Thursday, May 27, 2010

MARINE EXPEDITIONARY VEHICLE

The Marines have a problem.

Their Expeditionary Fighting Vehicle (EFV) is a 40-ton behemoth designed to transport 17 rufftuff Marines (which is a full rifle squad; and let’s not get into the gender thing here) from landing ship to shore. It has all sorts of great stuff like composite armor, a big German diesel engine that can power it at sea (25 knots) and land (30mph), more weaponry than the early-1970s vehicle it replaces, ethernet capability (presumably not for Facebook and Twitter) and – in order to offset some of the weight of all that stuff – is made of aluminum. It has a range of about 30 miles.

The Corps wants almost 600 of them at god-knows-what-cost each, although the program has already burned 13 billion dollars (which didn’t used to be much, but the party’s over and those days are gone).

The Marines want this thing because it will continue the tradition of their “signature” move: attack over the beaches from the sea.

Although it now appears that the increased range of missiles capable of destroying the things has now outpaced the 30 miles the thing can travel; so to avoid the missiles (at least while you’re launching these things) you’d have to be more than 30 miles offshore. But then the things wouldn’t be able to get to shore …. You see why generals and Pentagon staffers get paid the big bucks. And of course, once it did get within 30 miles, then the missiles launched by the putative defenders would become a concern.

Maybe those missile sites would be taken out by carrier-launched fighters, or by Air Force planes, or by drones.

But when these flat-bottomed babies hit the beach they won’t – it turns out – be sufficiently armored against road-side bombs (the infamous IEDs).

NO PRAHBLUM! Thus ejaculate the Pentagoons: we’ll add armor plating to the bottom and solve that. They hadn’t thought of the IED threat before?

But/and then: if you add several tons of armor (and to an aluminum hull) the thing isn’t going to be able to travel as far or as fast, on land or sea (at 40-plus tons nothing short of a nuke is going to get this thing into the air).

NO PRAHBLUM! The extra armor can simply be carried, and applied when the big babies have hit the beach. (Who’s going to carry the armor to the beach?) And you’re going to have mechanics available on a hostile beach to do such redecorating under fire? So your 17 riflepersons will be tied down defending the mechanics. Or else those 17 will be doing the redecorating themselves ( with even the females manhandling those heavy chunks of armor?)

You see how really not-so-simple the old blood-and-guts stuff really is. Anyone who gets their idea of war from movies … well, even if the uniforms and chatter are period-perfect, you see where there’s more to it than appearances.

I blame the Gulf War and Saddam.

He sat still like a total dork for all the months that it took the US to laboriously assemble the cash and supplies necessary to field a powerful field force (when a good general would have hit those forces while they were still trying to get set up and ensure a supply of AA and AAA batteries for all their stuff). And then, when everything was ready, he sat still and waited for the hit.

Which gave Americans the idea that they really did have – in the Year of Grace One Thousand Nineteen Hundred and Ninety One – a military qualitatively equivalent to the Wehrmacht in 1940. And worse: gave Americans the idea that ‘Americans always win’ because that’s just the way History is set up and that will never change.

(It also gave the feminists the chance to claim that since Americans will always win, and since the USSR is gone, then there won’t really be any fighting any more, the military will be nothing more than Microsoft with a tougher dress code, and that consequently there’s no reason why women shouldn’t be allowed such a ‘rich’ employment opportunity. Ach, those were ze happy times!)

More specifically, although little media attention was given to it, there was an amphibious force that set sail towards the end of 1990, and arrived in the actual waters of the Persian Gulf in mid-January 1991 after a leisurely passage. At just under 20 ships, it was the largest amphibious force the US (and the Navy-Marines) had sent forth since 1945.

Their mission was to create a ‘threat in being’ – posing Saddam with the possibility of an amphibious assault from the Gulf even as he faced the powerful land force that he had generously allowed over the course of months to put itself together on his other flank. This Gulf force never made a landing – although one of its ships did hit a mine while detached on a special assignment.

The Marine Corps now wants to beef up the credibility of its ‘threat’ with the EFV. No matter that it may have a few teething problems; the important thing is that ‘the enemy’ will be presented with a darned thorny defensive problem if they are ‘out there', ready to come ashore in these things, 17 guys (or gals) at a time.

It seems to me that the first and foremost strategic mistake the Pentagon has made is to assume that any enemy will react as Americans do to such Wonderland excitements: with a serious and straight face and much basso profondo hemming and hawing and that cheerible yet cocky assurance that America – whether in its Leftist or its Rightist dampdreams – makes History and the rest of the world simply stands by for its seating assignment on the gravy train. Ach, those were ze happy times!

With the exception of a tribal chief still in possession of blowguns and spears, situated on a choice piece of beach-front real estate, the prospect of a flotilla of these behemoths waddling ashore (or not quite, alas) isn’t going to seriously disturb the sleep of any modern potential enemy.

At best, the largest US amphibious ships can carry 1500 or so Marines – maybe 1800 – to be put ashore either by helicopters or the hugely techy Osprey aircraft (a disturbing tendency to fall out of the sky on their own and underarmored like their sea-going associate).

Of these 1800 only some will be combat troops (although, yes, every Marine qualifies with a rifle at boot camp – one way or another). There will be administrative types, medics, cooks, maintenance folk, supply types in several variants – and all this without factoring in whatever factors must now be made for the imponderables of … ummmm … gender.

So how many fighters are you actually going to get ashore, 17 at a time, in these monsters? How many of these beasts can the average amphibious ship carry? How big a force of amphibious ships will you need to carry a major assault force? How will you protect that force?

And if you have contracted out all the non-combat jobs to ‘civilian contractors’, then how do you get them where they need to be? And if they come later, after you have ‘secured the beach’, then you don’t have much time to do that ‘securing’ because you’re going to need all those civilians to do all the non-fighting stuff. So any delay – and such things do happen – and you have a big problem.

The whole World War Two approach probably went to everybody’s heads: even then, when the Japanese obligingly abandoned garrisons without hope of reinforcement or re-supply on ocean islands where the Americans had almost complete control of the sea and air … even then it took staggering casualties to ‘secure’ the islands.

And that was with troops who didn’t grow up in a victimist and entitlement and consumerist culture and with a country that didn’t expect war (or life) to be easy and fun. What happens nowadays?

Frankly, I think that if this country was ever faced with the old enemy-held-island scenario, the only thing anyone would stomach is to nuke it with a tactical thingie and congratulations all around for being so ‘efficient’ and ‘sensitive’ at the same time. Yah.

But there isn’t ever going to be such a scenario again. No natives, no enemy-held islands.

Hell, that was clear in March of ’65 when the Marines made their organizational debut in Vietnam from assault landing craft, even though the ‘beach’ was crammed with welcoming local lovelies carrying leis and a South Vietnamese Army brass band. No doubt the Corps wanted to remind the world and the taxpayers about the glory of twenty years before. But they were headed into ‘Vietnam’, and there came a time when no amount of happy-times remembering could change that.

There is a certain point where the laws of physics kick in: no matter how ‘optimistic’ and ‘can-do’ you are (or say you are) there is a moment when reality will reveal itself and say that you can’t move something this heavy over this much distance and at that much speed. You can cry, you can demonstrate, you can take it to court – but the laws of physics are what they are.

This is the type of reality that in Our modern American reality has been pooh-poohed as ‘essentialism’ and ‘backlash’ and such. If you just convince yourself, or if we all agree to agree, then whatever we have chosen to agree to will become the new ‘reality’. It’s democracy!

For the past 40 Biblical years, ‘laws’ that sort of let you know how the world is structured have gotten tossed out with the various ‘oppressive traditions’ that were masquerading as reality. We have gotten the idea that if you can hugely change the latter without consequence, then you can probably ignore the former the same way. After all, being American means never having to accept consequences. Left and Right both assumed that.

Well, the Pentagon seems to have drunk the same Kool-Aid as the cadres of the Left.

The same ‘traditions’ that allegedly kept the assorted Identities under some sort of oppression also apparently kept the government under some sort of control. Who knew?

And it’s Memorial Day weekend. Have you checked your local cemetery to see if the local vets’ Post missed a few graves with their flags? Maybe the WW1 and Spanish-American and Civil War graves that have no relatives or friends left? I did – and shelled out a C-note to get some extra flags; real remembering and real memorializing don’t come cheap.

But in doing so, and thanking each grave’s occupant for his service, I also remembered common sense and clear-thinking and the conduct of a life un-bolstered and un-befogged by Kool-Aid.

Make this a multi-level Memorial Day.

Or else we shall meanly lose what they who fought have thus far so nobly advanced.

Am I a Tea-Bag drinker rather than a Kool-Aid drinker? Not in the least. The first responsibility of the Citizen is to govern the government, not to get rid of it.

And for that duty you have to report with a clear head and a steady hand. And a mind and heart focused on the great unfinished work remaining before Us.

Labels: , ,

Monday, June 08, 2009

MILITARY SCHOOL

Over on Truthout an article reports the rise of “military-backed public schools” in the country. These are not military academies, as such, nor ‘boot camps’ as were popular a decade or so ago. These are public schools whose district superintendents have opened to the military itself.

As is characteristic of them, the Marines are vigorously involved in making this thing work.

Their efforts are reported in public school districts in suburban Atlanta, New Orleans, and Las Vegas. Georgia is no surprise; the Southrons have always had a soft spot for things military, and despite the rather decisive quashing of the Southron penchant for military Romanticism – especially as demonstrated in General Sherman’s tour through the State – it all reignited in the Reagan-era.

Reagan himself was busily and happily seeking to re-establish the American ebullience of his own youth, even as the national ethos and industrial infrastructure that grounded that optimism was slip-sliding away; ‘morning in America’ was not so much a well-justified national reinvigoration as it was a government-sponsored delusion to keep the citizenry smiling as America’s morning slid toward mid-afternoon.

Funny, but Reagan was a big believer in ‘stories’, just as the ideologists of the Left were claiming that nothing was ‘real’ and it was all about what ‘story’ you chose to tell yourself, either as an individual or as an Identity. Reagan got the entire country to tell itself a nice story to explain its present situation. Of course, telling yourself a ‘story’ – and We are indeed very much creatures who need Narrative to ground a sense of Meaning and Purpose – only really works if it not only makes you feel ‘good’ or ‘better’ but also actually corresponds to the success of the actions you take and to the situation unfolding around you. The classic mental-institution inmate wearing a Napoleon hat was indeed quite ‘happy’ – but that didn’t make the inmate Napoleon or change the fact that he was confined to an institution.

Ah, but that was thinking-too-much back in the day. And neither Reagan nor the revolutionaries of the Identity-Left wanted too much of that going on. Revolutions, famously, are not made by reasonable deliberations and critical thinking; nor, for that matter, by full frontal-lobe engagement. From their citizens governments and revolutions don’t want deliberation, they want support – or at least acquiescence. Anything beyond that is merely an obstruction.

So it’s hardly an unforeseeable consequence – unintended or actually sort of intended – that public schools began to de-emphasize reasoning, critical thinking, history, ‘abstract’ male thinking or any of the traditional stuff that used to be the job of education.

It’s not hard to see how public-school education began to go wonky in a big way.

Reagan’s approach also reflected deeper developments of his era. The Boomers had thrown away ‘structure’ and ‘establishment’ in the name of ‘luv’ and their vision of ‘freedom’. The ideological feminists built on that, but put French deconstructionist theory underneath it as a ‘philosophical’ foundation: anything that would serve to boundary, to ground, to structure, to shape … was deemed ‘oppressive’, and had to be done away with.

The general American approach to living life became much more ‘flexible’. This was supposed to make it more ‘liberated’, but it had the vast consequence of making the American way much more amorphous. You do what you want, what you think you’d like – that’s what being human is all about (as even the Supreme Court finally bleated outright in Casey).

Reagan thus found the military Way much more attractive. Not only because it played to his nostalgia for his own younger days, but because the military – by default – became one of the remaining few bastions of efficiency, and in its on-base communities with their still-vital organization, community spirit, and ethos the military seemed one of the last remaining embodiments of the ethos and the era that made America great. That was only increased by his opening to Fundamentalist elements; they brought not only a political and theological support for the ‘sacramentality’ of American government and ‘America’ itself as the agent of God, but also a way of conducting life that hearkened back to an earlier time.

Indeed, Reagan rather ‘sanctified’ or ‘theologized’ the military; not only its ‘efficiency’ but also its embodiment of the old ways. Yes, that helped lubricate the huge defense build-ups, but on a much deeper level it appealed to a profound need on the part of much of the citizenry, dizzy from and even dubious of all the revolutionary ‘progress’, and – for an aging population – a re-establishing of the world of their youth and of America’s genuine hegemony as an industrial and well as a political giant.

Well, it can hardly be surprising that the ‘military Way’ has returned again, and in such a way that the stunning frakkery of the Iraq War and revelations of vast mishandling of funds in defense procurement and expenditure and complicity of far too many senior, star-spangled officers such as Colin Powell in the whole sorry mess … all that doesn’t serve to damp down the rising enthusiasm.

The public schools, after all, are in tough shape. The curriculum is shot all to hell. Nor can We forget that the parlous condition of the American ‘family’ means that a student doesn’t go home to effective parental support and the essential insistence on homework, or study, or learning in general.; but politically you can’t tackle that problem head-on – the deconstruction of the American family is an objective dear to the heart of certain groups to which the Beltway has indentured itself.

So bring on the military. Maybe they can get the job done.

Of course, it isn’t all altruism on the military’s part. Competent troops are needed in an increasingly complex military environment, or at least kids who aren’t going to knee-jerkingly reject the prospect of military service. (Certain elite Ivy universities nowadays are also starting to cozy up to the idea of re-connecting to the military again; they can get more government money and their graduates might have a fall-back job when they graduate into the current economy.)

But neither the Southrons, nor the school supers, nor the universities are thinking things through. You take the King’s shilling, you do the King’s bidding – that’s a bit of ‘old’ knowledge that hasn’t ever changed.

And nowadays, a military career is going to wind up involved with aggressive resource-wars as well as the various contortions of a no-longer-super world power that wants to keep its place in the scheme of things. And with putting down the various inevitable resistance that such a plan will increasingly engender among other of the world’s peoples. Let alone among other – and no longer insignificant – governments. Ach.

The military’s value to American education is to no small extent an indicator of the failure of domestic policy to ensure a decent and well-grounded education to Our young. And that situation has been brought about as much from the Left as from the wealth-hungry, poor-ignoring Right. If there were still some shape and structure and genuine Ground beneath domestic policy, enabling it to prepare the young accurately for the real world in which they must carry on the American ethos and conduct a mature adult life, then it would not be necessary to invite the King’s shilling in the school-house door.

The military has its hands full, I think, with successfully and decently accomplishing its own traditional tasks.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

CHIMPS OR WIMPS

On the Slate site, Troy Patterson has an interesting – though not the definitive – take on Ed Burns’s “Generation Kill”.

The film is “too skeptical about authority to entertain neocons or red-meat nationalists and too depressing to delight a good liberal”. That may be a judgment on its marketability, and on its utility or the lack of it inregard to current political strategies, but it doesn’t grasp the larger import of the film.

But it’s worth a bit on its own. The film captures the Viking atmosphere of ‘boys’ at war. Of course, in that regard it’s as depressing as those queasy scenes in “Battlestar Galactica” where – in some sort of ideal alternative universe – male and female fighter pilots of the same age live in coed bunkrooms, the women equally as chimpish and loud and profane as the males - except, of course, when suddenly they are ‘feminine’.

Not to blame the scriptwriters; current cultural dogma as to the role of women in mixed-gender settings – and not just the gauzy world of college dorms but the brutal gruelling grind of constant combat - is … ummmm … mixed. In our modern American reality you can wind up in trouble for saying that women can bring an element of civilization to the combat milieu and you can wind up in trouble for saying that they are just the same as ‘men’. If you’re in the military, I imagine you can lose a career in less than an afternoon. Perhaps why one of the most essential career skills in the military nowadays is to be able to keep a straight face and talk about the weather. The situation is – frankly – soviet, a reality that did not die with Stalin or with the USSR itself but – in best science fiction form – has migrated.

The young males in this particular film’s unit – and they are all males – operate at that simultaneously winsome and repulsive level as any conflicted teens, though under the galvanizing and corrosive effect of sudden combat and the constant threat of it these highly-trained (but not matured) boyos start to shade over into the berserker, though here and there this or that one tries to get some traction for sanity with humor or insight or even a little philosophy.

The Service can train you, combat can harden you (or break you) but the Pentagon pays nobody to mature you. Nor, surely, can we expect Fundamentalist ‘witnessing’ and exhortations according to the stylings of the Book of Revelation to raise up the maturity of these youngsters. Put under this type of stress they start to cling wayyy to tightly to their Inner Chimp. And it shows.

It’s painful to watch. And that’s good. For Us. We need to see this. We need to see what they are going through, the profound dangers not only physical and ‘military’, and not only psychological, but characterological and even spiritual. Because if you clutch that Inner Chimp too long, and under too much pressure, it might be hard to let go – like those troops brought off the beach at Dunkirk, so deeply shocked that they cannot let go of their rifles even when the boat delivers them to a wharf in Old Blighty. Only this is worse. You can pry the physical muscles loose; not so the heart and the character and the spirit.

And Fourth Generation War (4GW as it’s called in the think-tanks) where there is no ‘front’ and no ‘rear’ where you can reasonably expect either combat or rest, and where the ‘enemy’ could be anybody not in your uniform, whether man or woman or child … in that type of situation, for weeks and months without significant relief, with no end in sight and every possibility that your glorious government will go back on its word and postpone your rotation home or even postpone the end of your enlistment, you are under monstrous pressures. How surprising can it be that the troops might discern as did Mark Twain: it was no place for a mature man, and I did not remain one very long …? No place for a decent man, and … the variations are numerous, and deeply disturbing.

Disturbing not because they are failing Us but because We are failing them. We failed to exercise mastery of Ourselves and so those whom We placed over the soldiers in positions of large authority were able to deploy them like pawns and plastic figures in a world far more complex than were contained in the Beltway’s dreams of easy imperium and quick-fixes.

We put wimps over the chimps. No, that’s too easy. The ‘chimp’ part, certainly, is too simplistic. And ‘wimps’ doesn’t begin to cover the numerous failings of those who surfed Our collective imbecilities to achieve large (‘great’ says too much) power. And who, as the light of power begins to fade, are looking to surf themselves to safety and – more! – continued status and influence, free from the consequences of their treacheries.

Strenuous liberty requires, by definition, strenuous maturity. And – at this point – strenuous prayer. Authentic and soul-fueled prayer. For Ourselves as well as for all of them over there.

Over there.

Labels: , , , , , ,