Wednesday, December 28, 2011

CATHARINE MACKINNON : HOW WE GOT HERE

A classic scene that has always remained with me: In 1939’s film version of ‘Gone With the Wind’, Jane Darwell’s proper Southern dame, Mrs. Merriwether, informed that Union troops were almost upon her beloved city, exclaimed: “Yankees! In Atlanta? How’d they git heah?”

The answer, which came to me as soon as I heard her voice the question, was that they had been coming all along, and for quite a while she had simply refused to entertain the possibility that such was so. Instead she carried on her wonted ways, living the life of a Southern dame as she always had.

And suddenly, the end was upon her.

At which point Gilbert and Sullivan’s obnoxious know-it-all comes to me as well: avoided by all decent company, whom he always loved to put down or to whom he always loved to administer a come-uppance, he laments his situation and “cawn’t think why” nobody wants to spend time with him.

Both thoughts came back to me as I recently put myself through law professor and touted ‘feminist scholar and thinker’ Catharine MacKinnon’s 1989 book “Toward A Feminist Theory of the State”.*

Not that either she or any of her sorority of vanguard cadres have ever declared any such moment of self-doubt; indeed, quite the opposite. She continues to receive encomia from other feminist best and brightest (such as feminist historian Christine Stansell and feminist philosopher Martha Nussbaum, to name but a couple of recent ones).

Such mutual and mutually self-serving encomia seem to be public valentines delivered to each other in assorted publications for all the like-minded to read. One thinks of the gilded if clunky encomia lavished by the early Soviet state upon those who cooperated with its utopian terraforming of Russia: Indefatigable Hero of the Five-Year Tractor Plan! Brass-hard Implementer of the Three-Year Cement Plan! Unswerving and Indistractable Protector of the Proletariat!

Yah.

And behind each element of such encomia, the bloody, soul-flattening wrack and ruin to innumerable lives and the subversion of an entire society and its culture and its people. Oh, and the enslavement of same.

But all in a good, indeed a marvelous and history-shattering, Cause.

Yah.

So anyway, in light of Our current omni-dimensional mess, I recently decided to look at this decades-old work, which contains thoughts which, she says (p.ix), she had been working on and talking about since 1971. Which, as it happens, is the year the Democrats decided to turn the Party toward the tempting female demographic, declare themselves “the Party of women”, and embrace whole-hog the agenda of radical-feminism (which, MacKinnon says, is the only feminism). Which, as it also happens, is the year before the Presidential election of 1972 when The People rejected the whole scheme  49 States to 1. And which, as it happens, is the year the Democrats began toying with the idea that since The People ‘just don’t get it’ then deliberative democracy (and the Framing Vision) were clearly not the way forward. **

And here We are.

And We are here, I will say, not because some amazing and powerfully coherent Theory suddenly swept all prior conceptualizations before it and had to be adopted simply in order to conform to a history-making discovery and revelation of how things work (such as, say, Newton’s Theory of Gravity), but rather because the desperate Dems (later to be joined by the Republicans for their own purposes) simply committed the entire power of the federal government and the Beltway behind it.

One thinks of Hitler promoting the utterly inexperienced von Paulus to command of the 6th Army in the Russian campaign, against all warnings that the man was a theoretician and war-gamer who had  utterly no field command experience – let alone in major combat – simply because Mr. Big figured that the man would be a pliable field commander who would without question carry out his orders. (Let alone that the orders von Paulus was to receive were increasingly militarily whackulent and lethally wrong to begin with.)

Radical-feminism ‘succeeded’ so quickly not because of the coherence and validity of its Theory but simply because the Beltway declared it overnight to be The Way in what has turned out to be a folie a deux of (ironically) nation-shattering proportions. Funny how the Theoretical, conceptual, and political night moves.

So let’s get on with this book – published in 1989, containing ideas she had been flogging since 1971 – and I think you will have a much clearer idea of a great part of the reason why ‘Yankees are in Atlanta’ now and the whole show now looks like it’s coming apart.

For that matter, I would recommend that We start looking at the history of the Confederate government – especially after the summer of 1863. (The Gettysburg and Vicksburg defeats were completed on the same day, July 4th, of that year. Who can say that History doesn’t have a sense of humor?).

What We would want to study, having looked at MacKinnon, is how a government starts to come apart after having fatuously committed itself to a lethal course, drinking vast draughts of the Kool-Aid of best-case outcomes and refusing to imagine any but the best Consequences issuing from its plans, and refusing – even as matters became ever more lethally serious – to ‘revisit’ its whole approach.*** (And can you say Iraq War?)

MacKinnon (henceforth: MacK) declares (p.ix) that she wants to demonstrate how “social power” shapes the way we “know” and how we “know”. In other words, MacK says here that there is no knowledge of reality that isn’t tainted with “social power”. Her plan is to replace ‘male’ social power with feminist social power and thereby create a whole new ‘knowledge’ – and anything built on the old way would be delegitimized.

You can see why radical-feminism was going to be – as Marxism/Leninism was – opposed to the Catholic Church from the get-go: the Catholic position is that there is a Reality, created by God, which human beings through their power of Reason (informed by Revelation) can reliably access: thus, humans can reliably (if not perfectly or completely) access Reality.

A Reality grounded not in human perception, but in God.

A Reality that reliably includes the nature and purpose of human beings, the ultimate meaning of their existence and the general Shape of being-human, boundaried but thus also focused.

Such a Vision was gall and wormwood to Marx as it is to MacK, since it leaves no ‘room’ to philosophically justify their agenda. (This is in no way a totalizing approval of capitalism or of theocracy, but simply a vital and utterly essential and basic aspect of the problem which Marx and MacK seek to merely sweep off the table as an element to be considered.)

MacK’s idea is that “gender hierarchy” actually distorts knowledge of whatever is ‘real’ and literally creates a false reality (p.ix). Therefore nothing that has previously been considered as ‘real’ (let alone Real) really is real, it is all thoroughly contaminated, and everything is up for grabs.

 Imagine, if you will, what such a corrosive idea will do if liberally poured onto the foundations – allowed to flood around, over, and under the foundations – of an entire culture and polity. This is what she’s going for (as Marx was going for) and it was clear not only from 1989 but from 1971 (when, she says, she first put together this book’s chapter on Marxism and radical feminism).

Did nobody in the Beltway care to give a thought to consequences? No. I would say that the Dems  and the Beltway entered into their pact with Marx and MacK and all their pomps and works with as much unthinking, delirious self-congratulation as the assorted State governments of the Confederacy as they seceded and envisioned the quick and easy winning of their war and the ushering in of their idea of the millennium, improving upon the Framing Vision at whatever cost it might take.

They imagined it would cost very little. It was to them as well as the people of the North that Lincoln admitted in his Second Inaugural that everybody had thought to expect “an easier triumph, and a result less fundamental and astounding”.**** And, for the Confederacy, catastrophic.  

She will look at the respective claims of Marxism and radical-feminism. (MacK considers radical feminism to be the only feminism; I shall refer to radical-feminism henceforth as R-feminism, to distinguish it from the ‘liberal’ and moderate feminisms which she helped kick to the curb.)

“Whatever its limitations”, she blithely says (p.ix), Marxism “confronts organized social dominance”.

Further, Marxism “identifies social forces which systematically shape social imperatives and seeks to explain human freedom both within and against history” (p.ix).

You have to wonder: did she give no thought to how Marxism actually wound up playing out? How perhaps it had to play out, in the further refinements of Lenin and Stalin and Mao? Mao, in the 1960s, was considered by the American far Left as the great liberator, whose Cultural Revolution – since revealed as a bloody and broad and deep wrecking of Chinese culture – was the clear sign that such a Way was the quick and easy high-road to ‘change’ and ‘progress’.

His 'example' particularly ensnared American leftists and Progressives – who had always harbored deep down an elitism of its elites against the unwashed and ignorant masses who wallowed in benighted ‘false consciousness’ and actually “just didn’t get it” and would have to be herded like sheep and stampeded like cattle toward the Great Good they were too weak and ignorant to embrace on their own.

But she – and she wasn’t alone among far Leftists in this country in those days – must have figured that there would be a way to import this plague bacillus and yet ‘baptize’ it with good intentions and make it work without ill-consequence here.

Or else she knew exactly what she was doing and said What the hell?

And the Beltway backed her to the hilt.

Marxism and R-feminism are alike in that they both have the good intention (let’s hope) of looking at a “social order” with an eye to “change” (p.ix).

And they are “theories of consciousness” before they are theories of change. In other words – sort of like religious belief – you have to “get it” before it all makes sense.

But how she can assert that Marx’s concept of “human freedom” (despite his admittedly good intentions) is valuable is beyond me. He reduced such human freedom to merely the material dimension, and the economic dimension, shearing off at a blithe but ruthless stroke any Higher dimension to human existence, and with it any Higher Purpose or Meaning.

She does the same, comparing R-feminism’s “explanation for the subjection of women” with Marxism’s “explanation for the exploitation of the working-class” (p.x).

This blithe assertion contains two huge assumptions.

First, the assumption that the economic exploitation of the working-class is accurately comparable to the “subjection of women”. Where the economic dynamics of capitalism were widely recognized as depriving the workers of a sufficient economic share of the wealth created, R-feminism’s theory of that “subjection of women” is a far more comprehensive and yet also immaterial, perhaps invisible and perhaps undemonstrable, claim. You almost have to “get it” before you can be sure you can see it … and even then …

Second, the assumption that the “subjection of women” as envisioned and asserted by R-feminism, is actually as easily attributable to some deliberate and determined “patriarchy” as the exploitation of the workers was clearly attributable to inequities in the distribution of the wealth created by the Industrial Revolution and capitalism.

While I don’t deny it as a theory or a hypothesis, yet there are surely alternatives and they are hardly minor possibilities. For one thing, it is equally possible that human civilizations – much like the builders of the Great Wall of China or Hadrian’s Wall – have from the beginning of human history built their social arrangements in some useful conformity with immovable physical realities.

Such as the quite probable evolutionary reality that since human beings are born so weak and require so long a time to reach even basic physiological and neurological maturity, the maternal human (i.e. the mother, a female by Nature’s decree) would be provided as a matter of evolutionary principle with the instincts and core-wiring to oversee that long developmental stretch. So that while the male is ‘gifted’ by Evolution with the urge to propagate, the female is gifted by Evolution with the urge to nurture; and the male is also gifted with the ability (and, it would be nice to say morally, the responsibility) to provide the material sustenance and protection during that long developmental stretch.

I am not here insisting that the Evolution-hypothesis is absolutely demonstrable, but it certainly qualifies as an alternative worthy of deliberation. (But of course, no such ‘deliberation’ was allowed and any such thoughts were, neatly, merely dismissed as “backlash” – not that Evolution seems to have gotten the Memo.)

The Evolution-hypothesis also gives some credit to prior millennia of human beings, who otherwise are hypothesized as being deliberately and mulishly engaged in or enthralled to some “patriarchal” conspiracy that has apparently existed since the beginning of recorded human history.

And that bit instantly raises rather difficult Questions.

How, for instance, did ‘males’ manage to effect this take-over in the beginning? How did they sustain it? If the plan was widely disapproved by half the species, how did it continue for so long (right up until the heroic cadres of America in the 20th century suddenly discovered it)? If the female half of the species did not sense that they were utterly oppressed and denied of some right, then what are We to make of that? If they did realize it, then what is it about them that enabled this thing not only to get started but to go on for so long (right up until the vanguard-cadres of R-feminism in the 20th century A.D.)?

We are induced to simply presume that the “oppression” has existed from the beginning of all time and must now be overthrown, just as Marx insisted that his materialistic reduction of all human meaning and fulfillment to the economic and material Plane of Existence simply be accepted as an irrefutable and fundamentally real given.

That is a huge given. And a huge give-away.

Of course, it is only when you have accepted a certain “consciousness” that you can simply accept the(huge and unproven) assumptions and gallop on from there, in the sure and certain ‘knowledge’ that your efforts to overturn the “dominant” and current “social hegemony” (p.x) are Right and Good and Real.

MacK is sure and certain that R-feminism had from the beginning presumed that it would have a theory of Gender as Marxism had a theory of Class (p.x).

But she establishes her cutting-edge creds not simply by taking Marx and substituting Gender for Class and ‘women’ for ‘proletariat’, but by insisting that Marx had not gone far enough.

So she has sought to “create such a theory by distilling feminist practice”, a theory that “could stand on its own” (p.x) and – nicely – perhaps blunt any objections that R-feminist theory simply took over Marx and made a couple of substitutions and then sought – alas successfully – to seduce the desperate Dems to buy what is basically Marxist analysis and put the resources of the American government at the disposal of the agenda to use that analysis and theory to attack American culture and society root and branch.

Did nobody see this in the Beltway? On the Hill? In the White House? Did the media not do any reading?

She quotes liberal thinker Sheldon Wolin that there are “epic theories” which claim to establish immutable basic principles in political life and then there are “scientific theories” that actually try to establish the facts of society and politics and effect changes here and there as much as they can.

Wolin, and MacK, humbly refuse to make “epic” assertions of principle.

But how establish “scientifically” the basic realities and facts of cultural, social, and political arrangements – especially if you plan to overthrow them from the get-go?

But that brings you right back to the queasy reality, even in MacK’s theory, that you have to “get it” before you can “see it”. And yet once you do “get it” then you “know it”, and even Know it with a capital-K since what your newly-raised consciousness is going to give you is nothing less than a reality (not just an opinion or viewpoint but a reality) that has been hidden from the beginning of time. It almost sounds like MacK has also done reading in St. Paul and John the Evangelist. And the Book of the Apocalypse.

And she surely has managed to resurrect the ancient concept of Gnosis, the special and secret knowledge that only the Elect know and that gives them the Key to all fulfillment and to how It All Works. How do you know the Elect? Only the Elect know the Elect and if you just don’t get it then you’re clearly not one of the Elect and you are hell-fodder so shut-up.

Such marvelous progress.

You hear echoes of MacK in the later John Rawls, as he tries to defend or cover the incoherencies in his own liberal-friendly theory of “justice” (first published, by the by, in 1972), by insisting that grand theories that explain everything (such as Christianity’s or any organized religion’s) with their unprovable assumptions should not be permitted to play a role in public deliberation and discourse since they are matters of belief; whereas his own – and MacK’s – theory does not indulge in unprovable assumptions but rather merely works with the ‘reality’ that “any reasonable person” could see.

Yah.

Marx fails, MacK asserts, because until she came along R-feminism “had no account of male power as an ordered yet deranged whole” (p.xi). Neat! But her assertions are more properly classifiable as a ‘theory’ or ‘hypothesis’ and most surely not as an “account”. The latter implies that it is an accurate and more or less complete explanation of something; the former indicates that it is one possibility open for examination and deliberation and analysis and testing. Which former is not at all what MacK or any other agents of R-feminism have ever allowed. (After all, why should they? Most people “just don’t get it” and any doubts or objections are only “backlash” anyway so what’s the point?)

We are still left with the Question of whether there even is such a thing as an entrenched and millennia-old “male power”, working in every known civilization and great culture in recorded history, imposed for reasons of pure macho greed and aggressive, assertive “dominance” upon females. And that has been deliberately structured merely to “oppress women”; a sort of millennia-long and world-wide Crime Against Humanity, or at least against half of Humanity.

That’s not a small Question.

Nor is it merely an academic or quibbling Question. On the basis of an asserted and assumed Answer to it, the US government has embarked on a truly world-historical assault on not only one half of its Citizenry but on the entire Culture and Ground of American society and its (putatively democratic) polity.

And now that the Consequences inherent in such incoherent presumptions and assumptions are now coming home to roost, this is no small Question at all. (And let Us pass over in silence for the moment the next Question: how any government on the planet – especially the government of a democratic and Constitutional Republic – could dare to abet it. Lenin, Stalin, and Mao tried it – among a pandemonium of lesser totalitarian demons – but this R-feminist 'success' has happened in the America of the past forty Biblical years. And was presented as cutting-edge reform and a Good and Great Idea. What are they going to think of Us, in future – and not too distant – generations?)

The state, MacK asserts, “participates in the sexual politics of male dominance by encapsulating and enforcing it in law” (p.x).

And now We get to where the rubber (so to speak) is going to meet the road. Law professor MacK is going to make her mark by leading the enlightened assault on American law. And perhaps now We get a better inkling of why the Constitution doesn’t seem to be working so well recently, either in ensuring fairness (you can’t, after all, have fairness in a system that is rotten to begin with) or in keeping the government itself within bounds (if any ‘reader’ can interpret the Constitution as a literary text however s/he wants, then why can’t the President?).

So she is going to “create a jurisprudence of change” (p.xiv). Which means that the Law will now serve the Revolution … and neither Lenin nor Stalin nor Mao could have put it more succinctly. In fact, now that R-feminism has so thoroughly infected the Beltway and the government, it could find no objection, or grounds to make an objection, to Mussolini’s world-historically pithy formulation:  “Nothing against the State, nothing outside the State, nothing above the State”. (Funny how the conceptual night moves. And who can say that History doesn’t have a sense of humor?) For if
the State has now become the bearer of the Great (and Gnostic) Wisdom, then there can be no opposition to such a Good Thing. This is a fatal error for a democracy and for a Constitutional Republic.

Then (p.xv) MacK goes pre-emptive. Against some, even among feminists, who ask how if we are the only ones who “know”, can we possibly “talk to” anybody else in this democracy? – MacK answers blithely and dismissively that “just because some people don’t like or fear what you have to say doesn’t make your argument wrong or impossible or untrue”.

 
Which is so, as far as it goes. But the fact that other people disagree with your ideas, perhaps profoundly, doesn’t make your ideas right, either. Except to adolescents, who somehow console themselves with the conclusion that if the grown-ups don’t agree with what they’re doing, then the kids must be right. Because, of course, grown-ups only exist to ruin your day and – not to put too fine a point on it – oppress you.
And which doesn’t answer the rather valid question she herself chose to ‘answer’. And clearly indicates that she’s not looking to talk to other people at all, but merely shut them up so she can make her point, which – she is sure and certain – is ‘reality’ and so those who “just don’t get it” don’t need to be talked-to anyway. Or at least, they should be talked-to, but don’t need to be talked-with.

Is it any wonder that democratic politics seem to have somehow collapsed, to be replaced with some nasty, irrational and childish something-else?

And anyway, she goes on (p.xv), Immanuel Kant’s whole approach of constructing universal principles (you know, like the ones that the Framing Vision and the Constitution are based on) is useless and wrong because it takes “real particulars” but then erects them into a “false universal”. Meaning that if anybody disagrees with you on principles, then all you have to do is wave them away with the assertion that there are no principles anymore and it’s all a matter of who can get the political clout to capture the “social hegemony” (which maybe you shouldn’t say in so many words – at least not til the Revolution is complete – but that’s what you can tell yourself – and then walk out and go have yourself a nice glass of a good Chardonnay with your sister-cadres who “get it”).

Kant is not “engaged” (shades of the ‘60s!) and R-feminists are “engaged” – meaning that they don’t approach a subject in the old masculine, abstractifying, detached way, but instead approach it with their deep inner feelings, which only others who “get it” can also feel. In other words, as the old ditty goes: “Here’s to all who wish us well, and all the rest can go to hell”. That “rest” meaning most of the Citizenry – and We wonder why the sense of “common-weal” is gone now.



But this ‘stance’ can hardly be the only one; even for an individual seeking to accurately understand an issue. This ‘engaged’ stance requires one to remain rather stubbornly and monomaniacally focused only on the problem and more specifically, focused only on the problem as one sees it and further presuming that the way one sees it is a) sufficiently accurate and b) the only way to see it. (One is reminded of the declaration (with its subtext of ominous threat and warning) that accompanied Nazi newsreels describing Hitler’s ‘successes’: Mehr als dieses braucht ihr nicht zu wissen!: More than this you don’t need to know!) Modern politics, influenced direly by this entire approach, also includes the cartoonish ‘logic’ that if you do not remain thus focused, then you must be a deliberate supporter of the problem yourself.

Rather, in order to get a fuller comprehension of a problem, you absolutely must also stand – at least for purposes of accurate analysis – outside the Problem. Once clear of its hot atmosphere, you can get a clearer picture of other factors (and their possible consequences); that is to say, you gain a clearer, larger, and fuller perspective. But this is precisely what R-feminist ‘engagement’ slyly forbids: to do anything that might weaken your burning emotional involvement is to betray the cause. Which, then, is precisely the great psychological and epistemological danger facing all ‘revolutionaries’: they purchase their emotionally vital attachment at the price of any fuller and more accurate comprehension of what faces them. They thus run the awful risks of taking ill-informed actions – which, of course, revolutionary theory would insist is not important because ‘revolutionary ardor’ will see them through regardless of the wisdom or whackulence of their actions. Hitler, as things began to go south in Russia, did precisely this, dismissing the Prussian Halder and taking on the Party-friendly Zeitzler as chief of staff: in the face of intensifying bad news, Hitler told Halder that “what is needed now is National-Socialist ardor” and not Halder’s frumpy insistence on facts and military realities.

I also note that when this approach – already well established in the Beltway and the national politics by 2001 – was deployed by Bush-Cheney (from the Right) in the analysis of intelligence during the run-up to the decision to invade Iraq, with lethal consequences. And if one wished to make the case that Bush-Cheney had decided to invade Iraq even before 9/11, then I would say that this simply demonstrates my point even further: the Objective you have decided on is all that matter, ‘facts don’t matter’ (that crapulent and hoary R-feminist mantra), and your zeal and willpower will force history and reality to conform to your dampdreams. Thus baaaad ideas migrate in the Beltway, to the undoing of all.
The R-feminist ‘knower’ is “inside” the problem; she is “situated” within it – that’s the hallmark of R-feminist “knowing” (p.xvi). In other words, I know what I feel, and what I feel is more right than whatever you think, and so I don’t have to listen to you or talk about it – nyah nyah.
My God.

And the Beltway bought it hook, line and sinker.

American politics as a bad 1970s family sitcom. This is the real dynamic around Carol Gilligan’s Breakfast Table. And it is no basis for a system of mature, adult, democratic government. As should be increasingly obvious.

But perhaps it’s too late for all that now.

Well, that was the Preface. There’s more – stay tuned.

 And start thinking.

NOTES

*My edition is the hard-cover edition published by Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-89645-9.

**See my Post on “Justice Brennan” here.

***In this regard, I remind you of Confederate General Pat Cleburne’s instant observation when informed, in the early months of 1865, that the desperate government in Richmond was going to allow ‘Negroes’ to enlist in the rapidly-dwindling army: “If the Negro can make a good soldier, then our whole theory of slavery has been wrong from the beginning”. Funny how the night moves.

****The text of that Address, here , is well worth a re-reading, imagining, as I have said, Ourselves in the position of the Confederate rather than the Union side.




Labels: , , , ,

Monday, June 21, 2010

SERIES ON NUSSBAUM: 1

Well, here We go – the series on Martha Nussbaum’s 2007 Harvard Law Review article (94 pages), entitled “Constitutions and Capabilities: ‘Perception’ Against Lofty Formalism”. The link to the text of her article is here.

Why do this? It is clear to me – as I don’t think has ever been made clear before – that the ‘reforms’ demanded in and incorporated into ‘feminist law’ or in the ‘governance feminism’ agenda are really far more significant and substantial than most Americans have been led to believe.

And on top of that, they are not only large but hostile to any traditionally understood concept of Constitutional praxis and the role of government in the vision of 1787.

And that a great deal of all of it has already found its way into major chunks of American law and legislation and regulations and regulatory law.

And that it has all been presented as being quite reasonable through the philosophical visions and systems of such professors as Nussbaum (she is one of the most prominent legal professors in the country and has been for a while).

And that her ideas have been widely propagated not only through feminist advocacy channels but even more significantly through several cohorts of law professors, whose students – or who themselves – have gone on to important positions as government or prosecuting attorneys, judges at all levels, and even as legislators at State or Federal level.

So this is important stuff if We want to grasp the dynamics underlying what has been happening – and what has happened – to the Constitution and the Republic and to a deliberative and democratic politics.

Enough said.

Let’s get to it. In this short series of Posts I’m going to go through the article sequentially, commenting on elements that strike me as significant.

As with all texts that are available in Adobe, there are two sets of page numbers: the page number assigned by the Adobe browser, and the actual page number of the document as it was written. In this case there is a 3 page difference, so when I make a reference to the text of the article it will look like this: page 13-16. The first number is the Adobe browser pagination, and the second is the actual text’s pagination.

When I discuss a particular point, I’ll try to quote the actual text on that point, so that you won’t have to do too much shifting from my Post to the Linked text.

Nussbaum starts by quoting Aristotle (2/5): “It is evident that the best political order is that arrangement in accordance with which anyone whatsoever might do very well and live a flourishing life”.

It’s a great thought. It represents a wonderful ideal. Western society has sustained a long struggle toward it.

Of course, you can’t just ‘quote’ a great thought from an acknowledged master and figure that you’ve done all work that needs to be done.

Aristotle, for example, would not have included women and slaves (and Greek slavery was not based on race – which was much more a European phase dating from the discovery of the New World) in his “anyone whatsoever”. He did mean, however, any adult male – and not just the ones in his particular City-State, which was quite a broadening thought in its time. He might even have meant ‘Persians’ and non-Greeks, which would have truly blown a few minds.

But there’s the second question about that “flourishing life”: you can’t know if a life is flourishing or not unless you know what it’s ideally supposed to look like. And that means you have to figure out what the Nature of the human being is, what the purpose of the human being is – in order to judge whether any individual’s life is actually conforming to the ideal.

(Nussbaum will depart from Aristotle here: in order to maximize its base and justify its deconstructive agenda, feminist law would claim – and the Supreme Court would echo in such cases as Casey – that while everybody has a right to ‘flourish’ YET nobody has the right to say what the ideal human being, or ideal human behavior, is or can be. In other words, the human being is totally ‘autonomous’, meaning that no power on earth can judge whether an individual human being is conforming to any ideal human-ness.

But she likes that ‘flourishing’ bit, so she’ll slyly keep it and let you think that she and Aristotle are of one mind and that her ‘thinking’ is just a continuation of Master Aristotle’s thinking, and equally as solid and reliable. Her bottom line – as you will see – is that the government has the responsibility to clear a path so that everyone can ‘flourish’, which means that they can do whatever they want to do and the government has to help them do it and keep everybody else from ‘judging’ it. Neat – a teenager’s dampdream.)

So she focuses on the question: “What are people able to do and to be?” (2/5) NOT ideally, but in terms of whatever they think it is that they want “to do and to be”. There can be no ‘ideals’ in Nussbaum’s (and feminist law’s) world: if there is an ideal, then somebody could ‘judge’ somebody else, and that’s a no-no.

But then you realize that this whole article deals with Constitutional law and thought, and thus with the role of the government, and especially in what ways the government MUST (because these are ‘Constitutional’ and ‘rights’ issues) aggressively and assertively shape national culture and deploy its sovereign authority to keep the field clear for all that ‘autonomy’.

So it gets your whiskers twitching when she immediately asks a follow-on question: “And are they really able to do or be these things … ?” (2/5) [italics Nussbaum’s] What she is introducing here is the queasy distinction between what things actually are when subjected to common objective examination, and what things really are [italics Nussbaum’s] … which means that only those with a certain special knowledge will be able to ‘see’ what’s ‘really there’. And you can see where she is going to be moving us into the realm of ‘special knowing’ (like Lenin’s idea that only the truly committed cadres, the ‘vanguard elite’, can really see and really know what’s good for Russia and for the Russian people).

So here at the outset Nussbaum is creating a slippery, shadowy field upon which national life and Constitutional issues are to be examined: there are things going on which aren’t going to be visible (or provable) to just-anybody, but instead will require special-knowledge (sorta like ‘you just have to get it’).

And this is on top of the fact that since these are Constitutional issues, then hugely fundamental matters are at stake, and the follow-on matter of how government might or must deploy its sovereign authority without obstruction or objection. So brace yourself.

About people, she continues asking, “Are there impediments, evident or hidden, to their real and substantial freedom? Are they able to unfold themselves or are their lives, in significant respects, pinched and starved?” (2/5) This is a flower-image – of the lovely flower unfolding as it blossoms, which recalls Flower Children, nicely enough. But it also implies that anything that keeps a flower from blossoming is bad (which it is, assuming the plant isn’t poisonous) and starts to grease the skids toward the follow-on connection that anything that keeps her ‘totally autonomous’ person from ‘blossoming’ is anti-natural and verrrry baaaaad.

And, with an eye toward anybody who will object to her vision: what sort of baaaad person would want to keep a flower from blossoming? Which greases the skids towards her conclusion that nobody can object because this is a matter of Constitutional Rights and so the government must impose it, and immediately and fully, without being slowed-down by deliberation, discussion, or the tolerance of any ‘intolerant’ dissent. Heeeeere we goooooo! You can see where all this might quickly lead.

She continues with the image: “What about their environment – material, social, political?” (3/6)

So you can see how quickly we’re out of the gardening and into the running of a nation and a culture.

“Has it helped them develop their capacities to be active in important areas of life? If people are like Pindar’s vine tree, is their environment more like a rich soil tended by wise and just gardeners, or more like an arid soil tended by indifferent gardeners, or gardeners with a restricted conception of their task?” (3/6)

So right off, you see where she’s going here. Assuming that the garden-tree image is valid, then it has to have a “rich soil” – and government has to make it so, and is Constitutionally required to do so.

AND if there are “gardeners” (the government) that either don’t care or don’t really ‘get’ just how much they’re supposed to be doing … then they are BAAAAD. As are, of course, any Citizens who might object to whatever she’s going to ‘discover’ with her ‘special knowledge’ that not everybody else can see; although they wouldn’t have the ‘right’ to ‘judge’ it anyway, and if they can’t see it, then clearly ‘they just don’t get it’. Can you get a sense of how Nussbaum is weaving a remarkably dense feministical web here? And laying the groundwork for a very anti-democratic, special-knowledge elite that nobody else has the right to argue with because nobody else ‘gets it’?

She cuts right to the chase: “How have the basic constitutional principles of a nation, and their interpretation, promoted or impeded people’s abilities to function in some central areas of life?” (3/6) Not a bad question, although from what you’ve already seen, she’s going down the garden path and we are all supposed to go along – and may well not have a Constitutional right to object.

Because she’s into Constitutional principles and interpretations here, and in matters that can be established to be relevant to fundamental Constitutional principles and interpretations, then the government in all its Branches can’t allow itself any delay in ‘fixing’ whatever is wrong.

This, you may recognize, is the application of the argument made in the First phase of the Civil Rights Era (up to July, 1965): because Negro/black rights to vote and influence public policy and live a life unhindered by race prejudice have so thoroughly been stifled by Jim Crow, then the Federal government, in the face of such clear, profound, and long-standing abuses has no right to delay in fixing things in the South right away, doing whatever it takes to clear away Jim Crow from Southern law (but also from Southern mind and heart and culture and society).

Which got the government verrry quickly into huge expansions of its power.

And in two ways.

First, the Federal government now took on the task not only of clearing away unjust laws, but also of literally Deconstructing Jim Crow in the minds and hearts and culture of the South and its Citizens, but also of Reconstructing those minds and hearts and that culture. Which is a huge expansion indeed.

Second, since Negro/black Americans lived all over the country – and were Citizens – then this entire project had immediately to be applied to the entire country, including the minds and hearts of its Citizens and the national culture. Which was even more huge.

When, shortly thereafter, the Feminist Revolution got itself going, the Feminists basically deployed the same scenario and the same argument (though never clearly and concisely stated): Males have done and have been doing to females exactly what the Whites of the South did to the Blacks through Jim Crow. Indeed, they said, the entire American culture and all its males and all its male-identified females are basically oppressing women with a gender-version of Jim Crow.

So then, ‘logically’, the government must Deconstruct and Reconstruct American ‘male’ society and culture and all the Citizens (male and female) who support it. And it has to be done NOW without any delay (or public discussion or deliberation – which is useless since most folks are gender-Jim-Crow types anyway) and if you can’t ‘see’ that, then ‘you just don’t get it’.

And that’s what drove so much of the wrack of the past 40 Biblical years. And – who could be surprised? – a Constitution that couldn’t be respected because it was Jim Crow in a gender as well as a race way, was in the Bush-Cheney era considered to be a Constitution that didn’t have to be respected when it came to government waging wars and doing all sorts of other stuff without wasting time on ‘ public deliberation’. "And the toe-bone is connected to the foot-bone, and the foot-bone is connected to the ankle-bone, and the ankle-bone is connected to the leg-bone", and … you know the rest.

And immediately she sets the script and the plot: “Does the interpretation of constitutional entitlements yield real abilities to choose and act, or are the constitution’s promises more like hollow verbal gestures?” (3/6)

Bang. What the country has now, she intends to show, are merely ‘hollow verbal gestures’. And that what she (and feminism) wants are not ‘new’ things that are ‘changes’ (which could be argued about and deliberated upon) but instead are “constitutional entitlements” – so no delay or dissent can be permitted. See where she’s going?

Naturally, what in current ‘everyday’ political talk is called ‘patriarchal oppression’ or some such, is – on Nussbaum’s much deeper Constitutional level – an ongoing Constitutional deprivation which must be addressed without delay or dissent. This is the old culture-war feminism now not claiming to be a ‘new way of thinking about things’ but rather now claiming to be a long-standing Constitutional issue of rights-and-entitlements-denied. And so there need be no more public debate or concern: it’s all Constitutional.

She’s going for government imposition of the whole old culture-war agenda, not simply out of political expediency (as it had been decades ago) but now out of Constitutional responsibility.
Of course, if a pol can do something politically expedient while being told that s/he’s doing it out of Constitutional responsibility – well, that’s real catnip.

And this thought of Nussbaum’s is not ‘new’ in 2007 when she wrote this article. She’s been teaching it and writing about it in law schools and other venues for decades, so generations of lawyers, judges, and pols are now not only familiar with it but also – I’m going to bet – were taught in law school that this was the True and Only Way to look at things. And you wonder why democracy and the Constitution don’t seem to be working so well recently?

But this is her plan and she’s sticking with it. “The idea that all citizens in a nation are equally entitled to a set of substantial preconditions for a dignified human life has had a lasting appeal over the centuries in Western political and legal thought – less because intellectuals have favored it than because it has great resonance in the lives of real people”. (3/6)

Notice what she’s doing here.

Suddenly it’s not a matter of the political rights of 1787, many of which limited the government’s ability to interfere not only with individual Citizens’ lives but also with the much wider civil society and culture. NOW she’s changed the field of concern to “a set of substantial PRECONDITIONS” … which means that government is not only going to simply referee a Game – so to speak – whose laws and bounds are already drawn (and refs have to follow the rules just like anybody else). Instead, government is now going to be mussing around in ‘preconditions’ – the refs are going to say where the field is built, the composition of the soil, the drawing of the lines, the whole enchilada.

And the government as uber-ref is now also going to be ‘interpreting’ just what those “preconditions” are (and of course, the more and deeper the preconditions, the more room for government authority). And what earthly government is going to say No to such a free-buffet of power?

Well, the government put together by the Framers of 1787 said No, but – Nussbaum and others are convinced – they were ‘defective’ and their Constitution and their Vision was ‘defective’, ‘incomplete’, and altogether “quaint” (as the feculent Alberto Gonzales said with waayyyyy too much candor in the service of the Bush-Cheney imperium … and his era of Beltway biggies had simply concluded that if the Left can re-arrange the Constitution for its own purposes, so can the Right).

And this approach of Nussbaum’s isn’t going to be on the visible spectrum, as say the great struggle from the 1870s to the 1930s was; Teddy Roosevelt and FDR and LaGuardia and the Progressives of the 1890s to the 1920s were trying to deal with concrete issues like wages and social insurance and the role of the government as being the only power in the country that could stand up FOR Citizens against the huge new agglomerated power of the industrial corporations and corporate combines.

No, this approach of Nussbaum’s is going to be along an invisible spectrum that only those who ‘get it’ can see. And this itself mirrors the attack – spearheaded by the Feminist Revolution and its cadres – upon the entire foundation of assumptions and beliefs and structures that not only have grounded world cultures since the beginning of human history but also ground the Constitutional Vision of 1787.

I’m not saying thereby that all of the Revolution’s agenda is ‘wrong’ – I’m saying that some change THIS big and THIS profound has to be looked at verrrrry carefully. And certainly has to be given more and more thorough public deliberation and airing than has been the case up to now. For 40 years the government simply imposed the Correct changes, with the cheer-leading connivance of a ‘free press’ that is supposed to be the watch-dog, not the cheerleader, of government activity.

BUT THIS IS PRECISELY what Nussbaum is trying to sidestep by saying that all of this is a matter of Constitutional rights and therefore you can have no delay and no discussion and there’s nothing to be deliberated anyway. Neat. Dangerous. Treacherous, even, maybe.

It’s a verrrry iffy thing – just what those “substantial preconditions” are. And also just what “a dignified human life” is – although we already know that Nussbaum, true to feminism’s agenda, is going to say that no government and no culture has the right to ‘judge’ what behaviors or characteristics constitute such a “dignified human life”; no, rather a human life is “dignified” simply by virtue of the fact that a human being says that this is what she wants to do and nobody can say No and the government has to make it all work out well.

And Nussbaum is writing in a cultural context where feminism has already ‘deconstructed’ any sense of the ‘moral’ and of the Beyond or of any standard or criterion in which a culture or a society or a civilization can say or choose just what characteristics and what Vision will Ground it. For political purposes, America exists in a flattened, two-dimensional world where there is only politics as a determinant of what does (or should) happen – which, come to think of it, closely resembles the Materialistic reductionism that ultimately made Marxism (from the Left) and Fascism (from the Right) so utterly inadequate to the task of addressing the reality of human beings who are – notoriously – so stubborn in their yearning for a Beyond-the-Material dimension to their daily existence.

Shrewdly, she is spinning her plan as not simply ‘good’ because “intellectuals have favored” it (the academic and Beltway elites of today) but rather because it has “great resonance in the lives of real people”.

That last bit sounds nice, but her (and feminism’s) view of “real people” is two-dimensional and Flat (as Marxism’s was). And as I have observed, “real people” are and since the dawn of the species have always been desperately and implacably concerned for a Beyond, for a Real that is more than the ‘real’.

It will be this actuality that will prompt her to give up, later in the article, on any democratic and deliberative process to get her vision accepted: because so many of those “real people” for 40 Biblical years have been stubbornly resistant to being Flattened. It’s not ‘backlash’; it’s more like the horse’s sense, after putting one hoof on it, that a bridge it’s supposed to walk over is wayyyyy too rickety and won’t hold up.

Nussbaum, just to give you a sense of where she’s going to be going, will argue that since most people in the country can’t be trusted to ‘get’ her ideas, then the acceptance of her (and feminism’s) vision and scheme can’t be left up to them and instead has to be imposed by the Courts (she doesn’t even trust Congress any longer). Thus this ‘Constitutional’ approach – since it sidesteps any public debate and deliberation.

Well, that’s enough for this Post. Let me just say that it’s not going to be necessary to go through every page of her 94 pages the way I have had to move through this first couple of pages here. In these early pages she is pretty much outlining her approach and so I have to spend more time on them.

(Please note: the site dates a piece by when it was first put up; I put this piece up in Draft form on Monday, June 21, but I didn't actually publish it until Thursday, June 24.)

Labels: ,

Saturday, June 12, 2010

SECOND PRELUDE TO NUSSBAUM

(As I said in my previous Post, I am preparing a short series of Posts on the feminist legal philosophy of Martha Nussbaum, since there is a hell of a lot in there that has been verrrry strongly driving all sorts of developments in legislation, jurisprudence, and general elite thought for decades now. But in the course of other responsibilities, I had to prepare a short series of comments that specifically dealt with Domestic Violence and Sex Offense developments from the legal and cultural point of view. I am putting them both up here since I discuss dynamics and ideas that have been introduced into the wider American culture and are still operating widely and robustly now.

A couple of acronyms u abbreviations: AWA is the Adam Walsh Act (2006, Federally organizing Sex Offense registries); SORNA is Sex Offender Registration and Notification; SO is Sex Offender.)

I wanted to do a follow-up Post restating or amplifying for clarity what I was driving at in the Nussbaum Post. I covered a lot of ground and there were – I think – some important points.

Before doing that, I have to make note of the Ohio Supreme Court Opinion in Bodyke and the US Supreme Court’s (somewhat surprising) Opinion in Carr. The cases are discussed at length on the several SO sites, and as so often, the Constitutional Fights site is a useful gateway.

In both cases the Courts have decided against AWA and in favor of the SOs. (And there is a further piece there about how States are still concerned about the financial costs of implementing AWA even with Obama’s sly addition of law-enforcement funding to cover some of the expenses; the start-up and projected expansion and maintenance costs have been – surprise! – understated by supporters of AWA, and the States – I wonder about the public – are shrewd enough to realize that they are going to get stuck not only with a big bill, but an ever-expanding bill for the whole thing.)

In Bodyke the increasingly interesting Ohio Supreme Court ruled that SOs cannot be reclassified by AWA if they have already been classified by court action (i.e. they were classified as part of the judgment that convicted them); this is a Separation of Powers ground (i.e. the Legislative and Executive cannot ‘decree’ changes to established Judicial Branch decisions).

Now this doesn’t reach – and the Court seems purposely to avoid the thorny thing – the issue of Retroactivity: can you retroactively add punishments to a crime for which one has already been convicted? As you may know, to raise the Retroactivity issue a Court would then have to formally decide whether AWA (and perhaps all of the Registration and Notification regime) is ‘criminal’ rather than ‘civil’; and that would be a truly significant decision.

As it stands, there are now 26, 000 or so Ohio SOs who must immediately be put back to their original conviction-classification on the AWA-compliant Ohio registry. Constitutional Fights reports that it actually called the Ohio Attorney General’s office and was put on hold and then given a run-around as to when the AG was going to get around to completing that now Court-mandated task; if the SOs’ names are left on the internet Registry in their new (and enhanced) AWA classification then the State itself will be committing an illegal act.

This will only have ramifications for SOs in States where the classification is actually part of the conviction sentence by the trial court. But Ohio is not the only State where that is done, and so this case will set a precedent.

In a larger sense, of course, the Ohio Bodyke case signals a judicial unease with the AWA (and perhaps entire SORNA) regime. And while the more professional SO sites, where attorneys make comments, are right to note that the actual legal effects are not large, yet still there is the unmistakable sense that the winds are changing.

There was a Dissent in the case where one of the Ohio Justices opined that reclassification is merely administrative and not a ‘further punishment’ – but that’s the old song.

In the even more surprising Carr case, the US Supreme Court, although divided 6-3, said that Carr could not be charged with a SORNA violation for an act that took place before the AWA law took effect. Again, the Court here does not clearly reach the Ex Post Facto or Retroactivity issues, which – if decided against AWA – would be lethal to the SO Mania law regime.

Instead, the Court simply states that Congress did not expressly authorize Retroactive application in the AWA enabling legislation. So it’s something of a ‘technicality’ – the Court leaves for another day the heavy-lifting involved in tackling head-on the Constitutionality of the regime. Congress could re-write AWA to expressly order retroactive application, and then the matter would have to make its way back up to the Supreme Court on those grounds.

Of interest here is that Justice Sotomayor wrote the majority Opinion, while Justice Ginsburg – the other woman on the Court – Dissented.

Sotomayor is deploying a bit of feminist-law thinking: that you have to consider not simply the formal law in question, but also take into account the effect upon those who must bear the burden of the law.

Ginsburg – true to a form that has not been sufficiently examined – seems to be writing from an older feminist-law thread whereby ‘women’ must be aggressively protected from male sex aggression and any law that works toward that must be upheld. I also note that Ginsburg operates well within the Nussbaum vision: since it is a ‘given’ that males ‘aggress’ against women sexually, then women’s rights are thereby violated and the government must use its sovereign legislative and police powers immediately and aggressively to put a stop to that. (Although it has become increasingly clear and well-documented how ineffective the SO regime laws really are even in achieving their stated purposes of public and women’s purported safety.)

See my thoughts further on in this Post where I discuss that thread and its approach a bit more.

All in all, I am verrrrry leery of the feminist-law approach and the mind-set that underlies it. (Which is not at all to say that I support genuine sexual offending by anybody of any age or gender against anybody of any age or gender; nor am I anti-woman or misogynist or in favor of female Citizens being deprived of Constitutional protections.)

And while it is nice to see how even feminist-inspired legal thinking can actually work in favor of SOs, I also realize that the entire SO Mania is profoundly inspired by the general feminist-law approach as it has evolved in this country over the past few decades.

So much for the cases. Let me move on to some further discussion of Nussbaum – since her vision is a major element in the theoretical underpinning of the feminist-law agenda.

As I had said in my previous Post, it seems to me that the 1970s saw feminist-law thinking and strategizing adopt the Black Civil Rights paradigm. In that paradigm, it was simply (and generally) accepted as true and as a given that the South of the Jim Crow Era (between roughly 1875 and 1965) clearly discriminated against Blacks in the South in such profound and clearly un-Constitutional ways that the government was justified in stepping in and vigorously re-arranging Southern culture and society in order to finally put an end to the whole Jim Crow regime.

Thus the government would be ‘regulating’ the South and its laws and its culture through aggressive action. So there was a ‘presumption of guilt’ – and that presumption was made against all Southerners such that you pretty much could and had to presume that everyone and everything down there was ‘tainted’ with Jim Crow thinking.

Nor did you have to presume that Southerners were individually and consciously seeking to abrogate or suppress the Constitutional rights of Blacks in the South: Jim Crow was so much a part of the warp and woof of Southern culture of that Era that even ‘decent’ white Southerners who had no conscious and deliberate ill or malicious intentions could grow up in that culture simply assuming the ‘normality’ (and even Constitutionality) of Jim Crow.

Thus ‘regulatory’ law would be the paradigm: the government would literally re-form or re-shape Southern culture so that it would no longer provide a seed-ground for Jim Crow-type suppression of Black Constitutional rights.

And, as I said, this ‘regulation’ presumed the tainted nature of Southern culture and of the mind-set of most Southerners. And Southern law – though ‘legal’ – and Southern legal thought had to be overridden in any instance where it operated to effectively deprive Southern Blacks of their Constitutional rights.

This might work in a ‘regulatory’ law approach.

But you can see where it bodes hugely dangerous trouble if applied to the practice of Constitutional criminal law: you cannot, in Constitutional criminal law, ‘presume’ the ‘guilt’ of an accused defendant. Indeed, such a presumption is not only un-Constitutional but profoundly anti-Constitutional.

Feminist law – and Nussbaum insofar as she codifies feminist-law thinking and underpins the feminist-law agenda – adopted the Black Civil Rights approach as it sought (and seeks) to re-shape American culture.

Thus, according to the paradigm: American culture is as hostile to women - and even more so - as Jim Crow culture was to Blacks; and since then the entire American culture is ‘tainted’ with those habits of thinking and acting, and since American law and jurispraxis is so tainted as well, then the government sovereign power must be deployed against American culture and the ‘male’ mind-set just as aggressively as it had been against the anti-Black Jim Crow culture and mind-set in the South.

Thus much of the ‘culture war’ dynamic as it has played out in the country for the past decades. Although most media and public attention was focused on ‘instances’ of such deprivation, rather than on the deeper legal thinking that was starting to flood in with ‘feminist law’.

But then in the Domestic Violence and Sex Offense legislation, you start to see the migration of this ‘regulatory’ approach into the criminal law. Thus for example, the ‘male’ is ‘presumed’ to be violating the rights of the female, and the government power thus must be exercised not to determine guilt (which is already presumed) but rather to ‘vindicate’ the rights of the female (increasingly cast as ‘the victim’).

You can see this clearly and quickly in the Domestic Violence entry in the massive “Corpus Juris Secundum”*, the legal encyclopedia that amasses all of the case law in a given area of legal practice. A 1987 Pennsylvania case is cited** wherein a court upholds the Domestic Violence legislation against Constitutional challenge by stating that such (at that time) apparently un-Constitutional novelties as ex parte court procedures, deprivation of access to property and family, warrantless arrests on the say-so of one person, and many of the other elements of Domestic Violence law were justified because of a) the ‘emergency’ of (male) violence and b) “to compensate for deficiencies in the criminal justice system”.

Note the ‘emergency’ bit. You don't have to go too far back in world history to see the ominous results of 'emergency' laws.

Note too that the “deficiencies” the court refers to are actually the Constitutional principles precisely set up by the Framers to prevent the hasty and emotional misapplication of the sovereign police power against a Citizen. IT WAS PRECISELY TO GET AROUND THEM that the feminist-law approach – with its incessant trumpeting of ‘emergencies’ that precisely DO require ‘hasty’ action – selected the ‘back-door’ paradigm of Civil and Constitutional Rights in order to insinuate itself into the American legal system.

Thus, Domestic Violence law is asserted to be ‘civil’ and ‘regulatory’ in nature and not ‘criminal’ (although, neatly, if you violate a DV protection order then you are subject to criminal penalties). And it ‘presumes’ the ongoing offenses on the part of the ‘male’ just as the Civil Rights Era anti-Jim Crow regulatory approach presumed the racism of the Southern culture and population, regardless of whether any of those folks thought they were committing, or intended willfully to commit, a crime.

And in the 1980s Domestic Violence law you start to see verrrry queasy ‘reforms’ that – by the way – are not at all unfamiliar to the SO community: these are ‘civil’ and not ‘criminal’ procedures (although – tee hee – criminal sanctions apply if you violate the Protective Orders); the ‘emergency’ is soooo great that SOMEthing must be done without any further delay; the goal is not ‘punishment’ but MERELY ‘prevention’; the now-traditional promise that the whole regime will ‘end’ something (in the Domestic Violence scheme, ending ‘family disruption’); and the grab-bag of dangerous tactics: ex parte issuance of Orders, warrantless arrests even on one’s own property, accepting the ‘word’ of the reporting party as sufficient to deploy the police power, as well as the de facto presumption of guilt.

Now what starts with Domestic Violence is taken to a dangerously aggressive new level in the 1990s Sex Offense regime – you are seeing an even clearer migration of the ‘regulatory’ into the ‘criminal law’ arena. And that’s on top of the whole invasive government-power paradigm derived from the Civil Rights Era.

The effect – and I believe the intent – of the feminist-law approach here is to sidestep or get-around the Constitutional safeguards that protect individual Citizens from the invasive and hasty application of the sovereign government police power through the criminal law.

Thus, SOs, like the Southerners of the Jim Crow Era paradigm, are presumed to be violent and dangerous; and thus they must be ‘regulated’ in the interests of an aggrieved group whose rights are already known to have been violated such that the government is not creating a ‘new’ level of invasiveness but rather is merely stepping-in to redress a long-standing abrogation of ‘rights’.

And thus SOs are not so much individual Citizens who – at most – have deliberately committed a crime; rather, like those Jim Crow Southerners, they are a deeply misguided group that has – whether deliberately or otherwise – been violating ‘rights’ and have to be stopped through ‘regulation’. AND you can presume as a given that they are doing the violating.

And so any ‘trial’ is going to be a ‘show trial’ in the formal sense: a trial not to ascertain guilt or innocence, but rather to ‘show’ that the government power will redress, prevent, avenge against actions that are so abusive of others’ rights that the actions must be stopped immediately.

THIS, I think, helps explain the profound intransigence of legislators and jurists in the matter of establishing and critically analyzing the SO Mania regime of laws. They are not simply politically pandering to vocal ‘interests’ (although that too now is a major element in this thing). Rather, they are convinced by this ‘regulatory’ paradigm (long espoused by Justice Ginsburg, and codified in the law schools by Professor Nussbaum) that they are doing The Right Thing, the same way that the legislators of the 1960s did The Right Thing by putting an end to Jim Crow culture in the South.

So the ‘regulatory’ and ‘civil’ aspects of the SO regime are actually vital elements of the Mania, specifically and deliberately (I would say) selected precisely as a way of circumventing ‘traditional’ American Constitutional safeguards.

To put it another way: if you have a ‘right’ not to have a crime committed against you, then any crime committed against you can be construed as a violation of your purported ‘Constitutional right’ not to have a crime committed against you (or, put another way, your ‘right’ not-to-live-in-fear-of-a-crime-being-committed-against-you). THIS THEN triggers the Southern Jim Crow paradigm, whereby you are having your ‘Constitutional rights’ violated and the ‘defendant’ or alleged perpetrator is now also an ongoing civil-rights violator.

AND ONCE THAT paradigm is accepted, then the classic and traditional (and indispensable) Constitutional rights accorded to accused Citizens that are enshrined in the Constitution are effectively sidestepped and defendants can be treated by the government not as the classic ‘defendant’ but rather as an already-presumed civil-rights-violator; and there go defendant rights (which are, let's be honest, everybody's rights).

And since the whole thing is a matter of ‘civil rights’ and not of a specific alleged crime, then not only are defendants' Constitutional protections sidestepped but defendants are subjected to the tripwire jurisprudence and legislation that are the consequence and legacy of the anti-Jim Crow campaign of the Civil Rights Era.

Verrrrry neat. Verrrrrrrrrrrrrry dangerous.

This entire dynamic is reinforced by Nussbaum’s long held belief that ‘emotions’ are themselves a form of ‘reasoning’ rather than a potentially dangerous rival to ‘reasoning’. (Which is a curious position for a feminist, who might reliably be imagined to refuse any such equation of ‘female’ and ‘emotionality’ as opposed to ‘rationality’ – but Nussbaum tries to solve that problem for herself by claiming that ‘emotionality’ is a form of ‘rationality’ … neat.)

And of course, one of the primary emotions is Fear – and once that is introduced as a primary element in jurisprudence and in the justification for sweeping police-power legislation (even when costumed in ‘civil’ or ‘regulatory’ sheeps-clothing) – then any Constitutional ethos is in a heepa trubble.

Ditto ‘outrage’ if you presume or discover yourself to have been denied your ‘rights’ all along.

Ditto raging impatience as you feel yourself justified to ‘demand’ immediate redress and vengeance.

Ditto the legislators and jurists who then want to mollify all these raging feelings and yet still claim to be acting (legislating, adjudicating) ‘rationally’. Oy.

And further, I had mentioned in the previous Post that Nussbaum wants to see her concept of ‘rights’ imposed by courts – especially the Supreme Court, because she doesn’t really trust ‘politicians’ or the ‘political process’ any more. But of course, you couldn’t trust the Jim Crow Era Southerners to clean up their own culture because they were so thoroughly used to it that they would neither be motivated to change nor able to see what had to be changed in the first place. They were like fish who are so used to ‘water’ because they have spent their lives in it and only in it, that they don’t and can’t realize that the water exists at all.

In the Nussbaum-Ginsburg vision, American culture (and – even more sweepingly – human culture) is as profoundly besotted and deformed by ‘male’ and ‘macho’ thinking and acting (especially in matters sexual) as Jim Crow culture was besotted and deformed by anti-Black racism.

And American culture doesn’t even know it – but the elite cadres know it, so We – like the lumpen, donkey Soviet masses – just have to trust them. Or else.

And that therefore, in terms of the paradigm, American and world culture must be as vigorously and aggressively ‘changed’ as the culture of the Jim Crow South was.

Hence you get a Beltway, now, that considers itself empowered to do all of that, and not only here but abroad as well.

And – since the trouble is not so much a ‘criminal’ act as it is a thoroughly tainted and debased ‘white and male’ cultural outlook and way of living and thinking and being – then the government sovereign power must be deployed against the most profound core of the national culture itself.

This is a recipe for a lot of things, not all of them good.

But it certainly requires something more than a ‘limited government’ in the Constitutional and Framing vision – which is precisely why the Constitution has been under sustained and lethally profound assault not only from the Right but from the Left (which was supposed to be the ‘liberal’ and pro-people side).

And, I think, it is the profound un-ease evinced in the hearts and minds of the Citizenry that has constituted so much sustained hesitation about embracing this vision that Nussbaum now (in her 2007 article) effectively declares that ‘democracy’ cannot be trusted to ensure her vision of ‘rights’! So she looks to the courts. (And thus you can see why, on a much deeper level than is usually noticed, it is essential that persons (and not necessarily female) who buy into this vision are appointed to the Supreme Court.)

Oy.

Which brings me to my last point: defining ‘rights’ in all of this. There are, I would suggest, three overall conceptions of American Constitutional rights: the first is the 1787 vision: Americans as individuals and as a civil society have a right to be free from any excessive government (National even more than State) intrusion or aggressive action that is not most clearly and undeniably justified. In this vision, the government police power and sovereign authority must be bound so as not to flood like the Mississippi and wreck everything built up along its banks and flood-plain.

The second vision is FDR’s rather overly capacious ‘Second Bill of Rights’ of 1944: every American should have a right to a job with a living wage, a home, freedom from unfair competition and monopolies, medical care and education. Now the government power is envisioned not simply as keeping the boundaries of the national ‘playing field’ steady and level and clear but is actually going to be running the national ‘game’ – this suggestion of FDR’s was a huge (and not altogether workable) change from the 1787 vision.

Even more so was his Four Freedoms: freedom OF speech and expression and freedom OF religion; but also freedom FROM want and FROM fear. You can see quickly that any government that would seek to implement the provision of such Freedoms as FDR proposes was going to have to be a verrrry busy government indeed.

And so especially in the matter of Freedom From Fear: if a government has guaranteed to its people that it will protect them from all Fear, then that government is going to need the wisdom and organizational ability and authority of ‘God’.

And if you watch the development of feminism and victimism through the last few decades in this country – where ‘fear’ seems to be the primary characteristic of Citizens … then you can see where this all can go. And if on top of that you accept the vision that one group of your own Citizens is by very nature and cultural upbringing the greatest source of ‘fear’ among the rest of the Citizens … you can see quickly where the Sex Offender becomes not simply a Problem, but a Necessary Demon that has to be invented in order to keep the Fear Factor up. Oy.

Or, to put this point another way: the massive post-1965 Second Reconstruction of Southern culture and laws could not have happened unless there was the 'emergency' and 'outrage' posed by the ongoing and violent 'taint' shared by Southern culture and by - for all practical purposes - all Southerners; the Southerners were the ongoing evil perps whose existence was essential to catalyze and justify the massively intrusive extension of Federal authority in those States.

So too, I would say that the existence of the ongoing, uncontrollable and irredeemable 'sex offender' is essential to the massive extension of Federal authority in the Sex Offense Mania and its regime of frakkulent laws.

And, of course, all of this dovetails with feminism's Deconstruction-Reconstruction of 'tainted' American culture and society and - oy! - the American Constitutional ethos and even the democratic and deliberative process. (After all: according to Nussbaum, it's not the 'process' but the 'outcome' that is important here: the 'taint' has to be thoroughly uprooted like the Biblical weeds among the wheat - and it has to be done RIGHT NOW because, neatly and slyly if also somewhat incoherently, it is a 'constitutional rights' problem.)

But then there is also this third vision of ‘rights’: Nussbaum’s Capabilities Approach. Here, as I noted in the previous Post, she is claiming that ‘formal rights’ aren’t at all enough: government must do whatever it takes in order to make sure that everyone has AN EQUAL CHANCE to exercise those rights.

And once again: when government is not only tasked with keeping itself from intruding into the polity, and not only tasked with ensuring protections that not even Divine Providence has historically guaranteed in this life, but is also tasked with ensuring that absolutely nothing interferes with the Capability to Exercise the Rights that the Constitution guarantees … then you have a Benevolent Despot from hell.

So when the term ‘equal rights’ is thrown around, you have to understand that there are hugely different ‘loads’ that the phrase might be made to bear.

And you have to ask the speaker of the phrase just how s/he defines ‘rights’ in order to get an inkling of just how much government power will be necessary to guarantee that they are ‘equal’.

And you can’t ignore the question as to whether any earthly government has a reasonable chance of doing so much. And doing it well.

And whether the government of 1787 – not because it was ‘male’ or ‘majority’ or ‘white’ but simply because it was HUMAN – has any possibility of undertaking such a huge agenda and yet still remaining a limited government.

Thus when you hear folks saying that the Constitution is ‘defective’ or ‘quaint’ or ‘inadequate’ you have to ask yourself some very serious questions as to just what the speaker expects the government and the Constitution to be doing.

Because if feminist law is essentially implying (though slyly not saying it in so many words) that if 'limited Constitutional government' doesn't meet its demands (couched as 'equal rights' arguments) then 'limited Constitutional government' has to go ... if THAT is the core dynamic of their programme, then We most surely have a huge national discussion to conduct.

(And if several decades of generations of law students, law professors, attorneys, prosecutors, and judges at all levels have already been produced under the illusion that this type of dreck is 'cutting edge' and 'progressive' and 'reform' thinking, then We most surely are in a heepa trubble.)

So then, I see after reading Nussbaum , that Sex Offenders and the Mania and its regime are not simply a cynical and duplicitous effort of a failing government to pander to certain ‘interests’ in the hopes of securing electoral support and distracting public attention from its own short-comings.

Rather, the SO Mania is simply a step in the deliberate effort, grounded and guided by Nussbaum’s game-plan (Ginsburg the most successful quarterback), to profoundly alter the role of government by seducing it into taking on Objectives and Goals that no human, let alone limited, government can ever realize.

To imagine that such a plan is merely ‘optimistic’ and ‘progressive’ is to imagine that a hippopotamus can fly – or even dance ballet in a tutu (the Boomers have gotten wayyyy too much of their political philosophy from Walt Disney, if you ask me).

And so Our present rendezvous with Destiny is located here on the cutting edge of this frightening shift in American governance as its elites attempt to move the tectonic plates upon which the whole polity rests. Blithely if not also arrogantly consoling themselves that they are on a Cutting Edge and in possession of The True, Correct, and Only Path to whatever Perfection they think they will achieve. And that they are merely ‘expanding equality’ and thus in total sync with the Constitution (though they know so much more than any of the previous generations – including the Framers – did).

I don’t think the rest of Us have to drink the Kool-Aid that is mixed with the Chardonnay and single-malt at A-list Beltway dinner parties.

We have a job of work to do.

And the country needs the help more desperately than it knows.

NOTES

*The CJS is a 100-plus volume copyrighted legal encyclopedia. I can’t find its material online; a large public library or university or law school library would have a set (about $7,000 for the whole). The ‘Domestic Violence’ section starts off Volume 28. [Verry interestingly, while the CJS has specific article entries for Domestic Violence and for Rape and for Sodomy, it has no article-category for ‘Sex Offenses’; perhaps the editors consider the subject too incoherent to organize; or too changeable to keep up with; or – could it be? – not a real legal category worthy of inclusion in their encyclopedia at all.]

**Yankoskie v. Lenker, 526 A.2d. 429.

Labels: , , , , ,