Monday, March 30, 2009

RAWLS AND RELIGION

In ‘The Times Literary Supplement’ (subscription required) of March 20, 2009, the philosophers Joshua Cohen and Thomas Nagel have an article (“Faith in the Community”, pp. 12-4) about how religious and spiritual the thought of John Rawls was. The article is a shorter form of an Introduction to a book about Rawls – “A Brief Inquiry Into the Meaning of Sin and Faith” – soon to be published by Harvard University Press.

Rawls, as I’ve said in previous Posts, came up with a philosophical ‘system’ in 1971 that became the underpinning of much of the ‘justification’ or at least intellectual ‘cover’ that was deployed to convince those eager-to-please Democrats (the Republicans still not an established ‘power Party’) to start seriously knocking down walls in the national Edifice. Much of that ‘creative destruction’ bore consequences that are still with Us (to put it nicely) today – and, I would say, are in no small part responsible for much of the train-wreck.*

Rawls was talking of becoming a priest in the late 1930s before he started college. He wrote an under- graduate paper in 1942 at the age of 21 that is the subject of the book and the Cohen-Nagel review. He went off to war and came back in June ’45 having lost his belief in Christianity “because of his experiences in the war and his reflections on the moral significance of the Holocaust” (a nice touch to connect with the waxing ‘Holocaust’ concern in America of the early 1970s as LBJ’s 1967 decision to weld Us to the State of Israel was starting to take hold).

Yet the reviewers assert that the paper demonstrates “the intellectual force and moral and spiritual motivation” which “made Rawls what he is”.

You wonder right off what the significance of a paper about his beliefs in 1942 could ultimately be, since he recounts that he had lost his belief by the time he came back from the war in June 1945.

Worse, I think, is that you start to think of ‘disillusioned’ believers who then take up politics. Stalin was a former seminary student, and the infamous Nazi judge Roland Freisler was a diehard Communist until one day he met the Nazis and suddenly became a diehard Nazi (and diehard enemy of Communism). There is a whiff of a disillusioned but molten mind and personality. There is also the strong potential for the ex-believer to abandon only his beliefs, while retaining the intensity and heat of his characteristic ‘need’ to be a ‘true and ultimate and heroic believer’ … in whatever it is that he adopts as his belief system. None of which bodes well for participation in a democratic politics (about which more below).

That uneasiness isn’t allayed when he says that philosophy can ground a “reasonable faith in the possibility of a just constitutional democracy” (nice enough, and inspiring) but that if such a society is not possible then it leads one to wonder whether “it is worthwhile for human beings to live on earth” at all. This feels wayyy to ‘hot’ to me, molten, liquid; sort of the kind of Ultimate Stakes that leads to ‘emergency thinking’, where the ‘emergency’ is so great that it will justify just about anything. Which, in an ominous irony, is precisely the type of thinking that led Lenin, Stalin, and Hitler to ‘do whatever it took’ in order to get control of a strong government so that they might respond to the ‘emergency’ by imposing their vision of the ‘good’ society upon everybody … or else.

Rawls seeks to get people to look at look at their social world and their place in it sub specie aeternitatis, which is an old Catholic theological concept that means ‘from the point of view of God’ (or ‘eternity’). It’s always a good mental exercise for the individual soul seeking deeper understanding of life-in-God’s-world, but that isn’t at all to say that it’s the basis for a philosophy of government, especially in a pluralistic democracy where lots of folks have different illuminations about God and the world. And it starts to feel like Rawls is going to be bringing his ‘religious method’ into what is supposed to be a governing philosophy of politics, and specifically American politics in the later 20th century. Are We going to wind up here with a “Christendom without Christ”? (You could imagine both Communism and Nazism as just such an undertaking, although with ‘The Leader’ substituting for Christ – and didn’t they used to call George Bush ‘The Leader’ in hushed and respectful tones?)

So if different folks have different visions of aeternitas, what then? You will have to impose some baseline ‘view’, whether you call it that or not. And Rawls winds up doing just that: he develops the “original stance”, which turns out to be essentially what Rawls thinks any right-thinking person in God’s place would think about life and politics. So Rawls will spin an entire ‘philosophy’ if you give him the benefit of the doubt. Those who do so will be the ones who ‘get him’ and ‘get it’, and those who don’t … well, there’s always the outer darkness for them, as Scripture (and ‘the Leaders’ hath often said). No wonder his philosophy quickly attracted numerous “disciples”, who had that certain look in their eye.

He’s concerned with “how political legitimacy can be achieved despite religious conflict (I imagine this means ‘conflicting moral values based on conflicting religious beliefs’) and how, among citizens holding distinct religious views, political justification can proceed without reference to religious conviction”. Well, it can’t be. You’re going to have to introduce some sort of ‘religious’ dynamic, dressed up as something else.

Yet, remarkably, Rawls will claim that it is tremendously important to “separate religion and politics”. But of course, he means ‘religion’ only in the sense of formal belief in a particular religious belief system (Catholic, Jewish, Baptist, and so on); the religious approach itself – this is what I believe and you are with me or you are not – will remain beneath the surface, hidden but verrrry active.

For he does insist that religious beliefs are “non-negotiable” and “binding absolutely” – which is precisely why the Framers, while presupposing that most citizens would believe, did not at all want the utterly unresolvable conflicts about which ‘belief’ is ‘true’ and therefore ‘must’ be allowed to define policy and law to gum up the works of constitutional machinery and fundamentally derange democratic politics.

Indeed, in his 1971 marquis book, ‘A Theory of Justice’, he is precisely looking to start from “a moral outlook”. But of course, what constituted ‘moral’ poses a huge question of definition, and that’s going to require an awful lot of deliberation to forge – if at all possible – a working consensus (there can never be an absolute and total ‘consensus’ in this world on such an non-material, ‘abstract’ concept) suitable to a democratic politics and polity. But then, if you’re addressing a ‘moral emergency’, you don’t really have the time to do all that deliberating. And if, on top of that, hot-eyed folks are using your ‘philosophy’ to justify large agendas of political and societal change that they want imposed right now, then ‘deliberation leading to consensus’ is not going to be the way they’ll go. Again, that spells serious trouble for a democratic politics and polity.

His main assumptions are: First, “a morality defined by interpersonal relations rather than by the pursuit of the highest good”. Sounds sorta nice, but that’s not enough. So human beings are not going to try to shape their lives on a quest to conform to the highest good (as best they can grasp it)? Instead, they are going to shape their morality on something of this-world: interpersonal relations. This is a Flattening of the remarkably sophisticated Western vision of existence that stipulates a higher dimension toward which humans could strive, in their personal self-development and in their societal development. You can’t ignore the activities and tasks of ‘this world’ (this dimension), but you can’t imagine that ‘this world’ is all there is – if you do, you are trapping yourself while at the same time denying that spiritual element of yourself that participates in a higher world, or a better world from whence human ideals originate. This is a lethal, a fatal, Flattening; to revert to it after the long struggles of humankind in the past millennia is not progress, but a massive regression.

Second, “an “insistence on the importance of the separateness of persons, so that the moral community or community of faith is a relationship among distinct individuals”. Each person is indeed separate, but each is also a member of a species (speaking in purely biological terms) and also shares a human ‘nature’; and in the Christian tradition (which helped shape the Western tradition) that ‘nature’ is dignified by its highest potential excellence and is also a reflection of the nature of the God who created it. You reduce people to such a profound ‘separateness’ as Rawls requires and they have nothing to connect them but ‘the things of this world’, again a Flattening and a desiccation and constriction of the horizon of human possibility in all its complex and mysterious possibility. But it’s convenient for ideologues looking to cut the rug out from under human communities and individuals; shorn of the strengths and hopes that Flatness has taken away, left only among ‘the things of this world’ human beings will be almost helpless before ‘the powers of this world’, which – come to think of it – is precisely what every revolutionary of the Left or Right has sought once the government has been taken over by ‘the revolution’. It’s also why the Framers very much did not want to squash citizens into a purely this-worldly definition of human activity and potential – it would give the ever-this-worldly ‘government power’ wayyyy too much room for “mischief”.

Third, “a rejection of the concept of society as a contract or bargain among egoistic individuals”. So there goes the “social compact” (kiss the Mayflower Compact goodbye). Individuals cannot come together and make their arrangements after mutual consensus, to the best of their abilities and according to their lights. No – so that would leave … government to do that for them, set the terms of the social structure? Well, if it’s a government that ‘gets it’, then Rawls would be quite happy. You can’t trust ‘people’; which was indeed a fear of the Framers – the ‘people’ might not reliably be up to being The People. But it’s also the view of Lenin and others, that most folks ‘just don’t get it’ and need to be led by enlightened ‘elites’ or cadres of the revolution. And while the Framers had their misgivings that people would always be up to the task, the great (so to speak) revolutionaries made it an article of faith and belief that ‘the masses’ were lumps and would never get it (and so would always need that elite vanguard to govern them as it saw fit). Oy.

Fourth, “condemnation of inequality based on exclusion and hierarchy ”. But the Framers realized that given the state of human nature as it had manifested itself throughout recorded history, there would always be ‘hierarchy’ of some sort. All the animal world separated itself into some sort of hierarchy, so some sort of hierarchy seemed built into the nature of things. But human beings were more than animals, and surely had potential that no human power could foresee or determine, so the Framers built in the concept of ‘equality of opportunity’, allowing space for humans to achieve what they might, to aspire. Greed and the lust for power would always lead some to take from others, and by Teddy Roosevelt’s time it was clear that ‘corporate’ wealth and the power it bought required the government to do something to ensure that the economic balance was not seriously deranged; he sought to regulate corporations and their wealth, as did his distant cousin Franklin 30 years later.

At the same time, across the pond, Lenin was taking Marx to an awful but ‘practical’ conclusion by making it an article of faith and belief, a historical ‘law’, that only government could ensure the distribution of material goods and wealth – but that didn’t work out so well, in the end, after stupefying blood and death were imposed upon entire populations. The Framers of the American approach, Lenin was sure, did not go far enough – and they didn’t, because they knew that they weren’t gods, nor would any human government ever reliably function as a benevolent deity. And they also knew that if you tried to squeeze humans into such a scheme, they would – it was part of their nature – eventually ‘push back’. So the Framers settled for a machinery to conduct an ongoing ‘balancing act’ and hoped (and prayed) that subsequent generations would be up to the task of handling the machinery well enough.

Fifthly, “the rejection of the idea of merit”. Well, if you can’t aspire to achieve and – yes, acquire stuff – then why get up in the morning? Stalin solved the ‘motivation’ problem by erecting a police state where ‘malingerers’ got a one-way ticket to Siberia; Hitler and Imperial Japan had ‘block wardens’ and spies and employers who were required to make sure that everybody worked hard on what they were told to work on, and all citizens were encouraged to report on anybody who didn’t. And children were ‘heroes’ if they reported on their parents. Lovely. “O brave new world, to have such people in it!”

And ‘excellence’? To strive to be all you can be? Why? Monks can do it, sometimes, simply out of love of God and humanity, or out of a desire to perfect the soul and the self – but the Framers rather shrewdly figured that most people weren’t up to being monks (they’d seen what happened when the Puritans tried it, and didn’t intend to go back to a Bible-police state). Rawls, I think, is heading toward a ‘Theory of Justice’-police state. I don’t see the progress here. I’m not feeling the progress.

Stunningly, Cohen and Nagel admit that “ideas about rights, law, constitutions and democracy play no role” in Rawls’s thesis. Lord, is this a man whose thought should be erected into a Plan by the national government of these United States? When ‘the vision’ takes precedence over law, constitutions, and democracy itself … isn’t this exactly what the Communist, Fascist, and other government-heavy visions demanded? And isn’t this the ‘religious’ dynamic that underlies all totalitarian visions: that ‘this’ vision (whatever it may be for the particular governing elite) must be accepted as absolute truth and you’ll get if in the neck if you disagree? Is it any wonder that We have seen so much ‘constitutional’ dysfunction in the past few decades? The Beltway is in thrall to this sort of thinking. And the law schools. And the universities. Go in hock so that you can pay 50 large a year so that your kids can ‘learn’ this?

Then they go on about Rawls saying that “the chief problem of politics is to work out some scheme of social arrangements which can so harness human sin as to make the natural correlates of community and personality possible”. Which is nice, but it’s pretty much what the Framers thought too. And they still made room for – fundamentally depended on – ‘rights, law, constitutions and democracy’. Which Rawls doesn’t. Indeed, he imagines that his ‘disciples’, suitably ‘educated’ and full of righteous zeal, will constitute an elite cadre that is ‘justified’ in doing an end-run around all that slow, inefficient, clunky machinery and just going for the ‘vision’ – imposing it, actually. Uncle Sam might be forgiven for ejaculating with Edward G. Robinson: Mother of Mercy, is this the end of little Rico? And at this point, so might We all.

“Ethics and religion should be concerned not with the pursuit of the good but with establishing the proper form of interpersonal relations: community”. Ach. So in the service of the Volksgemeinschaft religion and ethics should be willing to abandon anything not-of-this-world and just go with the approved flow. This frakking idea has been tried before. No wonder organized religion has been taking such a hit – as it has many times before, especially in the blood-soaked, very this-worldly 20th century.

And who will do the ‘approving’? Funny you should mention that.

Proceeding in a theological vein, the reviewers note that the theology of Anders Nygren decried the “infection of Christianity, through Augustine and Aquinas, by the ethical conceptions of Plato and Aristotle, according to which ethics is concerned not with interpersonal relations but with the pursuit of the good by each individual”. But Christianity has never held that seeking God was a zero-sum game: either God or interpersonal relations. Indeed, if God created all human beings, then to genuinely participate in the life of God is to participate automatically in the life of God’s children. It’s a tripolar circuit: Self-God-Others.

Rawls has followed Nygren down the inadequate path of bipolarity and feels that the zero-sum approach of an ‘infected’ Christianity misses “the spiritual and personal element which forms the deep inner core of the universe”. But it’s Nygren’s inadequate reading of Christianity that does that, not genuine Christian doctrine itself.**

“Christianity treats God as the supreme object of desire”. This, to Rawls, is wrong. Desire, in Rawls’s Flattened universe, is only appropriately aimed at the things of this-world. But the Framers accepted that they were only trying to put together a machinery for a workable human government in this life, and nothing more. They weren’t trying to build an alternative Church (blasphemy, that would have seemed to them) that would comprehensively encompass all of human desire. And if humans beings participate in some beyond-this-worldly ‘life’, then how can such desire be thwarted or refused? To do so would be a monstrous deprivation of the human birth-right.

And if God (however defined or conceived) is not present as a pole-star to illuminate the fogs and mists and dusts of this-worldly existence, then human beings have been knocked back further than even the cavemen. This is progress? This is Liberal? This will constitute grounds for hope and confidence?

Again, Rawls apparently believes that “appropriate relations of community can only emerge, and will emerge, if egotism is brought under control”. Well, that sounds right, and a fine theological and religious principle it is. But how does a government go about ensuring such a desirable state of affairs? Not without becoming a theocratic police state, I think. (And isn’t that what all the fuss with ‘Islamofascists’ is about?)

Achieving such a state of affairs “requires God’s grace and efforts by the elect to bring others into the community”. So far so Christian, and it’s nice to see a modern intellectual assert a positive and vital role for God’s grace. But it’s that “elect” that bothers: are We back to the Puritan polity here? And “elect” evokes “elite”, as in the elite Party cadres that ‘get it’. And is that wise? To combine the Puritan theocratic and virtuous police-state with the Flattened, materialist, secular totalitarian states of the Communist ‘left’ and the Fascist ‘right’? And, Rawls being Rawls, it also evokes the disciples who prove their elite-ness and elect-hood by having the wisdom to agree with him and accept his teaching. Ach. Oy.

“The thesis suggests that the problems of society could be overcome by controlling human sin”. Well, that’s hardly a new insight. Of course things would go better in this vale of tears if ‘sin’ were controlled. But how do you go about doing that? How does a government do that?

Marx suggested in effect that the greatest sin, and only sin, is economic and that a government should control the economy in the name of the whole people. Lenin took it further and said that only a vanguard elite can administer the government which rules the people toward the glorious end of economic fulfillment. Stalin simply defined sin as opposing the Party and the State and proved very adept at controlling that form of ‘sin’. Hitler went Stalin’s route, defining ‘sin’ as any opposition to the State that governed in the name of das Volk, and the marvelous Leader who governed that State (if he did say so himself). None of these illuminations offer much of value to a democratic politics grounded upon the transcendent dignity of its citizens as human beings created by God.

So I’m saying that Rawls is simply giving Us a Christianity without Christ, but with himself as His prophet. A secular Christendom.

Worse, he is saying that in the service of his great vision, the clunky and slow machinery of deliberative democratic politics and governance are merely obstructions to be gotten around.

No wonder We are where We are these days.


NOTES

*In emergency room lingo, a ‘train-wreck’ is a patient with numerous injuries or problems, all of them serious and potentially lethal, that are so interlocked that if you try to solve one you will exacerbate one or several of the others. At that point, the doctors have no easy, perhaps no ‘good’, choices.

**Of course now, the Protestant Reformation went and removed the conductor from the orchestra and since then various of the instrument groups have tried to play the entire symphony at the beat and tempo they think best – so when you go after “Christianity” you have to do some clarifying right off the bat. Otherwise your simply blaming Beethoven because of the way the Podunk High School Band is playing his Fifth at the graduation ceremonies.

Labels: , , , , ,

Sunday, November 23, 2008

REALITY ISN’T JUST A PRETTY NAME

Chris Hedges, as always, offers acute thoughts in his article “America’s Wars of Self-Destruction”, originally on Truthdig but also on Truthout (http://www.truthout.org/111708D )

Recounting the utter strategic folly of declaring global and generational ‘war’ on “a tactic” (terrorism) and on “evil” (whose ‘homeland’ is, famously, beyond the reach even of the U.S. military and even of its chaplainry, whether handling snakes or thumping Bibles), he adverts that We have, in effect, declared a very physical ‘war’ against a ‘metaphysical’ entity. And that is verrrry uncomfortably close to the standard set-up for any number of half-century-old B and C-level Saturday matinee horror flicks, where the villagers with pitchforks or the Army with tanks and bazookas attempt to defeat evil demons from beyond.

It has come to this. We – Boomers and their follow-on generations – are now re-enacting the amusements of their youth. Only this time with whole armies, whole economies, and the copious blood being shed isn’t just chocolate sauce or motor oil on a cheap soundstage. We may go out on a note of historical farce before this is all over, but held responsible for it all nonetheless.

And how We smirked at the hapless Catholic priests trying to drive the devil out of Rosemary’s baby thirty-five long years ago. Stand aside, pathetic poseurs! The Army is going to do it now, and if the babies have to be destroyed in order to save them, well …. Yahoo and Can-do! Been there – done that. But it’s more than pea-soup that’s flying through the air now.

Hedges observes that ‘We have a childish belief that Obama will magically save us from economic free fall, restore our profligate levels of consumption and resurrect our imperial power”. It’s amazing how, in the past forty years of shrill demands for and brassy-gassy celebrations of ‘empowerment’ and ‘liberation’, yet the American citizenry is more passive, more unable to think, more incapable of facing up to ‘reality’, more emotionally gelatinous, and more dependent upon some ‘father-figure’ (or ‘mother-figure’) to tell Us it’s not Our fault, wave off all consequences, and make everything go back to the way it was before We frakked it all up.

At the risk of sounding age-ist or judgmental, I’d say that We have become infantilized, male and female together.

He asserts that “this naïve belief is part of our disconnection with reality”. Ah. Bingo, as they say. Of course, ‘reality’ has taken quite a beating. The National Security State simply wanted to define it as whatever is in America’s or the Establishment’s or the government’s interest.

The National Nanny State went about it – drawing a lesson from its Leninist grand-uncle – in a far more organized manner: it embraced a modern variant of old philosophical Nominalism to assert that there is no ‘Reality’, there is only whatever any particular group chooses to call or name ‘reality’, which is always subject to change. And for good measure slathered a hefty dollop of deconstructionist theory to the effect that every oppressive group seeks to define ‘reality’ in such a way that it can continue to oppress the oppressed and – ta-dah! – with the cooperation of the oppressed who figure that if you can’t fight city hall, you sure as hell can’t fight ‘reality’.

So out went ‘Reality’ and any ‘reality’ that could reasonably (very generously defined) be construed as ‘oppressing’ anybody. Out went the fences. But the trellises as well, alas. Out went the walls. But the frameworks as well, alas.

Can’t squeeze through to get to the green grass on the other side? Break the bones that keep you ‘too rigid’. Thus the skeleton goes. That’s OK, it’s a good thing: now you’re much less ‘rigid’ and much more ‘flexible’. And how does a creature keep its shape without an endo-skeleton? Why with an exo-skeleton of course, a shell encasing and protecting the inner mush. Provided by a government now taken over – in their dampdreams – by the vanguard elites who ‘get it’ and are willing to make a great living doing the right thing for those sad lumps who ‘just don’t get it’. That was the plan, that still is the plan for far too many folks, and the consequences will intensify accordingly.

I’m not making a case here for troglodyte primitivism. But these consequences – not altogether unintended – could hardly have been unforeseen. Although, you have to ask yourself: did the screaming screw-ups of the Iraq War strategy simply leap full-blown from the whacked-out, half-clever minds of the Bushist Imperium? I think not. I think an almost premeditated, purposeful un-realism was pretty much par for the course in this country before Bush was ever – you should pardon the expression – elected.

How the frak do We fix this? Don’t even ask how ‘Obama’ is going to fix this. He was born the year JFK urged Us to ‘ask what you can do for your country’. By the time he was taking care of his own business at the potty - no offense intended – five years later that era of JFK was gone, baby, gone. Five short years and the whole American ‘world’ changed, and if not for the worse to all appearances, then at huge and unconsidered price – as We now can see. This has not been JFK country for quite some time, stranger. When they say ‘Camelot’ didn’t last very long, they said more than they ever knew.

Nominalism is dressed up now with the scientific moniker ‘social constructionism’. The insight of the latter is that human beings ‘construct’ what is their ‘reality’, as a group and as individuals.

From that it follows that there is no way they can know for certain any one big Reality ‘out there’; there’s no scientific way to prove that the ‘knowledge’ is accurate.

From that it follows that there is no one big Reality out there at all. We construct it for ourselves, as groups and as individuals.

Now the problem becomes: there is no ‘fixed point of reference’ which has an existence independent of humans and more substantive than human figurings, upon which serious life-affecting decisions and regulations can be made.

It’s as if, having come across some strange alien machine, and not knowing how it works and not being able to communicate with the designers, we just have to come up with some best guesses that we all agree is the way to use the thing. In a less enlightened age we might posit the example of natives coming across an abandoned airplane on their island, and having finally figured out how to start the engine, they proceed to cut down huge swaths of the island’s forests so that it can be driven around, like a giant bus with strange, protruding decorations. (The gas will run out eventually, but let’s not get ahead of things.)

This is the adventure of Nominalism in the modern world. There is no score, so everybody with an instrument get together (or not) and play what everybody (or somebody) thinks best. Until … they don’t. And then the whole thing starts over again.

And that’s without getting into just how people are supposed to find meaning in a life where there is nothing ‘fixed’ and ‘beyond’ them that can anchor their hopes and fears, let alone care.

But of course, if there’s no ‘scientific proof’ then there’s nothing there. Which has worked out quite well, in the short run but over and over again, for numerous groups that figured they would help matters by imposing their own ‘reality’. Meaning was reduced to the satisfaction (it would be too much to call it happiness) one would get from being a (almost always) very small part of that great saga.

Like the Bushisti now, the many vanguard elites of the past decades do not at this point want to acknowledge that they really intended to deconstruct the whole damned country - in terms of its fundamental grounds of meaning and purpose. But that’s where it’s led to, and to read a lot of them, you have to think that all along they sorta did. Feith and the feminists actually do have something in common, besides tenure at major universities.

Hedges sounds the call that ‘reality’ is playing now, summoning Us: “The old America is not coming back.” Hark ye to him. Boomers, the country you were born into, the country that was on top of the world – is gone. The America of 1945, 1955, 1965, even the moon-landing country of 1969, is gone and it’s gone for good.

I suppose you should have realized it when it turned 1980 and the cars weren’t flying. Maybe the computers and other shiny gizmos distracted you. Or when the ‘jobs’ suddenly became all burger-flipping and shelf-stocking, the stuff teens did in the old America just for pocket money after school.

Or when the Democrats kept rolling over so they could be ‘bipartisan’, but the Republicans never gave any ground of their own away. And the Democrats kept getting ‘bamboozled’ – but nobody thought after a couple-six years to figure they were either stupid as frakking rocks or treacherous as snakes.

But they weren’t stupid there in the Beltway. They figured a way to keep everybody stocked up with nice shiny stuff, even as the whole base of industry and decent jobs was being deconstructed for shipment overseas: cheap credit.

A citizenry that had learned to accept that ‘reality’ was whatever you wanted it to be was in no position to really say that something was not on the level – the standard solution was to change the way you were holding your head until things did appear level again. This is not an adult way to proceed. It never was. But then, ‘adult’ is a judgmental and age-ist term and so insensitive and inappropriate. Thus distracted, it was no longer asked But is it accurate?

So here We are. The party’s over. ‘Reality’ has returned, and needless to say, uninvited. Nor have many wise virgins made preparations, nor are lamps trimmed. Indeed, where are the lamps now? Where were they put – like old Christmas decorations – when ‘reality’ was declared nothing but a human (American, really) house-pet?

Time for a rendezvous with destiny. Time to show how this generation is going to be ‘the greatest’. Time to ‘man’ up (is that sexist? – I haven’t seen a memo).

But this is also the time to consider that there is a Reality after all. And that it cares. We leave politics behind with this thought. But We take a certain philosophy with Us, into a further realm.

Do I have to draw a map? The old ones are still around. Where We left them.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, September 01, 2008

THE OLDER THEY ARE

In the September 10th issue of ‘The New Republic’, the marvelous philosopher and commentator Martha Nussbaum has a meaty piece on Roger Williams (“The First Founder”, http://www.tnr.com/booksarts/story.html?id=511ec724-6299-4bf4-adf7-38059cff16ae).

We may not think it’s worthwhile spending much time on philosophy or on the thoughts and actions of persons long dead (and white and male and – the horror! – religiously inclined). After all, We are sore bethump’t and there may not be too much time left. Necessity might seem to demand Our being ‘practical’; once, it is said, that was what We were famous for.

But this is the equivalent of not wanting to take a quick for-dummies primer on sailing as the ship slows almost to the point of unmanageability and starts to fill. Granted, an only slightly precocious 9 year-old might point out that people shouldn’t put to sea unless they sorta have a working knowledge of what makes vessels work, and how best to care for and handle them. We had reposed Our trust in ‘the government’, or at least those gentlepersons whom We had elected to represent Us … they were supposed to keep an eye on things and keep this marvelous if not altogether perfect ship of state afloat and in business.

But now it appears time for Plan B. High time.

But in the best spirit of the Marines’ ‘every Marine a rifleman’ (‘rifleperson’) it’s not a bad idea for all the citizenry to have at least a modest understanding of how things work – just in case the official crew jump ship or maybe lock themselves into the first-class saloon with the swells, leaving the rest of the passengery to shift for themselves. Which in this case is Ourselves. You see how quickly the political can get personal. Even more so the philosophical.

“Mutual respect” is absolutely essential for a democratic politics, for a democracy, to survive. This doesn’t mean a tactical tolerance for the sake of some temporary alliance-for-gain. That’s merely a mutual shrewdness. What those hardy if sharp-edged first souls of the 1600s grasped before they even waded onto these shores was that a community embarked on a mission so grandly tenuous needed to draw upon each of its members in order to muster the strength and skills to see the job through.

Whether through temperament or variously distributed quanta of fortitude – the courage, to see clearly and to consider carefully under pressure, and then to take the best conceivable and possible action - a split developed in early New England. There was the Mather approach: that religious conformity must be enforced by the civil power of the community for the sake of public order and – the Indians having been most sharply treated with insufficient regard to consequence, let alone to their dignity and any mutual respect that might be due them – simply for public survival.

It can get to be a vicious circle: for lack of respect for limits, boundaries, or for the necessary honesty due in relations with other human beings, a community takes actions that engender consequences that put said community in grave danger; thus fear-ified, the community attacks itself in order to expel any hesitation, and thus fortified, it goes forth to ferocitize afresh. Which in turn creates more baleful consequences, which in turn … and so on.

There was in the midst of 17th century New England a man with another approach to things. Based on three particular elements of his thought (and he did a lot of thinking before acting, even in matters that to the less-matured eye might have seemed far too urgent for such an otiose plan as ‘thinking’) Williams evolved a far different modus operandi in regard to setting up shop on these primeval shores; and when New England – Mather country – refused to countenance his methods, he took himself as far south as what is now Providence, Rhode Island, which he founded – named after that thing God does – and deployed his methods with no little success and far less blood-letting. (At which point in the story the average 9 year-old might feel a bit let-down; but that goes with the territory of being that age, and adults are – it can only be hoped – available to teach the tyke a perceptive patience that will serve as far more effective a tool in the building of a self and a life.)

First, and without bringing religion into it (and Nussbaum is a philosopher, not a theologian) Williams grounded his entire take on being human in the observation that all humans have a capacity for conscience. This conscience is defined as the “seat of emotion, imagination, and ethical choice through which each person seeks meaning in his or her own way”. And it is this capacity that constitutes for Williams “the source of our equality, and it is worthy of equal respect wherever it is found”.

And “political principles must be based on that equal respect”. I don’t know how many of Us, especially the generations that have joined Us in the past forty or so years, have ever really been given the opportunity to take that observation to heart. It should be carved in stone on public buildings, and leave the Ten Commandments – may they be revered – for carving upon churches. Perhaps the fundamentalist brethren and sistern, famously averse to large stone houses of worship, might be assisted somehow to own or build a few, so that they can then carve the Commandments thereupon to their heart’s and soul’s content.

On the other side of the national divide, the equally fundamentalistic secularists (or secularistic fundamentalists, if you prefer) might be well-advised that when such vital mutual respect is for all practical purposes nullified in the service of creating monsters to destroy out of this or that small or very large segment of the national community … then they need to re-visit their complaints, plans and agendas. If the community called ‘American’ – for all its imperfections, and their name is Legion – is not granted primacy by any group, then that group has to consider to just what extent it has seceded from the American Experiment. And haven’t We been down this road before?

In the second place, “Williams believed that equal respect for conscience entails protecting an extensive sphere of freedom around the individual, and that this protection must be impartial, imposing no orthodoxy”. This might be construed as overtly religious orthodoxy or as that secularist equivalent masquerading as ‘political correctness’ (a phrase and a concept borrowed from a certain 1917 revolution that finally succumbed to its own outrageousness in 1991, only to be resurrected in an amended form in 2008 – which might be to some a ‘proof’ that George Bush, as he has always claimed, is acting on God’s authority ... Pray, pray for your lives).

And – marvelously on the part of both Williams and Nussbaum – such orthodoxy Williams termed “soule rape”. It’s not hard to see why such rape has not been embraced by the Second-Wave-inspired sex-offense mania: the last thing Pomo deconstruction wants to do is give any public airing whatsoever to the concept of ‘soule’ (modern: soul) and all that the term might bear back into Our midst. It is harder to imagine why the churches have not been more steadfast in their proclamation of this particular variant of monstrousness over the decades and centuries since the Founding; tastefulness and a desire to be polite at the table could be one reason: A-list dinner parties, country club verandahs, and small-town church suppers all have this in common: too vivid a presentation of some truths and realities is simply beyond good taste. But, alas, ‘soule rape’ is still on History’s (not to say God’s) table. Boardrooms, of course, have always been averse to the concept; paying thus the compliment that vice always pays to virtue, but thereby piling up for themselves treasure not-in-heaven.

And thirdly, “civil peace among people who differ in religion [and secular fundamentalism is a religion just as much as Marxian materialism was] requires a moral consensus that is itself impartial, giving ascendancy to no creed more than any other”. But our modern American reality runs into that ‘abortion’ thing, and no ‘moral’ discussion is to be permitted; indeed, the non-moral is to be ‘privileged’. Is it me or is the Republic once again in the same type of ominous bind that bethump’t the generations before the Civil War (and in Williams’s time and up to the 1890s, in the matter of the treatment of the Indians). We have regressed, it seems. No therapist could leave that alone and still in good professional conscience submit a bill at the end of the month. Nor are We insured; no larger power is going to cover Our costs on this one. When it comes to Amairikuh, famously, there is no larger power. Except the one that We are assured is on Our side and has deputized Us to go out forthwith and make either democracies or wastelands. Sorta like those intergalactic prophets of believe-or-die on ‘Stargate SG-1’: the Ori.

Williams himself actively promoted friendship with the Indians. He was not doing this (as Jonathan Edwards and assorted Jesuits and other missionaries did) in order to convert them. He was acting out of “moral decency”. And again – it’s been a while since that term has been welcome around the official national hearth. No room for it, due to the reasons mentioned above. And sure as shootin’ – Our national decency, domestically and internationally, has got up and gone. Are We the better for it?

“The experience of finding integrity and goodness outside the parameters of orthodoxy surely shaped his evolving views of political principles.” Well, and what happens to those political principles when an unripe, primitive, regressed either-or pugnacity and hostility becomes the major key in the national discourse? I wonder if We had any right to expect some decades ago that We could excise all of those political principles and still retain the political structure – the Republic – which was built squarely upon them? The twin towers were finally taken down from the top (their tops, I mean); but the first attempt was to blow out their foundations. They may hold more symbolic truth for Us than had previously been considered.

Further, Williams's thought is far more perceptive in the tricky subtleties of the psychological dynamics of “both persecutor and victim”. A functioning lack of mutual respect belies a constructive (as the courts would say; or ‘de facto’) lack of conscience that makes ‘beasts’ not only of the designated monsters but of the designating community itself. I say this while thinking of Solzhenitsyn’s sharp observation, jabbed into the hyper-inflated balloons sitting before him at Hahvahd that day thirty years ago, that this country was on its way to becoming a prison, both for its many prisoners and for its even more numerous imprisoners. As if We are not all “sinners in the hands of an angry God”, as Edwards famously put it. As if Our prisons are God’s prisons and the rest of Us are ‘saved’ and may graze peaceably, sleek and fatted, at a better table. Henry Clay Frick, called from his New York mansion to come up the few blocks to his former employer Andrew Carnegie’s even grander mansion, when asked by that aging tiger of commerce and corporate engorgement to join in a soul-raising project of building nice things for the public while there was still time (a gambit taken straight from the playbook of dying and desperate Renaissance condottiere), replied that it was too late for that sort of thing now, taking his leave abruptly with the under-appreciated benediction: “I shall see you in Hell, Andrew, where we both are going”. They don’t make CEOs like that anymore.

“Truth is not the basis for respect … the faculty for finding the truth” is. And even ‘men’ have it. Oy. Nor does this term refer only to those men who seek to embrace their Inner Woman. “Everyone has inside himself or herself something infinitely precious, something that demands respect from us all, and something in regard to which we are all basically equal.” And nobody among Us has a warrant, from God or a ballot box or by viva voce acclamation from a shoal of pandering pundits and roadies or from any ‘base’, to ignore that equality: not in the service of Party or of great ‘visions’ of Progress and Change or in the haste to meet this or that ‘emergency’. This Republic and this People does things the right way, or not at all. Lest any or all incur that awefull punishment reserved for those who “have practiced ‘violence to the soules of men’”. And he’s not talking about gays or child-molesters here. And if the fear of committing such a sacrilege keeps Us from giving bad example to children, it must also keep Us from bombing, rocketing, or otherwise blowing them up, and flaunting such impious malefaction in the faces of the rest of the world’s peoples, and declaring it to be “God’s work”, in JFK’s short but rock-like phrase. I don’t think We quite grasp just what God-fearing means nowadays. Or why far more accomplished generations of Americans put so much store in it.

“What does he mean by saying that “persecution takes ‘the world out of the world’? I think he is expressing the view that the spirit of love and gentleness, combined with the spirit of fair play, is at the heart of our worldly lives with one another. Take these things away and you despoil the world itself. You make it nothing but a heap of confusion and pain.” Reading a passage like this lights anew the hope that universities still provide something of more-than-tactical value to the young. And gives rise to the darkling intimation that Rome in her worst aspects has returned, making a desolation and calling it not just ‘peace’ but God’s will. And thence gives immediate rise to an expansion of Vachel Lindsay’s thought: Neither Lincoln nor any of the Founders can rest upon their hillsides now – they must be among Us as before. But only among Us: no matter how white the heavenly horses upon which they might ride, they cannot do for Us what We, even We here, must do to keep faith and to keep Our rendezvous with destiny.

“Peace and stability” are purchased at too terrible a price if they are purchased at the price of bringing wholesale violence into the lives and ‘soules’ of human beings. There must be ‘order’; but an order that deflowers the respect each is owed by all, and that each owes to all, violates an Order that is rooted in the foundations of humanity itself. The consequences of introducing such iniquity into the human realm, already sore beset, will be positively Greek in their utterness. And who would dare to boast that History cannot raise up barbarians to punish the barbarity of a civilization that has lost its savor? In a hell-hot irony, the barbarity itself breeds the barbarians who will avenge the impiety. We have seen it before.

“Williams is keenly aware of the danger of religious establishments as threats to both liberty and equality.” Yes, although Williams does not say – and I don’t think Nussbaum implies – that ‘religion’ itself is thus in essence only a danger and not potentially a 'good'. “Established” religion is, privileged by the government either formally or constructively. Eisenhower was on to this in a schoolboyish way with his insistence that the country couldn’t survive unless the citizenry were religious, and he didn’t care what religion. Of course, he didn’t quite appreciate – or never let on that he appreciated – just how grave the responsibilities a vital religious spirit must discharge: especially to stand in judgment over the doings of government.

But also: to speak with the authority of God does not mean that one is possessed sufficiently of God’s wisdom and knowledge so as to unsheathe the sword of righteousness and start whacking away according to one’s particular illuminations. I sort of think that John Brown still had to stand before that final awefull Court and face the consequences of those killings at Pottowattamie Creek. And that implies no disrespect to his burning anger at the outrages of slavery.

And I say again that the current ‘establishment’ of the ‘secular fundamentalism’ during the last forty years qualifies quite fully as a de facto ‘establishment’ of religion on the part of the government, and – alas – the Democratic Party. And We cannot escape the awefull symmetry: the fundamentalism of the Left ignited the fundamentalism of the Right. And now the ship of state is pulled lethally to both a port and a starboard list: no hull and no keel can withstand such pressure for long.

And finally, Nussbaum draws upon a third character who joins Truth and Peace in Williams’s ‘The Bloudy Tenent’: “’But loe!’, says Peace, ‘Who’s here?’ Truth replies, ‘Our Sister Patience, whose desired company is as needful as delightful.’” Patience, as I’ve said in earlier Posts, is not a hallmark of youth or of revolutionaries (and among the latter I number those impatient revolutionaries of the Identities who have found scant use for a democratic politics these past biblical forty years). There is a price to be paid for trying to court youth and revolutionaries: they have no patience for careful building – or careful renovation or reconstruction, for that matter. Patience is not what they do. But it most certainly is what We need and how We must proceed, if We are not to run amok among Ourselves and among all nations.

These be dark times, and such light as there is sheds a thin and lurid illumination that cannot enlighten. We must light a few lamps. It’s grown-up work. And We indeed must be a beacon, unto our own children if not – for a while – to the nations.

Labels: , , , ,