Monday, July 02, 2012

NAVY CHARACTER: THE TURKEYS COME HOME



As I have often said on this site, so much of the damage done to Our polity in the past forty biblical years has resulted from the pols’ refusing to consider consequences and outcomes (possible, probable, inescapable). So eager were they to get a chunk of the electoral demographic pie created by their newly-embraced client-Identities that they refused to think about – or simply ignored – the consequences of both a) “advocacy-group liberalism” generally and b) the specific demands and agendas pushed their way for rubber-stamping and (lavish) funding.

And as I noted in my essay on Catharine MacKinnon’s 1989 radical-feminist summa Towards a Feminist Theory of the State (among other essays), ‘standards’ and ‘ideals’ were merely macho abstractions meant to sustain the hegemonic, dominant, oppressive, and marginalizing reign of patriarchy. As Baudrillard said it nicely: every ideal contains within itself the seeds of oppression.

Thus ‘character’ as an ‘ideal’ has to go because it may well oppress. It will oppress you personally because now you will try to repress and deform your naturally gooooood self and all its natural impulses (Rousseau) in order to conform to the demands of this ‘ideal’ called ‘character’ which has been imposed on you by the patriarchy or the dominant-cultural powers simply to ruin your day (Boomers) or keep you subordinated to the status-quo (Marx and derivative revolutionaries). And if you try to impart those ideals to others, then you are oppressing them.

Just “getcha sef freeeee” (Simon & Garfunkel) and all will be well and the whole culture will gambol (Boomers) or march (cultural revolutionaries) into the eternal summer of love on a Frisco beach (Boomers) or into the brave new world of Correct thought and behavior (cultural revolutionaries).

In any case, everybody would be liberated from everything, except for the scripted oppressors, who would be ‘devalorized’ and kicked to the curb. Along with all their pomps and all their works. Which would include Character.

Does Character limit or boundary natural human impulses? Yes. Does it thus Shape a human being as an individual and as a social participant? Yes. But Boundaries and Shapes also Ground humans, giving them a solid keel thrust down into the deep to keep the vessel ‘on an even keel’ so that it doesn’t simply a) bounce along on the surface of whatever waves come along or b) blow itself right over as the sails’ motive power – unopposed by the staying-power of the keel – push the vessel to its destruction.

But no.

Kids and revolutionaries aren’t really into Boundaries and Grounds and Shapes and Limits. That’s just grown-up stuff (which, one would have thought, was what sustaining a culture and a nation- and its economic vitality and moral integrity – was precisely all about).

The military in all of this offers an interesting forum for observation and judgment.

The world of the military is in some very real ways Life writ small: there is a very palpable responsibility (to effectively wield lethal force) which cannot be ‘spun’ away; this abiding and ever-present responsibility creates a powerful and tight focus on running your life – as an individual and as a member of a common project – in such a way that you will always be capable of fulfilling that responsibility.

This creates a necessary Shape and Ground to a military life. And keeping that Shape and staying rooted in that Ground generates a necessary way-of-living, of conducting yourself and of shaping and grounding your personal life so that your own individual ‘vessel’ or ‘vehicle’ is always ready to fulfill the over-arching responsibility. * That necessary way-of-living and way-of-being constitutes a ‘discipline’ (askesis, in the Greek), a deliberately embraced ‘Way’ that keeps you always on the path to fulfillment of both your responsibility and your own genuine best human Self. And if everybody is doing that, then you have a remarkably fulfilling common culture as well as an individual Character.

It’s quite a Vision.

But it had to go.

At least, according to the summery urge-rattled Boomers and the gimlet-eyed revolutionaries of the late 1960s, soon embraced by the Dems and then the entire Beltway as the fresh, rich, transgressive, new demographic masters and – I’ll say it – mistresses of the New Order and of the Brave New World.

One thinks – and should have thought back then – of Mussolini’s shimmering new Fleet: bright-painted, newly-constructed, and numerous. It gave the Royal Navy – in its hulking gray, storm-battered vessels – quite a scare: so many ships, so new and shiny and fast, and not bad at gunnery either.

But of course, the sailors of those shiny new ships referred to their vessels as “the cardboard fleet”:  protective armor and heavy structuring steel had been somewhat sacrificed for speed and if you fired all the big guns in broadside simultaneously, you ran some risk of blowing yourself over. And they had no radar.

So if the waves got really big, or it got dark or cloudy … well, that was a problem. Best to go out on sunny days and calm seas. Why risk getting all snarled up in the occasional storm or darkness?

You can imagine the type of military efficiency and effectiveness such a plan of (in-)action would yield. And yet, given the fundamental weaknesses of the primary components (the ships, the crews that had no confidence in their or their ships’ capabilities), going forth the meet the Royal Navy wasn’t going to lead to a successful outcome either.

There were no good options left to them.

Now, as We approach the Fourth of July, in the Year of Grace Two-Thousand-Twelve and of the independence of the United States the Two-Hundred-and-Thirty-Sixth, comes Our own Navy … with a self-admitted ‘character’ problem.

There have been alarmingly large numbers of Navy commanding-officers relieved of command and Senior NCOs relieved of duty because of “personal misconduct” (adultery, fraternization, and fraud are specifically mentioned).

Perhaps, the brass are thinking, the “screening process” might be tightened up, or “with a little more training” then “they might have made better choices that might not have cost them their careers”.

Although you would have to read the Memos almost daily to avoid running afoul of the ever-expanding list of Correctnesses that must be embraced, and must be embraced with a straight face and, indeed, a cheerible can-do Aye-Aye. For more often than anyone would care to think, officers and senior NCOs have found themselves praying the prayer of Klink and Schultz: Whaaaaaat ammmm I sayyyyyink?

And today’s ‘standard’ might be tomorrow’s ‘oppression’ and the ‘devalorization’ of that standard the glorious ‘reform’; and the usual constitutional protections against Ex Post Facto don’t count in matters of promotion and career: if word gets around that you once raised your eyebrow or shook your head, it’s the Desk-Job without prospect of further promotion or some bit of an assignment wherever the Russian Front might be that month.

Is it brought to your attention that the weight-room on your ship is offensive to females because it reinforces macho-ness among the males in the crew? You had better never be seen even shaking your head in disbelief or bemusement. You had better never be heard trying to explain the reasons for this offensive practice of physical work-out.. Or if you are informed - and by superior authority - that the stand-up urinals create an 'unfriendly work environment' because it reminds everybody that there is a difference between males and females (I kid you not) ... you had better keep a straight face. And if you have the temerity to put your thoughts in writing in an official communication, then you have signed your own career’s death-warrant. It's all reminiscent of the defunct Soviet Navy, where the Party's political-agenda overrides the military mission.

And in matters of ‘sex’, where the list of ‘discriminatory’ practices or attitudes grows only a shade faster than the list of prosecutable military-law sex-offenses … you had best pay more attention to Moscow than to any ‘standards’, comrade commander. Your first task is not some distracting concern for ‘operational efficiency’ (which is merely a cover for the fuddy-duddy and un-Correct stubborn counter-revolutionary commitment to “your grandfather’s Navy”) but rather your first task is to the establishment of the New Order. Da! Ja! Yah.

After all, the U.S. is the undisputed world-hegemon (so the Beltway thinking went in the 1990s) so We can afford to forget ‘operational efficiency’ and focus attention on the demands of the Correct New Order.

So far, the Navy has not been put to the frightful tests confronting the Army and the Marines, confronting the awesome and awe-full Ares Ferox et Atrox on his own ground, the un-spinnable and brutally real test of Combat and Battle.

But now the Navy – as if by inadvertence – notes that it seems to have a problem with “moral failures”.

And – as is now Standard Operating Procedure in the New Order – a pandemonium of “experts” are going to be engaged, at whatever expense, to “address” the problem.

So then, first of all there will be a daylong workshop on “character and integrity” which all officers and sailors of the Naval air arm will have to attend. This might seem to be progress: for quite some time “character and integrity” were ‘devalorized’ as merely being pretexts for opposing the New Order. The Navy has too many standards and not enough women! – as the mantra went back in the day, twenty years ago.

This marvelous new program will be inflicted upon Naval Air first, because – perhaps – it was there that the slyly-constructed Tailhook brouhaha was first deployed, twenty and more years ago. It will then perhaps be expanded to the entire Service. But the retired admiral (nicely named Tallent) who is going to (be paid to) put the new program into operation got his start in Naval Air, so maybe it’s just a matter of convenience.

And next year, new screening-procedures for selecting commanding officers will be put in place. Although – you may rest assured – “character” and “integrity” still had better not have been demonstrated by opposing or not fully ‘getting on board with’ whatever whackeries the New Order imposes.

To imagine that it is precisely the forced acceptance of those whackeries that have deranged and derailed “character and integrity” in the first place would, no doubt, be ‘thinking too much’.

And your fitness for command will now include taking into account “subordinates’ opinions”; so that anybody who feels that you were not sufficiently ‘on board with’ the New Order (and his/her demands) can write-in a telling indictment that may well quash your further promotion and your career. 

All so charmingly Soviet.  It worked so well for them, didn’t it?

Marvelously, the Navy says that “neither step is a direct response to a recent spike in dismissals among commanding officers, deputy commanding officers, and top enlisted sailors”. But of course. Though the “spike” isn’t so “recent” and incompetent (but Correct) commanding officers have wrecked valuable major warships and damaged others, to say nothing of lesser frakkeries that included a well-connected female Captain throwing pottery at subordinate officers on the bridge of her major warship, and throwing a screaming hissy-fit on the bridge when a subaltern had the temerity to point out that her last engine-order would cause the ship to damage itself in a shallow channel (which it proceeded, to nobody’s surprise except the Captain’s, to do – at huge cost in fundamental repairs).

There has been a doubling of relief-from-command incidents, though, in just the Year of Grace Two-Thousand-Eleven and of the New Order the Twentieth (more or less).

Much of this can be attributed to Naval Academy and Naval education’s Correct ‘devalorizing’ of such putative skills as handling a ship, in favor of a ‘let’s just all get along’ approach that needs no standards about anything having to do with mechanical and technical stuff and combat-leadership, but rather has everything to do with enforcing the tenets of the Correct New Order.

But apparently a large chunk of these incidents now involve ‘unprofessional command climate’, ‘personal misconduct’, and ‘inappropriate personal behavior’, all ominously linked to the lifestyle and command-style requirements of the Correct New Order. Many of them involved “sexual relationships between male superiors and female subordinates” (it is axiomatic, but of course, that such things simply do not happen with female commanders, let alone among lesbian-inclined officers and enlisted).

Thus, We can see that “character and integrity issues” are really only about failure to make the New Order work as its proponents and their legislative enablers insist that it will work, if only everybody does everything Correctly.

If only, if only.

One solution might be to have gender-separate ships and units. But for some unfathomable reason,  that possibility isn’t and never has been even remotely discussable. Perhaps because such ships and units might all too quickly and clearly demonstrate the fundamental problems with the New Order’s basic premises; or perhaps because that would leave any lesbian-type misdeeds too vulnerable to exposure. Who knows? The Question – doncha know? - mustn’t be asked; it simply isn’t done.

But let’s not let all that get in the way of a spiffy major new Initiative.

After all, “incidents that stem from character and integrity issues have an adverse impact on our readiness as warfighters”, intoned a Vice-Admiral piously. Why, yes – yes they do. Although hopefully the Vice-Admiral doesn’t think that such a basic and ancient military truism reflects the cutting-edge of flag-level wisdom and insight.

But the secret info that does reside in senior-level military knowledge is that “character and integrity” have verrry speshull definitions in the New Order.

But rest assured that none of this will be the usual government or Pentagon boondoggle. There won’t be any “long lecture given with PowerPoint”; rather “it involves small groups discussing dozens of … case studies that are based on real instances in which sailors and officers made bad personal choices that ended their careers”.

Sort of a consciousness-raising session (shades of the 60s and 70s!), no doubt run by cadres of Correctness (who will also be taking names, if you get my drift). Sort of a Maoist indoctrination session with a happy-face.

And you can imagine what the carefully vetted ‘case studies’ will be and what you should and should not glean from them.

The cases will cover a gamut running from “inappropriate relationships” and “alcohol abuse” all the way over to “cheating on tests”, “wrongful use of government equipment” and “various forms of fraud such as lying to boost a housing allowance or a travel expense claim”.

The embarrassingly prevalent sex stuff is hidden in the simple portmanteau phrase “inappropriate relationships” (always the fault of the superior and/or male); the rest of it reveals an apparently widespread and pervasive, if garden-variety, disregard for what used to be covered by the standards and ideals of ‘officers and gentlemen’ and the tradition of the Naval Service – but those were ‘struck below’ quite some time ago, to clear the decks for the axioms and mantras of Correctness.

Nor is it evident that the Navy realizes what a bad example the highest-echelons of the Service have set for several professional generations now, as senior admirals went-along-with all the lethal claptrap in order to preserve their position now and in the post-retirement afterlife. Nor what a bad example the Beltway has set and continues to set.

The retired rear-admiral, the aforesaid Tallent, admits that he’s not quite happy with the ‘character and integrity’ moniker given to the workshops; since, he observes as if the insight is worth all the money he’s being paid, you can’t teach character to someone in a day.

No, you can’t.

You need a family and parents who will get to work on this task from the beginning of their child’s life (having already achieved some level of character in their own lives); you need a culture and society that supports them and demonstrates to the growing child the value and need of character; you most probably need some type of genuine religious experiences to help Ground the whole project, since the surface dimensions of this-world do not often easily support such a foundation.

And all that is before you get the kid into the Service. Where there must be an even more focused development of the foundational character-skills already well-laid down. You can no more start building character in the course of military operations than you can lay down the keel and build a ship when you’re already at sea.

So Tallent is going for some modest repair work. But of a very limited and rather familiar kind: you can teach people to ‘self-confront’ over their tendencies – not so far removed from the old handbooks for Maoist cadres. Or perhaps a good ‘command climate’ will include the running of required daily or weekly group-sessions where individuals can be accused or can self-accuse at the hands of everybody else. Though perhaps, as per any Correctness regime, any such confessions or recounting of “past mistakes” may be taken down in evidence or quietly kept for future reference and use.

Waxing theological (reflecting with an ineluctable irony just how much Correctness springs from a secular religion of the this-worldly), Tallent divines that of course not “everyone can be saved”. Yea, verily. And given the lethal structural deconstruction of the general culture as well as of the military culture for the past two decades, the numbers of the irretrievably lost are now far more astronomical than they need have been … or would otherwise have been.

It’s a wonder they aren’t all just written off as the eggs necessary to break in order to make the Great Omlette. But neither the Navy nor the Pentagon nor the Beltway really want to admit how many such broken eggs now dot the floor of the national Kitchen.

And Tallent will try to put them back together again. Or at least, as many Humpty-Dumpty’s as might be managed in a series of day-long workshops and a fresh wave of Correct impositions.

Good enough for government work, as the cheerible old cynical saying used to go.

Tallent ventures close to the edge of the Abyss: “It starts by having deeper, more honest conversation about these things than we’ve been having in the past”. You always run a great professional risk when you start to suggest that Washington (or Moscow or Berlin, back in their day) has been screwing things up but now you’re here to fix it and make it all better.

But Tallent is safe enough: he’s already retired with his rank and status and pay, and the current boss-brass know that he’ll make sure that such ‘depth’ and ‘honesty’ don’t get out of hand or stray off the Correct course. He’s – as the Brits would tactfully put it – “a safe pair of hands”; and the natives won’t be allowed to get out of hand on his watch.

An ethics professor at a Virginia university cautiously agrees (you don’t want to work in Virginia and be on record as disagreeing with the Beltway and the Pentagon): it “makes sense, at least in theory” and he thinks “it could make a difference”. This man knows how to say nothing while producing the desired blurb.

But – and the article nicely gives it solid play – a retired Captain with the command of three cruisers under his belt, notes that the new scheme of ‘subordinate reviews’ (sort of like students rating their teachers) “will do more harm than good” since the popular commanders will get great ratings (perhaps to offset their less-than-stellar combat and ship-handling qualities) while the less-popular but more competent officers will get slammed.

The Navy needs to make up its mind – says this retired Captain – whether it wants hard-edged competent war-fighters or “gentle, idealized characters who treat everybody nicely”.

I’d say it doesn’t quite have to be so cut-and-dried: you can be competent without being a raving ogre, although no amount of niceness will compensate for competence when trouble and challenge rear their heads.

Nor do you need a wartime situation to encounter that at sea. Even in peacetime, a warship is a whole lot of explodable and flammable stuff crammed into a very small space, and things can go very wrong on a perfectly nice calm day. Or night.  

Let alone in storms or worse weather-events.  Nor are such events susceptible to Correct impositions and regulation.

So the retired Captain thinks the whole plan is unnecessary. I wouldn’t say that: I’d say that it’s way too little, way too late.

And I’d base that in part on the assumption that the Navy has already decided what it wants: the Correct, happy-face, feel-good type. Because you don’t have to ‘master’ all those old macho, industrial-age, patriarchal skills of “your grandfather’s Navy”; you can be perfectly Correct and still reach high-command.

(Who at this point can fail to recall Gilbert & Sullivan’s Admiral: “he thought so little, they rewarded hee / by making him the ruler of the Queen’s nay-veee”? Make the appropriate adjustments for gender and diversity and richness and transgressiveness and so on and so forth, and you have the Navy’s chosen vision nowadays.)

After all – as the thinking went in 1991 – the Soviets were gone, there wouldn’t be any further need for that macho industrial-age naval combat like you saw in ‘Victory At Sea’, and anyway there were computers now that would take care of all the sailing and fighting. Wheeeeeee!

So worrying about ‘combat efficiency’ and ‘leadership’ was simply a mask for being counter-revolutionary and a backlasher.

And so the Navy (along with the other Services) was really just a differently-costumed opportunity for government employment and benefits. Think: Microsoft with a stricter dress code.

But another retired senior officer, a vice-admiral, now head of the prestigious U.S. Naval Institute, disagrees with the retired Captain. Because, says the retired vice-admiral, the Navy will use the new procedures "correctly" (small ‘c’ – but you see the Freudian slip here): the example of others’ past mistakes will be used to prevent future mistakes. Thus this recent unhappy “spike” of serious troubles and firings can be stopped.

But the retired Captain won’t back off: “the most important question to ask … is what caused the spike of firings in the first place”. (You can see why this well-tested officer never made admiral-rank: he thinks wayyyy too much and thus is not “a safe pair of hands”.)

And yet then they both agree on one cause: “the addition of women to ships”. So there it is.

With that one addition, I would say, you get simultaneously an astronomical increase in the possibilities of the sex-offense and Gender War soap operas becoming the prime programs occupying the attention of the Service, while simultaneously requiring the ‘devalorization’ of all the old macho virtues – war-fighting competence, combat leadership, mastery of vast quantities of technical lore and usages, relentless focus on preparation for the brutal and lethal realities of Naval operations and combat – and all those obstructive  ‘standards’ that have a nasty tendency to rule out the best cards ‘women’ bring to the table.

(Again, this might well be addressed by single-gender ships, but – again – that possibility has always been off the table.)

In light of the problems I suggested above, the assertion that overall this “addition” has “benefitted the Navy” is not credible and reflects, rather, the still-entrenched Beltway death-grip on the so-called ‘women’s demographic’. Instead, the Navy brass have committed the Service and all its souls to chasing Congressperson Ahab's Great White Whale, the common cup drunk, the Coin nailed to the mast.**

In the beginning – it is now asserted – a “healthy fear” of the women kept the males and females properly apart, but now the ‘success’ of their presence has resulted in a familiarity that leads to “zipper failures” at an increasing rate.

And yet as early as the first Gulf War, before the Tailhook brouhaha, such naval support vessels as had been integrated at that time, enroute to that combat mission, suffered pregnancy rates so high that the local commanders were ordered not to keep specific records.  Nor could they request replacements for the now-pregnant crew: that would provide official evidence that gender-integration was – at the very least – going to be a hugely fraught (if not ultimately impossible) gambit.

So the commanders a) had to make do by making the remaining crew take up the slack and b) had to accept command-responsibility for somehow preventing sexual encounters. If there was sexual activity, it was not the fault of the two participants but rather it was the fault of the commanding-officer who clearly had permitted a faulty ‘command climate’. The Beltway, like King Canute, would order the tides, and – more directly – would order its ship commanders to actually get that job done.

Be that as it may. The tides keep coming.

Pulling a punch with almost satirical obviousness, the retired Captain observes that all the sex was “the natural, inevitable, yet inexplicably unforeseen effect of stocking units with young, healthy men and women and putting them in isolation and under pressure”. [italics mine]

It was foreseen, but it was not allowed to be officially recognized. Too many powerful political advocacies had a heavy stake in propounding the illusion that you could do all the gender-mixing and not have a sexual-activity problem.

And as the ‘deconstruction’ of moral and ‘character’ standards proceeded rapidly in civilian life, then the incoming generations of recruits were increasingly less schooled in the mastery of sexual urges and impulses. Indeed, especially for young women, sexual activity ‘like a guy’ was an almost required badge of liberation. Thus the overall incoherences of national policies which Naval officers were then required to accept with a straight-face and a can-do Aye-Aye – and not ask any questions or ‘get philosophical’ about it all.




One truly prodigious howler of an incoherence: in military sex-offense law, a woman who has had just one drink is incapable of consenting to any sexual contact whatsoever – and yet these same profoundly fragile and limited creatures are to be considered as perfectly reliable shipmates and capable of major command responsibility. Simultaneously super-victim and super-competent. To which the only career-preserving response is somewhere along the spectrum from keeping a verrry straight face to drinking the Kool-Aid and making your competent crew drink the Kool-Aid and hoping that God will be around to fill in the blanks when the time of fiery trial arises.

According to the article, the best anybody can think to do at this point is to avoid punishing all infractions and deploy punishment only in really serious cases. Although in matters of sex-abuse, according to the still-connected advocacies, all sex-abuse – and it is verrrrry widely and broadly defined in the military – is ‘horrific’ and ‘traumatic’ and so on. So another incoherence pops up here immediately.

“The Navy has to find that balance” blurbs the retired vice-admiral hopefully.

You can’t balance an incoherence. You can only tackle the fundamental incompatibility head-on and make the hard choices about your priorities and then do what has to be done to conform to those priorities.

There is little chance of that happening in the near future. The radical and fundamental incompatibility between a)  the radical-feminist agenda and b) the Navy’s (and all the Services’) responsibilities to wield lethal force effectively and successfully in the national interest  cannot be wished or spun away, nor can it be reconciled.

The Navy will continue, as the nation must continue, going down a fast-flowing river with each leg balanced on a different ice-floe. That’s more of a balancing act than any leadership can achieve or sustain for long.

So have a thoughtful and deliberative 4th! And don't drink the Kool-Aid.

NOTES

*Let’s just observe in passing that this approach to life conforms rather nicely to the Classical and especially the classical Christian vision of what it means to be a human-being. In the latter case: you are created in the Image of God; which generates a responsibility as an individual and as a member of the human community to always work toward being capable of fulfilling that Image (and thus fulfilling your genuine (echt, in the German) self).




**Rumors are strong that the Marine Corps will now come to heel, opening up the Infantry Officer Course – one of its most grueling (and necessary, if you’re going to be leading troops in combat) – is now going to be opened to ‘women’. There go the standards. Because the rules of this Game are as follows: a) standards cannot be enforced if they make women look bad; b) this ‘milestone’ is so important that Allwomen cannot be made to look incapable even if Thiswoman is; c) standards are oppressive and hegemonic anyway; d) ground combat is a thing of the past and it’s really about job and promotion opportunities.

And given the current SpecOps and drone crazes, the Marines – whose salad days in the Pacific are almost unremembered as the Greatest Generation passes into history – will need all the Beltway goodwill they can muster in order to keep funding. And if that means …

Also, don’t look for hard-hitting investigative and exposure-type journalism into this the way you would see with the ‘military culture of rape’; you will get nothing but glowing encomia and feel-good puff pieces about all the ‘success’ of the program.
ADDENDUM

While writing this, the television next to my desk was showing 2003’s Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World. It is precisely this culture of standards and character, sustained in the face of awesomely challenging weathers and combats, lasting well into the 20th century, that was ‘devalorized’ over the past twenty or so years. It will have to be recovered, if there are enough of its practitioners left to re-instill it. And if not, not.




ADDENDUM 2

I would add the following.

There was – in the time before The Present Situation – a strong emphasis in the Service Academies on rules, stringent requirements stringently enforced. And those rules reached down to such day-to-day matters as being on-time for scheduled events (to use an example).

There was a purpose to this: war or military emergencies (the plane develops a problem while airborne; the ship develops a serious problem on an otherwise fine peacetime day at sea) present immediate and unavoidable challenges – ‘facts’ if you wish – that must be dealt with immediately and effectively.

To achieve this, command personnel have to be deeply habitualized to handling that type of situation with the right – and only – useful frame of mind and heart: control your emotions, actively get all the facts however unpleasant or ominous they may be, and keep your head as you evolve a plan of action to deal with the problem.

Such self-possession does not come easily.

It had been one of the primary and most fundamental objectives of the Service Academies to instill that habitual self-possession, as a vital personal ‘platform’ or foundation upon which all the special technical skills and know-how specific to that Service would then be built.

And since the Service Academy couldn’t simply create actual war-conditions or full-blown actual military emergencies, then they had to somehow develop a regimen of regulations and enforcement to create a usable simulacrum of a vital and unavoidable challenge. Thus the demerit-system whereby the cadet was continually required to perform a mental calculus as to whether and how much a possible course of action might cost him and/or his mates in the unit.

Thus too such stringent requirements as being severely punished if – even through no fault of one’s own – one was late for a significant event. Such as reporting back after leave: an ice storm in winter or a blockage delay on the highway, let alone a missed flight or train connection … you stood to get some significant ‘restriction’ or other ‘award’.

This, to the civilian mind, is being far too ‘strict’ – which most likely in civilian life it would be. But the Service Academies were not there to prepare you for immediate post-graduate entrance into civilian life. Rather, you were going to be a military officer with the responsibility of wielding lethal force, if so ordered, effectively and also of commanding others in that same mission.

The aspiring-officer had to learn to so structure his life and his thought that he would continually be performing the vital calculus as to costs-and-consequences of any possible action he might take, and learning as well to accept responsibility for outcomes even if failures were not directly attributable to him. (So, for example: did you want to go home on leave through a complex web of plane or train connections in wintertime or a holiday period? You should have considered the hardly improbable possibility that you could not control all the elements that might prevent your reporting back on time.)

But with the dawn of the Beltway’s infatuation with (and politically calculated embrace of) the Boomery worldview, things started to go seriously awry. The laid-back element of Boomerism didn’t like a lot of ‘regulations’ which – in marvelous kiddie fashion – were seen to be merely unnecessary obstructions to one’s enjoying a more fulfilling (read: enjoyable) life.

And the ‘revolutionary’ elements of Boomerism – spearheaded in this country by radical-feminism – saw all such regulations (and ‘standards’) as merely oppressive constructs devised to exercise and sustain the inevitable Patriarchal Hegemony.

So the regulations had to go. And of course the ‘standards’.

You couldn’t ‘Boomerize’ the Services without profoundly weakening their essential function and mission.

Nor could you ‘feminize’ them – as the term came to be deployed by the radical-feminist Advocacy and its political enablers – without also ‘civilianizing’ them.

And so to the long-standing fundamental dissimilarity between ‘civilian’ life and military life there was added the now-familiar un-bridgeable abyss between patriarchal-military and feministical-civilian.

But that was OK – it was blithely asserted – because especially after the fall of the USSR there would be no more need for a ‘military’ approach to life (so macho in its emphases on self-control, self-mastery, self-possession, and hard competence in hard matters in order to face hard and immediate challenges).

Thus the Service Academies have become ‘campuses’ – much like Microsoft calls its major institutional concentrations ‘campuses’. The military life as Microsoft with a stricter dress code.

And of course, since the Academies had been carefully calibrated to inculcate precisely those values – as best could be achieved – then the ‘standards’ vital to those values had to go.

And they were tossed away.

Although – as noted – upon the authority of those blithe but loudly-screeched accusations that they were merely pretexts for institutional misogyny and patriarchy. And anyway, the Services should forthwith and henceforth be seen as ‘employment opportunities’ and as ‘rights-arenas’ where the only necessary objective was to make sure that feminization (defined and shaped according to the radical-feminist playbook and game-plan) replaced everything that had gone before. ‘This is not your grandfather’s (name of Service)!’ became an in-your-face standard mantra that was supposed to be the trumpy comeback to any fuddy-duddy doubters, all those Archie Bunkers in uniform trying to keep ‘women’ from getting their slice of the purported pie.

And, by the most amazing coincidence, all the Academies now have ‘character’ problems and all of the Services seem to have a problem getting their missions accomplished.

Not a prahblum! The drones will do the fighting and the computers will run the aircraft and the warships.

Yah.

Meanwhile, on another sound-stage on the same movie lot and run by the same film company, the Beltway had run through and run down the national Treasure and Substance, almost guaranteeing that the new Age of Go-Out-and-Grab other peoples’ stuff was going to create numerous ‘contested sites’ around the entire planet requiring not only effective military operations but also a world-wide reputation for military competence (so that any potential adversary or rival would think twice about getting in the way in the first place).

The ponderous imponderables of International Affairs and War. But they were hardly un-recognized. They were simply ignored.

And now the turkeys are coming home to roost.



Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, March 18, 2012

CATHARINE MACKINNON 4

We conclude this mini-series on Catharine MacKinnon’s 1989 book “Toward a Feminist Theory of the State”.*

You can review my prior Posts on it here and here and here.

One note before I begin: I put ‘women’ in quotation-marks often here to recall that the term as MacK and other such deploy it refers not to all female human beings but to the specific beings envisioned by R-Feminism as being the only truly Correct, liberated examples of the sex – and indeed, of the species. The majority – the vast majority – of these females, according to R-Feminst theory, ‘just don’t get it’ either, and will have to be re-educated.

Her last Section (of three) is entitled ‘The State’.

Quoting Karl Marx’s observation that “a nation and a woman are not forgiven the unguarded hour in which the first adventurer came along that could violate them”, MacK then proceeds to quote a lengthy snippet from Adrienne Rich urging “the repossession by women of our bodies will bring far more change to society than the seizing of the means of production by the workers”. (p.155)

You can see here where the Marxist vision and project provide the soil for the Radical Feminist (henceforth: 'R-Feminist') vision.

But also that MacK and Rich are certain that they can undertake (and achieve, and without undue ill consequence) “change” and “change to society” that will leave Marx’s efforts in the dust.

It was not Correct in the late 1980s, and is not Correct now no doubt, to wonder if the failure of Marx’s vision – at such stunningly awful cost to so many and so much – could legitimately premise the brazen assumption that an even more and hugely intensified application of his paradigm (with the key change from ‘workers’ to ‘women’) would fare any better.

But as in all revolutions, one is not supposed to Kick Tire; one is supposed to cheer and get on with it and no further questions asked.

Plus, of course, the R-Feminists had been presented by the Dems in 1972 with the keys to the Beltway, a manna-from-heaven situation that not even Lenin or Gramsci ever imagined could happen for them because no Western government would ever willingly mule an attack on its own polity and Culture.

And then, in 1989 when this book was published, R-Feminists were giddy with the realization that Bush 1 was courting them eagerly to get re-elected but that the alternative was Billary, and both husband and wife members of that greasy, buttery-glowing tag-team were eager to usher in what would be called the era of ‘governance feminism’ when the White House would put its fat thumb and gimlet-eye to the task of ensuring that the Agenda got everything it wanted from government (if not – ominously – from the voters).

MacK continues with Rich: “The female body has been both territory and machine, virgin wilderness to be exploited and assembly-line turning out life.” This snippet neatly assumes the Marxist form of dividing the Russian people according to their roles (peasant or worker, field to be plowed or machine – hence the hammer of the worker and the sickle of the peasant combined to make the marquis Communist Party logo).

No room here for ‘Citizens’, let alone ‘human beings’ as roles or conceptual categories by which to envision people. Those categories, so long ‘traditional’ in the Christendom-grounded West, were merely tools of sustained oppression, so long and deeply accepted that now they were simply manipulative masks by which the ‘consent’ or acquiescence of people (women, specifically) in their own ‘domination’ could be sustained and continued. But not any longer, enlightened sistern!

Would such an envisioning have a weakening effect on the Framing Vision? So what? That Vision was merely a super-mask enabling the sustained hegemonic and oppressive dominance of the genderist equivalent of Marx’s ‘capitalism’: patriarchy.

Not taken as relevant is the fact that while human-designed capitalism assigned to workers the role of manning the machinery (that Produced the stuff that created the ‘achieved wealth’ of a nation), yet it was Nature (or Evolution) or some mysterious force or forces beyond any human ken that assigned to the female of the species the task and specially-evolved predisposition to bear and nurture the young of the species: a ‘natural’ reality which all human civilizations had dealt with by divvying-up the tasks (nurturing on the one hand, providing security and food on the other) as efficiently and usefully as possible.

This R-Feminist ‘change’ was not directed against some human-developed economic arrangement but rather against some far more profound ‘given’ that seemed quite clearly a largely immutable arrangement far beyond humans’ poor power to thoroughly and totally (or even largely) alter.

This new ‘change’ was going to require removing the foundations while the skyscraper of culture and civilization still stood, chock full of human beings on all its levels.

The Beltway was up for it.

And then Rich slyly reframes the ur-necessity: “We need to imagine a world in which every woman is the presiding genius of her own body”. Meaning – ‘logically’ in terms of this ‘imagining’ – that women needed to be freed from the requirements of bearing and nurturing the young of the species … unless they felt like it. Which, in less cheerible terms, means that women would not only have to be given legal authority over the lives they bore, but that they would have to be hugely and profoundly ‘re-educated’ to realize that this was all Necessary and Good.

‘Women’ – the vast majority of whom ‘just didn’t get it’ – would have to be taught to ‘get it’ by the infinitely insightful cadres who really did ‘get it’. ‘Women’ were their own worst oppressors, in a sense. The vanguard cadres of R-Feminism would have to terraform their own sistern even as they spear-headed an assault on the ‘other’ human sex. And – queasily – an assault on ‘heterosexual sex’ itself.

How would government assist not only women “bring[-ing] forth children (if and as we choose) but the visions, and the thinking, necessary to sustain, console and alter human existence – a new relationship to the universe” (still p.155).

Shades of late-night collegiate bong sessions and the chai and chardonnay-soused excitements of the oh-so-very speshull (and very particular and exclusive) ‘consciousness-raising’ and ‘sharing’ sessions. Wheeeee!

She was right about the ‘visions’ part but the “thinking” would have to be only that certain type of “thinking” that justified the whole thing. Any thinking that entertained doubts or objections or merely sought to analyze the ‘visions’ in terms of costs and consequences, in terms of whether the whole enterprise was workable … phooey to all that ‘backlash’ and ‘dominant, oppressive, hegemonic’ refusal to yield the old power.

It’s eerie to realize that this gambit reflected very much the same dynamics as the antebellum Southerners’ insistence that the nation not only allow Slavery but also accept and acclaim Slavery as Necessary and Good. That would be the only – to use a later term – Correct way to respond to their demands. Otherwise, they would make sure there was no America at all.  

And on the basis of that, antebellum Southern society and culture would have to clamp down even on independent thought within its borders, censoring speech and even the mails to ensure that not-Correct ideas didn’t reach the public discourse for general analysis and deliberation. But it would all be done tastefully, Scarlett, and oh-so-Correctly, as befits people who really know the score while the lumps all around them ‘just don’t get it’. Mah, mah, mah.

That all sounds kinda too familiar.

The bit about ‘women’ “creating new life” starts to veer into the theological as well as the hubristic, but what’s a little overstatement or even self-aggrandizement when you’re trying to sell your program to the government? And anyway, God was dead – Nietzsche had already signed the death-certificate – and people would have to be their own gods now. Wheeeeee!

‘Bearing new life’ would have been more accurate, but that would raise the queasy questions about just what ‘women’ needed to rid themselves of in order to clear their path to this “new relationship to the universe”. They needed to get themselves free of the child-bearing bit; “just getcha-self free” as Simon and Garfunkel put it in that mid-70s song “Fifty Ways to Leave Your Lover”.

Funny how the night moves. In those macho old Westerns of the patriarchal age, folks who wanted to ‘get free’ would just ‘ride West’ and see what happens. The R-Feminists’ equivalent of riding West in order to ‘get free’ is equally as aimless. Leave that thing in your belly behind and then see what happens. Whatevvvverrrrrrr.

This is what happens when you have freedom without any deeper concept of what human liberty – or human life – is for or about. But hey, like the West-riding rider, you can sorta make things up as you go along. Western movies wisely faded out at that point, the rider heading into the sunset, and didn’t stick around to see how a life conducted like that would play out. You might go to California now and see for yourself. Or maybe, like the two feminist heroes in that 90s flik, just hold hands and drive over the cliff – and fade out and cut.

Only, in the real-life of this nation, We are all passengers in the backseat of that Vehicle the keys of which the Beltway has given to MacK and her pandemonium of hand-holding sistern.

Happy trails! Happy motoring! “Jus’ getcha-self freeeeeee”.

In fact, Rich concludes, in order to pull this off “thinking itself will have to be transformed”. After all, you can’t make the ‘new normal’ normal if folks are still going to have the temerity to notice that this ‘new normal’ is on the level only if you hold your head at a certain pronounced angle. Folks have to be made not only to a) hold their heads at a weird angle permanently, but also b) be made to not-notice that fact, be made to accept that they are not holding their heads at a weird angle at all, but instead are simply ‘normal’ in this brave new way, this brave new definition of ‘normal’.

How will the State, the government, fit into this plan?

After all – MacK (p.157) quotes John Chipman Gray, a noted American law professor of the late 19th and very early 20th centuries – if Isaac Newton made a mistake in his calculations about the orbit of the earth, the whole planet wasn’t going to go spinning off its axis forthwith; whereas if judges get it wrong in a decision, then their mistakes are still now ‘the law’.

And – not to put too fine a point on his thought – the society and culture thus affected by those mistaken decisions would indeed forthwith be sent spinning off their axis. Which, amazingly, is precisely what has happened here to society and culture. Such marvelous progress. Such ‘change’.

But ‘the liberal state’ is so soused with oppression and hegemonic dominance that no simple ‘reform’ will “liberate” nor can the cadres accept the boundaries imposed by “legalism” (p.160).

Meaning that American society’s law (even unto the fundaments of it in the Framing Vision) cannot be allowed to stand in the way since it is not – in the R-Feminist visions – any law that deserves respect or obedience. (And can you see how this bit fuels not only a new Leviatha from the Left, but summons back the Uber-demon of Leviathan from the Right? The ‘law’ that obstructed the R-Feminist agenda also kept the government power and the corporate power in check. And thus pooh-poohing the rule of law because it gets in the way of your agenda served darkling interests on the Right (corporatism, neocon militarism) as well as the fevered dreams and visions of the profoundly authoritarian R-Feminist Left (the government is going to have to manhandle the Citizenry and impose all this ‘change’ on them because so many of them ‘just don’t get it’).

The ‘state’ is masculine and male (p.161) and ‘the law’ embodies that male-serving interest even in its very conceptual approach to things, emphasizing such masculine inventions as facts, formulas, tests, evidence and the processes of judicial neutrality, detachment, and observation (of some presumed ‘reality’). Whereas everything “tends to merge in women’s experience” – sort of like a hash or a mush or a stew.

All of that needs not simply to be ‘reformed’ but to be turned around 180 degrees into the very opposite. And you can say goodbye, then, to the legal evolution – so hard and bloodily won – in Western law since the Roman Republic, up through Medieval Constitutionalism (in the development of which the Catholic Church – yes – played a great part), the era of Protestant constitutionalism in England, and the insights and foundations upon which the Framers then grounded the Constitution and the Framing Vision itself.

Is it mere coincidence that after 40 Biblical years of all this – in matters of jurisprudence and government functioning as well as in the dampdreams and cocksure assertions of so many ‘scholars’ and elites and politicians – none of our legal and constitutional capabilities seem robust any longer?

“Law, as words in power, writes society in state form” according to the dictates of “the phallus” (p.163), and law then and thus “writes the state onto society”.

So ‘Law’ is going to have be turned around 180, or on its head, or ‘reformed’ (‘deformed’ might be closer to it) because “the state is male jurisprudentially” (p.163). That’s all there is to it; more than this, the vanguard elites brassily bray, you don’t need to know.**

“Objectivity” and “rationality” are “male”, and “liberal legalism” simply reinforces and sustains all that, and continues the illusion that all of it is “rationality” (p.162). So down with objectivity and rationality then. And do just the opposite, do – therefore – what ‘women’ do and see things the way ‘women’ see them.

A government that embraces this agenda is heading down dark paths indeed.

All that this “objectivist rationality” does is to “reinforce the existing distributions of power” (p.163) – so sweep away the infamous thing! It’s all about “power” anyway, and nothing more. (Which illumination was erected into a Plan when American elite and lesser law schools embraced Critical Legal Studies in the late 1970s, as a result of which there are now academic generations of law students now practicing law or judging or holding political office who have been taught this dreck.)

“The Constitution – the constituting document of this state society – with its interpretations assumes that society, absent government intervention, is free and equal; that its laws in general reflect that, and that government need and should right only what government has previously wronged” (p.163).

The freedom and equality the Constitution is specifically aiming for is a political freedom and equality before the law, thus preventing the arbitrary deployment of government power against the individual Citizen and preventing the government from slipping out of the control of its ultimate governors and the source of its authority (and legitimacy); that is to say: out of the control of The People.

What MacK wants to do is to insist that there is a profound cultural unfreedom and inequality in the American arrangement. Though to what extent Nature and Evolution have had a role in that, and to what extent government can undo that, and to what extent and in what ways such unfreedom and inequality are actually defined … these are Questions she doesn’t bother with; simply to ask the questions is kind of ‘male’ and proves that the questioner ‘just doesn’t get it’.

And that therefore, she goes on, “this posture is structural to a constitution of abstinence” (p.163). She wants, as the old Progressives sort of wanted, and as FDR opened the door with his enumeration in his 1941 State of the Union Address of ‘the Four Freedoms (of speech and expression, of worship, and from want and from fear), a ‘positive’ government that is not simply ‘negative’ about its role but rather abjures ‘abstinence’ and gets down to actively terraforming not only the laws, but culture and society and the foundations of human civilization itself.

FDR shrewdly tailored his Four Freedoms to strategically distinguish the US and the Western democracies from the Fascist and militarist regimes of Nazi Germany, Mussolini’s Italy, Stalin’s Soviet Union (that one would later be downplayed after June 1941) and imperial Japan.

But while the first two Freedoms that he came up with conform to a government boundaried by the Constitution and by a certain acknowledgement of the limits of human and governmental intervention and direction, the last two lay the groundwork (I doubt he thought this through completely) for a government that does not and cannot acknowledge such limitations on its activities and initiatives.

Clearly, any Party that got control of the government and presumed FDR’s vision as dispositive of American governance was going to imagine itself possessing a conceptual Warrant to terraform whatever came to mind, foreign and domestic.

Which is pretty much where matters stand today. With such results as you can examine for yourself.

LBJ, an old FDR hand, jumped in with both big feet, domestically and over in Vietnam, (and embracing the Israeli Realm for political bennies in the process).

And it has gone on from there.

When the government signed itself on to not only legitimately disassembling the odious regime of state laws sustaining Jim Crow in the South (which was its right and responsibility) but also to terraforming the culture and society of the South, and then extending that to the entire country in the matter of Race, and then in the 1970s accepting Gender as an even more outrageous category of oppression, hegemony, and dominance, then the government clearly could not accept any limits upon itself at all in the imposition of its ‘wars’ against this and that in the service of all its Great and Good Cause(s).

This was surely a matter for public deliberation. Which the Dems’ 49-1 electoral defeat in 1972 might well have been construed to be. But that rather clear voice of The People couldn’t be allowed to stand; and needn’t be allowed to stand, since – neatly – the government was assured by the likes of MacK and a pandemonium of other vanguard elite ‘thinkers’ that The People ‘just didn’t get it’ in the first place, so why listen to The People? And why oh why allow yourself to be limited by the patriarchal Framing Vision and its tool, the Constitution?

Which is pretty much where matters stand today. With such results – foreign and domestic – as you can examine for yourself.

And matters have progressed – as it were – to such a state that even an iconic black ‘liberal’ President (and law professor, and constitutional law at that) continues the ever-intensifying governmental march against boundaries and limits, masked by the burbling assurances that this is all just a form of ‘presidential liberalism’. Which, I would say, is merely a mask for something far darker and far worse for the Republic.

The leader becomes an emperor while the Senate diminishes and relinquishes its genuine responsibilities and contents itself with voting him a god and his horse a Senator. You recall your Roman history as the Republic fell into imperial dictatorship.

She takes an offhand swipe at “medieval law”(p.163), apparently unaware that it was Aquinas who approved a ‘mixed government’ whereby the people (created in the Image and likeness of God and thus possessing a certain ineradicable dignity and certain immutable rights which no earthly power could tamper with) would have a dispositive role in their own governance.

 (Indeed, the constitutional arrangements of Aquinas’s own Order of Preachers provided for the election of the Prior by the members of the religious community over which he would preside. “Medieval constitutionalism” is not an empty phrase. Nor a secular one.)***

R-Feminism, therefore, she says, is against the “negative” (i.e. restrained) state and also against “passive” judges and courts (p.164).

If they are only going to “reflect society back to itself”, and if society is so profoundly infected with patriarchy, the judges as well as legislators have to get ‘active’ and do their bit to help terraform society and culture.

Of course, that all presumes that the R-Feminist analysis of what’s wrong with society is right, and that a human government can effect the desired changes and ‘reforms’, and that it can do so without substantial ill consequence for the society and its ancient Culture, and that it can all be done without deranging the government in its Branches by wrenching it loose from its Framing Vision and that Vision’s first principles.

That’s a lot of presumption.

But, she insists, such a boundaried and ‘negative’ state is simply going to keep the status-quo going, more or less, and so it has to go. And it has to go now. Either because the ‘outrage’ is so great and profound, or because you don’t want to give people (and The People) time to think about it – but anyway they ‘just don’t get it’ so why listen to The People at all in the first place?

Oy.

Nor therefore does she allow that there is any abiding wisdom that resides in The People (Lincoln’s vision, among others) and so there’s no use trying to use up all the time it would take to persuade The People since they’ve been soused since about the beginning of recorded human history in ‘patriarchy’ anyway. And anyway, they might Kick Tire or otherwise decide not to go along with the R-Feminist agenda, and that is clearly unacceptable.

For R-Feminism, as for its Marxist-Leninist forebears, democracy is not the way forward.

The Beltway has bought into that game – using Us as chips, markers, and collateral.  

You can’t embrace MacK and her pandemonium and still remain committed to ‘deliberative democratic politics’, no matter how ‘liberal’ or ‘progressive’ you intend and envision and declare yourself to be. And Obama’s track record (not that at this point any recent mainstream Republican candidate could or would have done much better) is clear demonstration of that. The infection of this pandemonium is now – alas – rightly characterizable as ‘structural’.

And, but of course, activist legislators, judges, and chief executives (to say nothing of the government bureaucrats) are only acceptable to her so long as they hold her views. Any other type of activity is patriarchal, dominant, oppressive, and hegemonic. And backlashing and backsliding and regressive and fill-in-the-blank.

Lenin could not have established the dynamic and more effectively. Well, actually, he had Terror (government imposed) to impose on the masses; but that still didn’t work in the long run, although it drew enough blood, wrack and ruin.

Judges, she notes, are especially useful because in their arena one can avoid “messy political intercourse” (p.164). So much for ‘deliberative democratic politics’.

“The law of privacy treats the personal sphere as a sphere of personal freedom” (p.168). But, she says, this is only true for men; for women “the private is the distinctive sphere of intimate violation and abuse”.

So then it can hardly be a coincidence that within a year of this book’s publication the pols unveiled the first Violence Against Women Act and the domestic-violence and sex-offender police-state regimes (all so ‘male’ in their targets). Because “the male’s realm of private freedom is the woman’s realm of collective subordination” (p.168).

The realm of the private – free from government’s interference and imposition so that the Citizenry can carry on the vital work of society and culture and socializing the young whom they have begotten – has to go. Government, even its police power, has to be everywhere and especially in the realm of the private. After all, since heterosexual sex is everywhere, then the government has to be everywhere to stamp out patriarchy, dominance, and oppression as it is everywhere and every instant reinforced by heterosexual sex acts.

And the ‘family’ is transformed overnight into the biggest and longest on-going crime-scene in the history of the planet.

I hold no brief for violence of any sort, but surely this gambit is fraught with profound problems that reach to the very foundations of American and human society, civilization, and culture.

And that’s presuming that reports of such ‘violence – sexual, interpersonal – however defined and however credibly (or otherwise) ‘reported’ through ‘surveys’ accurately yield a picture of the state of affairs. Which is a big presumption indeed.

But the Bolsheviks saw too, and quickly, that to impose their visions and their regime they would have to reach into every nook and cranny of society and culture. In the previous Post I noted that point in regard to MacK’s quotation from Trotsky: he was trying to figure out how to get women to give up their children to Party-State run ‘collective creches’ (the Bolshevks knew how to deploy nice euphemisms too) where the kiddies wouldn’t be infected with the nasty blathering of parents who ‘just didn’t get it’ and could instead be terraformed from the get-go by vanguard cadres into their bright future as New Soviet Man (or Woman).

Women, as Trotsky sadly observed, were even more recalcitrant and obstructive in their insistence on holding on to their kiddies then men were in holding on to all those outmoded beliefs and traditions that the Party was committed to wiping out as quickly as possible.

But – Trotsky wondered – how can we do this without shooting all the parents? And then where would we be? (In this, he was actually a voice of moderation in the highest counsels of the Party; there were those vanguard cadres who just wanted to send in the secret police and scoop the kids, at gunpoint if need be, and shoot as many objecting parents as necessary to ‘encourage the others’. The little wall that marked off your hearth and property would make a fine backstop for any police bullets that missed and the bullet-pocked walls would remain as reminders to every other village parent that there was a new regime now and they’d better ‘get it’ or they would most surely ‘get it’ in the chest or the head.)

“The rule of law and the rule of men are one thing, indivisible, whether official or unofficial” (p.170). In case you were wondering where ‘the rule of law’ has gone in the estimation of the Beltway these past years and decades.

And in that matter of the government’s position on heterosexual sex: “Rape is indigenous, not exceptional, to women’s social condition” (p.172). And it is “indicative of male violence and sexuality generally”. So for all practical purposes, American Culture and the Framing Vision and any laws that support same are and always have been nothing more than an ongoing criminal enterprise and massive conspiracy (patriarchy, to use the handy short-hand).

How could anybody respect any of that Culture or that Framing Vision? How many any longer do?

How could anybody want to embrace and remain loyal to such a monstrosity as American Culture and its Framing Vision and first principles? And how many any longer do?

How can any house so divided long stand?

How could any government embrace what is in essence a ‘war’ against half its population?

How could any government do so and still reasonably expect to maintain any sense of commonweal and common purpose and bond among the Citizenry?

How could a Citizenry so divided, distracted, and in divers ways bethump’t by its own government and putative elites also find the time and energy to govern the government that putatively serves that Citizenry?

And how now to legally distinguish between heterosexual sex and sexual violence? For MacK (and she is not alone among that pandemonium) there is only a distinction so razor-thin as to be functionally non-existent.

All of this is, I will say again, a lesbian dampdream come true. Courtesy of the Beltway and all the Branches.

After all, every woman – according to MacK’s theory (or Knowledge, take your pick) – is from the get-go so enthralled by the fake ‘naturalness’ of heterosexual sex that she can be characterized as unable ever to truly ‘give consent’ to heterosexual sex.

Did nobody actually read this book in the Beltway before they went into the non-smoking smoke-filled rooms to do their deals?

But really, she asks, what is heterosexuality? (p.178). It’s nothing more than the eroticization of dominance and submission. (Again with this queasy lesbian undertone.)

Nothing about the vitality and vital role of the heterosexual sex act among the species and in its various societies, cultures, and civilizations since the beginning of recorded human history.

Nothing about how Christianity – for one – has tried to somehow frame sexual activity as having an ennobling purpose when it is seen in the context of human meaning and purpose and loving responsibility (rather than, as in the current usage, a form of entertainment or a pick-me-up when life seems blah and there’s nothing else worthwhile to do anyway or because as far as you can feel, sex is pretty much the only thing that does give meaning and purpose to a human life and self).

Such insight. Such progress. Such a civilization and culture and society you can build and sustain on ‘knowledge’ like this.

And any government that buys into an agenda premised upon such ‘Knowledge’ is going to have to become forthwith a police-state beyond even what the daffy but bloody-minded Bolsheviks in the Central Committee ever imagined, or dared to, or were witless enough to try to impose.

Because “the injury of rape to a female has nothing to do with the mens rea of the male” (p.180).

In other words, the male commits this outrage without even ever intending to; his intention when engaging in the heterosexual sex act is irrelevant. He is prosecutable simply because he has performed the act because the act itself reinforces the fake ‘naturalness’ of heterosexual sex that is actually reinforcing dominance, oppression, hegemony, and submission; and then further torts the enthralled female by luring her ever deeper into her benighted enthrallment to her subordinate role in the patriarchal scheme. The male, because of his (biological?) urge to heterosexual sex is a member of a class that is criminal by its very nature, and the act – regardless of any legal niceties and hairsplitting about ‘intention’ – is criminal in and of itself, malum in se.

So much for Western justice and jurisprudence. So much for the propagation of the species. So much for family and parenting. So much, even, for the role of the female as a free and independent agent in the commission of the act (the heterosexual female must be terraformed by the vanguard elites and their pandering government just as much if not more as the oppressing male).

Stalin would instantly recognize and approve of the dynamic here, but not even he dared imagine to deploy it in this arena of sex and with this scope. It was job enough to police ideological purity, but to police every sex act encounter or its preludes? Not if you had all the OGPU and NKVD and KGB ever sworn in could you enforce that level of surveillance and prevention.

Lenin might have imagined it, but even he (with Trotsky’s help) saw that you can’t shoot everybody and still keep the country going.

But at least you can ‘register’ them, the ‘governance feminists’ who read MacK quickly saw. And the computer revolution enabled the government to dispense with the rooms-full of 3x5 file cards and file folders so distastefully and obviously reminiscent of OGPU or NKVD or KGB or Stasi or Gestapo files from back in the day. Computers, apparently, only serve liberating and protective objectives and don’t work if put to any darker purposes. Yah.

The government stamping out heterosexual sex? Can you think of any world-class tyrant or government that ever imagined itself able to carry out such a plan?

Cue the Bhagwan and the Beltway. (And maybe, for a while back there, Mao’s cadres and officials.)

So “what women want” turns out to require – whether they realize it or admit it or not – a sex-addled and hugely invasive police state. And MacK and the rest of the pandemonium will provide the ‘philosophy’ that justifies it.

Gack.

Nor did the devotees of Leviathan, long caged by the Framers here, fail to notice that such a government would serve their purposes as easily as the purposes of ‘women’. It could be a bipartisan police-state! So democratic and liberating! So useful! So indispensable to the world’s ongoing progress!

Phooey.

“Most women who become pregnant became pregnant while having sexual intercourse with men” (p.184).

It’s hard to know what to do with such illumination. What is going on in the mind of somebody who would make or vigorously approve of such acute insight? But you can’t dispute her observation.

However, MacK then immediately goes on: “Most did not mean or wish to conceive” (p.184).

How does MacK know that? You might certainly wish to question, if not dispute, this assertion.

After all, it might well imply that ‘women’ take part in the sex act without really knowing the possible outcome. This limns a rather demeaning picture of women, to say the least. Do so many females not know? I refuse to believe it.

But MacK has to take this unappetizing route in order to cover her tracks. What she really and ultimately wants is for ‘women’ to be able to have sex ‘like men do’; in other words, an ‘equality’ that consists in the woman not having to put up with the possible outcomes provided for by Evolution and – if you wish – Nature. (Let’s leave God out of it for now.) It’s unfair, that is to say, that women cannot have ‘sex without consequences’ like males can – and it’s the government’s fault, or at least within the government’s putative responsibility and authority to do something about it and make that ‘inequality’ go away.

As if ‘sex without consequences’ was a government-permitted state of affairs just like the voting-obstruction laws of the Jim Crow South. Pass a law, get the judges to approve it, send in the federal marshals and maybe the 101st and 82nd  Airborne, and stop this now! The whole country, in MacK’s analysis, is just the Jim Crow South except even worse, because (though the R-Feminists are tactically tactful enough not to mention it) the outrages based on Gender are so very much hugely worse than the outrages based on Race.

Woman’s inequality in this matter – I infer from MacK – actually consists in the fact that when you come right down to it she is biologically born with the capacity to conceive children. This is a form of ‘inequality’ that doesn’t automatically suggest itself to any coherent theory of ‘rights’. A ‘right’ guaranteed by a human government to avoid a reality that seems rather conclusively built into you by dynamics far beyond the power of any human government to alter? Dynamics which originate in some place far beyond the power of any human government to initiate or to extinguish. Sort of like the tides of the ocean, which no king or government has ever managed to reliably command, though at least one is on record as having tried, and perhaps many have wished.

This alone was a conceptual gambit that should have received wide public deliberation.

But the whole idea of a revolution is not that you deliberate but that you act. You act to ensure that your agenda is enshrined as the only power in the land. And nothing can be allowed to stand outside it, nothing against it, nothing above it (to use Mussolini’s eternal and pithy phrase).

 And this is the kind of government that We now seem to have. By amazing coincidence.

After all, she asks, what does a baby really mean to a male? (p.186) If you infer – and rightly – that she means that men don’t really care about their children, then you can see the stilted, acid, corrosive, demeaning, narrow view she holds of men. She extrapolates – you might say – from the stereotypical unripe male to all males, and on the basis of her ‘finding’ dismisses the best instincts of males as if they were so much fake posing, masking a fundamental disinterest in anything except the high of ejaculating during the sex act and somehow ‘dominating’ the ‘submissive’ woman. (And who can deny that nowadays such unripeness has hardly diminished, where it exists, after decades of government-supported cultural terraforming? Such progress.)

It is, I will say again, a statement that bespeaks a rather nasty and greatly under-informed lesbian-tinged attitude – which is not to say that it is the attitude of all non-heterosexually inclined females.

MacK’s theory is a perfectly legitimate statement for an individual to make, or for a ‘school of thought’ to hold, but what I object to is that such a position was taken at face value by the Beltway and forthwith incorporated into so many profound changes imposed upon the Citizenry.

Because when you come right down to it, so much of this sort of stuff – held by MacK and so many others among that pandemonium – is dangerously corrosive not simply because it is their position (as whacky and nasty as it may be) but because it was so quickly and thoroughly incorporated by a government without any public deliberation and imposed under the repugnantly widespread assurances that it was True and Good and represented Progress and could not be delayed by any messy democratic public deliberation (or vote).

Which, again, was precisely what the antebellum Southerners wanted to achieve in the national discourse and consciousness in regard to Slavery.

And so this is why, she says, “the personal is political”: because “for women there is no privacy to lose or to guarantee” (p.191). Any boundaries that prevent the government from intruding into any imagined ‘private’ or ‘personal’ sphere in the lives of the Citizens have to be quickly taken down. (There is that vision, etched in the grainy black-and-white of newsreel film, of Hitler’s border guards happily tearing down the striped border-gates at the frontiers of Czechoslovakia and Austria – the Poles got the bombs first, with no cheerible photo-ops at the border. And those images of doors to houses and apartments – Jewish and otherwise – being matter-of-factly kicked in by government agents and officers.)

Do We not see where these concepts are leading? Where – it was clear as a bell to anybody who wanted to think for a moment – they always had to lead?

Boundaries on government action, she insists, only protect ‘men’. Get rid of all the boundaries on government’s will and authority to act.

Because “the private sphere is therefore a political sphere” (p.191).

Ach!

There are thus “two alternative paths toward sex-equality for women” (p.219). Either be the same as men or be different from men. Or, I suppose, be both and take both paths at the same time, and build laws that teeter precariously over the chasm yawning between the two paths.

“This equal recognition of difference is termed the special benefit rule legally, and the double-standard philosophically” (p.219). But since it’s easier to get control of some eager-to-pander pols and judges and elites than it is to refute logic and ‘valorize’ illogic or highly dubious logic, then she isn’t going to waste time on the philosophical (philosophy is so masculine anyway).

And so laws – passed by deal-making legislators and upheld by grossly illogical judicial justifications – must impose double-standards without admitting that that is what they’re doing. So much for equality before the law. So much, even, for the integrity of the legislative and judicial processes. So much, even more so, for the validity of the legislative and judicial authority.

Such progress.

And, in terms of legal process, get rid of the mens rea requirement and – while we’re at it – get rid of the burden of proof in sex cases, because women are – if you buy MacK’s theory (or Knowledge) – presumptively raped in all cases of (heterosexual) sex and to hold otherwise or to support the ‘old’ evidentiary and mens rea requirements merely serves to “deny that social reality is split by sex inequality” (p.231)

And what divisiveness is now introduced – injected, actually – into the entire sense of common weal among the Citizenry? What happens when that kicks in? (Current Beltway answer: distract the Citizens with continuing wars and financial concerns and assure them that by supporting all the government’s actions they are taking a huge bite outta crime and oppression, foreign and domestic.)

“Feminism”, she asserts neatly, “radically questions whether the sexes are ever, under current conditions, similarly situated even when they inhabit the same conditions” (p.232-3) (italics mine).

How in any Universe can any legislative or judicial power legitimately clear a path through a swamp like this?

If there is a case at law, say, and the presumption is that each of the two participants inhabited a different situation internally even though they inhabited the same bit of the time-space continuum physically … how then do you legislate or adjudicate in such a science-fiction universe (or universes)? Or – and MacK would be happy with this – do you simply decide to throw your legislative or judicial weight and authority (and credibility) behind the ‘universe’ inhabited by one of the parties, and on that basis take a stance hostile to the other (male) party?

This is something not so very far from insanity. Recall how the 17th century Massachusetts judiciary wrecked its integrity trying to adjudicate between both the earthly and demonic universes in the Salem Witch Trials. MacK re-introduces as unique, rich, bright, fresh, progressive, liberal and utterly indisputable ‘Knowledge’ an egregiously mistaken governmental approach that was exposed for the lethal witlessness it was three centuries ago.

And while R-Feminists have every right to ‘question’, the problem is that they have done a hell of a lot more than that: they have, with the eager pandering collusion of the Beltway and all the Branches, gotten their ‘answer’ to that still-hazily limned ‘problem’ erected into public law and policy with no substantive or wide public discussion at all. Just the assurances of the vanguard elites and their fellow/sister travelers who ‘get it’.

And she denies that “gender neutrality” as a putative “expression of objectivity” is “adequate to the non-neutral objectified social reality of women’s experience” (p.232).

In other words, she most very surely does want to see partiality and non-neutral responses from the pols, the judges, the bureaucrats, and the Executive.

No doubt it was put to the pols in 1972 (as it was put to the Constitutional Convention by the Southerners in 1787): you give us this or we walk and there’ll be no country.

So the pols cut a deal, and then another one, and then another one, until now they’re so enmeshed in the overlapping swamp-matrix of deals they made and the consequences that those deals spawned, that they can’t see how the hell to get themselves – let alone the country – out.

For legislators and jurists educated and experienced and mature enough to have achieved their high offices … for such persons to imagine that such a scheme could work, in this country as its Citizenry and political competence existed 40 Biblical years ago, with this country’s Framing Vision and its Founding philosophy of government, without corrupting not only itself but everyone involved with it – that has to be one of the most glaring dissonances in an age full of glaring dissonance.

Better, then, for the Beltway denizen to take a page from the Soviet nomenklatura of the 1970s and 1980s: just cut your deals, collect your swag, and get out of town with your nut when you feel like you’ve got enough. And none of your pals (and pal-ettes) remaining on the job will prosecute you because they are in it as deep as you were. Let the games continue!

No wonder this place is coming more and more to resemble the latter-day USSR.

In regard to Gender (as distinct from one’s sex), it’s (neatly and shrewdly and slyly) merely a “social construction” and the law in its most profound foundations merely “reifies and ratifies” the inequality built not into the biological sexes but into the humanly-constructed “social constructions” of Gender (p.238).

So maybe – she apparently hopes – folks can stop worrying that R-Feminism is trying to get the government to change Nature and Evolution (she never raises the E-word) which might be construed by those who ‘just don’t get it’ as being beyond the government’s authority (and beyond any rational explanation or justification).

Instead, she’ll settle for the government in all its Branches engaging in whatever societal and cultural terraforming is required to change the “social construction” of Gender, because at least those social-constructions are something that humans created (over, she neglects to say, all of recorded human history).

But even if you grant her that such a demand is somewhat symmetrically balanced (humans created social-constructions so humans can change them), you still have to ask yourself if any government – especially a putatively democratic one – can simply go and start massively fiddling with the foundations and vital structural innards of a culture while that Vessel is still at sea and greatly burthened with souls.

And even that has to presume that her analysis and her solutions are correct and workable.

That would be a world of work for the greatest conceptual and political minds the species has ever managed to produce. And for any Citizenry asked to pass ultimate judgment on the plan.

But to do what has been done here over the past 40 Biblical years … is nothing like that at all.

 It has to be done, she says, because “control over being produces consciousness … dominance reified becomes difference … coercion legitimated becomes consent … reality objectified becomes ideas; ideas objectified become reality” (p.238).

This is straight out of the thought of Antonio Gramsci at the beginning of the 20th century as he tried to come up with a way to insinuate Marxist-Leninist revolution in the established democracies of the West. (Though nowhere in this book’s text, nor its Index, does she ever mention him.)

It presumes that human beings are blank slates that can simply be inscribed upon by the power of tradition and law; that they are mere blank clay that can be shaped by cultures into any shape that the culture (or its government) chooses; that they have no nature and no inborn spirit and no conscience and – but of course – no qualities or capabilities or ideals or principles or any human nature at all imparted by anything such as having been created in the Image of a God, let alone the Christian God of benevolence and justice.

And that human beings are, in essence and primarily and fundamentally, victims (or victimizers). Who does what to whom? – as Lenin pithily described his definition of politics.

Lenin built Marxism into an actual operational (not to say successful) governance regime by demonizing several classes of Citizens (including sub-dividing even the ‘peasants’ into ‘good’ property-less peasants and ‘evil’ Kulaks, who were a class of peasants who had committed the egregious (in the Bolshevik schematic) crime of owning a cow or their own bit of land. He had to create a form of civil war within and among Russians).

The Gender revolution derived from all this has done the same thing, with ‘men’ playing the part of the ‘capitalists, aristocrats, and Kulaks’ who – simply be being members of the proscribed class – must suffer the consequences of the entire weight of the regime’s opprobrium upon and against them.

Such progress. Where Reagan wanted to turn the clock back to 1940s America, R-Feminists have turned the clock back to 1917 and the early years of the Soviet revolution.

And indeed, it seems to me like these Marxist-Leninist vanguard elites have now managed a re-do of Mao’s monstrous and self-created famine that killed so many of his own people in the 1950s: the necessarily secularist R-Feminist campaign here has created a spiritual and moral famine where there had been sufficiency before. Was that wise? Has this been worth the cost and consequences that now are becoming increasingly and un-spinnably clear?

In order to lever open the conceptual and social ‘space’ for their agenda, R-Feminists had to attack the carrying-walls and the foundation of the national Building. Somehow they either imagined that it could all be done without ill consequence, or else they figured that such a rotten structure didn’t deserve to remain standing any way.

But it’s a funny thing about conceptual foundations: they don’t just do what you want them to do. You knock them away or skew them for your own purposes, and the next thing you know they have not simply ‘made room’ for you and your agenda, but they then take the building itself (or a good-sized chunk of it) down.****

As the callow owner of Titanic discovered, you can screw around with the ship’s design so that you have more space for your first-class multistory grand staircase (which is what he did, reducing the height of several of the watertight bulkheads and thereby reducing her watertight integrity) and the ship did indeed make a grand impression as you descended that marvelous staircase for your first-class dinner. But then the ship also filled much more quickly than she otherwise would have, failing to stay afloat for the extra few hours it took Carpathia to reach her and take off her passengers.

That’s the funny thing about ‘changes’.

Did nobody remember?

In order to ‘get at’ the allegedly myriad (and male) perpetrators of ‘rape’ (however broadly defined), conceptual constitutional watertight bulkheads were breached so as not to obstruct the pursuit and prosecution of the perps, or perp-class (aka ‘men’). Women were “disadvantaged” as a class by patriarchal sexual oppressive dominance of heterosexual sex (pp.244-5), and – surfing the spirit of the age – the government had to do ‘whatever it takes’ (as the Israelis like to say) to root out this ‘existential’ (ditto) threat to women’s very existence.

But as Thomas More’s character said in Robert Bolt’s play (and later 1966 film) “Man for All Seasons”: once you have flattened the laws in order to chase the devil, and then the devil turns around on you, what can protect you, the laws now being all flat?

Or as Martin Niemoller – former WW1 U-boat commander turned pastor – ruefully observed of the Hitlerite era: First they came for the Communists, but I wasn’t a Communist so I didn’t speak up; then they came for the trade-unionists but I wasn’t a trade-unionist so I didn’t speak up; then they came for the Jews but I wasn’t a Jew so I didn’t speak up; then they came for me and there was nobody left to speak up.

Just so.

The monstrous Leviatha-Leviathan (bipartisan and bi-gender, if you will) government into which all the changes from Left and Right have now mutated, has no boundaries left to obstruct its ‘turning around on’ anybody and (as the Framers well knew about this type of beast) it’s only a matter of time before it seeks fresh targets among whatever and whomever is left of the Citizenry. Only a matter of time.

As her designer – also aboard that fateful night – told the captain, after inspecting the rate of flooding in Titanic’s lower decks: The tipping point where she loses her reserve buoyancy is engine-room 5; once you lose engine-room 5, her sinking ceases to be a probability, and becomes a mathematical certainty.

Have we reached that point yet? The continued Beltway reliance on the assertions of such ‘philosophers’ as MacK (actually, a law school professor, held in high esteem by her sister elites of whatever gender) – and make no mistake about it, these ideas of hers (and Gramsci’s) are still very active and still operating within the hive of the Beltway-elite collective – can only lead to a steeper rate of sinking.

The laws and policy changes and assorted regimes enacted and imposed based on the putative accuracy of her ‘philosophy’ are still in place and chewing and churning away deep within the nation’s foundational structures like oversized mutant termites in a 50’s B-movie sci-fi flik.

I think what was once said by one of Nietzsche’s defenders about that gentleman’s ruminations and illuminations also applies to MacK and many of her associated pandemonium: they are not ‘system’ thinkers, but rather ‘Problem’ thinkers.

Meaning that they don’t look with a wide lens at the comprehensive set of interlocking elements that underlie this or that specific phenomenon that has captured their attentions. Rather, they look with a narrow lens at the particular ‘Problem’ that agitates them, and then simply ruminate and agitate on until they have ‘addressed’ that ‘Problem’.

Imagine a surgeon who conducts surgery for a damaged vital organ, effects the necessary repair to the organ, but takes no thought of blood loss, consequent impact on associated physiological systems and organs. And yet, considers him/herself successful, even though the patient died from the deeper and unconsidered sequelae of the whole procedure. Your loved one had a damaged organ, I fixed the organ, and that’s what I said I’d do. If your loved one died of blood-loss or blood-poisoning or shock or sepsis or circulatory problems … well, I said I’d fix the vital organ and I did and your loved one, you may rest assured, died with a very well-repaired vital organ.

We don’t let surgeons with such tunnel-vision operate on people around here any longer.

But the Beltway and its pandemonium of elites let philosophers with such tunnel-vision dictate the grounds of huge matters of national law and policy.

And how much longer does the patient – which is Us as The People – have?

When does it all cease to be a probability and become – like it became for the Roman Republic and for Titanic – a mathematical certainty?

NOTES

*My copy is the hard-cover edition published by Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-89645-9.

**It comes to me, writing this Post, that some readers might think: this is all silly stuff and why waste time on it? But I answer that while it may indeed be silly – to put it too charitably – yet this stuff has become the elite thinking of the Beltway and governs the government approach to matters foreign as well as domestic now.

***You might want to take a look at Carl J. Friedrich’s work, and his short 1964 book “Transcendental Justice” is a good place to start.

****For example, just recently a group of Oxford University profs declared that allowing women the privilege of “post-birth abortions” is merely the next logical conceptual step towards the equality and liberation of women. Human life is not really initiated, they assert, until the being has the capacity to exercise human faculties; since infants and young children (otherwise quite healthy) cannot do that, then they are not rightly classified as humans and can be – under proper supervision, of course – done away with.

This is as clear a reversion to the Nazi concept of Lebensunwurdiges Leben as you are likely to run into this side of 1945. But once you’ve gone and flattened the carrying walls and retaining walls and ripped out the foundations, what’s to prevent such a ‘theory’ from appearing as if it made sense and as if it were at least possibly morally credible? Who’s to judge? And on what basis?

The best a secular state could do at this point is to insist that it will not allow it and no further discussion allowed. But in order to ‘make room’ for all the necessary social-space of the past 40 Biblical years, there are no moral grounds left to absolutely and clearly judge this proposal to be profoundly immoral on its face and at its very root and core, malum in se.

ADDENDUM

An alternative explanation for the R-Feminist position might be this:

In order to justify so huge and profoundly revolutionary a political and cultural agenda it was essential not only to have a Necessary Enemy (or construct one) but to have a really really big Necessary Enemy.

Because to explain her theory’s profound and sustained and pervasive place of ‘women’ (or of those who occupy women’s roles, as she might put it) over all of recorded human history, then you have to have a huge, pervasive, sustained and possibly deliberate and purposeful or possibly not deliberate and kinda of ‘unconscious’ conspiracy or synergy, and thus she constructs Patriarchy.

But ‘ideas’ are notoriously non-flammable when you’re trying to ignite a stampede of support so you need a real flesh-and-blood enemy, and thus ‘men’ have to be demonized. After all, the Salem Witch Trials did not prosecute ‘witchcraft’ as a concept but rather real men and women as ‘witches’ (or warlocks).

If you don’t do this, and if you don’t get the fire going really really hot as quickly as possible, then folks may well simply wonder if there isn’t something more ‘natural’ (however defined) about the role of women or women’s roles in the great scheme of things in human civilizations – and then they start asking all the questions you don’t want to be asked about all the possibilities you don’t want them to be considering.

Once you have decided upon your Necessary Enemy, then you skew all of the Correct ‘thinking’ around that Enemy in order to preclude any un-Correct thoughts or questions and keep the stampede going in only the direction you want it to.

ADDENDUM 2

In his assessment of Critical Race Theory (one of the hot items from back in the heyday of Identity Politics and Multiculturalism in the academy), an emeritus professor recently writes (concerning the minority professor who invented this Theory): “[He] knew that he was not qualified to teach at Harvard. He invented a theory by which Harvard could not judge him.”

This, I think, succinctly captures a dynamic that has been operative in all of the Identity Politics ‘theories’ and assertions and claims: they knew full well that their demands to be both i) accepted immediately as ‘Knowledge’ and ii) to be erected immediately into national law and policy were impossible to justify.

And their solution  for that  was to invent a theoretical justification why nobody had a right to judge them:‘Patriarchy’ had confused everybody and delegitimized all tradition and culture so that ‘males’ could not be trusted because they were patriarchal; women who did not ‘get it’ could not be trusted because they didn’t really understand what being a women was genuinely all about; intellectuals who disagreed couldn't be trusted because they were merely shills for the status-quo (an idea straight out of Antonio Gramsci);  and clearly no tradition, law, practice or thinking that disagreed with them could be trusted because it was all just part of the great big illusion called Patriarchy.

So nothing and nobody could 'judge' them or their ideas or their demands. Because everything else and everybody else was tainted. Since MacKinnon, the pomo thought evolved into even more treacherous and daffy depths: nobody can judge anything or anybody else because there are no 'objective' standards and - indeed - no 'objectivity' and for that matter no Reality and so it's all just a power play and when you are a revolutionary/liberal that's all politics is ever about: power - the power to keep everybody off your back and the power to get on theirs.

And the Beltway bought into the whole thing.
Phooey.

















Labels: , , ,