Monday, June 15, 2009

BARBARA EHRENREICH'S JOURNALISM

THE HAPPY DECLINE OF PROFESSIONALISM

Barbara Ehrenreich reports on an address she gave to this year’s graduating class at Berkeley’s Graduate School of Journalism.

The dean, she said, had wanted her to keep it upbeat – no doubt the faculty wanted to simply get the corpses tastefully and efficiently disposed of and get on with summer vacation, hoping – in best Micawber fashion – that ‘something will turn up’ by the time the summer is over.

Ehrenriech wouldn’t go that route. You have skills, she assured them, but nobody knows what to pay you for them now.

Well, yes, But then: what sort of skills have they learned? Surely ‘advocacy journalism’ and the lapdog stenography that panders to all ‘consumers’ by airbrushing stories about all but the most universally loathed targets. Invented to show solidarity with the Identities, within a decade it had skewed ‘news’ into selective and ‘positive’ stories – on soooo many levels they were indeed stories – and added ‘soft news’, which wasn’t really reporting at all. And then – with the Right’s meteoric rise under Reagan – the same courtesy had to be extended to government and foreign adventures.

Readers were no longer seen as Citizens in need of solid information as they were Consumers, waddling along with lots of buying power from all the ‘credit’ that suddenly welled up. One big happy party, with just enough designated ‘outrages’ to keep things spiced up.

Courtesy to government – not what you’d imagine the Framers envisioned for ‘a free press’.

But then Ehrenreich gets closer to the heart of the matter: “Welcome”, she told the grads, “to the working class”.

Bingo.

Because part of the obscene, butter-greasy glow of the Reagan years was the inflation of the status of ‘professional’. Reporters used to be hard-working stiffs, in scruffy clothes but with a great nose for what was really going on and the heart to pursue it. College professors used to wear patches on old sports jackets and drive modest cars (or the egg-like early-60s Volvo).

Doctors used to make house calls. Clergy actually believed in a God. ‘Ordinary people’ weren’t architects who lived in toney burbs and drove flashy foreign sports cars and had a computer (At home! On your desk!); they were working stiffs glad to be out of an era of depression and war and not so unhappy with a certain amount of peace and quiet; happy with a simple Ford or a Plymouth, and willing to leave the Caddies for the bosses and the foreign cars for the Commies.

Ah well . ‘Creative destruction’ made it all better – the story goes. And the creative inflation of credit, and the creative inflation of status.

And that’s where the professionals found their price. Everybody who could do anything was now a ‘professional’. It was a self-esteem thing, and the Left’s ‘sensitivity’ actually worked in Reagan’s furnaces as well: if you felt better about yourself, you would feel better about how things were going in the country, leave the Beltway alone to work its magic, and buckle down to enjoying the good things of American life. City bus drivers began showing up for work in a Mercedes – it was deemed great progress.

It all became so … well, Italian. Over there, nobody is just plain Signore unless you’re looking for a fight. Everybody is Professore or Dottore. The Italians knew how to make do with a little; how to make a little go a long way. And if the brute realities of life couldn’t actually be changed (too many important people had a stake in keeping things frakked up) then at least the little people could smooth the edges by ladling on the honorifics and the sincerely dishonest flattery.

‘Reporters’ became ‘journalists’, learned how to handle a meal where the place settings included three or more forks, and no longer took the bus. It was, surely, only gratitude that as they learned ‘manners’ they also learned politeness, especially towards those who were throwing the dinner parties. Having suddenly been brought into the national country club, they were in no hurry to start pointing out which of their new club-brothers (or sisters) were up to their ears in skullduggery, often involving the public till.

And, if they insisted on salving their consciences, then they could be ‘sensitive’ to ‘pain’ and skew their stories in the service of something ‘good’ – dishonesty in the service of ‘good’ is no vice. Or something like that.

Now the Bubble-fueled fantasy has run out of Bubbles. This is not something Americans have ever had to get used to (and this will be the world-historical mission of this era’s cohort of Americans: to preside over, as Churchill put it when his own moment came, “the dissolution of the empire”). What this generation of Americans will have to face up to is the dissolution of the empire of the American Dream.

What did Germans citizens feel like when they quietly figured out from the ‘glorious’ government newsreels that the Red Army – bulked up to a size the world had never seen before – was blowing through all the stop signs in Budapest and coming West? What did Japanese citizens feel like when they realized that their sons and brothers and fathers were dying of war wounds in places not very far away at all?

The ‘Dream’ – whether the version imposed by the Dems or peddled by Reagan and his spawn – is now revealed as the illusion it has been for so long. Neither the industry nor – alas – the character any longer exists to put a solid ground under any Dream. If a Dream is like a rocket that you launch with high hopes, there is no longer any solid ground from which to launch the thing.

Which should have come as no surprise, since things had been getting kind of iffy for quite some time.

But the ‘journalists’ were far too tasteful and 'positive' to notice.

So what skills does this graduating class have? That’s the first question. The ‘soft news’ and ‘advocates’ still have the advantage of fitting into the last known occupational model that worked – but that was in a time when there was plenty of almost-fake money to fuel their almost-fake professional services.

Maybe there are enough scruffy ones, though, with a grounding in some actual sense of reality and truth, who just get a genuine kick of telling the truth to people who need to hear the truth. Their labors would certainly be useful – at least to those Citizens who still look for the solid information they need to do their Constitutional job of grounding the never-quite-trustworthy government and all its pomps and all its works.

They could ‘report’ the old-fashioned way.

And leave the ‘Dream’ to the factories that have historically made them. Just the facts, please.
And yes, I know, there are no such things as ‘facts’. Well, there may be no such thing as the perfect fact, or at least not one that the human mind can encompass. But that doesn’t mean that there are no facts at all. Just because ‘we’ can’t ‘get there’ doesn’t mean the place doesn’t exist. That’s cargo-cult thinking, no matter how much it’s dressed up as ‘cutting edge thinking’.
We have regressed mightily, and down some very wrong paths.

It’s not enough to exhort “let’s face the music and dance”, as the 1930’s musical did. Better to face the facts and see what can be done with what’s actually left available to Us.

It’s worked before.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, October 02, 2008

POSITIVELY THINKING

Barbara Ehrenreich posts to Alternet: “How Positive Thinking Wrecked the Economy” (www.alternet.org/story/100396). The title says it all.

Michael Winship posts to Truthout: “Franklin Roosevelt, a Nation Turns Its Lonely Eyes to You” ( ). The title calls Us to consider whether it might not be a good idea to phone any very old relative who might recall his first Inaugural Address – assuming that said relative was paying attention to FDR and not Mae West at the time (although Mae, even in her sass and jokes, was a pretty reliable source of wisdom in her day – or evening). (http://www.truthout.org/092708Y)

“Positive thinking” and “optimism” – like “loyalty” – are very much context-dependent. An SS officer could be very loyal – “Loyalty is our honor” was his motto, after all – but you wouldn’t want the guy teaching your kids, or knocking on your door at 3AM.

The gist of the articles is that there’s been too much of it for Our common weal around here recently.

Yes. Because to really work, “positive thinking” has to be firmly anchored in reality. You can’t stand on the bridge of the Titanic after she’s churned beyond the berg and “be positive”. She’s ripped open like a tuna can, there aren’t near enough lifeboats, so the only thing a person might realistically be ‘positive’ about is that he’s positively getting himself – and maybe his friends and his relations – a place in one of those boats. That’s a kinda focused type of “optimism”, and in its way could require more than a little ‘courage’: pushing past other folks, making sure that the vast sweaty masses in steerage – and their nursing mothers and infants – are kept safely locked up below so as to ease the traffic up on the boat deck. Let them be nearer to God; you’ll have time for church when you get to New York and have had a good stiff tot to celebrate the mysterious workings of Providence – helped along by your own guts and wits. Onward then! And cue the band. Although there probably won’t be room for them either, if they play all the verses of the hymn. God worketh in mysterious ways; He giveth and He taketh away – best to be ready to deal with that.

The whole thing has somewhat to do with ‘context’, as aforesaid. If you are realistically taking stock of your situation, then a certain amount of ‘optimism’ and ‘positive thinking’ is a good thing: there’s nothing worse than the passenger in the airplane who, at the first sign of turbulence, starts bawling “Omigod, we’re all going to dyyyyyyyyyyyyyye!” Better to try to keep your head and not scare folks; and if the pilot is incapacitated, well … maybe even have a stab at the controls. Anything to help; anything to ‘do your bit’ as an older, less enlightened generation used to say, before ‘doing your bit’ was derided as merely being the willing pawn of historical and social forces.

When you have yourself done something wrong, and realize it, and try to make the situation resulting from your actions better, that’s thinking “positive”. But that’s a pretty stern ‘context’; most folks would rather find a less strenuous alternative.

Like not admitting , even to yourself, that you have done – or are still doing – anything wrong. So you keep doing it – and it does feel good – but you convince yourself that with enough ‘positive thoughts’ you can avert danger, or at least avert the thought of things going wrong. But this is – as the young shark specialist told the mayor in “Jaws” – simply ‘setting yourself up to be a hot lunch’. And, like the mayor, you’ll be setting a lot of other people up to be a hot lunch too. Or instead – since mayors and folks on the top of any particular heap tend not to wind up actually getting eaten by their own consequences. Getting eaten is what happens to littler folks – the Lord working in mysterious ways, but always respecting the sanctity of those who have used their gifts to climb to the top. Selah.

Thus – as many have mentioned recently – the ‘optimism’ of the likes of Angelo Mozillo, CEO extraordinaire, hobnobber of the guardians of the common weal, as his junkisch mortgages attacked Our economy like plague-bacilli. He refused to ‘think negatively’, i.e. that what he was doing was going to snooker a lot of poor folks and maybe even wreck the national economy. Consequences are for chumps (didn’t somebody in Washington say that ‘we’ were the ones who ‘make history’ and not the other way around?) And people who think about consequences – except for those outcomes where our little party turns up roses for everyone, or at least for everyone that ‘matters’ – are being ‘negative’, and are not ‘team players’, and don’t deserve to be employed on the Great Gravy Express. After all, even guys like the Chief of Staff of the Army can get canned for ‘thinking negatively’, for ‘not playing on the team’, and for darkening the brassy light of high-noon with talk of what could go wrong if there aren’t enough troops or if people fight back or if in any one of a hundred ways the collective dampdreams don’t turn out to be History’s chosen outcome.

To really work at its best, “positive thinking” has to be deployed early on.

And, actually, it has to be working in the service of a Larger thought, in the service of what Lincoln called at Gettysburg “a larger sense”. Not only did “positive thinking” not help the late unlamented Fuhrer as things began to go south in the East, but it really didn’t help him much when he discovered that his whiz-kids had figured out a more efficient way to run the Final Solution.

Because you have to think positively not only of what can-be, but of what should-be. Otherwise, you’re just another Ozymandias, strutting on History’s stage, “dress’t in a little brief authority”, wowing the crowd with this or that bit of fancy footwork, but just a two-bit hoofer, ultimately, and running out of stage. And hurtling into the darkling abyss beyond the footlights. Where be dragons.

I was impressed by that scene in “Ben Hur” (the 1959 version) where the Roman governor said to young Judah Ben-Hur that he was well-advised to forego his ideals and cut a deal with the powers of this world “and that power, for now, is Rome”. That “for now” struck me as something remarkably serious, far too serious for anyone to think about if they wanted to climb the ladder of this world’s success, for a Roman apparatchik. It wasn’t quite in character. But it was, I think, the screenwriter’s – maybe the studio’s – way of reminding a then-superpower of 1959 that it’s always “for now” and that there will always be a “later”, an “afterwards”.

And that the wise young person is well-advised to think about that. The Romans even had somebody ‘authorized’ (as We might say now) to walk behind a successful general in his triumphal parade and whisper constantly “remember thou are mortal”; it was not only moral, but it was hugely realistic, and it was civic-ly practical: if the great ones could recall their mortality, they might retain a sense of balance and proportion in their ambitions and in their “optimism” and in their “positive thoughts”. Win-win. If you keep ‘mortality’ in mind.

Now them Kathliks – they had the same thing, though too often lost in the miasm of repetition. On Ash Wednesday, Catholics go to church to have the priest plant a daub of ash on their forehead and say “remember you are dust, and to dust you shall return”. It’s actually a very positive thought: it reminds you that time is passing, that you’d better make the most of it, but also that when you return to dust, a very significant part of you – called the ‘soul’ – is going to be moving on to a place of judgment. That being the case, then when you “think positive” you’ve got to be operating within a personal vision that includes what you’re going to be saying when an angel intones something along the lines of “Heah kom da Judge”.

Much of this grave wisdom has been lost of late, in the feverish fundamentalist daydreams of being God’s deputies, empowered to separate the sheep from the goats and then keep the goats’ assets – which, come to think of it, was the Nazi plan as well. Funny how the night moves. Funny how the benighted all move the same way in the end. The Fool on the Hill sees it all. How oh how did the Boomers forget that?

Mr. Mozillo was no doubt thinking rather positively that the goats were an untapped resource, and that they could have a little piece of the action – for a time – while he got a nice big piece of it for himself. And that people are certainly sheep, even if they aren’t goats – and he was a sort of shepherd, herding them along to green pastures that he owned. Win-win. For a time.

“Thinking positively” with an insufficient grasp of the whole Picture is a recipe for serious unhappiness, in the fullness of time. Thinking that the Picture is only two-dimensional, Flat, is like trying live life only using the gestures and perspectives seen in Egyptian paintings: as if real people could actually survive in a world where they were always walking sideways, with both eyes on the same side of their head, like halibut. And holding their arms in those weird bent positions, front and back.

What use is “positive thinking” when you’ve stuck yourself in a world like that?

Funny how both ‘postmodern thought’ and fundamentalism have both collapsed the world into Flatness. The pomo’s and deconstructors say there is no Beyond, and the fundoozies say that the Beyond is easily and totally seen in this world, and works through the powers of this world. Either way, the ceiling drops on you as sure as it does on Indiana Jones – and squashed flat is squashed flat no matter how you look at it; you wind up looking like an Egyptian stick-painting for real.

And We have made a mistake that is becoming far too characteristic of Americans: We think a good thing can be had on the cheap. To think "positive" you first have to make a very comprehensive assessment of the situation, the good aspects and the dangerous aspects. And do some serious deliberation. None of which seems to be what citizens are supposed to do these days - neither the Security State nor the Nanny State want Us to be doing any of that, nor the corporate bottoms from either of the Parties taking up seats on Capitol Hill.

We as a nation have been thinking too positively, too optimistically for Our own good. We live now in a Flattened world, and one with no Beyond, and thus with no consequences. And no ‘judge’. It’s odd to see that a nation that incarcerates a larger percentage of its citizens than China (still Communist) and Russia (formerly Communist), doesn’t really have a solid grasp on the idea of consequences and judgment. Or rather, like with ‘bombing’, We think it only happens to other people. Where in the wide world of sports or the Bible did We get that idea? Or lose that idea?

“Social construction” was one place. This is the theory that there is no reality except for what people imagine it to be. So if you can get enough people thinking such-and-such, then such-and-such will be ‘reality’. It was a great little gambit to help the Identities along: if you just think such-and-such, instead of the old way you used to think, then such-and-such will be real. And if you don’t, then ‘you just don’t get it’. And if you persist in not-getting-it, then you most certainly are going to get it – right in the keyster. This was the basis of Political Correctness (borrowed from the Commies): make people see what you want them to see, and make sure that life gets tough for them – and maybe a whole lot shorter – if they don’t ‘see’. If they refuse to ‘see’ – in which case they deserve whatever they get, which will be whatever the government decides to give them as a punishment for such mule-headed stubbornness.

And it’s not hard to see how ‘Correctness’ leads to a lot of government intrusion, even into what you ‘see’ or don’t ‘see’. Lots of Germans (Hitler borrowed the idea from Lenin and Stalin) didn’t “see” and were sort of honestly surprised when a ‘judgment’ arrived and made them look at what had been going on all along.

But only sort of ‘honestly’; on some deeper level, they knew. They all knew. But they hadn’t wanted to ‘see’. They wanted to stay ‘on the team’; they wanted to stay ‘optimistic’; or they wanted to stay out of the camps, and off the lists and the registries kept on those little 3x5 death-white file cards kept by the Gestapo. They just wanted to get on with their lives. But their government made sure that its crimes were theirs. And judgment came, as it inevitably does. History, God, God through History – take your pick. In that sense, History most surely has not ended. Although their part in it had ended, at least in any shape they could recognize.

So ‘realism’ is a many-splendored thing. You have to really turn the thing around, like a hot diamond, to see all its aspects. A diamond is not a two-dimensional thing, nor is it Flat. And unlike a diamond, History is alive. And seems to know when it’s been dissed. And it doesn’t take kindly to that.

It’s funny how a country that can glue itself to TV or go to a stadium to watch football doesn’t get that idea: in the last second before a two-hundred-plus-pound defenseman lands on your anatomy, no amount of ‘constructing’ is going to get save you from pain.

‘Constructing’ works on one level of human activity. On the basic myths and fundamental beliefs, it works. But some things are ‘beyond’ belief; they have a life of their own. That’s reality. And even on the level of myths and beliefs, if there really is a ‘Beyond’, and ‘consequences’ thereby imposed, then your myth is not totally disconnected and free-floating from that reality. So if you put to sea in a ship that you and all your fellow and sister passengers have ‘socially constructed’ as ‘unsinkable’, well – not all the constructing that the whole of you can muster is going to change the destructing that the iceberg will do if you give it half a chance.

We’ve been subjected to a lot of social constructing these past umpty years. And a lot of social destructing in the service of creatively making space for the constructing. I’m going to imagine We reached a point where We couldn’t tell what was reality and what wasn’t, and certainly not on an ultimate level.

But I don’t want to be negative. To paraphrase Emily Dickinson: Though I never had time to stop for Reality, Reality kindly stopped by for me. Perhaps it is a ‘kindness’ on the part of reality, this awefull “fiery trial through which We pass” now. Lincoln ‘constructed’ the Civil War as a ‘trial’, and that can be taken on any number of levels. So that’s “positive”, but in a mature (and un-American, alas) sense: We are facing a great trial, but it is a trial and not the end, and so We must pull Ourselves together and make the best We can out of it, and hope to come through it better people than when it started.

FDR said “we have nothing to fear but fear itself”. True enough. But he did not then smile and say ‘Y’all just go shoppin, now!’ No. We must ‘construct’ the purpose of the trial, and thereby steel Ourselves to go through it to the far side. Because no matter what happens, and much ‘bad’ and much pain and suffering may indeed happen now, We believe that We can handle it. I will add “under the goode Providence of God”, although I am not forcing that on anybody. They will come to it themselves, or they will not – but belief cannot be imposed.

This is Our rendezvous with destiny in the Year of Grace Two-Thousand-and-Eight, and of the Independence of the Republic the Two-Hundred-and-Thirty-Second. We may not be the ‘greatest generation’, and God knows We’ve let a lot go to hell on Our watch, but We may have it in Us yet to reclaim a true democratic politics and a robust – and more humble, chastened – Republic.

It’s not a bad ‘construction’. And Our children and descendants, and all the world’s peoples, would be the better for Our having passed this way. There is still time.

Labels: , , , , ,