Saturday, August 13, 2011

THE UK RIOTS AND POLITICALLY CORRECT THEORY

There has been a great deal already written now about the last week’s extended period of rioting in the UK.

I am going to discuss some thoughts in light of what might be of relevance to Our situation here in the US.

An article in the Vancouver ‘Sun’ provides an excellent starting point. It notes the assorted ‘explanations’ for the ‘source’ of the rioting and I’m just going to follow along with its text and make comments as I go.

Was the rioting “only to be expected” in neighborhoods of great economic distress? Did the “police just ‘have it coming’”?  

The first point here is to note the now-conventional leap from violation of the law to ‘understanding’ the sources of the violations. Police enforce the law; sociologists and academics of other disciplines study events, perhaps with an eye to not only understanding but making some recommendations.

In which case you then have to distinguish between what is ‘ideal’ and what is ‘workable’, and then have to figure how to erect such recommendations into a national policy that will seek either to inspire or impose changes on the living complex organism that is a living society and culture – all of which should, in a democratic society and culture, involve wide and deep and sustained public deliberation and agreement before any such developed-policy recommendations are erected into law and regulations.

But then you have to factor in the advanced, ‘professional’ level ‘advocacy’ of the past 40 years (a UK as well as a US phenomenon). From the neighborhood ‘activist’ and ‘pressure groups’ of the late 1960s and early 1970s this has mutated and expanded into powerful, politically influential interest-groups that have set up shop within the Beltway (or in London) to participate in the Identity-Politics Era’s version of the (non-smoking) ‘smoke-filled room’ of the bad old days of Gilded Age, machine-politics; in this scenario, the ‘public’ doesn’t enter into it, and it’s a matter of those who have wangled or won ‘a seat at the table’ doing whatever ‘deals’ can be hammered out.

It is to this that deliberative politics in a large and complex democratic and constitutional republic have descended, and ‘principles’ or ‘deliberation’ don’t enter into it. The ‘deal’ will be hammered out by pols and interest-group reps who feel they’ve done their day’s work and earned their salt, and ‘the public’ will simply have to like or lump whatever laws, policies, and regulations are then formally erected and imposed.

And the second point is that the police are now put in the position of having to somehow not only enforce the law (which is a job enough) but also to enforce it with an eye to how it should be enforced and (as We shall see below) how they must not enforce the law ‘impartially’ (a prime fundament of Western culture’s achievement in world history) but rather ‘partially’ – meaning that all sorts of special restrictions, admonitions, policies, regulations, and practices must be taken to account depending on who is doing the law-violating.

This dynamic, even before you start getting to such freighted and fraught specifics as race and gender politics, is stunningly complex, perverse, and obstreperous (meaning that it won’t always go where you want it to go and produce the results that you foresaw in the clubby precincts of the (non-smoking) smoke-filled room where you decided to ignite the dynamic in the first place).

The third point is that the police, the ‘boots on the ground’ out there on the front lines of the job, are now put in a situation not only ‘nuanced’ and ‘complex’ but impossibly contradictory: either you are going to claim to be impartially enforcing the laws or you are going to be deliberately exercising ‘partiality’ in how you enforce the laws.

And the police will thus always be consulting their Memos and the latest edition of their guidelines, and wondering – since no politician is going to take the heat for claiming in rock-solid plain English what’s going on now – whether you are about to do something that will land you into treacherously uncertain and swampy procedural and legal territory, where inherently and deliberately mushy definitions might suddenly be turned against you.  The pressure is on you to just wait and see what instructions (including the treacherous and slimy wink or nod) come from Above.

Leading to the fourth point, that generations of senior British police commanders and honchos have now achieved their current status and authority primarily on the basis of mastering the Gumby-like malleability to speak out of many sides of their mouths and quickly shift their positions to accommodate the prevailing political winds. This is lethal for the efficiency of any organization, but especially a police organization, charged as it is with such authority and responsibility to ensure enforcement of the laws. And if your cardiologist allows you, give some thought as to what such a frakkulent miasm of swamp-gas butt-covering does to the integrity of an organization.*

And the fifth point brings Us to the entire point, again, of confusing actions and causes. The job of the police is to assess whether an action violates the laws and then act accordingly. It is up to the courts to assess the causes and motivations of the act; and then it is up to the legislature to consider wide changes that might be necessary (and workable) to address those underlying causes.
BUT you cannot cram all of this into the one dense point in time and space where the police encounter law-violations on the street, as it were. No human policy and no human beings (meaning the police themselves) can function adequately under such intense, almost astrophysical, amounts of pressure and radiation.

The article then goes on to ask “But what should we make of another theory, that the police handled the rioters with kid gloves because they were paralyzed by fear of being called racist?”.  

Who could be surprised if such were the case?

Here is the consequence (unintended - or perhaps not, but just as real, nonetheless) of all of the foregoing dynamics ignited and unleashed in the polity over the course of recent years. The unequal and deliberately ‘partial’ enforcement of the law has been discussed above.

In addition you see here the complexity of making the police not simply law-enforcers but also the hands-on representatives of the Nanny State , seeking to be ‘understanding’; deciding – like Carol Gilligan’s Mommy At The Breakfast Table – just what each of her squalling tykes needs (more sugar, a hug, a warning, a sharp rap on the fingers, deprivation of sugar, the humming of a favorite tune) simply to get through the meal.

You can’t have the police committed formally to impartial enforcement of the law while simultaneously requiring them in practice to decide – again like Gilligan’s Mommy – and in the tension-filled context of the ever-complicated and shifting waters of on-scene encounters, just which law violator gets the law enforced against him/her and who gets ‘understanding’ (especially, on the basis of Race).

This is a recipe for failure, disaster, and as general respect for the efficacy and integrity of law consequently declines, societal catastrophe. Which would include catastrophe for the government itself, which you would think might give pols and bureaucrats a bit of pause, but they have learned to brighten their days merely with the self-congratulation of making a good ‘deal’ in the (non-smoking) smoke-filled rooms of the Beltway, Whitehall, or the Commons.

This started out in the US as a way of simultaneously reining in the Southern Jim Crow police agencies of the 1950s and early 1960s and ensuring that so clear and clearly repellent a Regime of policing – and repellently enforcing the repellent Jim Crow laws to boot – would not continue.

But it kept spreading as the US suddenly found itself facing the mid-later 1960s ‘summer riots’ when the far more complex and decidedly chiaroscuro context of the non-Southern urban cities presented a far more and for all practical purposes clearly different challenge and reality. In that event, the almost ‘simple’ dynamics of the clearly good-evil melodrama (in the best sense of the word) of Freedom-vs-Jim-Crow were hopelessly inadequate to the changed tactical and strategic situation, and consequently the simplistically sustained application of the anti-Jim Crow strategy became a grossly inadequate response to the challenge presented.

And on top of that (in an eerie contemporaneous echo of the US military’s steepening descent into the morass of Vietnam), the efforts to continue applying the (now inadequate) strategy by intensifying it caused only a mutation of the genuinely effective and truly marvelous Southern Civil Rights strategy into the conceptually fraught and twisted race-partial Frankenstein-ian misch of laws, policies, and regulations that are in effect today, both here and in the UK. (Let us pass over in silence here the subsequent levels of legislative and jurisprudential frakkery as the Race category was joined and vastly expanded by the Gender category.)

Again, there is a world of difference on the ground, on the civic terrain, between robustly enforcing bad laws, poorly enforcing good laws, and impartially enforcing good laws. As has so often spelled disaster for armchair generals, the treachery of the actual terrain doesn’t appear on the flat, neat maps back at higher headquarters. (Hitler, as some of his general staff officers noted after the war, was fond of watching himself sweep his hands over vast clear spaces of Russia on the map – boldly directing to Go here, Execute that – while his vaunted troops were freezing and mired in the morass of the actual situation on the Eastern Front.)

Nor does it help clarify matters when rioters claim – as they have now been taught to claim – that they resent the police: “The police never talk to us, they ignore us, they don’t think we’re human in this area … the way police treat blacks is like we’re nothing … the police behave in an arrogant manner that puts people’s backs up”. These are the legitimate claims of Southern US blacks in the 1950s and early 1960s.

But they are not quite as easily applicable to later situations (up to and including the present). A riot is a riot, after all, and a truly terrifying reality if you’re downrange of it and not part of the party, and your home or business about to be torched.

And the riot is not especially ‘pure’ when general looting and pilferage and outright theft and even robbery take place in the middle of it, perhaps as its primary functional activity (all of the US riots demonstrated this, including New York’s as late as 1977 and LA’s in 1992, and the recent UK riots). ‘Understanding’ the possible or even probable economic causal elements doesn’t and cannot be allowed to have an effect on the police response to a riot.

(I can’t help but think that the LAPD did the Western world no end of harm when it conducted that ridiculous drawn-out ‘pursuit’ of O.J. Simpson in the now-famous white Bronco along LA’s freeways that afternoon: dozens if not hundreds of police cars respectfully following the vehicle at respectable speeds mile after mile, roads blocked, traffic snarled (and who knows how many ambulances en route to patients or hospitals delayed?) while the cameras were greedily grinding away. But it was considered in elite quarters to be ‘sensitive’ police work.)

And clearly the UK police were not ‘arrogant’; the riots went on in no small part because the UK police – replete with a heavily sensitized command structure and thousands of officers employed in ‘community liaison and service’ billets and warned never to go overboard (see below) – stood   by. A skeptical mind might wonder if all of those billets – no doubt filled in great part by quota-hires of race and gender, thoroughly indoctrinated in ‘modern sensitive’ policing  – for all practical purposes reduce the police to spiffily-uniformed social-workers and street-corner psychotherapists. And, ominously, all the potential and actual rioters know that now.

(In case you’re wondering, I am not advocating a return to the days of the Southern highway-patrols and sheriff’s deputies of the 1950s and early 1960s; in fact, I would imagine that they, even more than the LAPD , did law-enforcement a huge disservice by demonstrating with such awful vividness what happens when bad laws are allowed to exist for long stretches of decades and then such laws go on to corrupt even the well-intentioned police who dutifully follow orders and policy and try to enforce them. But you cannot expect the police – whose role in society, especially in the legal Universe of a constitutional democracy, is supposed to be limited – to embody and enforce all of the ‘changes’ that politicians so blithely legislate with a figurative, terra-forming sweep of their hands over the national map.) **

As this meaty article goes on to note: “Other residents who witnessed people carrying off carpets, trainers and watches noticed that [the rioters involved] included individuals of all ‘colours and creeds’, suggesting an outburst of sheer lawlessness rather than righteous retaliation for past racial slights”.

Or to put things in an American idiom: today’s rioters – and it has been this way for quite a few decades now in these parts – are not the long lines of self-disciplined, genuinely courageous Freedom Marchers from Martin Luther King’s glowing heyday in the late 1950s and early 1960s. These are not – to borrow a phrase from the feminist PR manuals – ‘your father’s’ rioters; in fact, during MLK’s ascendancy there were no rioters.

I can only agree wholeheartedly with the article’s assertion that “reluctance to use force is right and we should be reluctant to reproach the police for it”. This is right and proper in a constitutional democracy where, ideally, all the ‘public’ are Citizens who are committed to fulfilling the obligations and responsibilities that are so profoundly attached to that role and title.

But nowadays and as a result of decades of Correct ‘deconstruction’ of Western civilization and the deployment of Theory-driven agitprop Victimism by organized interests whose (short-term) advantage such deliberate wrecking has served, not all of the members of the public subscribe to – or have even been raised to recognize – such responsibilities and obligations as are utterly indispensable to the sustaining and nourishing of a genuine polity that respects the vital reality of its own common weal.

And as the British commentator Theodore Dalrymple has said: today’s youthful rioters are not so much suffering from a lack of self-esteem as they are wallowing benightedly in a surfeit of self-approval and an utter (and quite possibly unconscious or pre-conscious) lack of genuine self-respect (as Citizens and – not to put too fine a point on it – as adults). And after almost half-a-century of this crapulent wrecking, many of the rioters are no longer ‘youthful’ but – chronologically at least – are of an age when, as used to be said, they should know better.

In fact, it is positively eerie how some of the rioter’s complaints against the police – they don’t respect us, they don’t listen to us, they don’t pay attention to us – sound like nothing so much as James Dean’s character whining about his parents’ shortcomings: 'you don’t understand me', in the now-iconic 1950s film, Rebel Without A Cause. Go figure.
That being said, you don’t need to have completed a 300-level university course in Civics to sense deep down in your soul (yes, I know – the concept has been declared no longer road-worthy and among elites has been put up on blocks in the national garage, or sent to the crushing machine) that it’s somehow very surely not ‘right’ to go out and wreck other people’s property or take it for your own enjoyment, making a hash of their lives and perhaps physical well-being in the process.

And – one would imagine – a police command authority that has most surely taken advanced degrees in 300, 400, and 500-level courses in that area of professional study would recognize when matters have taken a turn that require the police to take legitimately robust measures. In the old days it was called ‘reading the Riot Act’, whereby a senior police commander would face the crowd in full boots-on-the-ground mode, unroll a copy of the Act and proclaim it out loud with its warning as to what would happen if everybody didn’t settle down forthwith, and then it was up to the ladies and gentlemen of the immediate assembly to decide what direction matters would take from there.

Curious how the Information Age has not resulted in the dissemination of certain useful and vital information. (Nor am I suggesting that the police simply enter the electronic age by tweeting the Riot Act to all personal communications devices within a certain riot-torn area … although you can bet some entrepreneur will be calculating how to make a few government bucks by submitting a proposal for funding. Not that there are many government bucks or pounds or Euros to go around any longer.)

But, the article sagely observes, “Since the Macpherson Report of 1999, the UK police have been hypersensitive about race. This attitude has now become so paradoxical that they find themselves standing aside when members of ethnic minorities are being harmed. The people who ran shops, or who lived in the flats above, were not given the protection they deserved.”

Following on the death of a young black man by what was to all appearances a gang of brutally laddish white boyos in 1993, a major UK government Report was compiled (see here for a superb British paper explaining  that Report, entitled “Racist Murder and Pressure Group Politics” released by the  UK think-tank “Institute for the Study of Civil Society” in 2000).

That Report, named after its chairman, insisted that despite the unhappy fact that there was not enough evidence to actually bring the case to successful prosecution (for which it recommended watering-down or side-stepping traditional Western and British rules of evidence – a gambit taken up in American ‘victim-friendly’ law around the same time) … despite all that, yet there was “institutional racism” that ran through British society and its culture and institutions like holes in Swiss cheese (my image) and that such institutional-racism extended to the police.

It ignored (perhaps as ‘thinking too much’) the complex and very difficult distinctions between perennially unavoidable misapplications of good law and policy, bad law and policy whether well or ill-applied, and deliberate and malicious race-conscious laws and policy (of which it admitted it could find little evidence and few examples).

BUT, it continued, the real problem was in “unwitting institutional racism” which, as you might quickly imagine, opened up everything to the fear that lurking racist Evil – like vampires, Communists, or sex-offenders – was hiding everywhere such that even well-intentioned people and institutions were “guilty” whether they knew it or not, whether they intended malice or not.

You can see where such a gambit simultaneously opened the floodgate to as many expert Witch-finders General as wished to appoint themselves and apply for government monies to fund their inevitable ‘shocking discoveries’; and also created a near-Mania atmosphere where the eager cadres of pressure-group advocacy could point the accusing and deconstructing finger in almost any direction and be sure of hitting some element of the common culture and polity,;and the general Citizenry could be intimidated and emotionally bethumped into numbed acquiescence under the demoralizing ‘awareness’ that they were and always would be and always had been guilty, guilty, guilty.

This hit the British police especially hard in the 1990s (just as the American military of that era was hit by the same gambit in regard to ‘genderism’ and etcetera and etcetera and etcetera).

The result in all the above instances was predictable: the agents of the culture were paralyzed as if by a snake’s venom, and could only “collapse like a boned fish” (that marvelous image in the filmed dialogue of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King in regard to Frodo’s being injected by the ancient spider-demon Shelob). All of the afore-mentioned authoritative leadership structures responded to such attack by, for all practical purposes, rendering themselves witlessly but deliberately invertebrate. Hence the UK police response to the recent riots.

The UK had already taken a solid whack from the Scarman Report of the early 1980s which had been commissioned after the Brixton riots of 1981. That Report drew the unhappy and infelicitous conclusion that “white” police lacked legitimacy in “black” areas; one is reminded of Lincoln’s annoyed exclamation when one of his Army of the Potomac commanders happily telegraphed that having repulsed an ‘invasion of the North’ by Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia, “the enemy has been driven from our soil”: “When will my generals learn that the entire country is ‘our soil’?”

The police were now not to consider themselves as enforcement agents of the national laws if they were ‘white’ and the neighborhood was ‘black’. This was possibly well-intentioned and certainly grist for serious and deliberate thought leading to some form of effective and workable action; but to immediately erect a government ‘policy’ that for all practical purposes recognized such a piously bleated assertion as Gospel was incomprehensibly and lethally witless if not also profoundly irresponsible on the part of a government that was quickly reducing itself to being National Panderer to this, that, and every other pressure-group Demand and Agenda, artfully and telegenically staged.

This was no way to responsibly face the admittedly vast and deep challenges of shaping an increasingly multiracial society – although, I would add, one would think that a common identity as Citizens of the British polity would have been considered a valuable element in formulating national policy … but prior decades’ worth of Identity Politics and the outré demands of full-blown Multiculturalism had already grievously weakened that element.

And then Scarman went on to assert that “there is widespread agreement that the composition of our police forces must reflect the composition of our society”. The article – and I agree – disagrees. The legitimacy of the police is not based on whether this or that group, however it considers itself distinguishable, recognizes in the police a satisfactory mirror-image of itself. It depends on the competence of the police officers and – one sincerely hopes – the wisdom of the laws they are sworn to enforce. ***

With baize-covered bravery, Scarman insisted that the police had to be diversified and sensitized “whatever the cost may be”. In that last phrase his Lordship acknowledged by sly omission that even then there was substantial professional concern that ‘efficiency’ would be surrendered to ‘equality’ (and, to use the American term, ‘diversity’). And the results of that recklessly well-intentioned pronunciamento were on display for all the world to see last week.

The US military, far more able to shield unhappy realities from its Citizen public under the guise of ‘national security’ and nowadays the stunningly cynical pieties of ‘supporting the troops’, has not yet found itself under what for UK police honchos and honchettes must be the nightmare-inducing torture of Klieg lights as their and their government’s gross errors and illusions rampaged through the streets of the national capital and other major cities for all the world to see.

Indeed, in 2002, as the article goes on to note, the UK Association of Chief Police Officers went the government one better and issued a ‘hate crimes’ manual that incorporated all the most outré frakkery of contemporary ‘postmodernist’ legal and political theory: ‘strict impartiality” was an illusion because every (Western, dominating, oppressor) police force was utterly and immutably incapable of being “colour-blind”, and the Chiefs derisively described impartial policing as “policing that purports to treat everyone in the same way [which] is flawed and unjust because it fails to take account of the fact that different people have different reactions and different needs … [and that] failure to recognize these means failure to deliver services appropriate to needs”.  

One would think that the job of the police is to enforce the national laws among the national Citizenry and those others who are present on the national soil. Meeting needs is not what the police are for, one would think, except for meeting the Citizenry’s need for the police to enforce the laws fairly and impartially (albeit with a hefty dollop of savoir-faire and competence).

And if this or that group claims to have a “need” to break those laws, well then it’s time for that group and the national authority to sit down and have a serious talk about brass tacks and turkey and such. And if this or that group claims to have a “right” to break those laws, well then … something is going to have to really really be faced up to, along the lines of parting-of-the-ways and Godspeed and that sort of thing.

In the article’s pithy phrase, “impartial justice was now unjust” – under the seal of the nation’s Chief police officers. This is Multiculturalism 101 in any specially-erected academic ‘-Studies’ department in the Western world, and that’s all it is.

Yet the UK police honchos and honchettes staked upon it their lives, fortunes, and their sacred honor (to borrow a timeless phrase). Oh, and the professional competence of the organizations and of the human beings under their command who had sworn an oath to justly enforce the laws, and trusted their commanders to maintain at least a working modicum of integrity, intelligence, common sense, and professional maturity.  

But c’est la guerre, it seems. Tut-tut and lah-dee-dah. One wants to get the medals for being au courant with the latest cutting edge ‘progress’ and ‘reform’; they jingle with such muted fineness at A-list dinner parties, twinkling back at the polished silver under the crystal light of the chandelier to provide a veritable visual symphony of professional success. Yah.

And, in a further paragraph that would be ominously familiar to any modern police or military officer in the UK or the US, the manual went on to observe that many boots-on-the-ground were not really in agreement with these new Insights – and that they would have to be “re-trained” and, if necessary, “disciplined”.

Ach. Ja. Yah.

You can thus imagine that UK police officers of all ranks were now in the position of race-horses who had been incredibly mis-trained and required not to run the race (let alone to win it), but rather to keep looking down to see if their legs were going up and coming down in the Correct sequence (reports in support and substantiation thereof to be filed within x-hours after each race). Good blessed frakking grief.

But as always in this sort of thing, the Chiefs slyly seek to grab the high ground: “There is no place in the police service for those who will not “uphold and protect the human rights of others”. Among which rights are apparently not the right to have your tax monies go to providing a police force that will enforce the laws impartially.

In Mary McCarthy’s acute phrasing: this manual should not be put aside lightly … it should be hurled against the nearest wall with great force.

Future historians will wonder how any advanced society’s government could embrace such self-destructive whackulence, and will probably conclude that sometime on or about January 1, 1990 the polities of the UK and the US became for all practical purposes historical mastodons: overlarge, unable to coordinate themselves even in the most essential tasks of competently maintaining themselves, and already past the fork in the road that led to the Land of the Has-Been. Joining, just a bit belatedly, their former Soviet adversary. Perhaps We are indeed approaching the end of history, as one popular conceit has it – or at least a certain version of history. (That clicking sound you should be hearing is you fastening your seat-belt.)







In a curious symmetry, the national governments of the US and the UK seem to have lost any self-respect for themselves and their polities just as the rioters seem to have lost (if they ever had it to begin with) any self-respect for themselves as Citizens.

A complex and highly developed society and culture – in this case those of the US and the UK as embodying the remarkable wisdom of classic Western civilization – is a living organism and somewhat fragile; if there is a vital need for ‘sensitivity’ in all this, it is first and foremost a sensitivity toward the need to nurture, sustain, and – yes - improve this amazing human achievement, Western civilization, in a way both desirable and workable. Great civilizations and their wisdom don’t grow on trees; and as experienced sea-going sailors say of their vessels: be nice to her, she’s our only ride home.
Continuing its sequential broadside, the article asserts (rightly, I would say) that “In this kind of atmosphere it is not surprising that officers in charge of a riot think it safer to wait for orders from the top rather than use their discretion to protect the public without fear or favour”.

Because the deployment of the street police officers’ authority has been so thoroughly and frakkulently undermined by both unripe academic Theory and politicized, ever-shifting definitions that mutate and shape-shift according to ever-changing political winds and whims (courtesy of invertebrate senior police commanders who have gotten their silver-encrusted rank doodads and tastefully tinkling medals by doing precisely the same thing).  

While I hold no brief for the late Lt. Col. Custer’s stunningly inept handling of his operations at the Little Big Horn, yet the man positively shines in comparison with the performance of the senior UK police commanders.  And in his earlier and happier days as a Civil War cavalry commander he at least had enough of the right stuff to insist that his command “ride toward the sound of the guns”: if you’re in uniform and the guns of battle are firing ‘over there’, then that’s most likely where you should be going yourself, and with some determined intention of making a useful difference upon arrival.

Thus endeth the Lesson.

NOTES

*Now, and again, and always again, I point out how this entire syndrome can also affect a nation’s military, as it has most surely in the US.

** And continuing the thought contained in the Note immediately above, the same goes for the military: its job – awesomely difficult enough – is to efficiently defend the national interest through the application of armed force and lethal combat operations. This is tough enough as it is (despite all the hoopla of push-button warfare and superman combat suits of clothing and gear) without trying to impose the highly-dubious theory of ‘diversity representation’ (especially in gender and competence) which carries with it the astoundingly horrific assumption that ‘equality’ (or rather: some organized interests’ definition of it) trumps combat efficiency … and the connection of that treacherous presumption to Our current, sempiternally ongoing military misadventures is a Story yet to be told.

***Continuing if I may to repeat myself, this flatulently and lethally fatuous dampdream, under the mindless Orwellian rubric of ‘diversity’, was whole-heartedly endorsed in this country by the invertebrate leaders of all the armed services in the 1990s (truly an awful decade in the history – such as it may remain – of Western civilization).


ADDENDUM

There’s probably even darker wheels within wheels here. Imagine a police officer who in the normal course of a week’s work, let’s say, might encounter 5 assaults/robberies or serious thefts. Arrests are made; in four of the five cases the accused are not-white; the officer, let’s say, is white.

Under the Correct rules, the simple fact that the ‘effects’ of the arrests are that they indicate a disproportion in terms of ‘race’ and so are ‘racist’. They may be ‘unwittingly racist’ rather than deliberately racist (i.e. the officer purposely only goes after and arrests black perpetrators) but that is no longer the main point of the exercise.

Rather, because of the mere calculation of the percentages, the matter can be primarily viewed through the lens of ‘racism’, and all of the consequent and scripted steps of a ‘racism’ instance can be set in train.

But this then gets an awful lot of powers-that-be off the hook. The government (politicians and bureaucrats) that has for decades imposed policies that have resulted in the weakening of the Family, of the authority and status of the parents and of adults, the conceptual assault on fatherhood and masculinity as well as adulthood … that government and all of its Correct minions, demographics, and Identities is now off the hook.

After all, this pattern of arrests is merely an outrageous example of the racism inherent in oppressive Western society and so on and so forth. And that is precisely the type of thing that the government had set itself to eradicate with its imposition of the radical Multiculturally-inspired policies, laws and regulations to begin with.

In this way, the whole show rolls on even though it results in the creation of an ideological fog that blankets its actual dynamics in the distracting and occluding miasm of a false cause.

Yes, there’s the theory that poverty (a poverty arbitrarily imposed by the economic arrangements of society) causes their violence and crime; but then why don’t all person who are poor commit crimes? There must be other factors.

And this is precisely where governments indentured to Correctness (the US and the UK most deeply) don’t want you to go. Southern blacks in the era of Jim Crow didn’t commit real crime (although they were abhorrently pursued for all manner of things by the police of that time and place).

And that’s where the question arises: to what extent does a secular, anti-Family, anti-Father, anti-male society – with character and virtue and decency and any solid grounding in an anthropology that supports constructive and purposeful maturity all ‘deconstructed’ or ‘de-valorized’ – contribute causally to the lives of violence and anomie now evident in what has become a genuine ‘underclass’ morally even more than economically?



Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

SAM TANENHAUS AND IDENTITY POLITICS

Things continue to get interestinger and interestinger.

No less a mainstream and Correct venue than ‘The New York Times’ has now published an article entitled “Identity Politics Leans Right”.

Well, my first fear was that this would be an attempt to run the now-typical progressive-formerly-liberal play: it was goooood when we did it, but the ‘conservatives’ are baaaaaad when they do it.

But no. They’re actually letting the writer, Sam Tanenhaus, do something more mature with it.*

His concern is that the Right is actually trying to take advantage of the weakening hold of Political Correctness and Identity Politics (the monsters summoned forth by those sorcerer’s apprentices now known as the progressives-formerly-liberals forty Biblical years ago).

I agree with him that such a move is a distinct possibility. And I more than agree with him that this would be a bad (but hardly surprising) development.

I don’t quite get there by the same route, so let me say this about that.

Prompting his thoughts is a recent move by the Texas Board of Education to tweak the History curriculum in that Great State’s elementary school system: the Board wants to make the curriculum more ‘conservative’.

The Board’s definition of ‘conservative’ – as always – is the key here. And that definition is revealed in the Board’s wish to teach students about their right to bear arms and “an individual’s protection of private property from government takings”. (Nor am I great fan of ‘government’ as that life-form has engorged over the past 40 Biblical years.)

In other words, the Board is simply trying to throw its own mud, now that the ‘other side’ has started to run out of mud or at least has started to lose the ability to get its own mud recognized as the pure revolutionary truth. Which reflects more than anything else the frakkulously unhappy fact that the Right was sucked into the Left’s mud-pie game in the 1980s and in doing so left Us with no Party speaking for civic maturity and seriousness in a mature and serious way.

And of course, the religious nature of the Founders is going to be included in the Board’s vision; the Founders were ‘Christian’. Which isn’t and is true.

They were interested in 1787 in setting up the machinery of a government that would be able to withstand the irrational and corrosive whims and schemes that affect all humans and every human endeavor. They were interested in creating a democratic process that would prevent the type of self-serving corruptions of government power that so often in history had not only resulted after the passage of time, but had also led to monstrously bloody and violent revolutionary agitations (in 1787 the French nation was on the cusp of precisely such a bloodbath).

And they were precisely not interested in ‘religion’, in several ways.

First, they did not want the government getting itself mixed up in ‘religious’ matters, since it would only entangle the government in the type of religious rockfights (and wars) that had for centuries rocked Europe.

Second, they did not want the government power to get drawn so intimately into the national life, and into the lives of its Citizens. The Founders had a very clear and limited vision of what role ‘government’ would play in ‘America’: government would be a smallish preserve, playing a vital but not directive or capital role in the nation’s and the People’s life. The limits on the government – the expectations placed upon it and the authority it possessed – would create a fenced-in zone, beyond which was a wide and deep field wherein the activities of the Citizens – mercantile, personal, communal, familial, spiritual and religious – would constitute the genuine and most essential ‘life’ of the nation and the Citizenry.

Third, they did not want government to interfere with religion. Human beings, in the Enlightenment vision, were endowed with the power of reason (indeed, the Enlightenment often saw Reason as some sort of independent force working in human affairs; sort of a ‘God’ without all the churchy accretions); Americans were capable of rationality and had the right to make their own decisions as to religious adherence.

Fourth, the government had no authority to go mucking around in anybody’s soul or mind. This newly forged America wasn’t going to be the Tsar’s Russia or any other monarchical replicant where the government would inherit the Absolute Authority of the Throne, whose Monarch simply took over the power and authority formerly ascribed to the Pope or simply exercised God’s authority as God’s Anointed Deputy.

(You can see how much the country slid backwards in the past 10 years, into the queasy absolutist slime from which the Founders had lifted it.)

But the Founders were also not anti-religious. Indeed, they lived at a time when the afterglow of late medieval Christendom and the Protestant Reformation still warmed and lit the lives and minds and souls of the Citizenry: no matter how much or how little or just how one was ‘churched’ in the young American nation, there was still a wide consensus that there was a God, and/or that one should be a ‘decent’ person. And that ‘decency’ was much defined by the old virtues, theological and practical.

And indeed, the consensus extended to the belief and the ideal that human beings were possessed of a soul, and created by a God (however defined) Whose plan gave humans purpose and meaning, and Whose help assisted them as they made their way through the soul-wracking complexities of this world.

That afterglow was something that the Founders could not only presume, but that they actually needed in their vision. Because if the government machinery they were carefully assembling (in its several Branches – Legislative, Executive, Judicial) was going to be the servant (indeed the employee) of The People, then that People had to retain such sense of confidence in their own meaning that they could sustain not only their own lives but also the government, acting as the ultimate human judge of its actions.

And, for that matter, the Founders assumed that any elected officials of that government would also be governed by their own sense of ‘virtue’ and ‘character’ as well as their sense of responsibility to The People and – as well – to the Ultimate Judge of human affairs and souls.

ALL of that was included in the Framers’ vision of the American polity, and it was only upon that dense and robust foundation that the actual government machinery was formally set up through the Constitutional instrument itself.

Today’s meaningless Rightist blather about the Framers being ‘Christian’ is a useless conversation. That word ‘Christian’ as used nowadays defines out to be the specifically fundamentalist sense of the word, and Fundamentalism is a movement that didn’t gain traction in America until a full century after the Founding. Arguing about it is equivalent to arguing that a particular Founder was a Cadillac or a Mercedes man.

Such ‘fundamentalism’ – with its (soooo highly-selective) ‘literal interpretation’ of the Bible – didn’t exist in the late 18th century, except as an un-esteemed bunch on the fringes of the Protestant fold.

Nor do I disagree with Tanenhaus when he says that “this controversy is the latest version of a debate that reaches back many decades and is perhaps essential to the heterogeneous democracy whose identity has long been in flux”.

But I am suddenly verrrry alert to where that thought might be taken.

His use of “decades” indicates to me that he is well aware of what the past four Biblical decades have wrought. And so, as with Neal Gabler in two very recent Posts, I am wary that Tanenhaus is going to try to soft-sell those forty frakkulent years as just another well-intentioned and mostly Gooooood effort to add some ‘richness’ to America’s self-concept and sense of identity.

Which lets the Beltway, the Dems, the progressive-formerly-liberals and the wild-minded revolutionistas of Identity Politics off the verrrrry big hook upon which they have willfully skewered themselves. And Us.

He starts in down that road, purring about how it occurred to decent folks that “in the 1960s and ‘70s, the concept of a single ‘race of men’ looked outmoded”. He continues: “Didn’t ‘race’ mean ‘white race’? and didn’t ‘men’ exclude women?”

I duly acknowledge that in this paragraph he also refers to the Sixties and Seventies as “convulsions”. Which, however, reminds me of Gabler’s “shocks” – as if they were merely well-intentioned jolts administered like an ER doc with the defibrillator ‘paddles’ to bring life back to a dying patient.

When of course they actually constituted – and were intended to constitute – a sustained, conceptually violent ‘deconstruction’ of not only the current concept of American ‘identity’ but of the possibility of any efficacious American identity at all (Multiculturalism) and of any possibility of any common American identity that transcended this or that difference or inequality, real or imagined (Identity Politics).

Yes, America’s ‘identity’ has always been in flux. Waves of immigrants brought their own particular contributions to it, even as they worked to assimilate themselves into the overall American commonality of belief and tradition.

BUT no wave of immigrants ever came over here intending to sustain a do-or-die assault on American identity itself, a ‘deconstruction’ (not so much a ‘re-construction’) of American identity. Except, come to think of it, the Anarchists who came over here as individuals committed to spreading European excitements of violently overthrowing established authority (they too didn’t have any replacement or reconstruction in mind; they figured that once freed from ‘authority’ then folks would do nicely enough on their own – which sounds queasily familiar, doesn’t it?).**

AND no wave of immigrants every arrived here to face an American culture and polity that had been so confoundingly weakened by 40 years' worth of sustained attack, aided and abetted by its own government.

AND no wave of immigrants ever arrived here to be told that what they precisely must not do is to assimilate to the local American culture. Since, the justification would be given, American culture was not worth their adherence anyway.

So, no, I can’t go along with the ‘moderate’ can’t-we-all-just-forget-it-and-move-on sort of revisionist history-making that is currently the rage among the suddenly-nervous Correct elites. Frankly, I think a little South American or South African or Central-European-after-the-Communists ‘reconciliation’ needs to be carried out here. And that would – I think – require something along the lines of a Truth Commission. Or at least, following the ancient Chinese wisdom, a Rectification of Names.

Because what We have been through in the past 40 Biblical years has not been a slightly bumptious, well-intentioned, liberating re-adjustment and expansion of American identity. It has been a hydra-headed (MIRV-ed, to use the old Cold War term) revolutionary assault on democratic deliberative process as well as – see above – on the very fundaments and existential possibility of any American identity at all.

AND such whackery did not ‘succeed’ on the strength of its own conceptual worth, but rather because it was espoused by the Democrats (and then later the Republicans in their way) and became in effect a government-sustained revolution. A government-sustained revolution against its own national ethos and Constitutional vision.

Oh, and against a rather sizable chunk of its own People.

Surely, somewhere along the line, this shaded into what the Framers would term “treachery”.***

A little too cutely, Tanenhaus tries to cover that base by admitting freely about these “changes” that “some were narrowing and erroneous” – he specifically mentions the black CCNY professor Leonard Jeffries’ 1980s black-studies illuminations about white European “ice people” and African “sun people” … for which higher education-level wisdom individuals or the taxpayers paid hefty tuition fees.

But he quickly tacks back: “Many of the changes were liberating”. Well, some were. To some. But the price of imposing such changes by doing an end-run around wide and deliberate consensus-building has been verrrry high – perhaps more, it may turn out, than We could afford.

He quotes “conservatives” who worried and warned at the time “that attacks on the ‘Eurocentric curriculum’ … were giving rise to ‘the notion that history and literature should be taught not as disciplines but as therapies whose function is to raise minority self-esteem’”.

Well now. So much of American activity has become ‘therapy’ since then.

And rather than ‘achievement’ it is ‘self-esteem’ that has become the pole-star of the awesome task of forming youth for the tasks of achieving maturity and sustaining an adult life and an efficacious communal and civic competence. I recall the line from a recent cartoon: ‘This isn’t a San Francisco youth league – we keep score!”. Which is a plaint for – if I may say – a ‘reality-based’ life as opposed to a ‘consolatory fantasy-based’ life.

Surely, the evidence of such fantasy-based, self-serving consolations has done nothing to improve the achievements of the Service academies. The Navy has relieved almost 20 commanding officers – many of them Academy graduates – in the past months; several hugely expensive vessels have been wrecked through accident or incompetence, including a nuclear missile cruiser and a submarine, both new. One lantern-jawed, butch-cut commanding officer called one of her subordinate officers an “idiot” in front of his enlisted subordinates and on the bridge underway she said to another officer “This is why I hate you!”; at a Royal Navy officer temporarily assigned to her command she threw a coffee cup (ceramic, not paper).

And in the matter of this 'consolatory-fantasy' gambit: things have gotten mightily and dangerously confused in the past 40 Biblical years. You recall that 'framing' has been one of the key insight in the feministical 'deconstruction' of any 'reality' that might stand in the way of their assorted excitements, emancipations, and liberating revolutions. There is no 'reality' out there - and certainly no Reality existing in some other, higher dimension.

No, there is only the outcome of however you choose to 'frame' things that might strike you as connected. So you hold your head however you choose to, see what you see by doing it, and that - for you - is 'reality'.

There is certianly an element of truth to this approach: humans never experience anything directly; like a Starship in space, everything that the captain 'sees' is mediated by the ship's sensor array, which then filters whatever feedback it gets from its scans of space and creates a picture on the view-screen on the bridge (did you think the Enterprise's viewscreen was just a windshield?). So in that sense, humans 'see' patterns that may not really be out there. OR - it has to be added - they may not see patterns that may indeed be out there.

What the feministicals did was to take this hardly-original philosophical insight and erect it into a Law of Perception: humans can never directly and fully grasp what's really 'out there'.

But then they went further and created a (falsely-derived) Law of Being: therefore there is no 'reality' out there and everything is all in your mind. (And therefore whatever the Dems wanted to 'change' in the rotten, patriarchy-filled, racist American culture couldn't be argued about since there is no 'reality' anyway on which anyone could base an objection. Neat. But frakkulously wrong.)

So, continuing to trace out the Great Mistake (or Treachery) of 'deconstruction': you don't have any 'reality' out there; all you have is your 'frame'. And you must be educated into the Correct 'framing' before your input in democratic political process is worthy of notice or even Constitutional respect. Ach!

But then human nature's stubborn reality kicks in: humans are always susceptible to the temptation to take a short-cut: if reality is too painful, the mind draws upon its powers of imagination to fabricate a fantasy that will make you feel 'better' - a consolatory fantasy. So, for example: Although I have jumped off the Empire State Building I really am flying and I will indeed start to pull up before I hit the street ... if you do that you feel a whole lot better.

But of course, as your mind accurately perceives 'reality' and realizes that you are now within 10 stories of hitting the pavement, it will send increasing alarms that will stimulate unpleasant emotions designed to get you to do something to fix this problem. So your consolatory-fantasy will have to kick into overdrive to blot out the alarm signals from your mind and emotions.

One of the skills, therefore, currently required in American politics is to be able to distinguish between a 'frame' and a 'consolatory fantasy'.

And to realize - despite whatever feministical 'theory' and 'deconstruction' insist through the mouths of Beltway and academic elite-bots - that A) there is indeed a 'reality', B) it is 'out there' for sure, and C) it may even be a Reality.

And that even if humans cannot know this r/Reality totally and completely, they damned well better be able to accurately figure out a little bit about it, or else they are going to go through life - to use a Sean Connery phrase from that 1990s Eliot Ness movie - having "brought a knife to a gunfight".****

So much for the ‘liberation of Me’ as a substitute for maturity, competence, and achievement. So much for the maturity of the Totally Free Self.

And of course, the crapulent invasion of a sovereign foreign nation was effected through the lubricating excuse of ‘therapy’ for the American people after the shock of 9-11. (Nor do I hold the late Mr. Hussein in any esteem whatsoever.)

And that same invasion – and several subsequent military misadventures – was undertaken merely upon the justification of the ‘feelings’ of the Beltway elites – with no serious deliberation or careful calculation or even the asking of that prime professional strategic question: And what then?

The foreign policy elites – like their domestic policy elites – “would be greeted as liberators”.

Which brings me back to Tanenhaus.

It’s not enough to gush about the good-intentions and desires for ‘liberation’ and ‘empowerment’. The actual results and the consequences (intended or unintended) have to be looked at clearly and carefully. And should have been from the get-go.

Tanenhaus notes that the Texas gambit may simply represent “the conservative variant of identity politics and this could invite a similar backlash”.

Well, as I’ve said before, “backlash” is just a little too simple, and shades into the simplistic. It should have been clear 40 years ago that so wide and sustained and profound a series of ‘changes’ should be passed through the purifying fire of wide and acute public deliberation.

And that would be even more essential since those ‘changes’ or ‘shocks’ or whatever you choose to call them constituted profound assaults on some of the most fundamental American beliefs and practices and even the sources of national and individual meaning and purpose.

And that these assaults would be successful precisely because they would be imposed by the government rather than achieved through the democratic processes of wide and acute deliberation.

If ANY progressive-formerly-liberal wants to say that nobody at the time (or during those 40 Biblical years) realized just how important a wide and deep programme of public debate, deliberation, and consensus-building would be … well, such an admission is a self-indictment on its face.

And if, in the alternative, any progressive-formerly-liberal wants to say that Yes, at some point that all became clear but by then they were in too deep … well, such an admission is a self-indictment on its face.

And “treachery” seems not so outré an option to describe things.

Tanenhaus nicely quotes Richard Hofstadter, whose 1948 “The American Political Tradition” opined that the tendency to “national nostalgia” constituted “an effort not to understand the past but to evade the present”.

Yes and no.

Yes, with groups as with individuals, a sentimental but uncritical search for ‘the past’ often indicates immaturity rather than maturity. And that maturity reveals itself in a comprehensive and sustained effort to engage the challenges of the present. (The Buddhist wisdom puts it very nicely: the prime goal of a person is to be a full Self in an accurately perceived Present. And both Self and Present are densely defined and capacious terms as used here.)

But no, not all concern for ‘the past’ is escapist. There is, after all, Tradition and Heritage: the never-ending effort to further refine one’s integrity as shaped by the ideals of one’s individual and communal Tradition and Heritage. These were all terms that were jettisoned – along with the dimensions of Reality to which they were portals – by the ‘deconstruction’ demanded by certain Identities that required total autonomy, free of any external commitments, in order to fashion the Totally Free Self (as lethal and frakkulent a fantasy as any era in any part of the world has ever erected).

And the government played along.

Nowadays, of course, ‘history’ is nothing more than what any particular group or interest wants it to be; to say that an assertion is right or wrong, wise or foolish, is to be ‘insensitive’ and ‘intolerant’. To say that an assertion is unsupported by any evidence is to be ‘rationalistic’. To say that an assertion holds many secondary but undesirable consequences is to be ‘un-hopeful’ and demonstrates that ‘you just don’t get it’.

For these reasons, Tanenhaus is on the mark when he acknowledges that the very existence of the Texas gambit “suggests that after so many bitter years of polarization, Americans stand on the brink of a collective identity crisis and no longer share a common set of ideas about the true character of the country and the true meaning of democracy”.

But he is being disingenuous by noting it as if by inadvertence. What influences started all those bitter years of polarization? What influences believed with the revolutionary zeal of convinced cadres that no American identity was possible or even desirable? What influences insisted that ‘truth’ and ‘character’ were “quaint” terms? What influences asserted that the Constitution itself was hopelessly tainted by its (pick one or all: white, male, patriarchal, corporatist, elitist) origins and was at best “quaint” and at worst bereft of any call upon Americans’ adherence?*****

It’s not only the America of industrial primacy that’s irretrievably gone now. It’s not only the America of economic primacy with all that gold in Fort Knox solidly backing up the currency. It’s not only the America with all those resources that made it able to sustain itself and feed and supply most of the world.

It’s the America that actually sensed itself a People with a Purpose.******

The universal solvent of ‘deconstruction’, joined to Identity Politics and its sibling Multiculturalism, has eaten so much away.

If you want to give yourself a serious workout, imagine that perhaps We are now each and all corpses shackled to a corpse. Individuals bereft of Place, Purpose, and Meaning, shackled together and to a government that has itself burst free from any shape, amorphously but omnivorously oozing out over the entire field of American life. We are no longer what We were meant to be, and neither is the government.

Is that enough of a rendezvous with destiny for ya?

NOTES

*He’s actually the Editor of ‘The New York Times Book Review’ and of the paper’s ‘Week in Review’ section (where the article is published). But it still had to get a green light from the higher ups, such as they are.

**Imagine if after that Anarchist blew up his waggon in front of the Wall Street Stock Exchange in 1920 (and then escaped back to his native Italy), the President had decided to consider all the world's Anarchists as 'terrorists' and to declare that since they were 'at war' with the United States, then the US was going to send its military to invade ... and put together a little list. And don't forget: not long after that, FDR was almost killed - and the Mayor of Chicago sitting next to him was - when Anton Czermak (another Southeast European, as they would have said back then) tried to shoot him.

***The noted commentator Leon Wieseltier, a senior Editor at ‘The New Republic’ magazine, shares his thoughts about Washington and the Beltway in the March 2th issue (p.40): “These are shabby days in the capital … for there are no heroes here now … there is almost no courage in the political class right now … everybody is transfixed only by their numbers … the instinct for self-preservation has routed all the finer instincts … there is no longer any dignity in in loss; if you lose a fight for a just cause; if you lose a fight you are merely a loser …”

****I offer this mental exercise to you: How much 'deconstruction' and its pooh-poohing of reality and Reality, and any working competence in dealing with them, has indeed hugely corroded and weakened Our individual and communal and national capacity to deal with important matters facing Us. And not only in matters of 'culture' and domestic politics and domestic policy ... consider that to cap off 30 years of the Left's 'deconstruction's' pooh-poohing of reality and Reality and consequences, the jingo Right (by then merged with the 'deconstruction-liberation' Left into 'the Beltway') went and invaded Iraq. They indeed did bring a 'gun' - most of the Army's available field force, much of the National Guard, and an even larger number of hired mercenaries from Blackwater and such - but they brought the gun to what turned out a totally different type of 'fight'. Seven years later - and with several spin-off 'wars' now raging - you can see what fools 'deconstruction' has made of Us in the eyes of the world; lethal and dangerous fools.

*****Recall Raymond Aron’s excellent conceptualization “democratic conservatism”, which he opposed both to revolutionary-utopian romanticism (from the Left) and to reactionary nostalgia and sentimentalism (from the Right). He realized in the late Sixties that he was starting to see what Tocqueville had called “literary politics” – the tendency of academics and others not responsible for effecting and sustaining actual and workable outcomes to judge societies by utopian standards (which, by their very definition, find all things wanting).

It was this garden-variety lunacy (sleazy when erected into a cottage-industry to effect and sustain professional advancement and popularity) which the vote-desperate Dems deputized as National Policy in the late ‘60s and early ‘70s, gleefully joining the Boomers (in both their feckless Flower Child and arrogant Radical Cadre variants) in conceptually sweeping off the board everything that had gone before (which, nicely, included the Dems’ frakkulous expansion of the Vietnam fiasco that by 1969 Nixon had committed the Republicans to continuing on the pretext of ‘national honor’).

******And to repeat what I’ve said in prior Posts here, I would define that purpose in Lincoln’s words in his Second Inaugural: “to achieve a just and a lasting peace, among ourselves and with all nations”.

ADDENDUM

Let me toss this at you. We have seen ‘humanitarian intervention’ frakkulously expand since the Clintons’ Administration, from the Left, in the name of Rescue. We have seen that expand to blend with some concept of ‘self defense’ in the Iraq War and the further ‘wars’ that it has spawned.

Now We are seeing ‘empowerment’ and ‘liberation’ of ‘women’, of entire peoples from patriarchy and oppressive traditions, folkways and – face it – from an entire culture, with all its heritage and traditions. (Nor am I here implying that all the folkways, cultures, heritages and traditions of all the peoples and sovereign nations of the world are all Goooooood.) See my Post here.

Is it at all inconceivable that as the Beltway further panders to the advocates of Big Pain and ‘empowerment’ and ‘liberation’ by trying to export the entire agenda overseas … that as this starts to speed up, then rather significant chunks of those other nations and peoples are going to resist having themselves ‘deconstructed’?

After all, even if they do ‘oppress’ – and given the elasticity of that term, which is about as much a play-clay term as ‘sex offender’ is over here nowadays – they will be sharp enough to realize (as the French did half a century and more ago) that to start playing with the Universal Corrosive of ‘deconstruction’ is to guarantee their entire cultural corrosion, a fundamental undermining of the entire Heritage, Tradition, and the fundaments - however imperfect - of such civilization as they and their ancestors have managed to achieve.

And if 'reconstruction' of such profoundly core structures is something to be undertaken only with the greatest care and prudence, the 'deconstruction' of them can only be infinitely more so. Especially since the results observable in America have been - to be more polite than those foreigners would be in their assessment - decidedly mixed if not worse.

And what will We do then? Send the Marines (or their super-drones and ‘bots) to ‘liberate’ and ‘empower’? Dead, white European males realized long ago that humans don’t like ‘armed missionaries’ – and I doubt that the fact that the US military version will come under the auspices of the secular illuminations of feministical dampdreams rather than bearing the Cross is going to make much difference to the ‘locals’.

They – to borrow the thought of Flannery O’Connor – can still tell a freakish danger when they see it. And they will resist. By whatever means necessary - to borrow the ominous phrase so favored by the Israeli State.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

"WHAT PRICE LIBERTY? HOW FREEDOM WAS WON AND IS BEING LOST"

Ordinary problems - extraordinary government

The Brits are noticing a problem: apparently they are expecting the government to "solve the problems of ordinary people".

Worse, the government seems happy to try and oblige. (I’m not going to say that the government is happy to oblige because that would imply that it has succeeded, is succeeding, will succeed, and ever can succeed at such a project.)

The implications for democracy in the UK – that “Englande” that was the seat of so much Western wisdom about the structure of government and its relationship to the governed – are not at all good.

This can hardly be surprising: if the citizenry as individuals become increasingly incapable of handling their own problems, then they will become more dependent on the government. And then the government, as is the nature of the thing, will happily step in to run the lives of the increasingly incapable citizens, and the result will be a death-spiral of democracy into a paternalistic (or maternalistic*) Big Daddy/Big Mama government. At which point whether the thing has a ‘liberal’-Left valence of a ‘conservative’-Right valence will be mostly irrelevant; whether a Big Parent or a Big Stick government will be a problem worked out in the smoking wreckage, sort of like the old Cold War ‘if there are now two of Us left standing, and only one Commie, then have We won?’ question … by that point there will be more pressing questions requiring immediate attention.

All of which is – as I have always said – relevant to Us over here.

The Brits of course don’t actually have a Constitution – so they have to rely on ‘traditions’. Which is an iffy thing, when you consider the ‘youth’ of most folks – and I don’t so much mean chronologically as I do mentally: generations over decades have lost the ability or the desire to really master their frontal-lobe, prefrontal cortex capabilities, settling for a far more (take your pick) mammalian, bovine, sheep-like, or even reptilian existence), responding primitively to primal stimuli or to stimuli packed to appeal to primality – and to trigger it. Oy.

Worse, they seem to imagine – which is and has always been recognized as a profound danger for humans trying to preserve a democratic politics – that the Big Things that hold up and shield their world are static, un-dynamic, unchanging because incapable of change and – sooooo much a child’s view of things – because they just don’t want the Big Things to change.

But as with all life, any concatenation of matter and energy – of elements and forces – is dynamic because matter and energy** are themselves in their very essence dynamic.
So Big Things are actually not so much ‘things’ as ‘sustained reactions’. And as any chef with something on the stove or research scientist or nuclear-reactor crew can tell you: a ‘reaction’ is something you need to keep an eye on and know how to manage.

So is History, then.

Most folks – in a child-y sort of way – seem to think that what ‘is’ has always been there and always will be. Oy.

Now of course here in the USA (or increasingly, the USSA – United Secure States of America or United Safe States of America; take your pick) We most certainly do indeed have a Constitution.

But there are all sorts of developments over the past four decades that have functionally reduced its stability and authority.

For a moment, recall that in 1948 in the discussions leading up to the adoption of NSC-68, the National Security Council document that set the basic plan for the Cold War, the American government adopted the policy of “scaring the hell out of the American people” to keep them mobilized and willing in this new type of war-that-wasn’t-a-war.

And that game-plan would draw in the knowledge and techniques developed over a busy couple of decades by the late Propaganda Minister of Hitler’s Germany, Joseph Goebbels. He had the only proven game-book, and it was a proven performer.

And that that concept was adopted by Beltway advocacies in the early Seventies, after a quarter-century in government Cold War service. Where ‘fear’ was stoked as an indispensable phase in this and that campaign to achieve the goals of this and that agenda.

So the stage was set with a public used to being stoked by fear and a government used to stoking fear to ensure acceptance of its plans and policies.

First, ‘deconstruction’ – especially when taken out of overheated university classrooms and embraced for their own purposes by the political and activist ‘elites’ – pretty much says that Yes there is that old parchment thingy in the big display case in Washington, but it’s really ‘quaint’ because it was put together by Dead White Males who just didn’t get it and it’s oppressive, and anyway what those DWM’s thought it meant isn’t as important as what modern readers think (or feel) that it means that makes it ‘meaningful’ to them now. Oy.

Then the philosophy of John Rawls from 1971 who basically said that his philosophy was that ‘liberalism’ shouldn’t really have any ‘philosophy’ and that it should be a matter of everybody adopting Rawls’s point of view as if it were philosophy and then proceeding logically to do whatever they thought was most ‘sensitive’ and ‘just’ (although, as I said and he implied) there is no Justice. Nor, for that matter, Truth. Or – come to think of it – Reality. There’s only elite folks who ‘get it’ and what they can do with political power deployed by ‘elites’ in the service of making things better (although there is no Good by which you can measure success in these things; and to have an all-demanding and endless Cause which cannot be measured for either success or failure is pretty much a Beltway wetdream of the first order).

Then the legal assorted legal philosophies such as “substantive justice” and “expressive law”*** which give legal-theory justification to all the moosh that Rawls gave philososophical justification to.

Then the genuinely and truly unholy alliances between the presumably ‘liberal’ Left and the government police power, especially in the past 20 or so years; certain broad swaths of feminist advocacy have invited the police power into the very core of sexual interactions between citizens, and into the very hearths and bedrooms of the citizenry.

And in an even more unholy alliance with the law-and-order Rightists, have weakened traditional concepts of law in a well-intentioned but hugely-fraught effort against domestic violence and – in a stunning Constitutional contortion with breath-taking similarities to Fascist and Communist propaganda and jurispraxis – have created the omnicompetent and omnipresent ‘monster’ of the uncontrollable and irredeemable and sexually omnivorous ‘sex offender’ from whom the citizens must be ‘protected’ by – that charming Israeli concept – any means necessary.

But worse, there is the overall presumption of the helplessness of the citizenry implied in the very vision of what I will call Victimism: that the citizenry are essentially nothing but so many gazelles on the savannah, and only the government has the power to go after the predatory beings that hunt them. (Although, were it to be suggested that Wall Street and even the Beltway contain more potent and lethally efficient predators than any bush along any American highway or byway … )

And a society, culture, and citizenry now enamored of ‘youth’ and ‘youthfulness’ – although those phases of human life are precisely known for their incomplete development of the prefrontal cortex, which is the seat of the most uniquely human potentials.

And fixated on consumption – as if all there were to being American were being a ‘consumer’.

And now more than ever tempted lethally to avoid a reality that they cannot handle by distracting themselves with spectating, with busying themselves with endless electronic nothings, by hiding in a thousand different ways from the challenges requiring a Citizenry and the immediate attentions of The People.

And if Michael Lind’s idea is right, that since the end of American postwar economic world-primacy about 1970, that the Beltway – regardless of political stripe and ‘principle’ – quietly purchased continued American ‘hegemony’ by giving the nation’s industry (and jobs) away to foreign nations, in exchange for a continued world reliance on American military superiority and diplomatic stature.

That hasn’t worked out well recently, and may never recover from the ongoing events of the past decade.

And on top of all that, a Multicultural vision (and not just the nice classroom respect-for-other-points-of-view variety, but rather the mature version with the teeth and the tusks) that insists that there is no ‘American’ culture and that such a culture would not deserve to survive even if it did exist, and that the many official ‘Races’ recognized by the government must each keep its own culture, like a salad, not a melting-pot.

And to embody that Multicultural vision, on top of everything else, vast numbers of immigrants now in the country who have no working knowledge of (the elitely declared “quaint”) Constitutional ethos and are far too tenuously placed – legally, economically, or both – to pay much attention or risk standing up to be counted in the first place.

So, you can see where things might go under the weight of all of this.

As one writer puts it We are “cut off from the mentality in which liberty was won”. Precisely. And that includes as well the sense of how once something is ‘won’ you must then tend it (like a plant, or a kid) to ensure its proper development (in a postmodern, multicultural culture that claims that there is no such thing as ‘proper’ or that there are infinite sorts of ‘proper’ – which amounts to the same thing).

Worse, continues the writer, We “have little faith in the ability of our beliefs to protect us against the threats posed by the modern world”.

Well, of course, Our “beliefs” aren’t doing such a robust job any longer because Our elites not only don’t believe them any longer but actually and positively are committed to overturning them. And too many of the Citizens are increasingly incompetent – along the lines noted above – to sustain either those beliefs or the government that is supposed to operate according to the Constitution designed to embody and protect them.

And of course, it’s not so much a matter of ‘belief’ any longer, but merely one of ‘perception’ – which is the Constitutionally reprehensible philosophy of Goebbels and of propaganda with a capital “P”.

Worse, the citizenry as individuals are now so under-developed in their skills that they need all the help they can get – which help, from a government now rather seriously broken loose from its moorings, is coming at an awful price. Because if there is no longer a citizenry comprised of competent Citizens who can function together as The People, then there is no need for and no basis for a Constitutional Republic. Which is starting to dissolve away, not so much by an easily-recognized Man on a Horse, but rather as if being pecked to death by ducks. But perhaps, once a certain tipping point is passed, then the Man on the Horse – even in the form of Big Daddy or Big Mama, and probably in that form – will present him/herself … and be welcomed by the desperate ‘sheep’, ‘children’ who need their Shepherd and their Parent****.

After all, aren't We 'entitled' to Liberty?***** And if this alleged entitlement is being threatened, isn't that what government is supposed to do - make it all OK?


OY and OY GEVALT.

If We – in the Hebrew Scriptural vision – are the current generation of the guardians of the Ark of the Covenant (the Constitution) then We are failing most seriously in Our role in world and surely American history, and thus We are failing future generations, as well as failing billions of human beings now alive.

If, that is, We realize just what a remarkable Gift to humanity the Framers’ vision really was and is.

Which brings Us back to the beginning again.

Which is where the challenge facing Us really lies. And has all along.

NOTES

*As I am writing this, I notice that the spell-check on my major word-processing program easily allows ‘paternalistic’ but does not recognize ‘maternalistic’ – and that says a lot.

**And of course quantum physics essentially claims that ‘matter’ is simply ‘energy acting densely’, which makes things even more fluid, dynamic, changeable, and – oy – unstable.

***See my immediately preceding Post on the Matthew Shepard Act.

****I can’t help but recall Flannery O’Connor’s vivid character Hazel Motes, in her 1952 novel “Wise Blood”. Possessed of vitality and zeal, yet he is un-Shaped or under-Shaped, seeking to give vent to his abilities by seeking a “Christianity without Christ”. Which rapidly devolved into an ideology, a ‘pure’ Idea un-tempered by the humanizing presence of Christ. And worse, an ideology still driven by zeal, which in the absence of any Christ-like humanity with its respect for actual human individuals and the slow processes of human maturation, rapidly resorts to violence for the ‘good’ purpose of imposing such a ‘good’ thing on everybody, whether they like it or are ready for it or not.

Reinforcing her point, O’Connor adds the character of Enoch Emery, a less gifted adherent whose excitements lead him quickly to regress to the level of an ape, deprived of both prefrontal capability and any soul, but willing to deploy any strength he has in an unripe and un-Shaped violent laying-hands-on the world around him – with monstrous and bloody result.

The usual conceit quickly presumed by many readers was that such whacked-out frakkery was confined to those dark and bloody and crazy, God-addled backwoods fundamentalist types.
But I think that it’s time to imagine that such awful whackery can be effected by ‘elites’ as well; you can get this crazy on Chardonnay as well as on moonshine and rot-gut, on so-called revolutionary zeal as well as on Fundamentalist excitements.

For when you get right down to it, the revolutionist (and revolutionista) and the Fundy are truly “sisters under the skin”: they both think that they ‘get it’ and that everybody else “just doesn’t get it”, and that they are therefore empowered to do whatever it takes to make folks do the ‘right’ thing and the ‘good’ thing.

My thought is that ‘good’ and ‘right’ are Good and Right, and yet no matter how Good and how Right (and therefore desirable) a thing might be, it must be planted like a seed and tended with all respect to the human ground in which the plant must grow; not simply jammed into the ground like a fully-grown tree being suddenly implanted by a giant claw-and-carry machine, which is by its very nature a violent thing.

And looking around at the country and the world around Us now, ‘violence’ – physical or otherwise, and no matter how allegedly ‘justified’ – seems to be on an ominous rise.
There is much that is monstrous in Our world now. But the ‘monsters’ are not primarily of the horror-flik variety. They are the developing and regressing monstrosities into which humans devolve when cut loose from any genuine Ground and any genuine Shape.

They knew that in 1776 and 1787 and for a long time afterwards. We have forgotten it. And the History that We may well be dooming Ourselves (and the world) to repeat is dark indeed.

That is the fierce urgency of Now.

*****And let's not even get into the distinction between 'freedom' and 'liberty': freedom, I would say, is something that individuals possess - although it is primarily a task of mastering yourself so that a genuine 'freedom' results. Whereas 'liberty' is a political achievement, and one that requires ongoing care and guard to maintain - as Ben Franklin saw ("You have a democracy, if you can keep it").

Labels: , ,