especially in its ‘revolutionary’ gender-feminist variant, launched an all-out sustained assault on the fundaments of American society and culture – precisely the job-providing society and culture that the Civil Rights movement was hoping to open up to blacks.

How did We miss that? Historians of this era will rightly believe that such complex oppositions should have been as clear as a bell to Us.

Nor can it be ignored, though Ford doesn’t raise it, that the Civil Rights era and movement was comprised of two verrrry different phases: the conventionally envisioned ‘Southern’ phase, symbolized by Martin Luther King’s nonviolence and his call for all Americans to unite in a rebirth of national integrity and virtue, and then the politely un-imagined ‘revolutionary’ phase of post’65, with the Black Power agitation, the black demand for racial separatism, and the assault on – if not rejection of – American values. (Before the gender-feminists went and 'deconstructed' them.)

Interestingly, when Ford reaches for positive civil rights imagery in his concluding paragraphs, he only mentions the Freedom Rides and the Montgomery Bus Boycott, both elements of the golden first phase.

The “civil rights focus on bigotry is attractive, even when it’s a poor fit [as an answer to the question and a solution to the problem] because it seems to offer a shortcut to consensus”. Just so. Nor can it be ignored that finding ‘bigotry’ behind every tree, and in every heart, opened up a new arena of paranoia, now racially based, that surpassed the destructive anti-communist paranoia of the late’teens and the 1950s. (And now layer over all that the gender-feminist sexual paranoia, wherein every act of relationship was either ‘harassment’ or ‘rape’ and every male was certifiably a potential rapist waiting to pounce … it is a frakking wonder the country hadn’t imploded by 2000).

But, as Ford indicates, it was easy to swathe everything in the golden cloak of that truly marvelous and awesomely impressive first-phase of the Civil Rights Movement, with genuine and clear good folks, equally vivid bad folks, and even some real heroes. And even the government came off looking good toward the end. For quite a few years, Americans heard ‘civil rights movement’ and simply figured ‘OK, it must be good then’.

But when that ‘wore off’, it was far too simplistic and inaccurate to write off skepticism and hesitation as nothing but willful and ornery ‘backlash’. After 1965 things got hugely more complex, there were numerous variables in a constantly dynamic and shifting national situation, and much of what the government (in the Dems’ desperate bid for ‘black loyalty’ at the polls, and then the Nixonian Republicans’ rival bid for it) was fixing to do would have given any sane drinker pause.

But ‘revolutions’ and careful calculation of consequences don’t blend well. And neither do glorious ‘rescues’- quick, successful, and with no bad consequences – which is the pose that the government was hoping to strike. **

So now ‘racism’ is no longer the only, nor even the main, problem. Nor is the natural hesitation any group of humans would feel toward major change any longer the main problem. After four decades of government action on an unprecedented scale, and unremitting indications that things are not getting better, there is more than enough legitimate doubt, uncertainty, and just plain tire-kicking skepticism among the citizenry.

Nor, as I say in the first Note below, is it a wise solution to simply replace the citizenry with folks who don’t recall any time when the government was held to some standard of efficacy in its actions, and thereby ‘erase the history’. This is a uniquely American variant on Stalin’s old scam of simply uprooting entire populations and moving them to the farthest reaches of the Russian landmass, where their ‘memories’ and obstructions would no longer trouble his ‘visions’ and plans.

Nor is it wise to ‘airbrush’ the history books, which is a tactic far more widely spread today than is often noticed, thus ‘erasing the history’ by keeping the young ignorant.

Ford has courageously raised a complicated set of questions. It remains to be seen whether We have reached that point, described by one Roman historian, where “we can tolerate neither the disease nor the remedy”.

Interesting times indeed.

NOTES

*Of course the other prong of that operation was to have government re-introduce race-discrimination, but ‘for a good cause’, in the form of ‘affirmative action’. Which promptly went and threw ‘equality before the law’ into a state of imbalance from which it has never recovered. Even more insidiously, or ‘subtly’, it threw out any confidence that the citizenry were each and all ‘equal before the government’, a not quite Constitutional principle the absence of which has had profound effects on Our politics. And one of the more insidious solutions to that problem has been to increase the number of citizens and voters who either don’t remember a time when there was such a confidence among the general body of the citizenry, or have never had an experience of a government where such a confidence would even be conceivable; if you can’t fix what has been broken, fill the room with folks who never knew the machine when it worked properly.

**Although with the exception of the 19th century fireman-into-the-burning-building type of rescue, most professional rescue-scene commanders have trained and equipped themselves to take careful stock in planning rescue operations, on the acute presumption that a hasty rescue attempt could most likely cause more harm than good.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, March 03, 2009

HOW IT ALL HAPPENED

Every once in a bit it’s good to step back and take a look at the Big Picture. There are now frequent such attempts to look at where the economy went wrong, and efforts to look at where the War on Terror went wrong have been around for some time.

For the record, here’s my take on things.

In 1948 the Truman Administration founded the National Security State which required that the government “scare hell out of the American people” so that they would see a ‘reason’ for the dual development of governmental intrusions in domestic affairs and the lives of the citizenry and of governmental expansion of the military as its primary weapon in the Cold War. In that same year Truman, facing a difficult election, chose to recognize the new State of Israel immediately and without question, saying that he had no “Arab voters” to worry about; he had been advised against it by diplomatic opinion around the world, which worried that the Israeli presence would only exacerbate the Middle East region and was ultimately fated to fail, though only after much bloodshed.

In 1965, LBJ signed off on the Voting Rights Act in the first week of July, while simultaneously fearing that he had ‘lost the South’ politically ‘for a generation’. Almost immediately the ‘Southern’ civil-rights movement hallmarked by Martin Luther King’s spiritually-based, inclusive and non-violent call to national right-doing was vividly undermined by the Watts riots, and along with King, Johnson and the Democrats were also fatally undermined. In the same year, Betty Friedan likened woman’s place in the American home and family to “Dachau”. And Seymour Melman reported that the American industrial infrastructure was now aging and losing its vitality because too much capital was going into military development and not available for investment in industry; other nations’ industrial infrastructures started to surpass America’s.

In 1967, as a US Navy ship was being repeatedly attacked by Israeli jets and attack boats and crew members were dying, LBJ ordered the rescue jets from US carriers turned back because he needed the Israelis as his agents and ‘allies’ against the Soviets in the Middle East (where all the oil was). Johnson also had no ‘Arab voters’, but he had ‘lost the South’ and he knew that he, like Truman, had – ummmmm – an other type of voter. And the government pursued its intention of instituting a massive program of ‘affirmative action’; it was said to be essential to affirmatively engage ‘racial quotas’ but that the program would only need to be temporary, lasting perhaps seven years or so, a decade at the most.

By 1968, the Democrats were faced with a Vietnam that was now irretrievably gone down the tubes. And also with a civil-rights movement that had evolved into a second, ‘Northern’ phase that rejected King (killed in April of that year) and instead emphasized violence, racial exclusivity, and revolution, and whose public stance was not to make exhortations but rather to ‘issue demands’. Worse, the Democrats found to their horror that not only had the South turned against them – as they had expected – but the working-class voters from the Northeast had also turned against them, thereby not only dealing a lethal blow to FDR’s New Deal coalitions but exposing the Democrats to the possibility of implosion as a viable political Party.

In 1969 the US domestic oil industry first became unable to meet national demand and the country began to import oil.

In 1970 other national economies began to surpass the US economy in various measures of output or achievement.

In 1971 Nixon abrogated the Bretton Woods agreements, and started to ‘float’ the dollar. There was a ‘sugar shortage’ that seemed to come out of nowhere which, among other things, tripled the cost of a candy bar because of the ‘emergency’. Almost immediately afterwards, there was a ‘beef shortage’ that raised the price of sirloin from around 40 cents a pound up over a dollar. Both the Cuban-American sugar growers of Florida and Louisiana and the Western cattle owners were groups that had supported the Republicans politically.

Also in 1971, on July 2, there arrives the 26th Amendment, granting 18-year-olds the right to vote. This is another in the Dem policy of raising up replacement voting blocs, ‘demographics’, Identities. But voters who aren’t even old enough to drink (and will turn out to be only a day past the ‘childhood’ of sex-offense laws) are a dubious proposition. Youth’s gifts do not include deliberation, patience, circumspection, prudence, and a large body of experience upon which to draw upon when analyzing a proposition for its possibilities, negative and positive, and its possible consequences, ditto. This will have an even more significant effect on the level of national political discourse, on electoral strategies, and on the quality of public thinking. Nor did anyone bother to recall that it was precisely among the young that Hitler was most successful in attracting voluntary adherents – their unthinking, eager, ready enthusiasm was precisely what the Reich was looking for in its citizens and agents. Each of the four great replacement ‘Identities’ raised up by the Democrats – the second and revolutionary phase of the black civil-rights movement, the Second Wave of feminism’s version of ‘women’, the young, and the Jewish vote (wooed by a unilateral government embrace of the State of Israel) – would have a significant effect on the quality of political thinking and discourse … long before the likes of Atwater and Rove. *

In 1972 the Democrats declared themselves “the party of women”. The South was gone; the ‘working class’ was upset both with A) the Democrats’ increasing embrace of whatever ‘demands’ that the civil-rights movement (the Northern or violent phase) and the emerging women’s movement were making, and B) with the queasy, rubbery, un-solid sense which was now becoming palpable if not obvious in the national economy. Identity Politics was now establishing its dynamics at the highest levels of national policy as the Democrats sought to cement their relationship with the two new Identities of ‘blacks’ and ‘women’ (and to some extent Native Americans, though they were not a numerous voting bloc – for historically obvious reasons). A budding Political Correctness – widely adopted by the media – made it difficult to conduct public discourse about the positive aspects of anything that the Identities’ representatives wanted to end or the negative aspects of anything that the Identities’ representatives wanted to initiate.

In 1973, following a belated Israeli victory (with American help) in another Middle East war the oil-producing nations, many of them Arab, formed OPEC.

In 1974 the first ‘gas shortage’ developed. Oil prices started climbing, first breaking fifty cents a gallon and then – despite media assurances that such an increase was temporary – a dollar a gallon. They have never stopped climbing (except for the last six months, which are reported to be the calm before the storm).

In or about 1975 mention first began to be made of ‘diversity’, which was revealed to be the proposition that many ‘minorities’ – not simply the black community – needed to participate in affirmative action quotas; the reason for this was that the country was too ‘white’ (and ‘male’) and that such diversity would be good for the country. No attention was paid to the dark assumption underlying this: that the existence of any minority of any kind indicated a fundamental injustice requiring government intervention in the society and the culture – a presumption with ominous consequences for a democratic society.

After all, if there is a ‘majority’ of anything in any respect, there has to be a ‘minority’ of the same thing in the same respect. But the danger was: if it is assumed that anybody can do anything, then if there is a situation where fewer numbers of somebody are not doing something, that can only be – according to the presumptions – because the fewer numbers are the proof-positive result of skullduggery. And the government – courtesy of the Dems – seeps in, or floods in, to ‘fix’ that, to uncover the skullduggery and its perpetrators. Anywhere, everywhere, anytime, all the time. That’s going to have ominous consequences for a democratic politics and a democratic society.

In 1976, with Jimmy Carter elected as a ‘peoples’ candidate through the working of the newly-restructured Democratic Party electoral rules, House Speaker Tip O’Neill, the old-fashioned boss of Capitol Hill, chose to conduct a power-struggle with the ‘people’s President’, and worked to block Carter’s initiatives, though Carter was a President from O’Neill’s own Party. O’Neill conceived, and then strong-armed corporations into accepting, Political Action Committees (PACs) as a form of contributing to individual Members of Congress; the sweetener was that such contributions would ensure friendly consideration from the pols on Capitol Hill. The pols thereby set up the game they would play even unto the present day: pander to the Identities no matter what wjackery they 'demanded' while collecting hefty cash payments from the corporations through PACs - the 'voter' no longer really figured into the scheme at all.

In 1977 in San Francisco Harvey Milk and the mayor of San Francisco were shot and killed in City Hall by a disgruntled former city official. That gentleman would offer as a defense at his trial that he had been rendered temporarily insane by ingesting too much processed sugar in fast foods and junk food – the so-called ‘Twinkie defense’; the most disturbing part of the whole thing was that a jury of reputedly average reasonable American adults accepted the defense.

Also in 1977 Alex Haley’s “Roots” made a huge splash as a book and TV movie, predicated in part on Haley’s search for his own African ancestry and getting back in touch with it, including the testimony of a native ‘griot’. Doubts arose and were pooh-poohed, and shouted down as ‘incorrect’ and ‘insensitive’. It was not until 1993 that it was established even by Haley that things were not quite so, and that – among other things - the ‘griot’ had been coached. Despite that the defense was made that Haley’s assertions were “essentially if not factually true”, similar to Andrea Dworkin’s assertion that she didn’t need ‘facts’ because she relied upon her own ‘experience’. “Facts” began to “not matter”. Noticing that ‘facts’ did not add up, or even doubting the asserted ‘facts’ became ‘incorrect’ and a no-no. The almost inevitable effects on public discourse were not noted by any of the ‘elites’. **

In 1980 the film “Ordinary People” depicted such an ‘ordinary’ family as living in a toney suburb, owning a high-performance foreign car, headed by a father who was an architect and who had a computer at home on his desk(!). It dealt not with issues of social-justice such as in the 1930s “Grapes of Wrath”, but rather with the family dynamics and assorted personal pains of the perfect-toothed individual members of this ‘ordinary’ family. It was considered very ‘sensitive’ and ‘insightful’; it was clearly a work of therapeutic insight rather than of traditional American economic and class insight.

In 1980, with Reagan’s election, O’Neill declared ‘bipartisanship’ to be the Democrats’ primary value; any ‘opposition’ in affairs foreign or domestic would be in essence suppressed, although some harrumphing and braying would be occasionally made in order to keep up appearances.

In the mid-‘80s the Savings-and-Loan scandal suddenly revealed massive financial malfeasance by major elements of the banking and entrepreneurial community, despite the existence of government regulations and regulators. Billions in taxpayer funds went to clean up the mess. Adults started to show up in jobs that had been traditionally taken by teens for pocket money.

In the mid-‘80s the ‘pre-school sex abuse’ mania started up; numerous children were believed to be sexually abused by day-care center providers around the nation, and many children ‘testified’ thus after leading and manipulative questioning by self-termed ‘experts’ and assorted law-enforcement personnel. Only when children reported adults in dragon suits and other exotic garb and some ‘raped’ children were found to be intact did things slow down, and many of the convicted were then exonerated and released from years of confinement. No significant connection was made between the newly-popular day-care centers and the national explosion of the number of families where both parents now had to work in order to make ends meet or for other reasons, or single-parent families where the parent had no other alternative but day-care. The numbers of abused tykes were said to be in the hundreds of thousands, perhaps – it was put forth – millions.

In 1985 one Lenore Weitzman, in her book about divorce "The Divorce Revolution, asserted that post-divorce men experienced a 73% increase in income while women (and the children, since custody was almost always awarded to the woman) experienced a 42% decrease. Questions immediately arose as to her figures and her research notes, which she refused for quite a long time to make available for scientific examination and corroboration. It was later discovered, after she finally had to make her research notes public, that she had used an absurdly small population (228 couples in Los Angeles) and had, among other things, failed to include costs to the man including alimony, child support, mortgage payments on the house that he no longer lived in. Despite that her figures continued to be used, she was invited by feminist advocates to address state legislatures, her figures were cited in appeals court decisions, and in 1996 – fully exposed – she was yet invited by Bill Clinton to speak in Washington. Not only ‘facts’, but accuracy and truth, no longer mattered, even to courts and legislators.**

In 1987 the Tawana Brawley case held public attention: a missing black teen was found smeared with excrement and scantily clothed; she claimed to have been abducted and raped by several white males, among whom were law enforcement figures. Al Sharpton among others raised the case up into national consciousness, with an eager media providing the public exposure.When it was finally discovered to be a hoax devised to cover the girl’s absence from home, Politically Correct opinion, led by Sharpton and Jesse Jackson, insisted that it didn’t make any difference whether she was actually raped or not since the most important element of the matter was its symbolism in calling attention to ‘white male oppression’. Naturally, the 'numbers' of such oppressive incidents was said to be stratospheric.

In 1988 in the Persian Gulf a state-of-the-art radar system on one of the Navy’s newest cruisers shot down an Iranian passenger jet, killing all aboard. It turned out that the system, hugely expensive, was only designed to distinguish between assorted military targets, and could not distinguish civilian from military aircraft, even though the civilian craft was transponding its identity. The crew of the cruiser did not want to override the computer’s assessment of the situation and fired the missile. If there was a lesson to be learned about thinking very carefully and conducting careful analysis before sending military forces into situations other than outright war, that lesson was not learned.

In 1990, in August, Saddam Hussein, the US protégé in the Iran-Iraq war, invaded Kuwait to shore up his ailing finances which had been sorely depleted by the eight-year war against the Iranians. While the US provided the bulk of the forces sent against him, public concern about US inability to foot the bill for such a large operation was allayed when other large economies, the Japanese among them, offered to pay for the operations in lieu of sending large military contingents. In the military equivalent of a fairy-tale scenario, Saddam obligingly kept his forces locked into static position, taking no action whatsoever, as the US took months to assemble the bulk of its Army and support forces and position them perfectly (a replay of the French Army doing nothing as the Germans prepared their next move in the Sitzkrieg of 1939-1940 on the Western Front). Saddam’s important role in the ensuing American victory was never recognized.

In 1991 the USSR dissolved itself, ending the Cold War.

In 1992 in Planned Parenthood v. Casey the Supreme Court continued the legal fiction that a woman’s grounds for abortion could include health grounds; the criteria for ‘health’ might extend to include nothing more serious than a desire not to carry the developing fetus to term. Acknowledging the weakness of Roe’s legal reasoning, the Court nonetheless refused to overturn that case with its basis in flawed legal reasoning because many women had come to depend on the advantages that Roe afforded them. The fetus would have no right (or reason) to depend on the women, apparently.

In 1993 Bill Clinton took office.

Throughout the early ‘90s, ‘business’ changed: rather than a number of older, more experienced adults running businesses that produced goods, younger hotshots simply ‘acquired’ new businesses in an leveraged buy-outs, not because they knew how to or even intended to produce goods, but simply to reap the revenues generated by effecting the acquisition and buyout transactions. Rather than take this as a symptom of something going fundamentally wrong in the economy, ‘experts’ declared that this was an entirely new type of ‘economy’, one based on F.I.R.E (finance, insurance, real estate) rather than on producing tradable goods for the domestic and world markets. This new economy would not require ‘masculine’ skills like the ‘old’ industrial goods-producing economy, but instead would be a push-button, conference and negotiation and transactional paperwork economy, producing ‘ideas’ rather than goods, and requiring only a knowledge-class and a service-class, thereby keeping ‘the women’ happy since the new ‘work’ would not be ‘masculine’, and setting the fate of many of the new immigrants who would provide the cleaning, delivery, and nanny services. Neither the Democrats nor the Republicans took exception.

In the early 1990s a disturbing number of studies began to find that the majority of domestic violence initiators were the female of the dyad, a fact not refuted but shouted-down by relevant advocates. It was not noted that there was a disturbing similarity to a standard Israeli publicity gambit of not refuting facts but rather disparaging the researchers or those who had the temerity to raise unpleasant and inconvenient facts. At this time, Naomi Wolf in her book “The Bonding Myth” asserted that 150,000 females a year died of anorexia, a ‘fact’ repeated by Gloria Steinem and numerous others. A check of Center for Disease Control figures revealed that in 1983 101 deaths from anorexia were reported, 67 in 1988, and 54 in 1991. After much shouting-down, the advocates then asserted that “up to 70” deaths were misdiagnosed as ‘heart failure’, leaving un-addressed the remaining 149, 500-odd asserted ‘deaths’. Pressed for her basis for the numbers, one advocate refused, claiming that the figures were “for the guidance of advocates” and apparently nobody else’s business – although it was the advocates who had taken public the number “150,000” in the first place.

Huge numbers were now being thrown out into the public forum, and used as a basis for laws and court cases, by legislators and judges, although they appeared to be completely fabricated and their advocates refused to make their research and methods public. I repeat here what I have said on this site before: Bush and Cheney must have looked at all this and figured, in 2001, that the entire spectrum of American culture – public, legislators, judges, media, intellectual elites and academics – would accept just about any numbers or assertions that were placed before them – with consequences We are now seeing, in blood, death, and destruction, including thousands of soldiers, and untold hundreds of thousands of civilians, mostly women and children. And the squandering of America’s moral capital in the world community. And the squandering of hundreds of billions – probably two trillions and more – of dollars that We cannot afford.

And in 1994, the ‘Violence Against Women Act’ – part of a larger crime bill – was passed, thereby involving the police power of the government in the very hearths of the citizenry; it was based on the fear that many persons, particularly women, felt in relationships that they themselves participated in or even initiated. Parts of the Act were later found to be unconstitutional; Joe Biden, a major supporter of the Bill and Act, had defended it even before the court challenges, claiming that “it may be a bad law but it sends a great message”.

In 1996 the rare outrage of a child’s abduction by a sexually deranged adult resulted in the explosion of the sex-offender laws, whose requirements for Soviet-style ‘registration’ and Chinese-Communist-style psychiatric confinement were justified on the basis of the legal fiction that they were not ‘punitive’ but only ‘administrative’, ‘rehabilitative’ and in the service of public safety. Lincoln’s observation came to mind: in response to Southerners who claimed that slavery was ‘good’, he observed that this was a most unusual and extraordinary ‘good’ that nobody wanted for themselves but that they were most desirous to see imposed on others. It was not noted that the whole mania coincided with the large number of children not under the direct care of their both-working parents or single-parent for long periods of time during the day or evening. Nor were local-media discoveries as to the misrepresentation perpertated by the initial set of parents allowed to interfere; nor were the huge 'numbers' provided provided by 'advocates' subjected to analysis.

In 1996 Bill Clinton signed the Telecommunications Act which, among other things, allowed a few large single owners to control numerous media outlets. He also, as noted above, hosted the discredited Lenore Weitzman in Washington.

In 1999, Bill Clinton signed the Act repealing the restrictions imposed by the post-Depression Glass-Steagall Act. With the industrial base gone, the pols on Capitol Hill had no ‘economy’ to keep the citizenry ‘happy’ and found themselves completely beholden to the economic elites to provide even the semblance of an economy.

In late 2000, the Supreme Court intervened on the flimsiest of legal fictions (a gambit at which it was proving quite adept and experienced) in the Presidential election and by stopping a crucial recount, effectively created George W. Bush as the winner and next President.

On September 11, 2001 airline hijackers, primarily Saudi, destroyed the WTC towers in Manhattan. Although the performance of all responsible agencies of the Federal Government – from the FBI and CIA to the Presidency itself – was hugely dubious, the public’s attention was distracted by the President’s immediate erection of a Global War on Terror. As part of his hugely enhanced powers as a reputed ‘war President’, which were then further declared to be limitless by the workings of a quasi-monarchical theory called the “Unitary Executive”, Bush ensured that public opinion would not only be distracted but its access to information about the workings of the government and Administration suppressed.

In 2002, the now unregulated F.I.R.E sector created a Bubble based on shuffling around packages of far too easily-granted mortgages. The citizenry was distracted happily by a huge expansion of domestic credit based on the ever-increasing ‘value’ of their mortgaged homes. The coincidence between the sudden ‘wealth’ enjoyed by citizens of all classes and the distraction from both the investigation of the 9-11 failures and the monitoring of the war then being brewed inside the Beltway was not widely noted. An economy now hugely diminished in its productive industrial goods-making capacities, yet required to provide employment not only for males but for females and increasing numbers of immigrants, had reached the point where it was simply creating ‘wealth’ based on a bubble willfully conjured by financiers and – I have to believe – knowingly abetted by A) a Congress that had no effective plans of its own and didn’t really want that fact widely discussed and B) an Executive that simply wanted the public distracted from investigating either its past malfeasances or its present plans for aggressive invasive war.

In 2003 an invasion of Iraq was effected on what proved to be false pretenses of WMD, although from the very beginning the possibility of the secularist dictator Saddam Hussein being in cahoots with religious fundamentalists seeking to erect theocratic government was hugely dubious on its face. It was then claimed that the purpose of the invasion was to bring ‘democracy’ to Iraq, although if invasive war is a preferred method of instituting ‘democracy’, then there were a large number of regimes in need of change whose overthrow would have been far less militarily complex than Iraq’s.

But no other country in the Middle East or anywhere else provided what an Occupied Iraq could provide: a ‘place at the table’ in the now-crucial oil-heartlands of the planet / for a seriously declining hegemon with huge international debt and no means of ever paying it off / and an unslakable thirst for cheap oil in a world where the increasing demands of developing national economies much closer to that oil would only drive up the price / and with a perennially besieged ‘ally’ state in the Middle East erected through invasive force and violence, supported in the interests of the hegemon’s domestic politics, that was in desperate need of decisive strategic support / and a perfect political ‘cover’ for its ‘Griff Nach der Ol-Macht’ in the confluence of Rightist and Fundamentalist ‘patriotism’ and so-called ‘liberal’ “humanitarian intervention” and the applied merits of the public’s rage and ‘pain’ over the 9-11 attacks .

And on top of that, the Bubble created by the mortgages wouldn’t last forever and then what to tell the American citizenry? Tell them that the last 40 years of the government’s stewardship had resulted in a fractious domestic cultural civil war fueled by vastly untruthful figures and driven by crass political expediency that had effectively balkanized and dumbed-down the citizenry and prevented its operating as The People, to the detriment of an economy whose decline was then ignored by the stewards and hidden from the public, which was itself distracted first by those core cultural controversies and then by blizzards of unsecured ‘credit’ that lured vast numbers of citizens into a Little Big Horn of personal debt while blissfully imagining that America’s winning streak would not only last but increase?

The key to saving the whole game would be a quick and decisive victory in Iraq – ‘victory’ defined as beheading the Iraqi government and creating for all intents and purposes an American protectorate or ‘wholly owned allied government’ that would put the patina of legality on that marvelous strategic possession of the Iraqi oil that would solve all the Beltway’s problems – foreign, domestic, financial - in a single stroke. Maybe Iran could then be taken – that would make things even better and would keep the Israeli ‘ally’ happy, the Israel whose PACs provided the perfect conduit to kick back to the pols taxpayer cash that the pols had originally sent to Israel to begin with. What was not to like?

In 2009, with the quick and decisive victory bungled away (if indeed it were ever possible to begin with), and the economic Bubble having burst and the citizenry reduced to a level of risk which it was not fitted to handle well, and Iran now in a far stronger position relative to the much-diminished former hegemon, the Beltway has few options: since it absolutely must retain a place – some place – ‘at the table’ for the indefinite future, then Afghanistan is left as the only usable pretext. However, with no ‘victory’ (an impossible outcome in any event) in Afghanistan capable of being strategically decisive as to the control of oil, and with the prospects of continued military dominance on the world stage starting to fade perceptibly, then the US will have to find a way to make the rest of the world respect its power – or else be reduced to a regional power itself, and possibly a bankrupt one. Afghanistan offers no strategic answers, but provides a temporary excuse for staying around in the neighborhood until – as Mr. Micawber might say – something ‘turns up’. Uncle Sam is now Mr. Micawber. That can’t be good.

The ‘Global War On Terror’ was a fiendishly clever justification for what the Beltway knew the US was now going to have to become in any case: a bankrupt former-hegemon resorting to world-class, world-wide strong-arming and hold-ups to keep up appearances and the payments on all its stuff. But I don’t think that the Beltway ever imagined it would fail so badly on the very first phase of its plan. That’s the Beltway’s fault: no odds-maker in Las Vegas would ever have given good odds for the Plan anyway – which is part of the reason it was all so hush-hush.

That, and the fact that the Beltway has been planning the type of thing that Imperial Japan and post-Weimar Germany paid terribly for having done. (Also that bald Italian guy with the great set of uniforms.)

And the US must resurrect its industrial, goods-producing capacity, and will have to single-mindedly focus all national attention on that project so as to achieve it (or re-achieve it, alas) as soon as possible. This is not a case of ‘turning back the clock’ but rather as coming back onto the solid roadway from a feckless, witless, half-addled foray off the road into the ‘shortcut’ of a swamp.

This will be hard to do without having to disarm the ‘outrage’ of the Advocacies that their several ‘revolutions’ are being ‘sold out’. It will risk having to admit that a great deal if not most of the ‘creative destruction’ – culturally even more than financially – of the past several decades has been greatly mistaken; hugely fraught with lethally negative consequences if not actually a mostly baaad idea from the get-go. It will take consummate political skill to manipulate events so as to prevent such a showdown and such a bald statement of fact. As things stand now, We desperately need facts, while We also desperately need to avoid being distracted by facts.

The solution will be to keep the focus on the actually important facts rather than on the symbolically important facts. At this stage, this will require skills long-neglected among the citizenry, the media, and the government Branches themselves: dealing with the Actual instead of the Symbolic.

All in all, the intentional use of fear, outrage / through the use of hugely dishonest assertions and numbers / to create ‘emergencies’ of various sorts / that can stampede the citizenry / into acquiescing in the most dangerous expansions of government power / aided and abetted by a media that both avoids substantial and skeptical analysis and indulges in partisan coverage tailored to its owners’ calculations of their best corporate interests / while the citizenry allows itself to be distracted from its crucial task of functioning as The People / while considerations of Party and personal advancement overwhelm any responsibility legislators and public officials might feel for ensuring first and foremost the common weal …

These, I would say, are the highlights of what has gone wrong.

Obama can’t solve all of this, and certainly not overnight. Nor can every interest can get what it wants, and even if he is going to give one or another ‘interest’ something that it wants, he’s not going to be able to say so clearly. This is going to upset the Advocacies who are used to being pandered to; the wealthy and the corporate interests who are used to getting their cash in the form of financial and tax legislation while they make whatever money is left to be made on what’s left of the economy; the PAC contributors who are used to getting what they have paid for; and the media who are not used to having to think things through to figure out what’s really going on and where things are really headed.

I don’t know how much time We have left afloat, but watching all these folks try to deal with the new world order of 2009 should provide much food for thought and meditation.

I’m still going with supporting Obama as he picks his way through this vast and intricate minefield, the one that We have been sowing for decades now. If he can’t do it … there won’t be any real chance left.

NOTES

*There were other Identities among the replacement demographics: gays, lesbians, and the disabled and the elderly are notable among them. By 2000, We were a nation indeed more solicitous of ‘creativity’ and ‘sensitivity’ than of ‘productivity’ – as Bateson had hoped would happen as far back as 1990 (see the immediately previous Post).

You have to ask yourself what Congress was thinking when it allowed – indeed abetted – such an assault not only on the national ethos and culture but also on the very heart and soul of national ‘productivity’. In fact, it might be accurate to imagine that the ‘outsourcing’ of jobs did not precede, but rather was enabled by, the general assault on the culture of productivity and those who for the entire life of the nation had provided it – the workers, supported indispensably by the institutions of marriage and family.

If so, then the assault on the ‘work ethic’ and on ‘men’ in general, resulted in consequences that were treacherously evaded by A) creating the supremely fatuous fantasy of a world-hegemon supporting itself on merely on ‘knowledge and ideas’ and ‘service’ rather than the production of marketable goods; and B) creating a ‘substitute’ economy – a bubble economy – that provided the ‘appearance’ of economic competency and wealth even though the actual bases for such competence and wealth were eroding, and eroding under the pressure of a Beltway-supported ‘war’ against what the Identities were pleased to call “the dominant culture”.

So many turkeys are now come home to roost: the ‘valorizing’ of ‘symbolic’ over ‘real’, of appearances over fact, of the narrowly and baldly political over the common weal, of political gain and power over truth and truthfulness. And in all of this, the utter evasion of consequences, from the simple consequence of having to conform one’s actions to proven facts to the abyssally more challenging consequences of having to face up to the wreck after so much damage has been done by willfully ignoring facts and truth – to lives and to nations (including Our own), such that only the most sustained spiritual maturity and strength can bear up to the duties now required.

**For a stunning and comprehensive compilation of such dubious figures and assertions, and how even when finally exposed they were still retained as valid in public and elite discourse, see the combined 1200 pages of investigation and analysis in Paul Nathanson and Katherine K. Young’s two books “Spreading Misandry” (2001) and “Legalizing Misandry” (2006), published by McGill-Queen’s University Press. Jean Bethke Elshtain's review of the latter is here.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,