Saturday, May 07, 2011

ALCOHOLICS AND BALLERINAS

I came across a remark made by an alcoholic in a treatment-program that operates housing in which the patients are allowed to drink (which is probably a Post all its own): asked if this ‘permission’ to drink was really helping him in his life, he shrugged winsomely and replied “ballerinas dance, alcoholics drink”.

There is a huge and treacherous gap in the reasoning under that comment. I’d like to look at it, since it may not be visible to the naked eye and certainly not to generations whose only training in getting beyond appearances and surfaces has been to ‘suspect oppression’.

Specifically, I want to look at the way recent political convenience in this country (and throughout the developed nations of the West) has required doing very serious damage to the entire task of growing up as a competent human being with a reasonable chance of success at sustaining one’s life as a human being.

To do this, I am going to look at Chapter 5 of Alasdair MacIntyre’s book “After Virtue”.* The Chapter itself is entitled ‘Why the Enlightenment Project Justifying Morality Had to Fail’.

Even such Enlightenment luminaries as Kant, Hume, Smith, Diderot and (in the next century) Kierkegaard, dwelt in the afterglow of the Medieval Christian synthesis and can be seen – whether they realized it or not – as “inheritors” of that remarkable tradition and its achievements.

Specifically, they all agreed to great extent upon “the character of morality” and upon “what a rational justification of morality would have to be”.

The vital basis here would be – as the Medieval Synthesis coherently and clearly dealt with – that A) there are essential features of human nature and thus that B) you can use your reason to work out from that nature what is moral and what is not. (This is just on the philosophical level; leave ‘God and religion’ out of it for the moment.)

By the time of the Enlightenment the Conductor had been dismissed and the individual players were coming up with their own interpretations of the score: Diderot and Hume figured that “the passions” were the essence of human beings; Kant thought that it was the human capacity for “reason” and for the “universal and categorical character of certain rules of reason” that all humans would by the workings of their natural reason have to accept; Kierkegaard thought that whether passions or reason, the fundamental human characteristic and ‘nature’ was the ability to “make a decision”.

MacIntyre (and I agree with him) judges that the entire Enlightenment project went off the rails at just this point and from then on has never had a chance to get where it originally hoped to go.

This is important for Us today because the Enlightenment Project was crucial in birthing ‘secularism’, the thought that the world and its affairs can get along very well without any Beyond or any Above or even any Deep Purpose coming from somewhere within the human or material realm. And it is this Enlightenment-generated secularism which has been taken up – for political more than for philosophical reasons – as the Correct understanding of what humans and existence are all about, and how they operate. More on that in a bit.

Aristotle in his day had come to the conclusion that everything has a function or a purpose (the Greek is ‘telos’, the adjective in English is ‘teleological’). And that once you understood the function/purpose, then you could get on with figuring out ‘morality’: whatever contributed to the function/purpose was moral, and whatever didn’t wasn’t.

But he was a shrewd enough observer of things and people to realize that just because something ‘is’ doesn’t mean that it is automatically the best instance of its kind that it can possibly be. A plow may be a good plow or a bad plow depending upon whether it is able to successfully and effectively perform the function of plowing. (Indeed, it almost goes without saying that when you say ‘plow’ you automatically presume the further judgment or evaluation as to whether it’s a  ‘good’ plow or a ‘bad’ plow, since it seems to be an ineradicable characteristic of life in this world that things do not always function as well as they might.)

Thus, Aristotle saw, there is in this world a profound and essential difference between a thing-as-it-happens-to-be and a thing-as-it-should-be.

And, of course, the same goes for human beings: there is a profound and essential difference between a human-being-as-s/he-is and a human-being-as-s/he-ought-to-be. Ethics, then, would be the organized knowledge that would help a human being achieve that “transition” from ‘is’ to ‘ought’.

Once, for example, you say a person is a ‘sea captain’ you automatically presume the next level of analysis: good sea-captain or bad sea-captain? Meaning: does this individual competently and effectively fulfill the tasks that go with being a sea-captain?

In the 12th century the Medieval Christian synthesis took the philosophy of the newly-rediscovered Aristotle and blended it with Christian religion: the ‘function’ of the human being was blended with the ‘nature’ and ‘vocation’ of the human being as a being created in the image and likeness of God, whose ‘function’ was (in the terms made famous by the Baltimore Catechism) to “know, love and serve God”. (You might think that this formulation leaves more than enough leeway not to seem ‘oppressive’, but let’s not get ahead of ourselves here.)

And so too, in the Medieval Synthesis human morality and ethics then receive the weight not only of reason and philosophy but also of Divine Law. But then again, if it is law designed to help achieve the function and fulfill the purpose, then it’s kind of helpful law. Sort of like the law written in big red letters that all pilots must always and everywhere and under all circumstances obey regardless of anything else whatsoever: do not attempt to fly this aircraft in reverse. Bad things – very bad things – will happen if you do. And not just because God, perhaps in a bad or ‘oppressive’ mood, has decided to impose a penalty; rather, because such an act is profoundly contrary to the functioning principles of the aircraft.

But the core dynamic here is not ‘religious’ in origin but ‘philosophical’ and rather clearly deploys the human ability to reason and think plus astute observations and conclusions drawn from those observations – which is not a bad simulacrum of the Scientific Method.

And so, in order to figure out your ‘ethics’ and ‘morality’ you have to have a solid grasp on the nature and purpose and function of the human being. You can’t just have an ‘ethics’ without any knowledge of the ‘function’, any more than you could figure out your position in space without a set of core coordinates upon which all subsequent calculations are based.

So with Aristotle (with the addition of the religious and theological level in the 12th century A.D.) you have for humans a triple-component schematic: human-nature-as-it-happens-to-be is initially unable to achieve complete congruity with human-nature-as-it-ought-to-be, and so needs to be helped to make the transition to genuine fulfillment and functioning through morality and ethics and practical reason.

You have an initially incongruent human-nature-as-it-happens-to-be; you have rational rules and precepts that can be taught and learned (and thus the skills mastered with practice until they are habitual); and you have human-nature-as-it-ought-to-be (which you can work toward throughout your life, since nobody seems to ever become perfect at it).

In a relevant aside, I’d note that Christian thought took that ‘initial incongruence’ that Aristotle noticed – the one between ‘is’ and ‘ought’ – and developed it into the concept of Original Sin or Original Sinfulness, which is not a specific sinful act but rather a predisposition to act in such a way as to degrade your purpose and nature as a human being (rational being created in the image and likeness of God).

So throughout the period of the Medieval Synthesis, to say that somebody ought to do something was to say that doing that something would enhance the function and progress of that person toward achieving the true purpose of his-her human nature.

Curiously, it was the Protestant Reformers and their still-Catholic Jansenist contemporaries who tossed out Aristotle and emphasized ‘God’s will’ as if the whole matter of ethics and morality were simply a matter of us human kids having to do what daddy wanted no matter what he said. Which wasn’t – and isn’t – the case at all.

There is no place for ‘reason’, said Calvin, since reason – along with every other human capability – was contaminated by the Fall. Only God’s grace can save you (and that depended very much on whether Calvin’s God was in a good mood or not).

Worse, Blaise Pascal – who in many ways was an astute observer of things and life – was also a man who admired the newly-developing Science of the era, and decided that since Science cannot reach conclusions about the non-material aspects of existence (about, say, human nature or purpose) then no other form of mode of reason (such as philosophical reason) could do so either. (Which is akin to saying that if several blind men each come up with a different description of the elephant, then the elephant cannot provably exist.)

So by the time of the Enlightenment in the 18th century those folks had inherited only incoherent fragments of a once coherent explanatory system. They were incoherent because you cannot start with different assorted notions of what human nature and purpose is, and expect to come up with a universally valid idea of what ethics and morality must be. If, for example, the flight schools each had different definitions of what an aircraft is, and how powered-flight works, then it would be impossible to achieve a coherent and comprehensive (and working) mastery of a pilot’s job. (And if the government, eager for the votes of pilots and potential pilots, insisted that that was OK and that all the graduates should be allowed to get into the left-hand seat anyway … well, let’s not get ahead of things here.)

The great symphony of the Medieval Synthesis now not only had no Conductor, but its assorted players and instruments were not even working off the same sheet of music. You would pay money to listen to that?

You can imagine what would happen if a human civilization and society and culture lost any firm or coherent grip on just what the nature and purpose of a human being is. If, that is to say, it suddenly was ‘no longer clear on the concept’. Would you fly an airline that hired pilots who weren’t clear on the concept of powered flight? Or who had been trained to think that there may be many concepts of powered flight and ‘rules’ for one school’s pilots might be merely ‘irrational presumptions’ for another school’s pilots? (The aircraft, and the rules of aerodynamics, after all, remain stubbornly real, regardless of the various pilots’ education – or lack of it.)

The Modern Age – and the ‘modernist’ approach to philosophy, literature, art and religion – reflect this massive gelatinous fluidity that had suddenly been injected into the foundations of the West. Things get confused, and a mushy profusion of possible ‘concepts’ about ‘the human’ pop up like kudzu. It is certainly possible, and the Age insisted upon it, that all this booming and buzzing confusion was actually a ‘creative’ profusion, a celebration of pluralism (as they like to say nowadays).

But then, there are places where it isn’t such a great idea to be unclear on the concept, or to have many concepts seeking to operate all at once, or where some concepts even insist that there can be no concepts at all. The pilot who claims that his way is fine regardless of whether any other pilots agree with him is going to have you sharing the skies with some might unpleasant possibilities.

Some things need a sort of coherent and reliable and sustained stability – foundations, say, or fundamental concepts about essential realities that have immediate consequences on life and history. That sort of thing.

But if things were queasily mushy and fluid in the Modernist Age, they went right off the rails in the Postmodernist Age.

And I’d say that there could have been no Postmodern Age without the assistance of the Beltway, or – in the initial phase – the Democrats who in the very early 1970s embraced radical feminism (which is quite a different thing from ‘feminism’ or ‘women’) whole-hog in a desperate bid to win huge numbers of votes to replace those lost with the break-up of the old New Deal coalition of Northern and Southern elements of the Party.

If radical feminism was an ‘interest group’ it was also a hell of a lot more than that. It was an Identity, claiming the clear and certain boundaries of sex: every woman was a member (whether she knew it or not, wanted to be or not) of their Movement; it had an agenda that was not only ‘revolutionary’ in Method (only the vanguard cadres, those who ‘get it’, have the right to control power), but was also ‘revolutionary’ in Agenda: what they wanted, pretty much, was for the US government to erase any and all practices, traditions, culture arrangements, or societal arrangements, which in any way gave ‘men’ more ‘freedom’ than women (which could only have come about in the first place if said women were ‘oppressed’ by men through the evil Patriarchy).**

I don’t know if the Dems of the day back then really knew what they were doing, or whether they simply tossed everything out in a fit of absence of mind (or electoral anxiety and greed). But before too very long it became clear that in order to give this new Identity everything it demanded, large chunks of some very basic structural elements of American and Western civilization would have to be ripped out and tossed: the Family; Marriage (in any recognizable traditional form); the concept of there being a ‘right way’ and a ‘wrong way’ to go about doing politics or even to go about being a person and conducting a human life.

And – they were nothing if not logical, these gimlet-eyed cadres – the very definition of human life.Women, the cadres had discovered, were always ground-zero for getting stuck with babies after sex, which could only be the result of the patriarchy of Western civilization and proof-positive that the Beltway must release them from their oppression. Which oppression, they insisted, did not begin until birth and which was nobody’s business but their personal own what they did with the ‘result’ of a sexual encounter with somebody, including any irrelevant entity such as the husband with whom the aforementioned sex had been had.

The government, in all its Branches, had to find a way to approve; political arithmetic alone demanded it. And in putting the weight of its authority (and its purse) behind the whole shebang, an incoherent bundle of corrosive and unprovable speculations, accusations, assertions and dampdreams – that would otherwise have remained in that far corner of faculty dining room behind the plastic ferns populated by the tenured but crazed true-believers in this or that bit of crackpottery – became the cutting edge and very officially Correct policy of the planetary hegemon and the self-proclaimed victorious protector of Western civilization against the crazed cadres of the Communist East.

But Western civilization, and its morality and its ethics, had been built on the Greek Aristotelian and Medieval Synthesis, and American culture was influenced by that still-powerful afterglow, since even the 18th century Enlightenment thinkers, for all their confusions, still believed that a) human beings had a nature and a purpose, b) human reason could figure out that nature and purpose and thus that morality and ethics, and that c) in such a way civilization and culture could somehow go on helping train the young how to get from as-you-happen-to-be to how-you-ought-to-be.

This was part of the warp and woof of the basic fabric of the thing. You could no more start just ripping stuff out than you could decide to quickly alter the foundations of a 100-story skyscraper after it was opened and fully occupied; or pull out and change the engines of an ocean liner while it was at sea with passengers aboard; or rip out a pound of flesh from a living body without also pulling out a whole lot of fluids and attached viscera thingies at the same time (even Shakespeare realized that couldn’t be done).

But the new Identity (theoretically controlling – though it has never been proven – a magical 52 percent of the electorate) needed much to be gotten rid of – and quickly.

There could be no ‘human nature’ because they needed the ‘space’ to redefine cultural arrangements; there could be no ethics or morality because they were planning on a lot of things being declared right and good that would otherwise have been though wrong and bad; there could be no purpose to human beings because they planned on trying out all sorts of stuff that might not work – but as long as there is no ‘purpose’ anyway, then who could say it didn’t work right?

And there couldn’t be any rival system that could stand up and remind everybody that what was being demanded – and dutifully provided by the Beltway – was incoherent and quite possibly unworkable and rather probably harmful to most of the human beings who would – willingly or otherwise – find themselves mixed up in it.

So philosophy – at least the way the Aristotle used to do it – and religion – the way the Catholics used to do it – had to somehow be tossed, or at least undermined. Aristotle was a Dead White European Male and Catholic priests had other problems with males, especially younger ones, and so the values of the Synthesis must be bad because of it.

And Science itself had to be twisted into service. In the current ‘Times Literary Supplement’*** the reviewer traces out how the biological sciences are now struggling to conform to Correctness: under no circumstances, even in studies of Evolution, must any reference to be made to ‘purpose’ or ‘teleology’. Nor is there any narrative or overriding conceptual ‘story’ as to how things happen; stuff just happens. Nor can there be any reference to Mind instead of Matter; it’s too dangerous because if there is any Mind in Nature then you get a God or a Purpose that might get in the way of the Movement’s Agenda.

There is only Matter, and whatever it does, it does randomly and without plan – since really, there is no ‘it’ there to do anything and the stuff just happens. And so, also, you can’t get an ‘ought’ from ‘is’ – there is no connecting medium, what is happens randomly and without consciousness, so you just have to deal with it (how convenient).

So if you want to keep your eligibility to receive grants and get invited to the big-venue conferences, then you’d better stay away from the deep end of the pool and paddle around in the Correct end. Thus there is an eager and expensive search for the primal and irreducible agents of history and progress, little monads of Matter that somehow are the only things driving all history, animate and inanimate, human and animal. (Although even if you were to find one of these asserted thingies, you’d then have to try to explain how it can combine with gajillions of others of its kind into the amazingly complex life-forms that are in evidence all over the shop here, and still remain Mind-less and utterly random … but to Correct Science, this is already thinking too much.)

The gene has been put forth as the new Final Frontier that will explain everything Correctly (or at least without endangering the Rube Goldberg machine that Correctness is enforced to protect). But there is no such discrete thingie as ‘the gene’ that somehow accounts for ‘everything’. The term is used  as a shorthand term to deal with the assorted bits of information, but it is not “the sole motor” of evolution.

And even if it were to exist as merely carrying ‘information’ then what is the intelligible structure which that information conveys and transmits? Oops, any talk of ‘intelligible structure’, like Rawls’s aversion to ‘overarching narratives’, is taboo. Verboten. Nyet. And etcetera and etcetera and etcetera.

But it is not only asserted to be the radical individual thingie that (so curiously and conveniently) reflects the radically independent sole-motor ‘New Woman’ of the radical-feminist cadres’ consciousness-raising. It is also a ‘selfish’ gene – existing in the primordial authority of the most basic level of being merely upon its own authority, which authority it also then deploys ‘selfishly’, and thus also so curiously and conveniently reflecting the radically-independent I-can-abort-if-I-please ‘New Woman’ who - according to the Correct philosophy - doesn’t have to care about anybody other than herself.

But, as the review notes, if there is any intelligent information being conveyed, then “the whole concept of ‘mindless matter’ is unsustainable”. Because intelligence automatically implies consciousness. And if there is consciousness in the universe then … well, you aren’t going to be getting any more major grants if you put that in writing.

In fact, you could make a very good case that intelligence automatically gets you involved not only with ‘consciousness’ but with ‘self-consciousness’.

In which case the Universe is not so much driven by Matter but by Consciousness, or Mind.  

And in fact, some physicists are beginning to wonder if rather than say that “consciousness is a property of matter” it is more accurate to envision “matter is a property of consciousness”  - and take a moment to roll that one around. It echoes the ancient conception of the body being in the soul, rather than the soul being in the body. But in any case whatsoever, none of it is Correct.

And while many biologists are trying to worm their way out of the evolution-and-Correctness mess by trying to become more like the really really serious and hard scientists such as physicists, who are reputed to have the clearest idea of just what the ‘fundamentals’ of It All are, yet today “physics itself has become spectacularly critical of any sort of atomism or ‘monadology’” – the physicists, that is to say, are no longer trying to reduce It All to one little material thingie that does all the work with none of the complications of Consciousness, Spirit, Purpose, Nature, or any of the other not-Correct stuff.

Worse, physicists today “are far more receptive to the idea that if anything is ‘fundamental’, it has to be consciousness”.

To the cadres of Correctness (among whom, I am going to imagine, are many recipients of this or that prize for making ‘feminist’ contributions to this or that science) this can only be gall and wormwood. They had been working toward Lysenko-izing American science: ensuring that scientists understood that in the New Order, scientists would first determine what it was they were supposed to ‘discover’, and THEN make sure that their experiments and observations ‘discovered’ it. And nothing else. Or else.

Now it turns out that Science itself, which they had been counting upon as a useful idiot, if not an ally, has started discovering that the reality of the universe is not necessarily set up to moisten the dampdreams of the cadres.  

Which can only pose a threat to the (incredible) credibility of the Post-Modernist and radically feminist Correctness regime. The scam,  in best revolutionary fashion, was to seize control of the government (accomplished when vote-desperate Dems started signing blank checks to the Revolution, and then all the Beltway pols and bureaucrats got in on the game). Having achieved that, the cadres got regulations and laws passed that made it much easier to get more of their number into key educational  institutions, where they began ‘discovering’ stuff that (so conveniently) ‘proved’ the rightness and need of the Revolution. Simultaneously getting into bureaucracies, more regulations were passed. More ‘research’ and ‘discoveries’ were made.

It was all done in a very ‘scientific’ manner, because this was a cutting-edge Revolution that was based on ‘facts’ (although it also claimed that ‘facts don’t matter’) and ‘reality’ and not on stupid old abstractions and mystifications thought up in the service of oppression by eons of Dead White European Males and their whacko male Sky-God.

Science, it was hoped, would now continue its usefulness by finally destroying the last vestiges of  any sort of a universe whose evolved order might in any way limit, boundary, or otherwise interfere with the total autonomy of the Revolution’s New Woman. 

Science would do that by showing that the evolved universe is nothing but Matter interacting with itself randomly: no Purpose, no Meaning, no Nature of anything (including humans), no God, no Natural Law, no Natural Order … nothing that could stand in judgment on, or give any voter a rational ground to base a judgment against, anything that any totally autonomous New Woman and the Revolution might wish to do.

The idea, you might notice, was not lost upon Bush-Cheney and the rightist whackjobs like John Yoo, who quickly saw that if the New Left was going to rip the country and the Constitution apart in the service of the agenda of New Woman (Womyn?) then the New Right could rip the country and the Constitution apart in the service of total autonomy for government. And who could argue that there wasn’t a certain neat, almost photogenic, symmetry in that?  And since the New Left relied on government power to impose its agenda on the Citizenry, and the New Right was planning to use government power to sidestep Constitutional limits and deploy military forces overseas, then the total autonomy of government had something to like for the two biggest Mobs in the Beltway. Such a deal!

Now, however, Science is beginning to realize that things can’t be as simple in the real world as the political schemes of the bosses would like it to be. American science, that is to say, is discovering what Soviet science had learned long before: when science is subordinated to political schemes (always in a ‘good’ cause, of course – what leaders ever said ‘This is a bad and evil idea but here’s what I want done anyway’ … ?) then science will be debased and the politics will fail; Truth – as every Revolution has to learn all over again the hard way – is going to come out.

The moral arc of the universe bends toward it; human nature seeks it out – and not even Stalin could change that in the long run.

It may yet be that the radical feminist cadres will pray, with that inimitable Dead White American Lumpen Male, Chester A. Riley: “What a revoltin’ development DIS toined out ta be!”

If human beings have a function philosophically and – why not? – a spiritual purpose, nature and function as well, then moral and ethical statements are factual statements: such and such is a good way to be human or a bad way. Which is NOT what Revolutionary Correctness wants to see at all.

But if there is NO way to ground a human purpose, nature, or function, THEN there is no way anybody can ‘judge’ anything or anybody else. And moral statements cease to be factual are reduced to the status of opinion. And perhaps to the same level as ‘religious opinion’ – which a Federal judge in Massachusetts recently characterized as “irrational” by definition (perhaps he meant non-rational or meta-rational, but then maybe he really meant what he said).

When a civilization turns upon itself, carrying its great founding genius to unbalanced and self-destroying extremes in a parody of its own best beginnings, it becomes decadent. Like a Ferris wheel that has come loose from its concrete base and moorings, its still-working motors simply roll it away drunkenly (that marvelous image from the concluding minutes of Stephen Spielberg’s 1978 under-appreciated gem, “1941”).

I think that has happened to this country. But wait.

It has happened not because the Citizenry decayed out from under the government, but because the government committed itself to an ultimately decadence-producing agenda and then strove mightily to fulfill its ponderous indenture by imposing it overtly or slyly upon the Citizenry.

The Great American Experiment in popular government has always actually been more of a Great American Gamble: that somehow human beings can come together in a polity and through common and careful deliberation exercise their Sovereign Authority to shape their polity on their own, rather than be indentured (or worse) to a King or a Leviathan governing apparatus.

The Framers themselves were not completely comfortable with that Great Vision. While it might work in small venues like towns and counties (although who in 1787 could forget the Salem Witch craze of less than a century before?), a larger national government would require representatives. The solution was frequent elections and the system of checks-and-balances, in order to keep the great Wheel of Government from developing its own momentum (and its own Will) and running away with everything.

Lincoln was always aware of this conundrum: can a government amass the power to function effectively without by the very exercise of its power undermining the sovereign rights of The People and of the Citizens? He was the only one among American Presidents to face a Civil War, and his were terribly difficult times. The actions he took were taken under the one exceptional situation that the Framers had recognized and acknowledged.

By the turn of the 19th century into the 20th, however, there is some question as to whether anybody in Washington really believed that the country – now so complex and large and diverse – could be effectively governed and its energies and resources harnessed, without the clear and direct direction by people who genuinely knew what they were doing in a way that no simple Citizen could ever know. Teddy Roosevelt wanted to run the government, but at least wanted to use its growing authority as a counter-balance to the great corporate combinations and their intensely concentrated wealth. William Howard Taft couldn’t see how else it could be done, but hoped that those who knew how to do things and who had power to get things done would act responsibly. Wilson was convinced that only a truly Great Man could be a Great Leader, which is what he figured the country would now always need.

None of them had really any practical use for the Vision of 1787. Perhaps they sensed, at some level, that they couldn’t afford that Vision.

And throughout their Administrations the Progressives were urging government to use its authority to clean the country up: clean up the food, clean out the nests of child laborers, get rid of liquor, and in a thousand ways be the Great Sheriff that would clean up Dodge (according to whatever this or that Progressive thinker took to be the Great Problem or Great Outrage of the day). There were problems that extended beyond any individual States, and there was also the Convenience Factor: it would be a lot easier to get one Federal law passed or regulation imposed rather than get each individual State to do it.

A great complex machine like the country had become now required ‘experts’; not necessarily great human beings, but greatly knowledgeable ones that knew what they were doing and  - always a slippery definition – what had to be done.

People ‘just didn’t get it’ because they couldn’t get it – everything was so complicated that the average Citizen just couldn’t get a handle on enough matters to form a respectably serious opinion.

That tension – between expanding the power of the national government to keep up with the expansion of the country’s complexity and retaining the Founding suspicion of and limits on the power of the national government lest it swallow up the power of the States and come to infiltrate the entire polity – posed a monstrous challenge.

Things were then rendered even more complex when the national government under FDR extended itself to combat the Great Depression and try to smooth out the workings of the economy, and then immediately thereafter when the national government directed the nation in the largest war-effort in its history, militarizing the already corporatized and industrialized society.

But what happened in the late 1960s pushed things to an entirely new level.  

The old Progressive urge to ‘improve’ became much more ‘revolutionary’. Not only did the Content of their demands insist upon all sorts of ‘change’ that went beyond ‘reform’ into ‘revolutionary’ change, but the Method of their demands also reflected the ‘revolutionary’ mindset: only those elites who ‘get it’ should have any real voice, and their job would be to get control of the huge government power and wield it as they saw fit.

If the original American Vision was already weakened widely by the 1890s and 1900s, it has now been weakened deeply and profoundly.

There is no easy answer to this problem.

At this point, even if the money – that mother’s milk of government-programs – runs out, will there be enough Americans left who can step up to begin functioning once again as not only ‘concerned’ but truly participant citizens, dedicated to a common-weal and to a sober and serious management of a nation far too riddled by excitements and appearances?

The American polity – unlike Divinity – is finite, and it cannot continue to absorb ad infinitum the various ‘deals’ that each sap it of vital and genuine strength. I sometimes think of the commonweal as a whale, under attack by sharks: while few sharks can individually take enough bites out of a whale to kill it, a frenzied gang of them certainly could reduce the great creature to bloody bones if allowed to go at it long enough.

When is long enough? That is the question.

If since the turn into the 20th century there has been a major question as to whether the country has gotten too complex for The People, and if since the turn into the 19th century there has been a major question as to whether people can ever really reliably function as The People, then thosequestions have in the past few decades intensified exponentially.

The revolutionary theory and the revolutionary ‘science’ and philosophy (or non-philosophy) introduced in the service of the radical feminist agenda, have now posed a profound contamination hazard: generations of Americans are now exposed to the corrosive undertow of ‘conventional wisdom’ that there is nothing solid upon which to ground any sort of judgment, and that there is no way in a mindless material universe that any input can matter except the organized and power-driven input of a government. Thus participatory democracy declines as citizens decline to participate in what appears a hopeless and meaningless activity.

Worse, maturity declines as people, facing the prospect of weathering the challenges of the perennially unruly human self and the perennially treacherous uncertainties of human events, without family and without committed human connection, and with only the increasingly cash-strapped government to rely for hope (or ‘optimism’), consolation, support, care, and any meaning beyond their own momentary exhilarations … will respond to such a frakkulous challenge by withdrawing from social participation, whether noisily or quietly.

A spiritually and philosophically immature people will not be able to function politically as The People. And if there is no People, why keep a Constitutional Republic? Why keep the American Republic? As John Adams said – almost as if he had a crystal ball into the America of today: “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”

If it appears these days as if the Constitution is not working as well as it ought to be, I would suggest that even before directing primary efforts at the Augean Stables in the Beltway, We must look to Ourselves. I think it was Stanley Hauerwas who has said that the liberal project has always been to make a just government but not a just people.

Like the concrete base upon which the well-constructed and well-powered Ferris wheel is anchored, a just and well-grounded People – comprised of a critical mass of individual Citizens who are themselves grounded in a mastery of their human nature (philosophically and perhaps theologically as well) – is essential to anchor the great Machinery of the Constitution and the Republic.

This is what I would call civic or ‘meta-civic’ competence; it is a priceless and indispensable asset to the American polity or to any polity. And it is not something that you can ‘get’ overnight. Nor is it something that can easily be recovered if lost.***

In the mindless race to the conceptual bottom that has become the pandering politics of Identity in the past three decades, the Beltway has accepted the corrosion of the fundamental life-force of the American polity (PLEASE don’t say that the fundamental life-force of America is ‘the economy’): Nothing and nobody can have a Purpose, nothing and nobody can be judged, nothing or nobody can ever be wrong (except white males, and then excepting from that set the subset known as ‘male feminists’ who have proven they ‘get it’), and there is no morality (which is a relief to the government which no longer has to pretend).

So this meta-civic competence is a gift that reaches back to Aristotle; it presided over European culture’s high noon through the Medieval Synthesis devised by Aquinas. And it came to America in the still-powerful afterglow of the later Enlightenment.

The materialism that shadows all earthly endeavor, intensified by the ready abundance of consumer capitalism; the shocks to faith and reason administered in the 20th century by the First even more than the Second World War; and the stunning adoption in the early 1970s by the Beltway of what was essentially revolutionary Method and Praxis, and everything that has flowed from that frakkulous decision … brings Us to the point where the Agenda now demands that the country abandon all philosophy (except its own web of justifications for its demands, which it insists is not philosophy at all – with which insistence I think I would have to agree).

Such a demand will Flatten Us, Flatten this country and its ethos, and snuff out whatever hope and light this Great Gamble ever had of being a beacon to the nations. And in that regard, the night is far advanced.

I urge that We do whatever We can to make sure the dawn is not far off.

POST-SCRIPT

And in regard to that opening comment about “ballerinas dance, alcoholics drink”: balletic dance is the result of consistent effort to discipline the self to develop a particular functional human skill. Alcoholic-level drinking is rather the opposite on all counts, requiring not the development of competence and self-discipline but rather the abandonment of self and life to a rather primal human ‘passion’, to consume and to thereby induce a less-demanding level of consciousness. This may in some ways be considered a disease, but it in no way can be spun as an ‘achievement’. It is a clear consequence of the times that such a dysfunction can be even imagined to be a sign of achievement.

NOTES

*MacIntyre, Alasdair. “After Virtue”. Notre Dame, IN: U/ND Press, 1981. I am using the text of the 3rd Edition, published in 2007. ISBN 0-268-03504-0.

** At the 1995 World Women’s Conference in Beijing American feminists were opposed to supportive resolutions on Marriage, Family, Freedom of Religion, problems of motherhood, and parental rights. It must have been clear to many societies in attendance that what the Americans wanted to bring along with ‘democracy’ was going to be hugely corrosive to their cultures and even the stability of their societies and perhaps their governments.


***In the print edition for April 22, 2011, pp. 8-10. The review is entitled “Such A Thing”, by Rowan Martin. It reviews Conor Cunningham’s book “Darwin’s Pious Idea”.

*** As developing nations are learning as they try to operate great aircraft carriers in mimicry of the US Navy in its heyday, you can’t just build the vessel and buy the planes from somebody and paint your national emblem on them; you then have to develop an entire complex matrix of cultures and competences: the pilots who can operate from the ships, the sailors and officers who can handle the ship, the support specialties that service the planes and their subsystems, and a general can-do culture that saw its best days (and I am NOT saying this out of witless sentimentality and nostalgia) in World War 2 and most certainly in the past two decades has taken a beating from Correctness from which it will not soon, if ever, recover.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

THE MEANING OF LIFE

Terry Eagleton has written a short but meaty book entitled “The Meaning of Life”; Laura Miller has reviewed it over on Salon (“What is the meaning of life?”, www.salon.com/books/review/2007/06/14/eagleton.print.html).

One of his key points is that life – most especially human life – is ‘contingent’: we don’t have to be here and – as if that’s not enough – our being here is the result of random forces. This fear (I’m not going to call it an ‘insight’) can be seen clearly by the end of the 19th century in – say – a piece of literature like the American short story “The Open Boat” and in the famously-put exchange where ‘man’ says to the universe ‘I exist’ and the universe ho-hums the reply that ‘the fact however does not evoke in me a sense of obligation’.

Such contingency is a triple-whammy: a) it leaves human beings alone in the universe; b) it leaves human beings functionally helpless in the universe; c) it leaves human beings in a universe that is indifferent to them, if not itself downright hostile, and the universe might also thereby leave humans prey to powerful and dangerous and even hostile sub-forces over which the universe has no control or refuses to exercise control. Any human being who gets up in the morning embracing that ‘modernism’ is going to become deranged or deformed by sheer terror and anxiety almost immediately, and will then become further deranged and deformed by whatever response s/he attempts to muster (withdrawal from ‘reality’; existentialist in-your-face or rock-jawed pseudo-adult posturing; a retreat from the more mature forms of being where one is required to ‘know’ and to ‘act’ and a simultaneous retreat to less mature forms of being where one simply floats more or less vigorously on the surface of events and of one’s own being). It’s not a pretty picture.

And ‘post modernism’ is no improvement because it denies that there is any solid ‘reality’ at all. And while this relieves us of the nightmare of a hostile or indifferent universe, it leaves us with no solid ground to stand on, and no solid landmarks to get our bearings whatsoever. One thinks of Kirk’s original “Enterprise” suddenly going beyond the bounds of ‘this galaxy’ and into another one so different that none of the ship’s instruments – or that main computer with the old telephone operator’s voice – can fix its position. Or plot a course out of there.

As has been noted in recent Posts in regard to the Israeli state (or “realm” as it apparently prefers to call itself), such a monstrous and awefull experience can throw humans – and especially those who govern states and peoples – seriously out of whack. We might propose that the Holocaust was the ultimate ‘modernist’ experience: suddenly a people ‘discovered’ that it was utterly alone in a very hostile world without the power to resist. To avoid ever having to go through that again folks and their government would be willing to … do whatever it takes. (And since their first major step in the direction of securing their future against a repeat was to set themselves up on a piece of real estate by ejecting its inhabitants, then they set themselves up for endless threats and deformations at the very outset of their quest for security … )

Anxiety and terror – especially if sustained – deform us humans. They cause our behaviors and our thought patterns and our emotions to revert to the most primitive, least evolved and least matured parts of our brains and selves and they mutate us into sinister forms of life similar to Tolkien’s ‘Orcs’ – those monstrous results of the effort to reduplicate the marvelous Elves – or his ‘wraiths’ – those former humans who served Evil so deeply that it has now consumed them and they exist without hope and full of purposeful hatred in a shadow world that borders our own, whence they enter into our reality possessing no power to create but great power to destroy.

Any quest for the ‘meaning’ of ‘life’ starting out from the precincts of terror and anxiety is going to be similarly burdened from the outset, and its ‘discoveries’ similarly dark, dubious, suspect and dangerous.

It is a huge insight of Eagleton’s that he realizes that both the ‘liberal’ and ‘left’ postmodernists and the ‘fundamentalist’ and ‘right’ conservatives (so-called) are radically similar in their philosophical presumptions, as unexamined as those are these days.

Both ‘sides’ are, for different reasons, philosophical “Nominalists”. Nominalism is the philosophical position that all entities and beings are ‘named’ purely as constructs of human convenience and that there are no guiding essences in some other dimension to which these entities in ‘this life’ would have to conform (and to which, in consequence, our thoughts about those entities would also have to conform).

Early Protestants embraced a form of Nominalism in order to lever some conceptual and political space for themselves against the huge weight of the organized Roman Catholic Church. Very much accepting that there was another governing dimension (God in His heaven and in His glory) beyond this one, they yet insisted that God alone had power over the shapes and forms of our ‘earthly’ dimension and that no this-dimensional, ‘earthly’ power such as the Church and Popes and bishops’ and ‘priests’ and sacraments and ‘human’ rules and the rest of the Catholic panoply of belief and practice could adequately or even legitimately constrain the workings of that Divine Will. And whatever that Will at any particular moment said was good, was good – and whatever that Will at any particular moment said was otherwise, was otherwise. The human world and human life itself was not sustained by ‘laws’ but by the ever-present, directly-intentioned Will of God, and that Will would abide no ‘middleman’, no Church taking upon itself the ‘authority’ to apportion God’s gifts or to speak and act in His name.

Clearly, that illumination - such as it is - allows for no substantive mediation between the fierce-hot direct contact with God's Will and the leaden, sluggish matter of this earthly existence and its affairs. Further, following it out, one comes to a pretty dark and demanding role for humans in such a set-up: participating, collaborating, mired in and enwhored to the dreck-sludge of material existence, humans have no choice but to throw themselves onto God's hell-hot mercy and hope for the best while trying to keep their noses clean and close to the grindstone. Thus John Calvin.

American 'fundamentalism' was and is - well - American. So you have to have a happy ending. And you have to have the Lebensraum (oops, I borrowed that from a different messianism) to do what you have to d0, to do whatever it takes, and still stay in the Divine Will. The solution that the Fundies evolved (oops, again) was to get 'saved', or rather, to declare oneself 'saved'. Thus burnished, one could do whatever one felt it was going to take to do whatever one felt was the 'best' way to go, while still enjoying God's delight and - wheeee! - His authority. What was not to like?

Post-modern nominalism grew out of a similar need to lever some Lebensraum. Given the oppressive control exercised by the established 'have' powers of the world, and by conformity to those powers' concept of order and identity and right and wrong, the post-modern Theorists - with the most noble intentions - figured that the quickest way to proceed was to pull the conceptual rug out from under the whole edifice. Thus, there was no Right and no Wrong, and no authority to tell others what to do or how to do it and so the whole thing was up for grabs and may the best grabber win. Everything was wide open and totally fluid and life was just a bowl of cherries except shapeless and without-essence and waiting for those human hands that 'got it' to stretch forth and do the creating thing previously ascribed to that ultimate Dead White European Male, the artist formerly known as 'God', and His (male) minions. Grrrowwff!

Probably, the deeper-thinking post-modernists and advocates (the ones who did not deceive themselves as to the essentially calculating political nature of their glorious revolutions) figured that once they had actually come to power then they would need to sober up and start acknowledging that the Highway of Being indeed needed - and had - some very clear lines painted on it. But, like the Great Yellowstone Fire of 1988, things sorta got away from them, and the controlled but groovily creative destructions so gleefully begun began to create their own outcomes, and all those outcomes began to change the whole ballgame and define a new 'reality' altogether. Had one not been constrained by the already-entrenched Political Correctness, one might profitably have exclaimed with Albert the Alligator: "Gack!". But no such warning alerts were permitted, since a revolution in Theory brings no dangerous downside (except to the former oppressors who deserve whatever they would get). The sorcery mastered the apprentices. It could happen to anybody.

So we are now to conduct our individual lives, and We are now to conduct the life of the Republic, while existing on or in a sea of Ultimate Mush. The Fundies have solved that problem by pretending that they are standing on the solid rock of God's Authority and Power. The assorted revolutionaries have solved that problem by avoiding it, presuming - but not daring to say - that there really is nothing else but this-world, Mush though it may conceptually be; and that everybody can still feel good enough if they just focus on achieving 'milestones' and 'goals', however symbolic.

And so here We are, in the Year of Former Grace 2007: the Fundies are making war on Evil (them 'libbuls') and Sin as national domestic and foreign policy; the assorted revolutions are making war on crime (certain types) and men (generally, but with a few graciously-declared exceptions). We no longer produce much of anything tangible; We are in hock to the nation identified as America's most probable rival; Our currency is starting to become rather 'symbolic' itself; We have zero tolerance for pain or frustration, We have the attention-span of a three-year old, and We consider the ability to present oneself as a Victim to be the summation of maturity; We can no longer tell Right from Wrong, especially if it looks like We might be up to Our necks in Wrong.

Meanwhile the Executive has authorized torture and child-abuse (for 'enemy' children) and pre-emptive nuclear war on non-nuclear nations and has now given itself the right to run the country if it feels there's an 'emergency'; the Congress can barely recover its ability to influence events after Twelve Years of an orgy that can most charitably be referred to - as Scripture would have it - as a "whoredom of whoredoms"; and the Supreme Court considers that torture makes a great organizing theme for a dinner party and that it is itself the great giver of Order to the shapeless mass of the citizenry - if only the citizenry would stop yapping and listen up. We are losing a war and an army in Iraq and the Executive seems ready to throw the Navy and the Air Force at Iran. We appear oblivious to what the rest of the governments and peoples of the earth are thinking about Us.

We are desperately in need of some grown-up to burst through the door and demand "What is the meaning of all this?".

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, June 11, 2007

LOVE AND TEACHING

William Deresiewicz has an interesting article in the “American Scholar”, entitled “Love on Campus”. He takes up the matter of professors and erotic energy exchanged with students, especially as seen through the lens of recent literature and film.

For the most part, recent films give us the impression of immature middle-aged male professors of literature or communications, either passively self-pitying or actively seductive (almost always toward their female students).

Deresiewicz raises the interesting possibility that professors are popularly seen as immature and “effete” because such a view feeds the abiding American suspicion and resentment of intelligence and intellect. When the universities – especially those ‘abstract’ literature departments – became the enthusiastic new home of discredited Theory, expelled from France like an intellectual plague, who can doubt that such suspicion intensified a thousand-fold?

This country has never successfully managed one of its crucial conceptual problems: how do you ensure political equality for all while respecting (and constructively nurturing and making use of) those gifted with more intellectual ability than their peers? Jefferson had spoken of a “natural aristocracy”, a group of individuals defined by an intellectual ability, a managerial competence, and a maturity moral and characterological. But how to enable American society to identify such persons and then provide them with the opportunities to develop and contribute their natural gifts?

Even more difficult: it appears that the Jeffersonian panoplium of ‘gifts’ almost never occurs in individuals in its entirety. Rockefeller and Carnegie and Ford were naturally gifted managers, but their moral and characterological abilities were hardly impressive. Indeed, it can be proposed that American business solved the problem of its own ‘moral’ authority by simply presuming that ‘business’ allowed its practitioners to do things that in the ordinary individual would be considered immoral and even – later on – sociopathic. In that regard American elite culture – even its popular culture – needed no large indoctrination by the Holocaust-deranged Israeli state and its ‘anything is allowed’ morality.

I don’t fully agree with his analysis that “the famously overprotective parenting of the baby-boom generation has put pressure on universities to revert to acting ‘in loco parentis’”. It may indeed be true, especially as the 1990s progressed. But two decades before that Political Correctness had been hugely enforced in the universities not to ‘parent’ the students but rather – in best revolutionary praxis – to take ‘children’ from the (presumptively outmoded and regressive) formation they had ostensibly received from their parents and re-educate them into the iron platitudes of Theory and the programmes of the various Identities.

But he shines as he reviews the wisdom of education in the Western tradition, to the effect that there is indeed an Eros (an Erotic element – not primarily sexually defined) involved in the best teaching. He uses the example of Socrates, an ugly, goggle-eyed lump of a man physically, who famously surfed the erotic attractions of the young Alcibiades to get the young man alone – at the young man’s invitation – in order to speak enthusiastically and energetically (the basic sense of ‘erotic’) about ideas with this hugely talented – if also drop-dead handsome – student. Socrates seduces the young man into “brain sex”, as Deresiewicz aptly quotes Alan Bloom’s pithy phrase. This is a scenario utterly beyond the comprehension of the current, sex-reductive, sex-obsessed mind.

American culture has no skill in grasping, let alone properly deploying, this sense of the Erotic. One thinks of the intelligent German, a young adult in the time of Hitler, who described Hitler’s entrancing speaking to the crowds as “er massiertete uns” – he massaged us. One thinks of two film-character teachers (not mentioned by Deresiewicz): Robin Williams’ teacher in “Dead Poets’ Society” and Maggie Smith’s teacher in “The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie”. Smith entrances her “girls” with romantic and ideal visions of changing the world, such that one of them runs off to fight the Fascists in Spain (in 1936) and dies. Williams’s teacher, more of a performer in front of his students than a teacher of his students, ignites ideals that one sensitive student cannot reconcile with his parents’ prosaic desires for his future success, and winds up killing himself.

The Williams film, made in the already sex-offense addled later 1980s, carefully avoided any physically erotic attraction between teacher and students. And Smith’s film was made in the mid-1960s, and in any case she was a woman – who in the American demonology do not commit sex-offenses.

Deresiewicz does not take up the most recent film dealing with this, Britain’s world-renowned “The History Boys”. Here a widely-educated older prep-school teacher, intensely dedicated to the knowledge that he wishes to pass on to his class of gifted students, has the unhappy habit of giving this and that one (except the admittedly gay one) a ride home after school on his motorbike, during which journey he would inevitably contrive to momentarily grasp the student’s genitalia.

A habit taken very much in stride by the sexually-aware male students who also have the wit to recognize a good education and a devoted and unique teacher when they have one and absorb this groping into their daily round, firmly establishing it among their concerns as a much lesser priority than sharing in the passion for knowledge. This is not a reality with which contemporary American society is prepared to deal. Such value as it may contain is lost.

The passion for life and living – Eros – exists among Us in a very Flattened state. We shop, we cheer on sports teams and we track celebrities, measuring out our lives no longer in teaspoons but in text-messages. That We might pursue the Stoic ‘prosoche’ – the unceasing attention to our own maturation and development and right action – is an opportunity lost to Us, tossed out with all the other outmoded furniture crafted by Dead White European Males. That We might cultivate Our desires so that they are usefully keyed to worthwhile objects yet still capable of providing a life-enhancing pleasure – in the Epicurean vision – is equally lost to Us now. Americans are a weird mixture of Garbo’s dour revolutionary apparatchik Ninotchka and the ditzy Valley Kid besotted by appearances and the teapot-tempests that can only entrance an unripened mind.

Our concept of 'the good life' is purely a matter of surfaces, appearances, materiality. That the most valuable and essential 'good' is a well-mastered and well-matured Self (vitally connected to God and other human beings, as them Kathliks would remind Us) is utterly beyond the memory or the imagination or the desire or the will of far far too many of Us.

We are desperately in need of better education. And We are very much in need of more carefully thinking-through Our approach to the nation’s young. Is a youngster protected from passion in any form going to be any better off in adult life? Is a youngster raised in ‘total security’ going to be any better off if sent immediately thereafter to wage “the Long War”? Or will We import other nation’s youngsters to do that suffering?

Worse, will a youngster taught not to think but to memorize slogans and platitudes (and perhaps the tell-tale signs of ‘sex-offenders’ the way an earlier generation was taught to identify the silhouettes of Nazi and Japanese aircraft) be able to grow up as a Citizen who can join others to People this Republic?

The director John Ford missed a great opportunity in 1962. He completed “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance” that year. In that film, a reporter says knowingly to Jimmy Stewart’s U.S. Senator: When you’ve got the facts and you’ve got the legend, and the legend is better, then you print the legend. Ford, at almost the end of his career and feeling that his earlier feel-good patrioteering pictures had left out consideration of the darker side of American culture, left it at that and figured he’d balanced his books.

I’ve always felt he could have done better with that scene. He could have given Stewart’s Senator the last word, something like: And how can you keep a Republic by doing that?

We sure as hell know now. You can’t.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

MOYERS ONE

A trio of articles by Bill Moyers have gotten my attention. I’ll Post a bit on each of them.

He’s got “Discovering What Democracy Means” on Tom Paine (www.truthout.org/docs_2006/021307A.shtml).

He is as valuable for his apt quotations as for his thoughts; and he draws upon a wide knowledge. Martha Nussbaum is brought in with her gravid insight that the Greek dramatists had no “message” except “simply the revelation of life as seen through the sufferer”. But this is hardly a small thought. To be able to develop a wide and widely-informed empathy is a significant achievement in maturity. It is vastly seen in its absence in present-day Washington City, even more than one would usually expect in those precincts; and the consequences of a failure of empathy for – and of knowledge of – other human beings are now bearing their awefull fruit on the Eastern front.

I think I’ll take this opportunity to point one thing out. It’s a major concern of this site that what are here called the Revolutions of the Identities have borne some very damaging consequences of their own, greatly corroding democratic praxis, jurisprudence, the structure of the Republic, and the weakening of the Peopling skills of the citizenry. This is not at all intended to be some coded understatement to the effect that we should bring the 1950s back again. It is not first and foremost the substance of the Revolutions (although some of the claims are surely questionable enough to have deserved far more public deliberation); rather it is the method of proceeding – the revolutionary method – that has created the most serious damage.

It is true what was obvious even to contemporaries in the late 19th and early 20th centuries: that once Jim Crow was established in the South no normal democratic process was going to be able to reverse it. But once the great march to the Glorious ’65 was successfully completed, then the more-revolutionary and less-democratic methodology should have been set aside in favor of the longer, more complex and frustrating process of grounding public consensus through wide public deliberation.

Instead, the advocates’ resort to increasing Federal involvement in ever-deepening and ever-more-specific aspects of public and private life – especially in the deployment of criminal law and prosecution – was fraught with dangers that are now bearing their poisoned fruit. And of course, this dangerous dynamic was only intensified as subsequent Revolutions of further newly-hatched Identities sought to jump-start themselves and quickly create their own beach-head of ‘facts on the ground’.

That all of this took place in incessant waves was bad enough. That it took place just as the United States had passed the zenith of its postwar position that sustained its stupendous economic growth and predominance was a profound irony whose significance and consequences are still not fully realized.

Little can be reversed now and I am not proposing such a bootless undertaking. But We must realize just what damage was sustained in the journey to our present situation so that We can take corrective action even as We pursue the course that has been set. Surely, the inherent nobility and humaneness of trying to see events from the point of view of the sufferer is a desirable and an indispensable trait of the character of the People who engaged in or at least permitted such revolutionary activity on a vast and pervasive scale.

But the methods of revolution are inherently inimical to the skills and virtues of a democracy. And empathy is neither the equivalent of nor the substitute for carefully and widely considered policy and law. That the Right (hardly to be called ‘conservative’ in its present incarnation) is the current wielder of Jacobin power is obvious to all; that the Left (hardly to be called ‘Liberal’ in the classic sense) wielded it to Our great detriment for decades and indeed created the vacuums that evoked and enabled the Right must be seen far more clearly than heretofore.

Moyers continues his quotation of Nussbaum: it is greatly valuable to see “the complexity that’s there, and seeing it honestly, and without flinching, and without reducing it to some excessively simple theory”. The ability to appreciate and tolerate complexity is another hallmark of maturity. And again: if such maturity is brutally absent among the Unitary Incumbency’s minions, it had also been ruthlessly – if more ‘tastefully – absent among the advocates of the assorted revolutions. And if the utterly fatuous ‘theories’ that underlay the strutting neocons’ dreams of invasion are now revealed for the bankrupt lunacies they have always been, the utterly corrosive consequences of Theory as it has been propounded domestically by our elites for decades must also be recognized.

Moyers proposes that we might nurture “the higher affections of our intuition – what has been called our ‘inner tutor’”. I think that he demonstrates for us here the newly-recovered strength and the long-entrenched weakness of the Left – and the Liberal – agenda. He introduces again the use of a Vertical dimension to the individual, and that Vertical presupposes an individual’s Interiority as well. Both dimensions have been unforgivably de-emphasized in Theory’s decades-long occupation of our cultural and societal discourse.

Generations of children, many now adult, have grown up with a working conception of Life in which these two dimensions of being and acting have been largely absent. Verticality implied ‘judgment’ and the imposition of ‘values’ and the truly sensitive and enlightened did not do that. Interiority led to a certain social ‘passivity’ and ‘withdrawal’ that did not sufficiently get out and force societal change; one’s status as either victim or victimizer and one’s actions as one or the other (not even, as most often happens among us humans, as both) were the only significant aspects of living (one’s robust consumption of material goods always being taken as a given). Thus Our selves and thus our lives – as individuals and as a society) were much shrunken, and even desiccated.

But that other vast and wondrous and utterly indispensable dimension of life and Life, of being and existence – the Beyond, the Meta – is still almost unspeakable. We have an “inner tutor”. This is as ‘spiritual’ as even Moyers dares to be in his article. We could say that this does not even rise to the level of the spiritual, but is simply ‘non-material’, which is hardly sufficient to meet the voracious – indeed the constituent – hunger of the human spirit. And if we must contemplate in muted shock the ‘enlightenment’ that demands the willful ignoring of the human spirit – shades of Lenin – then we must also reflect ruefully that it was precisely the creation of this abyss that sparked and sucked into awefull life the violent derangement of Fundamentalism and rammed open its path to the pinnacle of our ‘polis’. All to Our great detriment.

So carefully that I can’t figure whether he is treading carefully or isn’t quite aware of it himself, Moyers then quotes Thomas Jefferson’s reprehension of the “bastard muses”, those special-pleadings for specific causes that calculatedly mask themselves as a comprehensive and undeniable ‘wisdom’ and insight into the heart of ‘reality’. Truth is lost; the ability to perceive Truth shrivels. While we might take some heart that such pernicious folly as it was evinced among the neocons and Fundamentalists and even the ‘realistic’ Macher of Washington City is now betraying those who so cockily and arrogantly tried to ‘hire’ it, we must also accept with a justifiable fright that such inability to seek and apprehend Truth is now pervasive among Us.

He quotes – but valuably – Leo Strauss, who had noted that “vulgarity”, the coarseness and crudeness which is a hallmark of boyo and macho and Fundamentalistic hubris, rises from an “apeirokalia”, “the lack of experience in things beautiful”. “Beauty”, like Truth, is not congenial to the profoundly immature, the ‘unripe’ – and we are all born more or less unripe. Beauty and Truth are also irrelevant to revolutionaries, whose harsh discipline of Outcome requires them to focus on lesser, more immediate things. In that sense, of course, ‘business’ and ‘revolution’ are sisters under the skin. Thus visions of both the Right and the Left share a common poisonous root.

And he goes on then that today “we are all institutionalized”. Yes, and it is not so much that Our civilization has reached a complexity that erects numerous ‘institutions’ as that Our civilization has ignored the human-ness – in all its marvelous heights – that would enable Us to remain the masters of those institutions. And We are also – he omits to say – “balkanized”, divided and sub-divided into numerous squabbling Identities as well as shrunken into the hot or cold, hard surfaces of surfaces and Appearances.

Thus has the government power – through the National Security State and the National Corporate State and the National Crime State, artfully wooing the macho and the ‘sensitive’, the ruthless and the socially ‘concerned’ – taken advantage of our weakened and divided condition – as individuals and as a society – to raise itself up as our Primary Protector and Provider, roles previously ascribed to the Beyond – however conceived. The reliance upon the government power as that Primary Protector and Provider quickly shades into a functional idolatry, a functional paganism. All to Our great detriment.

Are we as a People now become merely “a fiction”? Are we become a shadow? A wraith? A shade? For Us as for that tortured princeling of Denmark the urgent question remains: To be or not to be?

Labels: , , ,

Monday, December 11, 2006

IS THE ESSENTIAL ALSO THE REAL?

David Swanson has written an article “Honesty in Iraq” (www.truthout.org/docs_2006/120706N.shtml). He notes that a large metropolitan newspaper has editorialized about Incumbent Bush that “his pronouncements now bear no resemblance to reality”. Acutely, Swanson immediately asks “Now?” and he’s spot-on.

We begin to see the tremors preparatory to and indicative of a tectonic shift in public opinion. Such massive shifts are not simply two-dimensional, however. Even as public opinion shifts from one pole to the other, that shift must simultaneously serve to preserve the popular sense that the said public’s opinion is, will be, and always has been right – or, at least, well-intentioned. The Pentagon has evolved a nifty solution to this challenge: it will issue a press statement to the effect that Nothing is wrong and repairs are being made and no harm was done. But what has to happen now among the populace is even trickier: matters must be arranged so as to a) generate approval for change, without at the same time b) kicking the tripwire of anger that things have been so badly managed that they need to be changed as all, and all the while c) stroking the ego of the populace so that they don’t get feeling angry at being tricked or guilty about making the wrong choice in placing their trust or – worst of all – pissed at whomever made them look like inattentive, gullible herbivores bunched up at a shallow creek-crossing. And when they are in the latter state, a guilty party WILL be found, and no politician wants to be at the business end of THAT pointing finger.

Blaming the Iraqis is a good start. It gets everybody off the hook, on the American side of the polygon, anyway. The government only wanted to help, the media only wanted to help the government help, the voters supported the government that had nothing the best and most disinterested of intentions, the generals did a fine job … it was simply that the Iraqis were as ungrateful a bunch of liberatees as any redeemer nation could ever have the bad luck to invade. God won’t force people, y’know; it’s not His way. Our dispatch of most of the Army, much of the Marine Corps, and frequent visits by Air Force and Navy air ‘assets’ was not intended as a deployment of force as much as it was a powerful rescue operation. The secret, torture-authorized CIA squads and legions of under-guided mercenaries were similarly boons of benevolence, not steps in a sequence of in-your-face Plagues redolent of fire and brimstone. In fact, as Deputized by God to bring the entire world under His authority, the U.S. is double-00 authorized, just like James Bond only without all the kinda queer good taste and culture. Further Affiant saith naught. Except that perhaps, as Bishop Limbaugh piously reflects, the next time we should just go in and flatten’em all and let God sort it out. Then the suffering would be God’s fault and – as is well established by precedent and statute – if God does it, then it’s not a crime.

It was as clear as a bell from the first debate with Gore that Bush was Eddie Haskell. When the camera turned to him he had the look of a kid who was surprised by parental authority, kept his cool, deflected judgment with a combination of sugar and oil, and yet – true teenager that he was – KNEW he was getting away with it and just couldn’t keep the smirk off his face. That actor was good, the one who played Eddie Haskell. Who knew fifty years ago that he was back from this future to warn us of what was coming? But a generation that could grow up with Vietnam and then go on in the full bloom of adulthood to get into Iraq … well, that’s a truly special generation. Soooo speshull.

In the alternative, it can be embraced that Bush is losing his mind. Who knew? Who could be blamed for not foreseeing such a mysterious and sudden malady? And who’s to blame? Poor Bush? The well-intentioned folks who cheered him and cheered him on? Nope. No guilty parties here. Lot of wreckage, oceans of blood, danger blasting across the Iraqian landscape like wind at the South Pole. But it’s nobody’s fault. I wonder if a large fraction of American viewers don’t simply imagine that after the nightly-newsclip the bodies just get up and walk down to the Iraqish equivalent of Starbucks for a coffee.

All legitimate topics for reflection. But nowhere near the significance of his best point: “Is aggressively attacking another nation in an illegal war something that can be done without catastrophic results if it’s done right?” In other words: can Success make a Bad thing Good? Or are some things so fundamentally and irrevocably Bad and Evil that not only can nothing make them Good, but that because they are fundamentally Bad and Evil they actually create Bad and Evil outcomes (sometimes initially camouflaged as Successful outcomes) such that no Good can come of them because they will turn every outcome that flows from them and everyone associated with them into Bad and Evil … ?

Can that happen? For that to happen, we’d have to be living in a universe where events and actions can be characterized as Good or Evil, because they actually had an interior nature that was Good or Evil; and then that nature itself would have to be somehow connected with all the rest of Nature (or Life or Existence); such that the ‘vibes’ (in this case Evil) from one particular event or person could radiate out like shock waves, strong enough to deform whatever they encounter in their path. I know: it sounds kinda New Agey or hippie-ish; better to stick with sound science: legions of angels bearing flaming swords who will chopper out the Good in the Last Minutes and then whack everybody else in the Last Minute itself.

Or again: we’d have to be living in a world where all things have consequences, and that Good acts have Good consequences and Bad acts have Bad consequences. But can Bad acts have Good consequences, like two butt-ugly dragons mating and making a unicorn? Or is the Evil-creates-only-evil and Good-creates-only-good theorem pretty much the way it all works? And if a Bad act can have a Good consequence in theory, is that enough justification for going ahead and doing the Bad act, literally actualizing Evil, just because there’s a chance you will get the Good outcome you’re looking for? Can you risk your life over it? Other people’s lives? Can you kill for it? And avoid all the Evil consequences? Does “Life” or “the Universe” blow back? Lash back? Recoil? We know God does – or did, when He was the accepted Theory.

How can an Evil thing or a Bad thing be “done right”? If the technique is competent, is that all there is? Or does one have to have a Good purpose as well as competent technique and technical proficiency? Can you do an Evil act “well”? And where does that leave you? And what does it cost you? Now? Down the road?

Worse: if you are responsible for other people can you afford to ask questions like this? Shouldn’t you just go ahead and do what you have to and once people are safe hope that “God” or Something will recognize the risk you took for a Good cause and eliminate the consequences?

Anyway, is Violence always Evil? Can’t Violence be Good, in its inner essence, so that it wouldn’t be an accident that such ‘Good’ Violence brought about Good Consequences, but rather it would be a fulfilling of whatever laws run the world … ?

Or maybe it’s just that there is a type of person who will ask questions like this, wade into a swampful of conceptual thickets and never emerge to be successful in this world. And then there’s a type of person who will do what has to be done to get Success, and then worry about Good and Evil as a secondary, follow-on phase. Western civ would have a lot fewer works of art if medieval movers and shakers didn’t get to a certain point in their life where they realized that they were running out of phases and hoped that God would accept a new chapel or a painting in lieu of an eye for eye for each human life they had deformed while clawing their way to the top of the heap and staying there. Without Evil we’d have a lot fewer museums.

Once you’ve opted for Evil, is catastrophe certain to follow? Soon? Later? And if later, are there odds that it would be so much later that it would be worth it to do the Evil act now? Is it even sane to talk about an Evil act being ‘worth it’? If the catastrophe isn’t obvious, then does it count? If the catastrophe isn’t clearly connected to the Evil act, then might it just be an unhappy coincidence: you did Evil act A and Evil Event B happened to you shortly thereafter … ? Are all Evil events that happen to you ‘consequences’? Of your Evil? Of somebody else’s? How can you get stuck with somebody else’s consequences? Is the cosmic balancing act even so complex that it can track all that? But if there’s some “act” out there capable of tracking and balancing, then isn’t it possible that such an “act” is God? And if there’s a God, then shouldn’t we have some clear guidance in all this stuff? And if there isn’t a God but there is still something Beyond us, then what? And if there’s nothing Beyond us, then why ask all these questions?

Popular films and then TV all have one thing in common: things always work out well for our favorite people in the last reel of the film or the last segment of the show. Generations of Americans – almost all of us, by now – are so programmed to expect this that we hardly think about it any more. And the assorted Advocacies have not changed that: for every outrage, there is a court case nowadays that will bring the designated baddie to some form of ‘justice’. This is pure melodrama, which initially meant drama with music to heighten the effect. Even in so-called ‘news’ shows now the ‘music’ is there, playing in our heads: baddies get theirs and we – or our surrogates, the ‘victim’ – win. Our favorite people win, and who are our favorite people? Why, us, of course. It’s all a neatly tied-up bundle, a self-repeating, self-serving feedback loop. No wonder the news media – most of them – figure it’s easier to put out this kind of ‘reporting’ rather than do the hard and expensive and dangerous work of actually finding out facts and putting them out there.

But then we tried this in the foreign policy arena. It isn’t working at all. Even when the Incumbency – which had been banking on manipulating our melodramatic weaknesses all the way to Empire – captured Saddam, there was no sudden relief, no Win moment. Other peoples weren’t following the script, and we couldn’t spin them into it. With our homegrown perps it’s been easy: don’t let them speak, don’t let anyone speak for them, and to all appearances the melodrama rolls on to inevitable victory. The Advocates are welcomed as liberators of this or that victim of this or that oppression. Cakewalk. Slam-dunk.

Well, it’s not working. And now we’ve got a whole lot of un-spinnable folks mad at us. And worse: there appear to be consequences. Big-time. For us. It’s starting to become the new illusion that it’s all the Republicans’ fault, but now all that will soon be over because the Democrats are coming in. In “The Nation” magazine for November 13, Eric Alterman takes the country’s elites to task for failing. Absolutely. But then he opines that the elites failed in refusing to stand up to the fundamentalists and Republicans. And for the forty years before that? Are the Fundamentalists to be held completely responsible for their whacko ‘creation science’ when for decades before that they’ve had to listen to the ‘science’ put forth in support of this or that Identity and this or that Revolution? The ‘science’ that led to the passage of an awful lot of legislation that we’re probably going to be stuck with for quite a while but that not many of its erstwhile proponents really want to talk about it anymore now. The elites who jumped on the anti-white bandwagon, the anti-West bandwagon, and/or the anti-male bandwagon … ask them now about the ‘science’ that apparently convinced them to do so and you’ll get the same look Allied reporters would get when they talked to certain well-fed Italians in late 1943: why yes, they do recall being in government service until very recently, but it’s all rather vague and – frankly – they’d just like to go home now and be remembered as dedicated civil servants; and no consequences please; they were different times, life is so complex, why look backward now? That sort of thing.

So does Badness/Evil/Violence ‘work’ if it’s just done right? Well, if there’s nothing to life and History except appearances and if you control the appearance-making facilities, you could probably make a neat little closed circuit ‘reality’. But you’d have to keep it controlled and closed. Any ‘outside’ events or thoughts that got into the circuit could make a hash of your neat little game. Mussolini’s Italy looked pretty cool, and worked smoothly enough according to its own lights until he went and took his show on the road, out into the wide world, where there were uncontrollable others with their ideas and their passions and their abilities. Once his armies couldn’t control them, and then couldn’t even defend Italy against their retaliation, that was that. So too for his Axis allies.

And so you can almost trace the fortunes of Germany through Goebbels’ press releases and speeches: the Wehrmacht is advancing all along the Eastern Front, the Wehrmacht is fighting to consolidate its gains, the Wehrmacht is advancing backwards to draw the unexpectedly numerous but inferior Red Army into a trap, the Wehrmacht is shortening its supply lines by moving closer to the borders of the Fatherland, the recruitment ages have been extended to teens and old men to give everyone a chance to be patriotic, we just have to “ausharren” (stick it out, in the marvelous double-entendre), Victory or Siberia, and at the end many many Germans – civilians as well as soldiers – killed by rampaging Nazi Party members for not fighting as the tanks of the Red Army came down the main drag of their city or town.

But if there’s more to History, and thus to Life and maybe even to Existence and to the Universe, than just the appearances and how you spin them, then we are into a game we hadn’t even imagined existed: not a simple flat chessboard, but Vulcan chess with several boards and interaction among them. And from the sounds of a lot of our erstwhile elites, they weren’t even expecting chess – only checkers.

So in that sense, Iraq is not only a crisis in its own right. It is also a symptom of what has been happening in this country, to us, for decades now: we have a far too simplistic vision of Life and it is rendering us incapable of maturely interacting with the world. And we have a far too simplistic vision of what it means to be a Self, and that is rendering us incapable of maturely interacting with each other, too.

“Adulthood” has to be re-claimed and ‘valorized’ again. Just as a British population besotted by the Princess-Di funeral couldn’t muster what an earlier generation of Brits had mustered in the Blitz, so too there are far too many Americans who, in thrall to their assorted and diverse besotments, cannot muster the skills of Citizenship and thus cannot People this Republic. No People, no Republic. That much is simple and as clear as a bell. A firebell in the night.

Labels: , , ,