Tuesday, July 22, 2008

BIDDEN AND FORBIDDEN

Glenn Greenwald takes on an ancient foe in “Rendering Public Opinion Irrelevant” over on the Salon site. (http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/).

I had forgotten how much can be hidden in plain sight, simply because the MSM refuse to notice it. Thus, that – prescinding from the tremendous preponderance of world opinion in the matter – a stupefying 71% of Americans believe that America should take an even-handed approach in the sempiternal Israeli-Palestinian mess.

I had forgotten. And to hear Congresspersons and pols and government apparatchiks tell it, you’d think that We were all for being the ‘bodyguard’ for the Israeli realm (for which, I think, the German word would be ‘Reich’).

Historians will have a field day with this. 22nd-century academic careers will be made writing about how for so long so many Americans wanted to take a balanced approach, and yet the American government – for votes and cash and an excuse to grab oil and keep at a seat at the Eurasian table – took a stupendously one-sided approach.

Greenwald recalls the stunningly bad experience of Howard Dean – whose ‘even-handed’ comment got him into irretrievable difficulties with AIPAC and the other usual suspects, including just about the entire roster of Democratic Party biggies including Reid and Pelosi.
America must support Israel’s right to exist and to be free from terror, bleats the chorus of pandering frogs whose only remaining virtue is that they are bipartisan.

A couple of things come to me:

This was a sorta preventable problem 60 years ago. The Jewish Zionist movement for almost a century had envisioned a ‘safe home’ for Jewish folk. It was a very understandable desire, given the uncertainty of the status of Jewish folk in Europe and European Russia. There would be a problem with finding a patch of real-estate, since most of it was taken up. Some shrewd negotiating with various governments might have yielded benefits. But the ‘solution’ that the Zionists latched onto almost immediately was to equate the ‘safe home’ with a ‘return’ to the real-estate once known as ancient Israel, until in the time of the early Roman Empire that particular property was taken from them after their unsuccessful revolt. But, of course, if the Bible is used as a Registry of Deeds sort of book, then the Jewish ownership of ‘biblical’ Israel is pretty much eternal (Jewish thought on the religious validity of this usage has not been unanimous.).

And once, at least in theory, the very real concern about the permanent safety of the Jewish folk was indissolubly linked to a piece of real estate no longer in their possession and indeed ‘possessed’ – to the extent any land is ever possessed – by others, and for a period of many centuries … well, even in theory and on paper the almost-total intractability of the problem was clear.

But then came the Third Reich and World War Two. Western revulsion at the monstrousness of Hitler’s demonic vision and the inconceivable efficiency of its execution was complete.

Surfing the complicated but not unfavorable wave patterns, the Zionist elements within surviving world Jewry began to make serious noises about ‘going home’, and that they were ‘owed’. That something had to be done to ensure no such massacre would ever happen again seemed clear to any reasonable adult. That the surviving members of world Jewry needed a place to go to call their own was not quite so clear, but certainly a matter for consideration. That world Jewry, represented by a Zionist vanguard, should be permitted to go and re-occupy its old biblical homestead, erect a sovereign state, and to hell with world opinion or the objections of anybody – such as the present inhabitants of the place – did not seem a clearly logical or wise course of action at all.

Harry Truman, as he noted at the time, had no Arab voters and a lot of Jewish ones – and being in charge simultaneously of the world’s new superpower and a Democratic Party that was not sure of its own voter-base – figured that numerous birds could be killed with the one stone. And he cast it. The Pope advised against it; and while he famously had no divisions, he did draw upon almost two millennia worth of highly professional Vatican insight and diplomacy; Harry ignored him. The United Nations and others expressed objections with varying degrees of circumspection – Harry was the new superkid on the block, after all – but to no avail. And by then Zionist-connected militant groups such as Irgun were already over there, setting off car bombs and killing troops (British, even) to let the world know that business was meant and that No as an answer was not on the table.

In a part of the world where memories go back centuries and are never repressed, and in which his nation had no abiding interest (in 1948 the US was pumping its own oil from domestic sources), Harry stretched forth his arm and the people returned ‘home’.

Straightaway, the foreseen intractables began to manifest themselves. The inhabitants resisted to the point where the newly-established Jewish State had to deploy methods not quite so different from the Wehrmacht’s a half-decade before.

And the perky Israeli solution to that inconvenient reality was to insist that a) there were no people there to be militarily eliminated, b) and anyway they were not resistance-fighters but terrorists, c) the horror of the Holocaust has created its own kind of emergency that justifies ‘whatever it takes’ to prevent its repetition, and d) to mention this whole inconvenient reality is to be anti-Semitic and perhaps even Nazi yourself. Behind this queasy cloud of unknowing the Israeli plan was to create itself as a Fact on the Ground that nobody could make ‘go away’; hewed to tenaciously, in season and out of season, this strategy would simply use the West’s famous distractibility as a tool: the West’s attention would be worn down until Israel would appear to be as natural a part of the regional furniture as the mountains and the sand.

And in that plan was the basis of an indenturing of vote-desperate and newly ‘sensitive’ Democrats, a thoroughgoing Political Correctness, a comprehensive media manipulation of public opinion, and a fundamental disconnection between accurate perceptions of reality and repeated official versions of reality that would eventually poison the American polity, ‘host’ and benefactor of the Israeli state, and then would be taken up by the Advocacies of the Identities in the late ‘60s and corrode the very foundations of American democratic politics and the ability of its citizens to People their government.

But to think about it all – except in the way that the Israeli state found useful and convenient – was Forbidden, by parties unknown - or at least who don't care to acknowledge their role in this treacherous mess.

For quite some time it was useful to de-emphasize ‘religion’ in American society. Hence for years there was an unstinting support of the ‘secularization’ of American society. After all, since the country was mostly ‘Christian’ (although not necessarily Fundamentalist, back then) it stood to reason that the less ‘Christianity’ was loose, the less danger of a repeat of the Holocaust happening. And – a happy two-fer – this dovetailed nicely with the feministic emphasis on de-emphasizing ‘religion’ in American society not only because the feminists of that Wave wanted to destabilize the white, male-dominated ‘rape culture’ of American society, but also because ‘religious’ arguments were the greatest conceptual obstruction to the ramming home of pro-abortion laws.

And yet then when it became clear that the Democrats were no longer as useful as they once had been, rapport was established with a Republican Party whose conceptual and emotional base was in the whackery of American Protestant Fundamentalism, an early-20th century phenomenon that believed in the literal truth of every single word of the Bible except wherever it said ‘wine’ (which, according to the most authoritative preacherly exegesis, really meant ‘grape juice’). Not historically averse to the virtues of the grape themselves, the Israelis tactfully overlooked the oenophobia and embraced those particular elements of Fundamentalism that would surreptitiously spackle up the notoriously flaccid American citizenry with a respect for authority and efficiency (ja!) and with a sense of how urgent it was to win the unavoidable battle for Armageddon that would establish the Israeli state in total peace and security by flattening all its enemies.

Ominously, the tidal wave generated by 9/11 provided the vehicle by which a now energy-and-economy-challenged US government could simultaneously make its bid for fresh supplies of energy, a place at the evolving Eurasian table, a refreshed stature for its dangerously ungrounded currency, and a securing of the Israeli state’s regional position (and thus of the American Jewish voters’ undying gratitude) … so many nice birds with just the one stone.

The current US government need to spackle up the American citizenry for 'resource wars' and national-interest preventive wars and other assorted overseas adventures dovetails nicely with the Israeli government's need to keep the US involved 'over there'. After all, it wasn't rocket science to see - even in 1948 - that if the Israelis for all practical purposes invaded Palestine, and then had to resort to Wehrmacht-tactics in order to establish their beach-head, then in that never-forget part of the world a lot of the locals would be mickle displeased with the Israeli state for the forseeable future. The Israeli governments of that era could be forgiven for thinking that such hostility - generated not by a conceptual anti-Semitism but rather by an abiding outrage over the invasion and 'pacification' of Palestine - would in itself be useful, creating an ongoing 'emergency' that would justify any further harsh measures of military repression and also sustaining an ongoing 'emergency' sure to snag American voters and politicians. And so it has.

And - also not rocket science - the Arab states accurately perceive - also not rocket science, given US pols' statements - that the US is the strength propping up this whole Israeli gambit. And do they hate 'us' for who we are? Or for what the US government has done and continues to do? Funny how Bush hit on that point, in exactly that odd way of putting it, immediately after 9/11. And answered his own question - what did We expect? - that it wasn't anything that We 'did', but rather that 'those' folks were simply hating-on Us for who We are. Which, also, in a marvelous but no doubt innocent coincidence, is precisely how the Israeli government likes to present itself, thus blotting out the original invasion, that ironic original-sin upon which the entire enterprise is built. My my my. Yah.

It also occurs to me: if Congressfolk are opposing so large a majority of the public, and – as we’ve seen in matters sex-offensive and Patriot-ic – aren’t even bothering to read the laws that they then vote for, just how legitimate are the laws? Issues of ‘legitimacy’ – profoundly ominous – arise, politically even if not (for the moment) legally. There is a 71% majority of Us who wish to see a more 'balanced' - face it, a more intelligent - approach to the Israel-Palestine problem, and Our pols ignore that?

Many of those 22nd-century careers will also be made tracing the debacle of the US government’s gradual self-indenture to the interests of the Israeli state – a state with which no official alliance exists or has ever existed, one of the very few states which had attacked US forces, killing and injuring many, in repeated attacks in the broad light of a terribly long day … an achievement in infamy not even effected by the USSR in all its long, dark tenure.

And then those 22nd-century scholars will start looking at Us: what the frak had gone wrong with Us that We could have let things – Our government included – get so far out of hand?

What indeed? Inquiring minds will want to know.

Labels: , , , ,

Friday, July 11, 2008

FAULT HAS MANY LINES

Andrew Bacevich, retired Army officer, reviews two of the latest crop of books coming out of the Iraq War (“Fault Lines: Inside Rumsfeld’s Pentagon” http://bostonreview.net/BR33.4/bacevich.php).

In keeping with the Autumn-’44 scenario, several of the then-major players are already writing books to explain that they weren’t really major players or – more predictably – that they were major players but that interference of some sort ruined their fine and wise plans … seeking to strike a sort of a “Look what they done to my song, Ma” note.

Who can blame them? After all, history demonstrates that after such maniac – and failed – blunders of this magnitude, inquiries will be made. Their concern is only modestly justified. In the first place, many gentlepersons who should have had to explain themselves escaped having to do so in Germany and Italy in the years immediately following 1945 for the simple reason that too many people had gone along with the regime, the Party, and the war and the remainder of the citizenry had more pressing matters to deal with.

And the commanders of the American forces of occupation, possessed both of a sense of perspective that today would be considered grossly ‘insensitive’ and a military competence well in the above-average range, realized that no matter how many boots on the ground the U.S. could muster, the task of ferreting out and identifying every single Nazi – especially if that definition were expanded to include Party member, collaborator, sympathizer, and relative thereof – would be impossible enough to be unachievable, but intrusive enough to weaken the occupation and deeply anger the German citizenry. 'Zero tolerance' was not a wise option, and most wisely it was not deployed. As them Kathliks have always known, total purity or total perfection or total anything is not an option in this world. Not possible, therefore not wise. Americans knew that once in the not so distant past.

In the second place, Our modern American reality is so fundamentally comprised of an inability to process information maturely that the chances are better than average that the Iraq-perps will walk. And better than walk, they will remain on assorted A-lists, or B-lists at the worst. This thanks to the aforementioned regressed-imbecility of Our national maturity and the complicity of a corporatized media that gets the best of both worlds: keeping the powerful happy while keeping the peanut-gallery excited.

Already we see that Douglas Feith – described, if memory serves, by General Tommy Franks as the ‘dumbest such-and-such alive’ (and Franks should be an expert in that regard) – has wound up in a tenured position at Georgetown, a university founded by the Jesuits at a time now clearly long past when they were at the top of their institutional game. Who the hell has he been sleeping with? (figuratively speaking, I’d like to imagine).

Retired Major-General Ricardo Sanchez is also positioning himself, out of the line of fire and into the limelight. He wasn’t the best man for the job, but he was willing to go along to get along – the dark side of being a crisp and snappy ‘team player’. The perennial military dilemma of keeping an essential order and cohesion and enthusiastic institutional identity while remaining open to vital institutional self-criticism … well, it’s safe to say that there is no working balance currently operating. Corporations are even more besotted in this regard, and one wonders if the historical corporate bias against ‘bachelors’ has not been so much a matter of ‘homophobia’ so-called, but rather a matter of control: men with no families have far fewer hostages to fortune who might be taken, leaving them far freer to speak out, being free of the responsibility to keep a paycheck at any cost for the sake of supporting a family.

Such short-comings as these two exemplify might have been debilitating once upon a time. But not now, with a citizenry unable to any longer effectively function as a People, as The People, because of its disorganized and infantilized capacity both individually and communally to continuously demand, obtain, consider, and accurately judge essential information, and to communicate the results clearly to its representatives. And its hired Executive.

The result has been the horses running away with the proverbial wagon or – less charitably – the clowns running the circus. Though very dark and dangerous clowns. Sleazy ones. Treacherous ones. But each and all capable of playing to the citizenry’s increasingly pathetic reliance on ‘feelings’ and ‘appearances’ to chart a course through life and the world.

In this regard, the matter of John McCain’s military experiences has always intrigued me. Imagine you are a military commander. Your nation is fighting a long war against a powerful enemy on your own territory, and the enemy’s aircraft are inflicting great damage to your people. One of those pilots is shot down; he turns out to be the grandson of one of the most famous commanders in your enemy’s greatest war, and the son of the theater commander of your own present enemy. He is somewhat injured.

Do you torture him? Do you simply let him disappear into the quotidian miasm of POW camps until – whenever it may be – the war will end? Do you give him special treatment, including the best available medical treatment, in order to use him to your advantage in some inscrutable (sorta stereotypically ‘oriental’) way?

And if you are said flyer, considered by your military peers from the get-go as bratty, too cocky, and not altogether sound in the framework department, and you find yourself thus shot down and captured, do you not-identify yourself? Fight to the death to avoid a capture that will only complicate your nation’s (and your father’s) war effort? Get too cocky and then have to buy your way out of some unpleasant impending punishment? Just try to use whatever chips you’ve got to make things easier for yourself ‘cuz deep down you’ve always been kind of unripe beneath all the boozy bluster?

It’s a set of questions that certainly beg to be asked, nowadays when We are being asked to elect somebody in that situation to the Presidency.

In an article on Counterpunch (www.counterpunch.org/valentine06132008.html) Douglas Valentine considers the possibilities, while also noting that U.S. losses along the air routes used in McCain’s ops increased 60% in the year after he was captured, until finally the routes and some of the tactics had to be abandoned. Good pilots were lost. While not conclusive, these facts raise hugely significant possibilities. Little attention has so far been paid.

I am not at all suggesting the scurrility of a Swift-Boast style campaign except this time mounted by Democrats. Name-calling and a raw blurting of ‘feelings’ – two modes of ‘discussion’ unhappily introduced into mainstream national discourse long before the Republican Ascendancy - are unworthy of the seriousness of the issues: of the election and of Mr. McCain’s competence and worthiness as a candidate.

We as a People and a nation are – as it were – running out of flight deck here. We either have to get into the air or plan to take an unhappy swim, and there is little window left for the decision. The world has put up with Our increasingly erratic and unserious carrying-on for a number of decades now, but there’s little chance that this state of affairs will continue. Especially nowadays when to ‘erratic’ and ‘unserious’ must be added ‘aggressive’ and ‘unilaterally willful’.

As We now see with Congress’s cave on the FISA telecom immunity, the new President is going to be facing monstrous interlocked problems, foreign and domestic, but in addition will face even with his own Party a widespread, deep and long established avoidance of authentic representative government and an addiction to the financial, political and personal gain that can be achieved by holding high elective office. Before tackling the huge issues, he will have to fight the entrenched, well-coiffed but greasy treacheries that have long been resident on Capitol Hill.

If it will be wondrous should he manage to succeed even modestly against such a matrix of unlovely habits and addictions, it will be nothing short of miraculous should the Congress manage to heal itself.

Entering this Augean stable, if the new President has even a modest chance of being Hercules, it is The People who must be his cleansing river, whose powerful freshets can start to clear away the accumulated choking muck.

But only in the mode of a mature citizenry and a mature democratic politics. We have had 40 years in the desert of ‘revolutionary’ politics, of the Left even before the Right, and have little to show for it except a stunning loss of Our heritage and competence as The People and a now-astounding record of incompetence and aggression.

No lazy hazy crazy days this year. Summer school for all. Expect very hard knocks. Pray as if everything depends on God, work as if everything depends on Us. (This last a variant on the wisdom of St. Ignatius, founder and now probably widower/relict of the once-great Jesuit Order that is presently brunching with Feith and all his pomps and all his works.)

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, July 08, 2008

FEAR AS FUEL

Joe Galloway published a nifty piece about 4th Amendment violations (http://www.mcclatchydc.com/homepage/story/43123.html).

Concerning Congress he opines that “a majority” and “on both sides of the aisle” have made “a stunning surrender to those who want us to live in fear forever”. To which one can only respond: Bingo.

To put in a nutshell what I’ve Posted about all along, the lethal synergy that developed in the later-1960s was between a) the ‘revolutionary politics’ first embraced by the vote-desperate Democrats and b) the Israeli state’s playbook on how to succeed in establishing “facts on the ground”; the latter became the how-to master-plan for any Identity’s ‘advocacy’. And ‘advocacy’ quietly but quickly came to mean something hell and gone from the civics-textbook vision of a citizen saying up and speaking a piece in order to inform and maybe persuade other citizens at the town meeting; ‘advocacy’ became a cottage-industry and then a big business, but one poisoned by its roots in the ruthless, ends-justifies-means philosophy of ‘facts on the ground’ (hereinafter: “FOTG”).

And ‘facts on the ground’, in a profoundly dark irony, found itself running the same plays as the master manipulator of Western Civ’s most heinous spawn, Hitler; more specifically, the plays adopted and deployed by Hitler’s propaganda boss, Joseph Goebbels, who himself had creatively distilled ideas from Lenin and the great American advertising pioneer, Edward Bernays. Ach, such fearful symmetries, and so few degrees of separation, between Good and Evil. You almost have to imagine the distance between them, when comparing Goebbels and FOTG; if you look for more palpable differences, you may be looking for a long time.

The bottom line, of course, was to get large numbers of persons – the ‘public’ – to buy your product or support your movement. To achieve that End, ‘democracy’ was a poor tool: too slow, too much potential for distracting questions either irrelevant or far too relevant; too much possibility that at the end of the day too many folks would just say no.

Being a government, one had options that (in those days) commercial companies didn’t have: you could appeal to patriotism, you could tap into the deepest feelings in folks – feelings that were rooted in primal, atavistic fears, however neatly they were overlaid with a nice layer of civilized thought and behavior. And, if you really really couldn’t afford anything to go wrong and really really had to keep to a schedule, then you went for the gut. Forget appealing to ‘approval’ or ‘educating desire’; hit ‘em where they lived!

And fear is where all animals live, in their deepest, most primitive brainparts. We denizens of the world’s most enlightened, advanced, educated, cultured, tasteful, productive society and culture … we don’t like to be reminded of those dark places. And since our funeral industry has managed to paint over Death with a thick layer of skin-toned paste, and since our plumbing industry has found a way to quickly and efficiently remove our more animal producements, and since our media industry has found it to be far more profitable not to remind us of places where Death and defecation still play a major role in shaping people’s lives, well, we’ve lost the mental and spiritual skill to co-exist in the same dimension with Death and all the other dark and messy stuff. In fact, we like to think we’re above all that, beyond it.

Which makes us as fat and easy a bunch of targets for enterprising barbarians as did the imperial cities of Rome for the Goths, Vandals, Visigoths, and all their sisters and their cousins and their aunts. Pioneers couldn’t be so easily rattled by fear: man, woman, and child they lived with Death and animality and darkness, and they had developed and passed on the chops to deal with it all. There was a reason why even the youngest, most doe-eyed soldiers in those old Civil War-era photos (I know: daugerreotypes) were possessed of a sober fierceness that gave them a dynamic solidity, a seriousness and sense of living in the presence of large-things that are now utterly alien to Americans. And have been since the days of flappers and sodas, indoor plumbing and funeral parlors. (So shrink your hat size, Greatest Generation; you were the ‘adults’ in 1968 and you let the whackjob kids pretend they knew more than you did. Thanks a bunch.).

Fear is the great motivator, the great convincer, the great stifler of dissent. Not the opium of the masses but more like the crack or Ecstasy of the masses: propelling them to levels of energy and boundary-breaking behaviors they’d never be capable of on a normal day.

The National Security State knew it needed to stimulate and harness ‘fear’ in the American citizenry before the barrels were cooled after WW2; fear of Stalin and of the USSR and of ‘godless communism’ and of the Russkies having the Bomb. The National Nanny State, so profoundly rooted in the soil of feminist agitprop, built on ‘fear’; fear of physical assault, fear of sexual assault, fear of one’s children’s being sexually assaulted (and – one can only wonder – fear of one’s children being sexual at all, the great insight that made Freud even in his prime unclubbable and kept him off much of the dinner-party circuit). The fearfulness and the attendant suspicion and the ceaseless desire for safety and security (and – logically and much more darkly - revenge) became one of the great unspoken fuels of the burgeoning, engorging, Nanny State.

It has never been addressed, that the feminist ideology touted the sempiternal historical oppression of ‘women’ (when I talk about this stuff, I am not actually referring to all humans of the feminine sex/gender/persuasion or whatever the accepted word is today) but simultaneously touted its product – the liberated woman – as being a transcendent boon for society, instantly capable of taking the natural place she deserved, unmarred by eons of the fear and suspicion and anxiety and urge for revenge which must logically be at least part of the make-up of any human being so long and so thoroughly oppressed. But no. Political correctness, ‘sensitivity’, and the fear of being branded as any number of evil things kept anyone from kicking the tires, or even observing that a vehicle with this kind of history must have some serious and hard mileage and a transmission and shocks in need of serious work.

But fear was the first fuel and it was put to work forthwith. Fear of children being abducted in the hundreds of thousands every year (the late ‘70s); fear that children in day-care were being systematically molested by faculty (male and female) in costumes all around the country (the early-‘80s); fear that Catholic priests were systematically raping or at least touching children - defined within an age range from infants to military recruits, often without anybody having known for decades (the mid-‘80s; and the early-‘90s, and the early-‘00s … this tornado keeps turning around and coming back down Main Street); fear that many, maybe most, possibly all dates were ending in rape (the late-‘90s); fear that many women in marriages were being battered – defined within a range from being murdered to being not-spoken-to over the phone (the mid-‘90s); fear that unnumbered hordes of perverted strangers were roaming the land, not abducting children (that was the ‘70s) but rather murdering them after sexual assault, the possibility of family members being far more likely perpetrators conveniently ignored (the mid-‘90s and on into the present day).

We have become a fear-driven society. A society herded by fear. Stampeded by fear. A fear that, conveniently in many ways, allows no skepticism, no deliberation, no discussion.

Can it really be any wonder that when 9-11 occurred, the individual and societal circuitry that transmits and processes fear was already in place, tested, and perfected through long use? Can it be any wonder that a society that was willing to call the government into its own bedroom was willing to tolerate that government invading another country – for the purpose of alleviating American fears … ? (No, it makes no difference that now even Greenspan and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs and Bush’s former press secretary among others admit that the control of oil has always been the primary strategic objective. We were used, and we had been rendered usable and had convinced the enterprising barbarians that we were usable by sitting still for decades of fear-fueled government invasions of our own lives.)

And let’s leave it to historians to figure out how it came to be that the feminist movement that so loudly brayed against being stereotyped as hysterical and irrational and driven by emotions, became a favored Identity of the Democratic Party and with that power embarked on a sustained wave of fear-and-revenge-fueled initiatives that under the Clinton Administration even managed to deform criminal law and jurispraxis, in addition to ensuring that generations of citizens have now been raised to be fearful and suspicious and, driven by those emotions, open to a panoply of anti-democratic ‘solutions’ to immediately eradicate ‘pain’ and achieve ‘closure’. While at the same time imagining that our modern American reality is merely the latest and greatest stage in the march of American democracy in all its tasteful, sensitive and compassionate power and perfection.

This is madness. And we laugh at the Fundamentalists?

Fear cannot be the fuel for a democratic politics nor the primary mental and emotional tone of a democratic citizen’s personality. Early generations of Americans, including the immigrants, were not fearless, but they had learned as children – from their adults – how to face fear, to live with it and to master their responses to it. And that involved a hefty amount of complex internal development, by the by, of a sort that could ground a personality, a character, an adulthood. And you could achieve a democratic politics with a People like that.

You can’t achieve a democratic politics based on fear. And you cannot trust anybody who says that you can. Other peoples in the past 100 years have yielded to that seduction and killed more human beings – man, woman, and ‘minor’ – than are dreamed of in our Identities’ worst media-amplified scenarios.

Nor can you in any way foster fear and consider yourself Liberal. You cannot bind yourself to a politics of manipulation rather than a politics of information and deliberation and call yourself Liberal. You may well be a revolutionary, although one in a good cause – but you are no Liberal.

And you cannot embrace an engorged government surveillance and a ‘unitary executive’ and call yourself a Conservative, at least not an American conservative. A German conservative, maybe – ala the Reichstag of the early 1930s, but not an American Conservative.

And you cannot consider The People as a manipulable or expendable mob of ‘extras’ and call yourself American at all.

I am not at all suggesting that women are second-class beings or that they do not deserve respect and the opportunity to contribute to society and culture – all citizens bear that right and that responsibility. Nor am I in any way suggesting that ‘the clock should be turned back’. But I am saying that the historical truth is that huge deformities have been introduced into American culture and society through the particular workings and agitatings of the feminist movement; and that those deformities have seriously compromised America’s very capacity to conduct a democratic politics; and that if this reality is not acknowledged then the chances are that democratic politics and American Democracy – which is our truest ‘identity’ – is doomed to go the way of the dodo.

And this country will go the way of Rome, as the Framers feared and as we are already seeing.

Labels: , , , , ,